Thread 717090117

What's a good example of a character design that looks great in 2D but is poorly adapted into 3D and if there's an example where it's the opposite?

Hard Mode: No Sonic or Pokémon

>>717090117 (OP)
why is jimmy giving bedroom eyes

>>717090117 (OP)
Lisa Simpson

>>717090117 (OP)
Street fighter has never looked very good in 3d. More so a problem of capcom z team just being incompetent and 3d models being used in a 2d genre being a retarded idea to begin with

I had a classmate like Jimmy Neutron back in elementary school. We bullied the shit out of him until he killed himself.
I feel kinda bad about it now since that guy was genuinely insanely smart and was already studying university level stuff in his free time. Who knows what he could have done for the world.

>>717090596
My goodness did they massacre Karin and especially Birdie in SFV

For Shantae the 3D fan models ain’t bad but she just works so much better in 2D

Butch Hartman's artstyle is so disgustingly ugly and lazy it's unreal.
His cartoons were the original "CalArts" style of copy and pasting the same bare minimum effort outline.

>>717090723
You think karin got it bad?? Look at my dood ken, they massacred my boy

>>717091371
this is just lazy 3D artist, they didn't even tried to replicate Tezuka's style.

>>717090637
Eddy's cheekbone seems a bit droopy.

2D jimmy looked NOTHING like jimmy.

>>717090117 (OP)
I also saw that Twitter thread!

Edit: thanks for the gold, kind stranger!

>>717090117 (OP)
Fortnite. We are always disappointed

>>717090723
SFV Karin might be the worst conversion/revival of a character ever because while I was never a huge fan of hers in Alpha 3 she at least had a decent design and a fun rekka. SFV Karin has a shit design, removed her rekka outside of the gimped version in VT1, made her an insane mary sue in the shit story mode, and managed to make her High/Top tier the entire lifespan of the game to boot so you could never ignore her. People can shit on SF6 all they want, no veteran got a downgrade as bad as this in that game.

>>717091896
Speaking of Fortnite, Goku

>>717090857
I feel like the fan models try too hard to make her look like a generic anime style when her official art is highly stylized in every game. You can make it work in 3D but the people doing the modeling aren't really trying to.

>>717090669
He was weak willed, he wouldn’t have made it anyway.

>>717092085
Still Better than dbfz, because fortnite at least plays good even if some of the cross over characters look a little rough. And to be honest that whole arcsys celshade shit looks all jaggy and pixelated anyway, it doesnt even look much better

Spyro

>>717092170
looool

>>717091896
that looks great though?

>>717092316
Ultra retard

>>717092170
Considering that that game had skin for batman the animated series that was accurate for the art style, the weirdness of the batman beyond suit doesn't make sense.
Arkham Knight's Batman Beyond suit is cool because it gives the feeling thats what Batman Beyond looks like in the arkhamverse.

>>717091896
You'd make a point but those are all great transitions from the concept art.

>>717092316
>fortnite plays good
Stupid nigger.

Why arcsys fans such cultist fanboys?

>>717092832
why are you a blind retard?

>>717090669
Hey look on the bright side. You're still here, being a good for nothing sack of shit and a waste of human resources for said world like the rest of /v/.

Aren’t there 3D Ace Attorney Games?

3D animation was the original "we're too lazy to draw" before AI.

>>717095162
>lazy
>takes decades before it even looks good in practice
>took weeks to render fucking anything
I also remember too lazy to 'animate' jokes about Hana-Barbara stuff. But both takes man hours, even today, to make look good. Assuming the 2d isn't calarts/tweened strawmen and 3d isn't another flavor of candian cartoon.

>>717095847
it used to be impressive work in the late 90s and 2000s but 3D has become lazy slop today, and you can tell it was around the time Disney dropped 2D for good.

>>717095981
It's not lazy, it's very resource demanding and reliant on a huge ass team if we're talking Dreamworks/Pixar 3D. Even if you were to take out all the poos, that still hundreds of people. Higher-ups fund 3D because it's simply better to sell spectacle on, if there's a sequel you already have models to work with (which I guess you could attribute to laziness), but the same 2D story boarding and roughs are happening.

I'd still argue 2D tween animation is lazier than anything else.

>>717095981
For every rendered image you see in games or film or porn there's probaby another 70% that never made it past the drawing board so I disagree. disagree hard. If you wanna see lazy slop look at renders that people don't care about. also
>complains about 3d being lazy slop
>probably doesn't even draw his own 2d slop
pyw because I don't think non-artist opinions are real

>>717095162
Some of those late 90's 3D cartoons like ReBoot were pushing what they could with the software and hardware, it took a pretty good amount of time before that shit became truly standard. Also funny that Lazy Town used Unreal Engine 3 in some cases. But to be frank, lot of modern 2D is also pretty bad as well. New adaptations of high profile manga for some reason is sullied by cheapening out for terrible shitty animation especially, like with Berserk and HnK.

>>717090117 (OP)
when we have things like Guilty Gear Xrd, there is no point in these discussion.

3D won and if you are a nostalgia nigger, just do cel shading, the tech is already good enough to imitate your shitty 2D style.

>>717093017
Phoenix & Maya (and Missile) are fine in MvC3.

>>717093017
yes, but the models look fine

>>717100596
Lighting is so important to making a 3D game look good. Bloodstained wouldn't be so fucking ugly if it wasn't so hideously lit.

>>717090459
raep

>>717090459
luikoogjes
Never trust someone with eye lids like this.
picrel

>>717091896
that skin on the bottom left must he the ugliest shit ever

>>717091451
i hate the clay-esque artstyle of sfv so much, so many characters look like theyd melt if you put them in the microwave and it has not aged nearly as well compared to 4 or 6

>>717090117 (OP)
i never seen a eddsworld 3D model that looks good

>>717090117 (OP)
Fusionfall immediately comes to mind

>>717103946
I miss the fuck out of the 2D artwork and ingame portraits.