Thread 714832105

Do you prefer Sonic’s original design?

>>714832105 (OP)
Or his 2000’s design?

>>714832105 (OP)
>>714832124
Alright. I'm just going to get it out of the way now.

Amy & Rouge sexo

classic classic sonic > classic modern sonic > modern classic sonic > shit > modern modern sonic

>>714832105 (OP)
>>714832124
its funny that there isnt a game that looks like either of these

>>714832105 (OP)
>>714832124
I like both, but I think the modern designs are generally superior

>>714832105 (OP)
>>714832124
Both look best for their medium. I don't really like the adventure style sprites in the advance games, and I hate 'classic sonic' whenever he shows up in new games. Both were handcrafted for their respective games, and using them elsewhere always looks off.

>>714832105 (OP)
Classic tails is so much cuter than modern tails. And seriously, no pedo.

>>714832105 (OP)
Yes and his personality

>>714832105 (OP)
The only modern design I prefer over the originals is Amy's

>>714832105 (OP)
Artwork based on the original design is pretty comfy.

Obligatory

>>714832105 (OP)
Original. I cannot say why, but the 2000s design always bothered me. Maybe it's because of Sonic X, but I'm not sure.
I also cannot say I enjoy Sonic's personality in modern games.

>>714832981
>>714833138
Classic Sonic never smiles, get this shit outta here

>>714832105 (OP)
>>714832124

both of these styles are the perfection of Classic and Modern sonic

>>714833262
>Classic Sonic never smiles,

>>714832961
Same. Though I think the original works better for what Amy's role in the story.
>>714833138
Lmao
>>714832981
why are they smiling? They are about to fucking die
Neither eggman or that bird can save them in time.

>>714832105 (OP)
Yes because of one simple fact. He can open his mouth and actually emote without looking like a complete freak.

Classic > Paramount >>>>>> Adventure onwards Edgy Looney Tunes OC which all suffer from this glaring issue

>>714833331
That's a smirk, nearly a sneer
He's not being silly and having fun
He's about to wreck your fucking shit and is going to enjoy it

>>714832124
2000s Sonic or should I say the Yuji Uekawa art style really suits the series

>>714833430
>He can open his mouth and actually emote without looking like a complete freak.
What fucking difference does it make when classic games don't have stories

>>714832124
amy and eggman are the only different designs here
I would add vector, he went from skinny to muscular

>>714832105 (OP)
Classic, but it's fucking bizarre that they make Classic sonic mute even on 3D games. Though I'm not sure I 100% like Sonic from the OVA, at least that was something.

>>714832124
Main Cast looks bad, the robots look really great. Metal Sonic is the only returner that got a straight upgrade and new additions like Gemerl and Emerl wear the style well

So what do we think of Modern Bark?

>>714833138
>nooooo, you can't look like you're skiing while wearing skiis! That's too try hard! You have to stand in an awkward posture, like you're taking a family photo.

>>714834525
Another angry expression

>>714832261
Move the shit one to the left and it's accurate.

>>714832261
>classic modern

>>714832105 (OP)
>>714832124
Adventure design but that's probably because I've been conditioned to associate classic Sonic with low effort nostalgia bait cash grabs

>>714832105 (OP)
I think his 00s design looks better
Far more personality and SOUL

not that classic doesn't, but it's just less

>>714835168
>I've been conditioned to associate classic Sonic with low effort nostalgia bait cash grabs
Modern Sonic has been the same nostalgia baiting shit since since 2011.

>>714834049
>what do we think of classic Bark with an added iris
not much

>>714834496
>you can't look like you're skiing while wearing skiis!
noobdy skiis like that
sonic looks like he's about to fall backwards and then proceed to roll down the mountain in a cartoon snowball

>>714836574
You mean when they started including classic Sonic into the games?

>>714837458
I mean when they started using some variation of Green Hill, Chemical Plant, and/or Sky Sanctuary in every new game.

>>714834585
>>714833262

>>714837650
>Three goddamn Green Hill levels alone in Forces
There's so many other nostalgia levels they could use. they could even throw some curve balls in from the 8-bit games

>>714837650
How come they never reference Emerald Hill or Angel Island? At least those levels have way better music tracks than Green Hill

>>714840154
>>714840819
For the most part they're just reusing assets. The better question is why they don't reuse/mix in some assets from the spinoff racing games instead of relying on the same Generations environments over and over again. Frontiers could have used some of the environment assets made for Team Sonic Racing in its cyberspace stages, for example.

>>714836862
>noooo! a cartoon character can't perform cartoon antics! it's too... CARTOONY!

>>714841263
who are you quoting

>>714832105 (OP)
No.
>>714832124
Yes. 2000's design 100%

>>714832105 (OP)
Classic = Modern Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, Eggman
Modern > Classic Amy
Classic Metal Sonic > Neo Metal Sonic
Deceptive, sardonic, but ultimately remorseful SA2 Shadow > Modern stock antihero Shadow

>>714835168
Based I share the same sentiment anon

I puffer classic design cuz it cool and it better imo

i don't really care about any character except eggman here. classic eggman is the best character design of all time. he's adorable. he's full of so much joy and mirth and sovlbotnik. modern eggman pales in comparison

>>714832105 (OP)
At least classicfags and adventurefags can agree that the modern designs are inferior.

>>714832124
This still looks cool as fuck

>>714832105 (OP)
Original. 2000's is inconsistent but has some standouts

>>714832981
Yep, Harmony is the absolute best look for Sonic

The backgrounds that were included on the pc cd of sonic and knuckles collection will always be my favorite aesthetic. Looking at evokes the feeling that everything was right in the world for at least a moment.

My one problem is Amy absolutely looked better

>>714832105 (OP)
Yes.

PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS PINGAS

>>714833948
Metal Sonic (since rivals 2) is probably the worst out of the bunch
>>714844747
>>714833138
There was a reason they moved away from this. The harmony stuff veers too far away from the cool aspect of Sonic. It looks as gay and sanitized as Sonic is nowadays but people defend it because its from the 1990s

>>714832105 (OP)
Both, but i prefer the original.

>>714832105 (OP)
For 2D.
>>714832124
For 3D.

>>714845991
Classic Amy is cute but I really hate how messy her color scheme is. Classic characters all have very simple color schemes that stay within 3-4 colors max. Hell even Shadow follows this too. But Classic Amy has pink, green, orange, blue, white, red. Total mess. For me, this design she has for a Mario 64 mod is much better and absolute peak.