>>712847319I like doom, but prime is good for almost exactly opposite reasons. Just because they're both FPSes doesnt mean they play the same way.
Its like comparing doom to an imsim like deus ex or system shock 2.
Sure you could look at the relative speed and see how in imsims you have to fiddle around in menus more. Theres what you describe as " clunkiness." But thats an abstract term that people can't even describe well. You could say "doom is better because faster game = better game" But I don't want my imsims to be fast like boomer shooters. I WANT them to be slow. Because that leads to more methodical combat. You manage your resources more, you map out areas, look for anything any way you can progress.
I mentioned imsims because they're probably the closest thing to prime games, but even that connection is minor. Nothing on the market plays like prime.