Thread 716456181

itt: girls no one picks

sorry meant to post this

>>716456234
Id pick her every time if she was obese

>>716456181 (OP)
>>716456234
faggots both of you

>>716456181 (OP)
She should pick some new eyebrows out

I picked her. She's the only Persona girl that fills my niche (I like to be mistreated by a slut with a high body count)

I can fix her.

>>716456181 (OP)
Ai is the one of the few girls in P4 that has an actually good arc tho.
You should've posted the drama club bitch if you wanted the actual answer.

>>716456181 (OP)
I'd pick her if I didn't have a complex about not wanting to cheat on my favorite girl. I do like her though, it's just some of the other girls are better

>>716456181 (OP)
The older I get the more I like stacies

I tried but her script to come see me between two lessons never happened.

>>716456705
I don't know why they set up Yu's rejection to be so embarrassing for her, who's going to say yes?

>>716456181 (OP)
unironically better than the playable female cast

>>716456705
I have never said yes to her.

>>716456651
She doesnt. Shes a Karen through and through.

>>716456750
what does the eye thing mean and why do womins do it when looking at my tiny pecker

>>716456705
this the true pic

>>716456809
you're not collecting the girls like pokemon?

She gave Naruakmi his first kiss in the anime.

>>716456576
I love her so much.

>>716456234
Jamal picked her

Did anyone actually have Pikachu as their best girl in P4? She's nice, but she gets mogged hard by all the other girls except for maybe Yumi.

>>716457054
Maybe i should do it, because she reminds me of Part 1 Hinata in Naruto.

>>716456401
Have you had that irl? Because I have. And it gave me a major cuck fetish as a coping mechanism after getting cheated on a bunch by her.

>>716456181 (OP)
I picked Ai.
I love Ai.

>>716456885
>Shes a Karen through and through.
Ai tries to be a Karen, but she doesn't even have the power to defeat Yukiko.

>>716456181 (OP)
>>716456234
Reminder Yukiko absolutely fucking MOGS Ai
Though Ai mogs Rise
which makes sense because Rise is shit and Yukiko is the best girl

>>716457438
>duplicate file exists here
a few secs too late

>>716457542
I wish girls were like this in real life because they liked you and not because they were secretly cheating on you :(

>>716457585
that's my gf you bitch
I held on for a long time, game was just okay but that was a surprisingly effective ending sequence.

>>716457438
doesn't stop me from thinking about ai x rise
with ai forcing herself on rise

>>716457054
She's actually kind of cute in this image. Her in-game portrait is hideous.

Ai is for marrying and letting her get fat again and loving her all the same.

>>716456181 (OP)
Ebihara is a true hardworking beauty, though.
>1st playthrough
Ayane
>2nd playthrough
Ai

I just had to google Persona 5 journalist girl because I forgot Ichiko Ohya name

>>716456234
I picked Yukiko. She's perfect gf/wife material.

>>716457429
>So unpopular that her new date scene in P5R has her mention that (You) have weird as fuck taste for picking her

People talk about her personality being gross, but it doesn't help that Fatlus went with the worst design. Guarantee that there would've been more people willing to deal with her alcoholic ass if they chose the ponytail or exposed 5head look.

>>716458017
Your perfect wife is an ADHD retard? Me too man.

>>716458051
>but it doesn't help that Fatlus went with the worst design
Yeah seriously, what the fuck were they thinking? Especially in a game with heavy cake competition.

>>716457986
>>716458051
Oh yeah!

>>716458281
I mean, based on my last gf, I guess so kek

>>716456705
Yumi was my first playthrough's choice.

>>716457016
What do you love about Marie? I mean she's pretty flashy and "cute" but that's about it? Def not as kind as other persona girls.

>>716458660
>anon gets guilt tripped into a relationship with worst girl
Sorry to hear that.

>>716456401
Persona girls aren't sluts stop lying

>>716456705
This is the real answer. I have literally anyone talk or post about what her dates are like

>>716458460
As a romance option it's shit, but she definitely looks and acts like she's an extra from Catherine which is kind of neat.

>>716456291
You too? I dunno what it is about her but somehow she's the best P4 girl for that kinda content

>>716457054
Its been too long for me to say shes best but i do love ayame, shes cute af

>>716457054
Ayane has nothing that Nanako doesn’t already do better

>>716457741
I hope P4R does her justice, she's a proper qt in the anime but I agree that her portrait (along with a bunch of other characters) looks weird as fuck.

>>716457054
Me. Her social link is very sweet and her reaction to you turning her down after all that is unironically gut-wrenching to me.
>>716459432
You can't date Nanako though, sadly

>>716456234
I picked her

>>716457683
Girls like that don't exist IRL... yet.

>>716456234
If we're going by main cast girls, then pic is easily the one that nobody picked. She can't even be saved by the
>"Oh but she joined late"
excuse. Fuckloads of people still went for Naoto even though she's the last party member in P4.

>>716456181 (OP)
Ai means love

>>716459906
I picked her. Faggot.

>>716460152
>I picked her.
why

>>716456705
I've picked her up.
Her quest hit somewhat close to home. My fiancé has a history of daddy issues. Mommy issues also. Also her mom has alzheimer, and this just fucking sad.

>>716456181 (OP)
I picked her.

>>716459906
It would easily be Fuuka if P3 had you make choices, but yeah I agree.

>>716459841
>implying I'm not already speaking to an AI bot that's pretending to be my daughter stealing me away from her own mother by getting knocked up with our inbred child
:)

>>716456705
YUMi, too bad her dates are more shallow than the other girls

The social link stuff is the least interesting part of Persona and it feels like it's all anyone cares about. You have a cool dungeon crawling game with summonable demons, interesting party members, a unique plot structure and solid themes and the only thing you care about is half-assed dialogue options?

>>716459906
I actually think Haru is pretty popular. She's my favorite girl of the main cast and usually pick her to romance

>>716460612
Atlus must've felt really dumb sabotaging their new series by not including it.

>>716460612
>interesting party members
Most of them are only interesting if you do their SLs, otherwise they come off as pretty one note characters.

>>716460612
Dungeons are the least interesting part of Persona. Persona 6 should ditch dungeons and go open world like SMT V. Dungeons in P5 was ok but not particularly deep, while those in P3 and P4 are miserable (still better than the ones in P2).........

>>716456705
I think she's the prettiest girl in the game, but I don't actually remember anything about her social link.

>>716456181 (OP)
I liked her but there are better picks. She does feel the most human of all the P4 girls though.

>>716456181 (OP)
Wrong.

>>716459906
She literally was my first

>>716457429
>>716457986
Poor Ohya couldn't even keep her one character trait to herself.

>>716459906
Joining late never had anything to do with it. It was always about character and Haru is barely one before and after she joins

>>716459906
>getd introduced in the worst arc and overshadowed by the asshole cat
She never had a chance.

>>716459906
Haru's problem was more that her story got hijacked by the faggot cat.

>>716459906
>>716460330
Haru and Fuuka are both boring characters

>>716460612
But there are tons of games where you can explore dungeons and play turn-based battles
I wanna pretend to be an anime protagonist and spend time with my anime friends while getting to choose the winning girl

>>716456181 (OP)
only valid choice is the journalist from 5. every other girl has their fans.

>>716461602
>every other girl has their fans.
There is no such thing as a Yuko fan.

>>716460612
Social links let you learn more about your party members and interact with them outside of combat

>>716456576
She is LITERALLY the canon wife.

>>716456181 (OP)
I wasn't interested in her until she revealed she used to be a landwhale during her last social link.

HOW WOULD YOU IMPROVE SOCIAL LINKS IN P6?

>>716459089
LITERALLY the best girl in P5, she shouldve replaced Makoto or Haru

>>716461951
idk P5 already nailed down the concept pretty well, the only things I can think of is making sure they aren't written like shit and maybe adding some kind of post SL conversations thing so that you don't end up hitting rank 10 with someone and then just ghost them for the rest of the game.

>>716461951
As long as they are all voiced like P3R, 5s mostly seemed alright as a system, writing could always be better though

>>716461951
Making them actually feel like they need to be 10 ranks.

>>716461951
I prefer the relationship interactions that were used in Metaphor where your social stat and story progress are the only things that keep you from maxing a character's story. Or just drop the goddamn calendar system and just structure your game like other JRPGs and allow the damn story dungeons to be done at your own pace.

>>716456181 (OP)
Nobody wants this old imperial hag.

>>716459089
Nah she has fans. The real pick would be the alcoholic or the fortune teller.

>>716461951
one thing I hated about 5’s confidants were having to do a mission in mementos in order to advance some of them. That shit got annoying real fast

>>716459906
When Naoto joins, she hijacks the spotlight from the other party members. When Haru joins, her plot is hijacked by the housecat. That's the difference.

>>716461951
I'd double down on them never being faggot shit. Maybe have guy that looks like he could be some gay link but then have you get a game over if you try.

>>716461716
>>Yuko
Who?

>>716462882
>she hijacks the spotlight from the other party members
That sounds way too exaggerated

>>716462825
>or the fortune teller
Chihaya slander will not be tolerated itt.

>>716463117
she reminds of an actress, I think that was on scrubs for a few seasons. cant remember her name.

>>716463092
Anon, the main story is a detective investigation, and she is the world's greatest detective. She becomes by far the most important person when she joins.

>>716463092
She literally takes Yosuke place as the one who explains everything to the group after you already figured it out

>>716463232
Name one deduction Naoto did that helped everyone solve the case

>>716463117
isn't she technically the hardest to romance

>>716461951
For romance options, don't have a bunch of them revolve around giving advice about a character's relationship with a third character that only appears in the S Link. I feel like P5 overdid that.

You’re playing Persona wrong if you don’t pick as many women as possible.

>>716463435
Makoto had the worst SL in the game, it was pretty baffling.

>>716463375
The fact that the romance gets ruined if you don't say you like older women seems kinda bullshit. I mean, she seems really young
I bet the original script said "do you like onee-sans?" and they didn't know how to translate it

>>716463493
Being a manslut is gay.

>>716463548
how do people larp about her being best girl with that god awful social link?
Oh wait, persona "fans" don't play the game.

>>716456234
>girl who is going to be set for life for carrying on the family's business
>also has a secret "silly" side that she likes to indulge in

If you have a clown fetish, you love yukiko

>>716457054
I did, she has the prettiest smile.

Persona 4 developers every time they add a joke about a character not knowing how to cook

>>716459089
Can you really become a girl's fan is she waves her hand at you?

>>716463605
IDK I assume if they do play the game it's because most gamers are dumb and need things laid out for them so being told how great she is probably effects it. The game sucks are off and she's almost never in the wrong or shown in a bad light.

>>716463639
>NOOOO I DONT WANT TO RUN THE INN
>okay, do what you want
>UHHH ACTUALLY I DO WANT TO RUN THE IN

Literally zero character development, she just learned how to communicate at a higher level than a bucket of dirt.

>>716463605
Makoto's appeal starts and ends at her awakening scene. It was very misleading.

>>716463769
I hope they add more in the remake. Have the boys cook something and the girls seethe over how good it is

>>716463605
People think she's cute because of things like the clumsy way she spies on you or the way she asks you to hold her hand because she's scared of ghosts

>>716459089
Why does NTR art always look like "that", I found the gallery on e-hentai and I was right.

>>716463890
>first few awakenings are painful, visceral ordeals
>Makoto stomps her feet >:( , Futaba gets tentacle raped, and Haru looses the spotlight to the fucking mascot
cringe

>>716463868
>jap developer
>"I'm insecure about following my family's legacy"
>"actually, everyone who loves and supports me is here, I'm privileged to have this and shouldn't let my emotions ruin my life"

>western developer
>"yo, fuck capitalism and tradition, I'm gonna go on a journey to find myself (have sex with different men) fuck you dad"

>steals your waifu's spotlight
Whatcha going to do about it, bitch?

>>716463605
>almost 10 years and anon is still seething his waifu will never be as popular and liked as Makoto

>>716459189
Exactly she fits it perfectly. The quite reserved personality meshes well with an obese body

>>716464069
You're missing the point

>>716464261
>"yo, fuck capitalism and tradition, I'm gonna go on a journey to find myself (have sex with different men) fuck you dad"
Persona 6 sounds based.

>>716464267
get cucked you useless cat

>>716459089
Not the least popular, but certainly the most boring. Especially since just about everything in her "arc" happens off-screen and just gets told to us.

>>716461951
Make them more dynamic, especially for the non-party characters. More variety of interactions, more influence and shaping of how the relationship develops (good for multiple playthroughs), less "just go to their location and listen to them ramble about their woes."

>>716464267
I don't follow. Mona steals his own spotlight?

>>716461951
Have them alter the ending slightly. Have your girlfriend show up before everyone else to say goodbye first and maybe throw in a fade to black kiss like how Ann and Margaret had with the mcs

>>716465781
>scene where the rest of the gang finds out who you're dating

>>716460612
Social link is there to make the characters more interesting and make them feel like actual people. The only other JRPG series that has something like this I can think of is Tales (and Trails of Cold Steel but that's more outright dick riding than the other series)

>>716463769
To be honest P4 protag destroying the girls at an omelette contest and Nanako pretending everything tastes good because of how happy she was is a great scene

>>716456181 (OP)
I did! I did it and I only slightly regret it!

>>716460612
The "dungeons" in persona are subpar and kind of a backdrop for the persona collecting and fusing autism.
Tartarus was Meh, the TV world was meh. Mementos only exists to pad the game and grind and the palaces are surprisingly small and seemingly intended to be done in a single day even if this ruins the entire pacing of the game because it always leaves you with at least two weeks of nothing to do but social links

>>716461951
Tie them MORE with the actual combat. Have combat stats influence social and viceversa, make more dungeon shit needed to advance links
Persona still has the combat and the VN too separated for my taste, the VN does a lot to ease combat, but combat does barely nothing to ease the VN

>>716465781
Also this, maybe give an extra level to your romance so you actually have a reason to go on dates

>>716456181 (OP)
>>716456234
But they are the 2 best girls of p4
>>716459089
My shogi queen... I wish she was a party member