Thread 713216987

Where does it rank amongst the rest of the series

>>713216987 (OP)
Right below Zelda 2 and above TotK and the cdi games

>>713216987 (OP)
in the dumpster outside

>>713217123
fpbp

>>713216987 (OP)
Above skyward sword, phantom hourglass, Zelda 2 and tears of the kingdom.

Below everything else in the series.

last with totk

>>713216987 (OP)
>imagine zelda if you removed the dungeons entirely and it was just the open world
What do you think?

>>713216987 (OP)
Pretty low. Above windwaker but below everything else. I had a better time with Skyward Sword. Oh and TOTK is on the bottom. At least Zelda 2 is fun to replay.

>>713216987 (OP)
Top 5, being the last one. So yeah, its the 5th best Zelda game, doesnt matter where you put the rest of them

>>713216987 (OP)
it's below Ocarina, Majora's Mask, Wind Waker, Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword

Botw/totk was ok, but I don't like the open world design and short and limited dungeons, build mechanic is neat and the tech behind it is awesome but nothing comes close to the titles that stick to the Ocarina formula, we need to go back. I'm tired of open world slop with no proper dungeons.

>>713219451
pretty much nailed it, I'd say

>>713219451
>Zelda 1 in F
>LttP in A
Do you have brain damage?

>>713219451
Zelda 1 is near the top. Surprisingly great game that has aged like wine and nailed a ton of the fundamentals on the first game even way back in 1986

>>713219754
>>713219837
I just don't like NES crap. I dunno. I tried bro. Also /v/ likes to shill the Classic Castlevania games on NES too, and I also think they suck

>>713220129
faggot

>>713220129
>Wind Waker
>average
nigga kys, it's top 3 easily

>>713220241
lol, no my friend it's really not. It's the worst of the 3D entries.

>>713220382
You have Twilight Princess and TotK at the top, your opinion is in the trash can where it belongs.

>>713220382
Wrong.

>>713220382
>It's the worst of the 3D entries.

Wrong, after Ocarina, Majora's Mask, it's WInd Waker. You can't argue this, if you think otherwise you didn't play or understand what makes it top tier. aka retard.

>>713220625
Exactly, TWW is one of the best Zelda games ever made, pure soul

>>713220625
It's easy to argue because Wind Waker is unfinished piece of shit with an awful overworld and terrible dungeons. Nothing makes it remotely close to top tier.

>>713219451
I.. actually agree with this. TP should maybe be higher but other than that yeah

>>713216987 (OP)
not having areas gated off by item progression makes it not feel that much like a zelda game as i know it. it an excellent open world stoner game though.

>>713219451
>Zelda NES that low

>>713220625
>after Ocarina, Majora's Mask, it's WInd Waker
after TP, BotW, TotK, OoT, MM, SS, it's Wind Waker

>>713216987 (OP)
I just hope they scrap the open world gimmicks and small/limited dungeon design and go back to a more linear approach with massive dungeons and good puzzles like OoT/MM/WW, a more horror/dark vibe would be nice too.

I have no reason to get a switch 2 if they don't do this.

truth nuke

>>713221457
>and go back to a more linear approach
disgusting

>>713219945
Most of NES is unplayable jank
Mario 3 is literally the only exception

>A Zelda thread without Arthur or the Ericspammer to shit it up

Good riddance

>>713221469
>WW above OoT
C'mon now...

>>713221580
only slop enjoyers like you are ok with open world gimmicks. When I say linear I don't mean don't have any exploration at all. They can definitely implement a Dark Souls 1 style level design and have classic dungeons like in older games.

>>713221665
Cubekiddies are a different breed

>>713221619
Zelda 1 hasn't aged a day. Neither has Contra, Super C, Tetris, Super Mario Bros, SMB2J, SMB3, Battletoads, Castlevania, NG1-3, Kirby's Adventure, Gradius, or Punch-Out

>>713221715
you are a relic, and I will enjoy walking atop your grave I might even do the floss

>>713221821
not an argument, kys faggot.

Twilight Princess>Wind Waker
Objective fact

It feels like your average open world game with Zelda characters in it for some reason.

Objectively, it's near the top, but personally I rank it towards the bottom because I actually like all the stuff they threw out so this game is less to my taste than the previous entries.

I have not played even 5 minutes of TotK or EoW, so I think this game might have killed Zelda for me lol.

The games would rank pretty low. When you remove all the metacritic and game journo praise and game awards, there's so many cracks and inconsistencies below the surface, and they really show themselves once you inspect them closer. The whole game wanted to be gigantic, but it has nothing to fill the void with, so it copypastes koroks and bokoblin camps everywhere.

Tell me, why do you think the game gives you like 100+ fast travel points? If the world was so fun and full of interesting stuff to do, you wouldn't even need half that many. Infact it would be fun to backtrack to a shrine or a shiekah tower on foot, if need be. That right there is always the telltale sign of a game that value quantity over quality. Wind Waker was similarly guilty of this with the ballad of gales. Without that, sailing the seven seas was boring as sin.

>>713221912
red pilled

>>713223221
>there's so many cracks and inconsistencies below the surface,
such as ummmm and errrrm uhh

>>713223954
The ones I literally mentioned? Did you even read more than 1 sentence in?

>>713216987 (OP)
Under Twilight Princess, Wind Waker and A Link to the Past, above Majora's Mask, Minish Cap and Skyward Sword

>>713224063
>the ones I figuratively mentioned like uhh the world is like really big and umm there's multiple ways to get around it and I errrm will resort to fast travel and claim it's bad

>>713220129
Finally, a based post in a Zelda thread. OoT gets far too little hate for being an inferior rehash of Alttp.

>>713224170
Why have a world that big if there's nothing worth finding in it? If the best way to backtravel somewhere is to just fast travel around it all, then you've made a boring world.

>>713217123
That's an insult to Zelda 2 to be quite honest with you.

>>713224362
>Why have a world that big if there's nothing worth finding in it?
that's a good question, but for the wrong game

>>713225645
Did I stop talking about Breath of the Wild?