RDR2 has better gameplay
better characters
better mechanics
better weapons
better world
better hype moments
better everything and yet you retards think this 15 year old outdated game is better

>>715514802 (OP)
but have you considered that I played RDR in high school and that those memories are forever?

You're right, maybe you shouldn't take these retards seriously

>>715514802 (OP)
>RDR2 has better gameplay
RDR1 is the same gameplay but with less bloat
>better characters
Oregon trail friend simulator crap, lone cowboy in the mexican desert is more kino and true to westerns
>better mechanics
Le 12 minute animations for everything
>better weapons
Same old timey over under shotgun, same old timey revolver, same old timey stick of dynamite
>better world
I concede
>better hype moments
What does this even mean
>better everything and yet you retards think this 15 year old outdated game is better
Games don't become outdated zoomzoom. They age. And RDR1 aged like bitcoin wine

>>715514802 (OP)
Not only /v/ like that

>>715514802 (OP)
>RDR2 has better gameplay
2 has better gunplay, sure
>better characters
Fuck no, 1 has actual memorable characters. There's a reason why the only memorable character from 2 is Dutch
>better mechanics
Realistic is not the same as good
>better weapons
They're the same
>better world
I don't play westerns to see pine forests, swamps and fucking New Orleans. I want prairie and mexican deserts, something 2 was severely lacking
>better hype moments
???

>>715514802 (OP)
you eat babies anon

>>715514802 (OP)
I got rdr2 like half a year ago and couldn't deal with all the cutscenes and characters constantly annoying me. i bought rdr1 this summersale and have already 20 hours in it. It may not be better but it hit that western itch I had perfectly

>>715515318
None of these white trashes are memorable

>>715514802 (OP)
1 is straight
2 is gay

>>715515454
Wrong. Also you left out Landon Ricketts

>>715514802 (OP)
>better characters
Stopped reading there. Bait thread. You didn't play either or you only played 2

>>715514802 (OP)
What did you expect from contrarian goat fuckers?

>>715515318
>Fuck no, 1 has actual memorable characters. There's a reason why the only memorable character from 2 is Dutch
You're either really good at rage baiting, or a complete retard. Lenny is far more iconic than any of your fucking characters.

>>715515932
Who the fuck is Lenny? That irishman who was killed and you're supposed to feel sad about it?

>>715515932
>>715515975
It's the meme nigger. Of course zoomer loves the meme nigger

>>715515725
Kiss my ass

>>715514802 (OP)
Because the hate against rdr2 is because retards got triggered by Arthu being liberal or something
Rdr 2 has more side activities, side quests, customization, hunting, secrets, items, weapons, mechanics, longer, the missions are more varied

>>715516380
>Arthu being liberal or something
i see people complaining about too long animations to literally everything you as much as gay RDR2 story

>>715514947
>Same old timey over under shotgun, same old timey revolver, same old timey stick of dynamite
you don't need more

Rdr2 has Sadie Adler so that makes it better. Post Sadie

>>715518195
>tfw almost no Sadie art

>>715516161
holy fucking SOVL

>>715514802 (OP)
RDR(evolver) shits on both tbqhdf

>>715514802 (OP)
gayman

>>715514802 (OP)
my favorite is when they call it a spaghetti western. like bruh, was it made by an italian company? oh you mean it's inspired, like all american westerns since the 60s

Yep. Unfortinatly alot of people don't want to think for themselves just want to go along and "be cool". Please corpos let me slurp your cock gobble, gobble, slurp, slurp.

>>715514802 (OP)
>RDR2 has better gameplay
What? RDR2 feels like trash to play. Arthur moves way too slow.
>better characters
lmao far from it
>better mechanics
Nah, the sim autism is tedious as fuck and sucks the pace out of the game. There is no point to any of it.
>better weapons
Aren't they about the same?
>better world
I'll give you this one
>better hype moments
You are 12 years old.

>>715523084
horse riding is awful in rdr1

>>715514802 (OP)
I was amazed when RDR2 was basically the exact same story beats as RDR1. How did they get away with telling the same story twice?

Gotta say though as a massive fan of 1, 2 was great fanservice. Especially the epilogue section.

>>715523378
It's fine. Sounds like a skill issue.

playing rdr1 after 2 makes it feel like a cheap mobile knockoff.

>>715514802 (OP)
I played RDR1 once when it came out and then again last year. It hasn't aged well. It's a big open world with literally nothing to do. Even less to do than in GTA's empty open world. All you do is ride horses to the next cut scene and then have a gun fight. That's it. I went in with the nostalgia goggles on but it disappointed me. It's still playable but it just feels empty overall. The only reason to play is for the story, which you could just watch on youtube anyway.
I'll never play RDR2 btw. Rockstar died to me a long time ago.

When will they make a cowboy game where you play as a Spaniard cowboy shooting natives

>>715514802 (OP)
Red Dead 2 has less action. Both games are, fundamentally, boring, both have open worlds with nothing to do, and a lot of missions without any fighting, but RDR1 has, per capita, a bit more fighting.

>>715514802 (OP)
RDR2 is as canon as Red Dead Revolver in my mind.

No shit rdr1 is literally just another generic gta game with a cowboy theme put on top.
Meet wacky character
Protag is annoyed with them
Still does their busy work
Repeat 6 times
Go to new wacky character
Repeat 7-8 times
Games over
Rdr 1 multiplayer was pretty fun though, my favorite rockstart mp

>>715514802 (OP)
RDR1 has better shooting but the game itself isn't as fun as RDR2. I liked riding around in RDR2 and just finding funny situations, hunting and admiring the scenery. There's little to do in RDR1 other than just shoot dudes and play cards.

>>715524145
>I liked riding around in RDR2 and just finding funny situations, hunting and admiring the scenery.
You can do the last part pretty well with the PC port at 4k on a decent HDR monitor. It's a great port, easy to torrent the latest version.

>>715524145
>play cards
That's the best part.

>>715523084
Name better characters literally fucking name one. Irish, Seth, Dickens your typical rockstar wacky one off characters, Mexican army characters, typcial backstabbing scums. It's incomparible to Hosea, Dutch, Micah and Charlse in RDR2.

>deviate one inch from mission expected guidelines
>dead

RDR2 is gutter trash

they shoulda never made 2 a prequel
shoulda just made a new story new characters
dutch is a hopeless faggot i woulda shot his ass before chapter 2 he is the real problem in the story he was supposed to be some badass like the brief scene he had in 1
but instead he is blithering cunt
there are no memorable characters in 2 they all lack charisma & are shallow contrived unironic sterotypes of the faggots and tranny lovers that wrote the script (houser brothers, unsworth , humphries)
its not a wild west game its an industrial revolution era game , nobody asked for that

>>715514802 (OP)
>RDR2 has better gameplay
I like 1 better
>better characters
I like 1 better
>better mechanics
I like 1 better
>better weapons
I like 1 better
>better world
I like 1 better
>better hype moments
I like 1 better
>better everything and yet you retards think this 15 year old outdated game is better
Yes

>>715524490
Rdr1 isn’t that much different in that regard, san andreas was the game that started being more restrictive in goals

>>715524145
>RDR1 has better shooting
you can't do this in rdr1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ixNYlYyZl0

Woke DEI Slop

>>715514802 (OP)
RDR1 is better thna 2 because when I get off my FUCKING HORSE in 1, I can open my Gunwheel and see all of my guns ARE STILL THERE.


OH YOU FORGOT TO EQUIP THE GUNS YOU WERE JUST USING? HERE’S SOME DOGSHIT PISTOL FOR YOU

>>715524364
HERBERT FUCKING MOON

>>715524638
My only issue with that system in rdr2 is that sometimes it does give me my weapons and i have no idea why

>>715514802 (OP)
both shit

>>715524638
do you pull them out of your ass?

>I'm a normalfag!
If you're a normiefaggot who likes that "cinematic" turd written by women and faggots who hate cowboy media, more power to you. But you should go back.

>>715524756
I pull them outnof the same space Arthur morgan keeps his hundreds of bullets buddy

>>715524638
>>715524689
took me 2 years to realize you can move the camera over either shoulder in rdr1 it was simple d-pad press in 2 you gotta hold 3 fucking buttons

Both games are good, but after replaying RDR1 after it dropped on Steam I tend to agree that 2 is better. I did enjoy my time replaying 1 and it was not as bad as when I replayed Red Dead Revolver after playing RDR1.

>>715524364
>Micah
lmao worst R* antagonist by far

>>715524846
>cowboy media

>>715514802 (OP)
RDR1 was my favourite game for years but, much to my surprise, 2 blew it out of the water. It expanded on all the mechanics that wanted to be deeper from the first game, like hunting and customisation, and added much more

RDR1 does still win a few areas, namely having a better background score, better sunrises/sunsets and having Liar's Dice. Also being able to play Poker for real money rather than just pocket change

>>715525079
you only hate him because he is ugly (he is supposed to be 39 btw)

>>715524605
Indeed Zelda Tears of the Kingdom is Woke DEI Slop which is why RDR2 is better

why is it the same people posting in these threads?

>>715525116
>being able to play Poker for real money rather than just pocket change
that would've broken the economy even more than it already is with the game showering you with money

^
pinkertons

Micah was a waste, having someone you hate and dont get along with would've made him better to cooperate with because it got results

>>715514802 (OP)
All those things are by no means great in RDR1 (as RDR1 is still a Rockstar of David game, and thus mediocre) but RDR2 is straight up terrible from a gameplay standpoint. I find it to be unreplayable, unlike RDR1.

>>715525553
rdr2 is unreplayable because of how depressing it is, gameplay has nothing to do with that

undead nightmare is the greatest dlc of any game ever theres nothing you can even compare it to
they can save rdr2 with a dlc on that level

>>715525792
>save
lmao retard, the game sold over 80 million copies, they got what they wanted from it until gta6 online starts printing money.

Everything in RDR is superior to 2 except graphics

>>715526000
easily fixable

>>715525883
they gunna drip feed 6 for 20 years
you seem to forget 5 was empty for 2 years then heists came out
rdr2o was a beta for its first 18 months

>>715526000
Not really

skub thread

>>715526056
rdr2 online will never not be unfinished. they just dropped some stupid steampunk dlc for it that nobody asked for.

>>715525372
Well that's sort of my point. By the time you're halfway through the game you'll have so much money that it doesn't really matter anyway, so why not let you go all out with high-stakes poker in Saint Denis? It just feels a bit unsatisfying to play for such small amounts unfortunately

>>715526050
god smite this man dead

>>715525781
Fictional stories aren't depressing when you're an adult. It has everything to do with the fucking constant input lag and gameplay systems like bounties, the law, and challenges which are just worse than they were in the first game. Hunting is better in a lot of ways but any of the good stuff relies on an RNG spawn system that defeats the entire point of hunting.

>>715525178
Meds, tranny

Stop whining, brownoid.

>>715514802 (OP)
>RDR2 has better gameplay

>>715526309
theres literally no games worth buying for the last 3 years all dogshit
i think they have an 'expanded & enhanced' rdr2o ready to go they just want sony & ms to get into a bidding war for it

>>715526481
the minigame doesn't even have real poker odds, it's cinematic cutscene poker, because it was rigged to deal strong hands for you and your opponents more frequently

>>715526671
Often the case in videogames sadly. I don't even trust online poker to not do this

>>715526671
I'm good at irl poker, everybody has a reaction

>better hype moments

OP is a worthless zoomer retard with non-valid opinions and shit taste.
Move along folks.

>>715526671
>>715527169
At least it's not as bad as videogame mahjong

>>715515454
OP proving that he is infact a brown child with shit taste.

>>715523792
I played it last year. It aged fine. Saying the world is empty means you have to ignore all the side objectives and even then, you have undead nightmare as a decent piece of content

>>715518195
RDF2 has Sadie Adler so that makes it unplayable trash for feminist simp retards.
But yeah post Sadie getting fucked in the ass.

>hype scenes
like when everyone started dancing like a bunch of kansas city faggots in the bar

>>715527512
I am east asian.

>>715523903
Never. The Indian Reservation doesn't even let you use weapons in RDR2. It's the wokest piece of western media ever made.

A game about scalp hunters will not happen unless a massive cultural purge of women and their pets happens.

>>715527635
So... American?

this is /v/ bitchboy OP
we judge games by how much porn was inspired by it

>>715524638
>Several missions force random guns on you

I never played RDR2 again the first time I realized this was a design choice and not a bug.

>>715525792
Shivering Isles mops the floor with it.
No game has come even remotely close to Shivering Isles expansion.

Even Shadow Of The Erdtree was phoned-in and lazy when compared to Shivering Isles.

>>715527635
Wrong. Your soul is brown. You're brown.
You also didn't deny being a stupid child.

>>715528036
Blood and Wine

>>715525175
Nta but I don't like him cause he is comically evil, and in an actual gang of outlaws, and not the adult daycare that is the Van Der Linde gang, he would be shot for being a blatant liability. His writing is also juvenile, having to literally spell it out for the player that he is "a survivor" instead of the player figuring out for himself from the 60+ hours of gameplay.

>>715528153
Being brown is you westoids obsession. I've got nothing to do with it nor care about it as an east asian.

remember to do your camp chores like a good boah or dutch will get mad

>>715528623
man why did we never get a poncho like that in rdr2, not even in online fuck

>>715525175
I don't like him because he's a fucking retard on every task
>we have to rob this train let's keep it quick clean in and out ok
>I'm gonna punch everyone I see with a bow tie and honk each breast of every woman on the train. I will honk the right breast with my left hand and the left breast with my right hand. I will reholster my gun instead of simply swapping hands in order to be more intimidating to the husband and other women on the train
>michah what the fuck are you doing
>I trust the plan arthur sure the sheriff got here sure I shouted our full government names and location of our camp challenging the FBI to come and get us but that's where you and I disagree
>michah what the fuck are you talking about
>I am a real outlaw arthur and basically you're gay
I tried to get him killed every mission I had with him but ultimately it made shit take longer than him fucking it up on his own.

>>715514802 (OP)
>better hype moments
Wtf does that even mean?
Also, let me guess: you have no father and that's why you think Arthur is le cool character, even though he's a cowboy who thinks like a modern day leftist. Undead Nightmare shits all over your feminism and interracial faggotry quests. Liar's dice online was a better experience than playing through the whole RDR2 online content. By the time they brought Call to Arms the game was already dead.

I'm still mad that Nigel West Dickens isnt in RDR 2 even as a cameo. Best RDR 1 character by a mile

>>715527635
POO

>>715515705
and Seth

>>715530205
that was a good one yes

RDR1 is too much like GTA, it's very generic. RDR2 has simulation elements and it's super detailed, can be boring sometimes, but it's much better.

>>715530676
It would be funny as fuck if he sent Arthur on some fetch quest and then just stole his money and disappeared from the game

>>715516161
>>715526143
>>715527635
>>715528623
>clear and sharp textures instead of blurry assets
>vivid and colorful sky boxes instead of lazy volumetric clouds
>proper contrast instead of anti soul gas 20ft ahead of you
We unironically need to go back

>>715514802 (OP)
>RIGHT
>RIGHT
>RIGHT
>RIGHT
>RIGHT
how can you be SO fucking right?
RDR2 > RDR1

because it doesnt have any gameplay

>>715514802 (OP)
No i found 2 to be pretty gay. The first feels more like a dying cowboys journey

RDR2 is an incredible game. I've never once come across someone who dislikes it who wasn't obviously just a seething faggot triggered by women

>>715514802 (OP)
Are RDR games worth playing if I like gritty Westerns like No Country For Old Men? Senseless killing, old grandpa figures feeling sad and defeated, no one gaining anything but more guilt to carry on their shoulders, stuff like that. Basically, are the games well written, or just action flicks?

>>715534320
>Senseless killing, old grandpa figures feeling sad and defeated, no one gaining anything but more guilt to carry on their shoulders, stuff like that
RDR is entirely this, sounds like you'd love the games

>>715535165
Nice, I'll give them a whirl then. Gonna start with 2 though, because 1 (the remaster) is more expensive for some dumb reason.

>>715534320
>Basically, are the games well written,
They are in terms of the standards of 2010s AAA video games, but it falls apart the moment you compare it to actual film. Frankly there are moments where the game's story and characters contradict themselves because obviously, this is a video game reliant on a stream of action set pieces and you can't get that without characters behaving with occasional contrived stupidity.

>>715527512
I'm brown and I disagree with him

>>715535430
2 is a prequel so that order still works quite well, apart from the first game feeling a bit emptier mechanically in comparison when coming straight off the second game