Are these really some of the best RPGs of all time?

Elden Ring is great, haven't played the rest of these

Certainly none of them on my list

Only one of those is an actual RPG and it's okay at best

>>715198151
lettme guess your list:
>olden boomer shit

>>715197965 (OP)
ER is a souls game so not an actual RPG
No idea on 33
BG3 is still an unfinished shitty mess that's just a reskin of an incredibly shitty tactics game
KCD 2 may or may not be. I've never really given more than two hours to it. I found it too boring with how they tried to be RDR2 all over again

No, this is

of this decade, sure. of all time is to be determined, though I imagine at least BG3 will qualify. E33 will probably be seen as overhyped in a few years, and Elden Ring will be overshadowed in legacy by its more focused and impactful predecessors.

>>715198057
>Le open world slop is great
Normie probaly never played a game.

E33 is

Being contrarian is a poor substitution for an actual personality

>>715198929
Meant for >>715198493

>>715198459
this is the worst smt all games included even Persona 4 is better than this garbage

>>715197965 (OP)
playing Ex33 right now, it's great but not quite sure if I'd put it on the same level as ER or BG3
a lot of people overhype it but I assume they haven't played a lot of (good) RPGs

>>715199119
No purse owner is better than any smt
Even soul hackers 2 or Tokyo.mirage

>>715197965 (OP)
>>715198057
Yeah Elden Ring is pretty good. Not much role playing though, feels like more of an action game than anything else.

Is Baldur's Gate 3 really that good? I pirated it yesterday but I couldn't get into it. It felt so boring and uninteresting. Does it ever get good? I couldn't get past the first level because I could not force myself to care about the setting or the ugly frog lady.

>>715198474
>E33 will probably be seen as overhyped in a few years
The way people are talking about E33 right now feels like the way people were talking about Metaphor Refantazio last year. No one is talking about Metahpor anymore. Lol

>>715197965 (OP)
I only played ER, it was great. It's RPG aspect isn't that deep though, I mean the only real "RPG" aspect it has is build crafting / character building for combat. It does that pretty well but other RPG elements are missing.

>>715197965 (OP)
Playing through BG3 really convinced me that crpgs are troonslop.
also it's worth noting that only half the playerbase made it through the first act...

>>715197965 (OP)
are any of these rpgs? if these are all rpgs then that's a meaningless term really

>>715199316
>or the ugly frog lady.
That's a man.

>>715197965 (OP)
No.

>>715197965 (OP)
Elden Ring is not an RPG. It's an action game that has a more specific ruleset than most action games. It's more akin to Hellgate London than it is to BG3.

>>715197965 (OP)
I played 3/4
I agree on all of them.
Elden Ring is one of the best Action RPGs of all time.
Expedition 33 is fantastic
BG3 is god tier RPG and is my favorite from those.

>>715199316
>but I couldn't get into it
Its not for everyone, maybe its just not for you, nothing wrong with that.

>>715197965 (OP)
I guess they are, aside from Kingdom Come 2 which I didn't play
But I also don't have really high standards