Is this rifght?

>>715361819 (OP)
No. "Muh all killer no filler" crowd are drooling retards who want to clap at a cutscene and then put the game away. 100 hours of actually good gameplay >>>> 20 hours of "muh tight narrative"

>A great game is better than a good game

>>715361948
If you had played a single game that focuses on replayability you wouldn't be spouting this nonsense, zoomer-sama

Yeah it is

>>715361819 (OP)
only if theres more shit to play. which there isnt, dont kid yourself.

>>715361819 (OP)
Divinity Original Sin 2 vs Dragon Age Origins

most 80h+ games are better than 8h-20h games

>>715361819 (OP)
8 hours long amazing game (with high replay value)>>>>>

>>715362665
name 1

>>715361948
>brings up narrative out of nowhere
nice straw man

Why not 100 hours long great game?

>>715361819 (OP)
No. Your choices are either:
1. infinite grind live service slop
2. 15 hour indie game trying and (failing) to be a SNES game

Option 1 has sexy anime girls. Option 2 was drawn and animated by someone who grew up using Gaia Online and Tumblr as a replacement for having an actual social life.

>>715362706
Half life 1/2
Max Payne 1/2
Boomer shooters either legit boomer or the retro wave.

>>715361819 (OP)
If both cost 20$ i'd rather get 100hours of out it than 20.
But that being said if both are good games then i dont care that much.

>>715361819 (OP)
Yeah honestly I don't even bother with gigantic games anymore. Playing Super Metroid and having the fucking time of my life.

>>715361819 (OP)
I don't care how long a game is only if it's fun.

>>715362812
can't believe AAA games aren't being made anymore

You only want games to be 100 hours long with tons of shitty filler and boring sidequests if you're a poorfag with no hobbies desu.

>>715361819 (OP)
>took me around 20 hours to beat this
>check playthrough
>1 hour 34 minutes

I was searching for a playthrough not a speedrun you FUCKS. How do you even enjoy the vibe and atmosphere going through everything like sonic the hedgehog

https://youtu.be/vlJAI62gFYU

>>715362978
Neither of those are good. You just have nostalgia.

>>715362706
VANQUISH
Time splitters fp
Zone of the enders 1/2

>>715362706
That's literally every game that isn't a JRPG from the 6th gen and before.

>>715362706
Nintendo babies need not reply

20 hours is still too much. 10 hours with enough replayability and bonus content to hit 20-30 is the sweet spot

>>715362180
>Elden ring is several hundred hours long and has more replayability than any short linear game
Your response?

>>715361819 (OP)
If it takes 80 hours of drudgery for me to enjoy the 20 hours of good content, then yes this is true.

>>715364218
Being several hundred hours long is not a good thing

>>715361819 (OP)
What about a 100 hour long great game vs a 20 hour long great game.
Also
>hours

>>715361819 (OP)
>play game
>get tired of it
>am not a total retard
>stop playing it
>come back to it a few months later and play the fresh content that was waiting for me
vs
>play game
>get tired of it
>force myself to finish it because i want achievement points in case someone looks at my profile they would be impressed even though no one even looks at that stuff even in 4chan threads dedicated to sharing your steam info/achievements

>>715361819 (OP)
Depends. Trails is garbage and the latest games reach 100hrs. Dragon Quest VII is good and it's also a 100hrs game.
Final Fantasy IV is good and it's a 20~25hrs game. Xenosaga Episode II is garbage and it's a 20~25hrs game.

>>715361819 (OP)
More hours will always be better, just as open world will always be better.

>>715364169
Yeah I agree, a linear game that's 20 hours long will inevitably have tedious parts to make it longer.

Only RPGs should be that long, MGSV and Death Stranding have no business being 50 hours long.

>>715364735
>t. journalist from 2007

>>715361819 (OP)
More like 100h game with 5h of good content

>>715362706
space marine 1/2 campaign

>>715363114
>I was searching for a playthrough not a speedrun you FUCKS. How do you even enjoy the vibe and atmosphere going through everything like sonic the hedgehog
Most gamers (especially casuals like the average /v/ user) speed through games ASAP so they can finish and be part of the online discussion.

>>715361819 (OP)
Nope I enjoy playing FO4 off-grid all the time and I'm sad I can't play System Shock 2 anymore

Great game also has to be replayable so it'd likely rack up far more then 100 hours

>>715361819 (OP)
100 hour long games are almost never consistently good. A great 20 hour game doesn't overstay its welcome with pointless bloat.

I'll take a 1 hour great game with branching paths.

>>715364129
Dat wooks scawy
Whewes Mawio?

>>715361819 (OP)
but what about 200 hours long of one of the greatest game ever?

>>715361819 (OP)
during gen 6 games were plentiful and most were short, so when you finished a game there were plenty of others to play
wish we could go back to that

>>715368187

>>715361819 (OP)
The best games are either sandbox or session based, however

>>715368187
90% of it is copy pasted content. it's all very formulaic.who cares about the cave I'm going in? I'll fight the same enemies, fight the same recycled boss, and get as a reward a spelll or weapon I won't use

>>715363587
Neither is used when talking about two things, ESL bro. He mentioned four games

>>715361819 (OP)
No. I seldom pirate, play or buy anything that can't give me 60 hours of playtime at the minimum. Over 100 is better.

>>715367886
Based Starfox 64 enjoyer.

I typically start getting burnt out of the game around 35-40 hours mark. So yeah, i will take a great 20 hour experience over something overly drawn out.
There are some exceptions though, Astlibra had like 70 hours of content in it an i just devoured all of it like i would devour Kuro's tits.

>>715368494
This
All you need is Fallout 4 and Melee
I main Roid

>>715368618
This.

>>715368747
No.
>>715368642
This.

>>715361819 (OP)
No I would enjoy them both
Why would I say no to a good game?

>>715362706
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow

>>715364218
>has more replayability than any short linear game
Blatantly and comically false. Lmfao

>>715369181
Elden Ring is the BBC of games