← Home ← Back to /v/

Thread 718409729

170 posts 26 images /v/
Anonymous No.718409729 >>718409974 >>718410018 >>718411917 >>718413821 >>718414081 >>718414374 >>718414417 >>718414683 >>718414973 >>718415175 >>718415204 >>718415230 >>718416802 >>718418009 >>718424378 >>718424381 >>718426770 >>718428457 >>718428468 >>718428663 >>718429829 >>718430445 >>718430538 >>718430596 >>718431192 >>718435540 >>718441631 >>718443064 >>718443486 >>718444453 >>718444625 >>718450249 >>718450528 >>718452047 >>718455665 >>718456735 >>718460197 >>718460710
Monolithsoft
Will Monolith Soft ever make a game that sells at least 5 million or even a 10 million seller?

Are they forever stuck with limited resources and constrained budget cause their games will forever only sell 1.2 million worldwide?

What the fuck do they need to do?
Anonymous No.718409882 >>718412552 >>718419212 >>718456314
>soon
Anonymous No.718409974
>>718409729 (OP)
XB3 could have been that game if they didn’t pull back from the XB2 formula.
Anonymous No.718410018 >>718410420
>>718409729 (OP)
Let the Xenoblade brand rest for a bit and do a new IP.
Xenoblade fans will be there no matter what they come up with.
Anonymous No.718410287 >>718411662 >>718412136 >>718420296 >>718430825 >>718431026 >>718460710
>Retro Studios titles sell 7 million
>Next Level Games title sells 14 million
>EPD title sells 60 million
>Monolith Soft best sales is 2.7 million

Fucking why
Anonymous No.718410420
>>718410018
>Let the Xenoblade brand rest for a bit and do a new IP

Hoping it's this. New IP to expand their portfolio and reach a wider audience. Monolithsoft has yet to show they can make a game that doesn't just pull in a niche anime audience though. Feels like they can only make niche games.
Anonymous No.718411662 >>718413897
>>718410287
Retro and Next Level have taken the easy route and make no original IPs of their own and have sold their soul for safe success by churning out new entries in already popular and highly established Nintendo legacy IPs. Easy sell.

Monolith on the other hand make completely original IPs of their own and success isn't just handed to them. They haven't taken the easy and safe route and sold out by making entries in another companies games.
Anonymous No.718411917 >>718412161 >>718432992
>>718409729 (OP)
Why does every studio need to make massive sellers? They’re doing fine running support and making their own niche stuff on the side.

The last thing I want is for them to start chasing the normalfag dragon. U love Monolith because they make massive games that appeal to dedicated audiences in an age where that almost NEVER happens.
Anonymous No.718412136 >>718412828 >>718430991
>>718410287
Monolith games are very different from other Nintendo IPs, mostly being story focused instead of gameplay focused.
JRPGs are inherently niche and more complex for normalfags to get into than platformers or cart racers. Xenoblade doesn't have the mass appeal that Pokemon has.

Also, most hardcore Nintendo fans are allergic to anime.
They also say Xenoblade has too many games because they unironically think Xenoblade and Fire Emblem are the same thing.
Anonymous No.718412161 >>718412378
>>718411917
>The last thing I want is for them to start chasing the normalfag dragon. U love Monolith because they make massive games that appeal to dedicated audiences in an age where that almost NEVER happens

You can still make RPG that appeals to dedicated audience that sells 6 million. Looks at Elders Scrolls, Witcher 3. Western RPGs that have sold so much.
Anonymous No.718412378 >>718414827
>>718412161
I can’t think of any JRPG series that went after western normalfags and didn’t suffer for it.
Xenobimbo !!YK0s7/VSKnx No.718412552 >>718414186 >>718450370
>>718409882
That's a placeholder for Zelda/Link for their work on the open world zelda games. It has nothing to do with a new IP.
Anonymous No.718412828 >>718413183 >>718414196
>>718412136
Yeah its like a mate of mine who is a Nintendo fan. Loves most things Nintendo (though mostly just Mario and Zelda, plus DK/Metroid, classic Nintendo stuff) but just has no attachment or interest in Xenoblade. Hes completed Definitive Edition back when it released. But has had no interest in 2 and 3 and X:DE. Other people i know who like Nintendo are just silent regarding Xenoblade.

It's weird for a company owned by Nintendo to continue making these large scale RPGs that continue to only sell 1.5 million. Surely they must know the ceiling for Xenoblade in its current state but also must be thinking of ways to sell past that.

Surely Monolith aren't happy with the status quo.
Anonymous No.718413183 >>718413724
>>718412828
Monolithsoft wasn't bought for their games. Monolithsoft was bought for their technology..
Anonymous No.718413661
Bump
Anonymous No.718413724 >>718414050
>>718413183
Nobody really knows the real answer.

Just that Iwata said the games they make is what they want on their platform and the philosophy of Suiguira is the same as theirs.
Anonymous No.718413821 >>718414316 >>718414498
>>718409729 (OP)
Iwonder how much they seething at Sandfall for selling 4 mil with they first ever game
Anonymous No.718413897 >>718414364
>>718411662
>Retro and Next Level have taken the easy route and make no original IPs of their own
Retro's hiatus from 2014 until Prime Remastered was specifically because they spent a long time conceiving an original IP which ended up going nowhere, there are leaked videos of early builds of it that you can look up
DK and the odd exceptions like Luigi's Mansion 2&3 notwithstanding, neither studio's output is significantly more of an "easy sell" than Xenoblade either if you go by sales figures
Anonymous No.718414050
>>718413724
Lately Monolithsoft has been a support studio for various games. They're really good at optimizing games.
Anonymous No.718414081 >>718414169
>>718409729 (OP)
They need to pull a FF and make games being their own universe, people can't keep up with 5 connected jrpgs
Anonymous No.718414169
>>718414081
Literally every Xenoblade game takes place in its own universe
Anonymous No.718414186 >>718419212 >>718456314
>>718412552
>SOON
Anonymous No.718414196 >>718414901 >>718419496
>>718412828
Monolith must feel like Kamiya with Bayonetta 2 and 3, seething seeing those dmc sales while Bayonetta 2 and 3 get way less sales because it's limited to one platform
I mean Nintendo doesn't even bother to advertise Xenoblade saying FROM THE ONES WHO HELPED CREATE BOTW WORLD
Anonymous No.718414279
Monolith is a company focusing on raising beginners for gaming industry. I would like to see their work get more recognition but their primary goal is always experimenting new ideas and facilitating Nintendo projects
Anonymous No.718414316 >>718414498
>>718413821
>Sandfall
I don't think any Japanese developer is seething at E33. It's a niche game there.
On the other hand, if people at Monolith are aware of it, I can see them praising it like Kojima and other westaboo developers did.
Anonymous No.718414364 >>718414667 >>718415026
>>718413897
>Retro's hiatus from 2014 until Prime Remastered was specifically because they spent a long time conceiving an original IP which ended up going nowhere, there are leaked videos of early builds of it that you can look up
>DK and the odd exceptions like Luigi's Mansion 2&3 notwithstanding, neither studio's output is significantly more of an "easy sell" than Xenoblade either if you go by sales figures

So then why does Nintendo keep Retro and Next Level as nothing but vessels for churning Nintendo legacy IPs and Nintendo let's Monolith build a name for themselves through their own original IP they conceived themselves?

Also Retro and Next Level do have an easy ride compared to Monolith. They make games are guaranteed big sellers.
Anonymous No.718414374 >>718450280 >>718450280 >>718450280
>>718409729 (OP)
>Will Monolith Soft ever make a game that sells at least 5 million or even a 10 million seller?
I hope not. That would mean they'll casualized the games.
Anonymous No.718414417 >>718414920
>>718409729 (OP)
Its always possible, Nintendo just needs to market them more. Xenoblade X and 3 were barely marketed by Nintendo America and Europe.
Anonymous No.718414498 >>718415634
>>718413821
>>718414316
The composer of E33's favourite game is Xenoblade, this comparison is meaningless.
Also I noticed that the discord trannies decided to stir away from shitting XB3 on sight to shitposting about sales, how wonderful.
Anonymous No.718414667
>>718414364
>Nintendo let's Monolith build a name for themselves through their own original IP they conceived themselves?
because monolithsoft are genuine fucking wizards, they are some of the best developers in the industry and their environmental design is completely unmatched
Nintendo writes them a blank check in return for cannibalizing their staff for major first party projects, xenoblade 2 was made basically by a skeleton crew while a huge chunk of monolith was working on botw after Nintendo realized how fucking insanely talented they were after xenoblade X
Anonymous No.718414683
>>718409729 (OP)
They contributed heavily with botw/totk so I guess yeah
Anonymous No.718414827 >>718431072
>>718412378
King’s Field to Demon’s Souls is a massive upgrade
Anonymous No.718414901 >>718415223
>>718414196
Xenoblade on switch sold more than FF7 rebirth and barely less than ff16 despite the enormous budget differences (especially with marketing). Sales are also comparible with p3p/metaphor despite those being multiplat. I think they're fine
Anonymous No.718414920
>>718414417
Yeah, they really need to advertise the games more. 2 at least had TV ads, but it feels like they really don't care about advertising the games.
Like fuck, XDE was basically shadow dropped. If it reaches a million sales it will be a miracle.
Anonymous No.718414973
>>718409729 (OP)
F.E.A.R. 4 never
Anonymous No.718415026 >>718417929
>>718414364
>Nintendo let's Monolith build a name for themselves through their own original IP they conceived themselves?

There is no tetsuya takahashi at Retro or Next Level. There is no guy with that kind of pedigree. Takahashi is the guy who made Xenogears, was involved with some of the most popular and acclaimed RPGs of all time, Nintendo respects his talent and his legacy. There's undoubtedly people at Nintendo who are fans of his work and Monolith's passion for making games.

Who the fuck can you point out at Retro and Next Level who have that kind of legacy?
Anonymous No.718415175
>>718409729 (OP)
>Xenoblade X sold poorly on the Wii U, a failed console.

>port it to Switch, a successful console.

>Still sold poorly, couldn’t even make it to 1 million.

Let’s laugh at Elmafags.
Anonymous No.718415204
>>718409729 (OP)
they made Breath of the wild, a 30 million seller.
Anonymous No.718415223 >>718415649
>>718414901
If your only comparison is just 2 shit games trapped in some shitty console...
Even p3r and metaphor sold way less than P5.
Anonymous No.718415230
>>718409729 (OP)
>What the fuck do they need to do?
They're also a support team who have been involved in nearly every open world game Nintendo has released in the past 8 years. Nintendo's acquisition of Monolith Soft is one of the best acquisitions in video game history and no one acknowledges it.
Anonymous No.718415634
>>718414498
>Also I noticed that the discord trannies decided to stir away from shitting XB3 on sight to shitposting about sales, how wonderful.
Wait, we can talk about games!??!?!?!
Anonymous No.718415649
>>718415223
>If your only comparison is just 2 shit games trapped in some shitty console...
No i brought up multiple examples. Do I need to compare them with kiseki or something too? Xenoblade is very successful for a true exclusive jrpg series.
Anonymous No.718416802 >>718416986 >>718417262 >>718418735
>>718409729 (OP)
I think they're incredibly good at making fantasy, fantastical worlds, they just need to lean in on that and they could probably grow a following for a new series. They almost did it with Xenoblade but fucked up with X by making a too-different spinoff rather than a sequel (the Wii U bombing probably didn't help either). Xenoblade 2 showed growth and some recovery but then they fucked up with 3 again. 3 is just super bland and the fucking retards just did a mash-up world of 1 and 2 rather than a new one. Seriously, making amazing worlds to explore is like their #1 strength and then these idiots decide to make the fucking 3rd title in their trilogy by recycling landmarks from the previous 2 and making a mostly empty world dotted with military camps instead of actual cities and settlements. What the actual fuck?

I think they have the talent for a bigger series, but they need to not fuck it up like this. I don't know if Xenoblade can be salvaged at this point. It doesn't have a major fanbase, getting new people to jump into your fucking 5th game in the franchise is hard and the people who are here seem to be deeply divided about the 4 existing games. It's kind of fucked, maybe they'd be better off with a new IP and try to do it right from the start.
Anonymous No.718416986 >>718417376
>>718416802
Thats why they should make every game independent of each other like ff
Anonymous No.718417262
>>718416802
Good points. I somewhat agree.

Hope their next game is a fresh start of a something new. I think a clean slate is the best idea. Leave Xenoblade to rest for a bit.
Anonymous No.718417376 >>718417851
>>718416986
I would love to see that, or at least keep the connections loose like between XC1 and XC2 where they barely touch and you only find out in the ending of XC2.
Anonymous No.718417851
>>718417376
Even Capcom forgets previous points and is starting to use names over numbers to not scare normies away, and those games are not 60 hours long
Anonymous No.718417929
>>718415026
For Retro you can kind of point at Tanabe though he's with Nintendo EPD. He's been in charge of every retro game (not counting the canceled one(s) between tropical freeze and prime remastered)
Anonymous No.718418009
>>718409729 (OP)
>stuck with limited resources and constrained budget
Are you literally braindead?
Anonymous No.718418735 >>718419839
>>718416802
3 sales being lower are due to being a late switch game vs an early one, tracks with every nintendo sequel on the system
Anonymous No.718419212
>>718414186
>>718409882
I think the people who desperately want this to be a reality are the same ones who were deeply impressed by that AI vid of walking in pixel fantasy world that no one would shut up about for a couple days
Anonymous No.718419382
>I think the people who desperately want this to be a realAAAACCCKK
it's real and the fact that both mkworld and bananza started as switch 1 prototypes in the early life of the previous hardware should tell you everything you need to know
Anonymous No.718419496
>>718414196
>Nintendo doesn't even bother to advertise Xenoblade saying FROM THE ONES WHO HELPED CREATE BOTW WORLD
Nintendo aren’t ones to pull those sorts of stunts since it’s all under the nintendo banner anyway. They weren’t advertising splatoon as “from the makers of animal crossing” or arms as “from the makers of MK8”, hell i’m pretty sure most normies don’t even know of there being different EPD teams
Anonymous No.718419839 >>718419964 >>718424053
>>718418735
This sounds like desperate cope, the Switch install base grew tremendously in-between 2 and 3. 3 didn't manage to sell because people didn't like it as much and as such didn't buy it.
Anonymous No.718419964 >>718421591
>>718419839
sales of sequels are generally lower than the first game, tears of the kingdom sold far less than botw and there was a similar pattern with zelda games on previous nintendo consoles
Anonymous No.718420296
>>718410287
Retro Studio hasn't made a game since 2014. In the same timeframe, Monolith released 3 Xenoblade games, two DLC expansions, 3 remakes/remasters on top of helping with multiple Nintendo big hitters like Zelda, Splatoon, Animal Crossing, Mario Kart, etc.
Anonymous No.718421591 >>718421747
>>718419964
>sales of sequels are generally lower than the first game
Do you even apply any thought to what you're typing? XC2 is their best seller and it's the fucking 3rd game in the franchise, not the 1st. It had no problem selling more than the 2 previous XC games. There are plenty of franchises out there which exploded into major success stories with sequels selling far more than the 1st game. This is in fact quite normal, because it's more difficult for unknown IPs to get big sales numbers than something already established and already well-liked.
>tears of the kingdom sold far less than botw
Wow, Zelda: Recycled Game World sold less, just like Xenoblade: Recycled Game World? How could that be? Could it be people bought the earlier games and then weren't as interested in recycled games selling themselves on the past's greatest hits? If only Monolith had the wisdom to fucking see this before deciding to make XC3 into what it is.
Anonymous No.718421747
>>718421591
>and it's the fucking 3rd game in the franchise, not the 1st.
I obviously meant sequels on the same hardware, I thought the context would make it clear but I forgot /v/ is now mostly populated by indonesian and brazilian half-monkeys my bad
Anonymous No.718421892 >>718422221
Hey guys, how's it popping?
Anonymous No.718422221
>>718421892
Not now Al
Anonymous No.718424053
>>718419839
Total install base doesn't mean anything if the active userbase falls off which began happening to the switch around late 2021.
Anonymous No.718424378
>>718409729 (OP)
>What the fuck do they need to do?
Make a good game like XC2, and not a shit game like XC3.
Anonymous No.718424381 >>718426994
>>718409729 (OP)
who fucking cares
takahashi gets to make whatever kino he wants while the other half of the studio supports nintendo's big releases. it's a sustainable model for them.
Anonymous No.718426770
>>718409729 (OP)
They need to take control over Nintendo.
Anonymous No.718426994 >>718427402
>>718424381
>takahashi gets to make whatever kino he wants while the other half of the studio supports nintendo's big releases.

So basically Monolith are always struggling with a lack of manpower during development of their games? Nice one Nintendo!
Anonymous No.718427402 >>718428083
>>718426994
monolith have more than tripled their workforce ever since they were bought by nintendo, are you retarded or one of these buttblasted shitposters seething about nintendo all day every day?
Anonymous No.718428083 >>718428403
>>718427402
Takahashi literally says their biggest challenge they are currently facing is a lack of manpower
Anonymous No.718428403 >>718428593
>>718428083
>obviously talks about the switch 2 added power requiring more people
>this means that they're "always" struggling
real jewish hours in here
Anonymous No.718428457
>>718409729 (OP)
It's run by a massive weeb who curbed his wife for being a better designer than he was. Of course not.
Anonymous No.718428468
>>718409729 (OP)
Honestly its fine as it is, the fanbase is bad enough with this much, imagine if the games sold more
Anonymous No.718428593
>>718428403
They shouldn't be lacking manpower. Nintendo should funnel them some personnel
Anonymous No.718428663 >>718428868
>>718409729 (OP)
BotW, TotK, AC New Horizons, Splatoon 3 and MKWorld all sold over 5M
Anonymous No.718428868 >>718429034 >>718429175 >>718429359
>>718428663
None of those were created by Monolith Soft. They're EPD titles.
Anonymous No.718429034 >>718429272
>>718428868
On the contrary Monolith Soft are credited on all of them.
Anonymous No.718429175
>>718428868
They're credited in the creation of all of them
Anonymous No.718429272 >>718429806 >>718430101
>>718429034
But not as the primary developer like they are for Xenoblade. It's not *their* game in the way a Xenoblade is at all. It was contract work.
Anonymous No.718429294
https://nintendoeverything.com/xenoblade-dev-monolith-soft-sees-19-profit-increase/

>make games with modest budgets that find their audience and make money everytime
>NOOOOOOO THEY SHOULD MAKE TRIPLE AYS EMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES THAT SELL 6 GORILLION COPIES LISTEN TO ME DEAR SIR
why aren't /v/jeets tired of being always wrong
Anonymous No.718429359 >>718429492
>>718428868
You can't divorce Monolith Soft from those games. The the worlds of the Zelda's and MKW clearly draw from Monolith Softs design philosophy
Anonymous No.718429492 >>718429614
>>718429359
I get that but the games weren't conceived, design documented, and thought up by Monolith Soft. They aren't games that Monolith make. They make JRPGs: Xenosaga, Baten Kaitos, Xenoblade. Those are all Monolith Soft games through and through.
Anonymous No.718429614 >>718429953
>>718429492
They are the games monolith make
Anonymous No.718429806
>>718429272
this is moving the goalposts and cope, Monolith soft themselves tell you they were a part of the creation process of these games
Anonymous No.718429829
>>718409729 (OP)
I'll give em one more sale once I finally get around to playing Xenostuff in my backlog.
Anonymous No.718429953 >>718430778 >>718430851
>>718429614
Not in the purest sense.

They are the games Monolith assist Nintendo in developing, who is the primary developer of those games. EPD, to be exact. There's also other companies involved in the development of them besides Monolith, too.

Are we gonna call Xenoblade 3 a Graphinica, inc. game because they assisted Monolith with storyboarding, cinematic direction, animation, 3DCG animation and production management? No.
Anonymous No.718430101 >>718430306
>>718429272
They're more or less co-developers on botw/totk. More monolith staff were on botw than xc2
Anonymous No.718430218 >>718430440
I know I'm going to get attacked for this but I wish tendies dedicated all their shitposting against FF (the mmo one deserves it though fuck mmos) to shill and support Xenoblade instead
Anonymous No.718430306
>>718430101
Yeah they were co-developers, absolutely.

But Zelda Botw/Totk wasn't greenlit because a Monolith Soft employee pitched it to Nintendo. It was conceived by EPD.
Anonymous No.718430440 >>718433020 >>718433651
>>718430218
The worst Xenoshit will be always be a better game than any Final Faggotry.
Anonymous No.718430445 >>718444648
>>718409729 (OP)
I want them to stay where they are
any more popular and their games will become shit
I like how much pyra makes the queers on r/games and /v/ seethe, though ;)
Anonymous No.718430538
>>718409729 (OP)
Monolithsoft just needs to make whatever they want and I will buy it.
Anonymous No.718430596 >>718450602
>>718409729 (OP)
After 3’s censorship it’s gonna be an even longer time unfortunately. Shouldn’t have tried to appeal to the modern audience :/
Anonymous No.718430778 >>718431830 >>718432016
>>718429953
Are you going to go to Monolith Soft and tell them they weren't involvement in the creation of those games? No
Anonymous No.718430825
>>718410287
>Fucking why
Blue ocean strategy, it doesn't sell a lot but appeals to a different audience casting a wider net if potential buyers.
Anonymous No.718430851
>>718429953
>Are we gonna call Xenoblade 3 a Graphinica, inc. game
yes
Anonymous No.718430991
>>718412136
>mostly being story focused instead of gameplay focused.
Nah, people who haven't played it like to say that because they're intimidated by the cutscene count but the reality is that makes up an incredibly small portion of the game as a whole where the main appeal is exploration of these wide landscapes with hidden nooks and crannies everywhere.
Anonymous No.718431026
>>718410287
Fundamental gameplay isn't fun in Xeno games. Lots of people aren't into JRPG combat

>Retro Studios titles sell 7 million
Come on bro, they've not been that successful lately. Their new IP looked like garbage
Anonymous No.718431072
>>718414827
Are you trying to say Demon's Souls was meant to appeal to the west?
Anonymous No.718431192 >>718431792
>>718409729 (OP)
I want to know what secret Jap wizardry they employed to perform miracles on the glorified tablet they were shackled with.
Anonymous No.718431792 >>718431860
>>718431192
Anon I'm going to blow your mind. Power hasn't mattered in years.
Anonymous No.718431830 >>718432016
>>718430778
Where did I say they weren't involved in the creation of Zelda botw/totk? I haven't said this. I just agreed they co-developed the game.

But you're insane if you ever think the gaming media are ever going to say "Zelda BOTW, developed by Monolith Soft". Lmao.

Zelda is primarily made by the Zelda team at EPD. It's their series.
Anonymous No.718431860 >>718431925 >>718432093
>>718431792
I'm going to blow your mind. The switch is a joke and everyone is aware of that fact.
Anonymous No.718431925
>>718431860
its got the most games tho
Anonymous No.718432016
>>718431830
See >>718430778 for gaming media
Anonymous No.718432093
>>718431860
Everyone is apparently aware of this fact and still bought it. Thanks for enlightening me
Anonymous No.718432371 >>718433084 >>718434096
Best obscure JRPG franchise?

Xeno, Ys, Trails or Tales?
Anonymous No.718432992
>>718411917
because OP and his little zoombuddies act like they hold stock in these gaming companies, but don't. They don't own stock in anything and maybe that's why they LARP so hard as pretend investors
Anonymous No.718433020
>>718430440
You wish
Anonymous No.718433084
>>718432371
Xeno isn't obscure.
Anonymous No.718433651 >>718433941 >>718433958 >>718434182 >>718461281
>>718430440
I like Xenoblade but nah
Anonymous No.718433941
>>718433651
He's not wrong. Only 6 and maybe 12 are on par.
Anonymous No.718433958
>>718433651
Why
Anonymous No.718434096
>>718432371
my favorite is Ys but I don't think it's obscure anymore
Anonymous No.718434182
>>718433651
FF always feels like it places a limited on the types of themes it expresses and the depth of its story so that it stays family friendly and appeals to the masses. This is why FF isn't anywhere as interesting to me as a Xeno game is. They feel like they play it too safe.

FF is like the gateway drug to more interesting RPGs.
Anonymous No.718435485
Just give us side content akin to X, characters as detailed as 2 or 3, and main story as integral to gameplay as 1.
Anonymous No.718435540 >>718435906
>>718409729 (OP)
>Will Monolith Soft ever make a game that sells at least 5 million or even a 10 million seller?

they already do. they provide extra manpower for nintendo's main AAA titles
Anonymous No.718435906 >>718438132
>>718435540
Pretty sure if Xenoblade sold 7 or 10 million then it would benefit them in ways much greater than if Nintendo's games they assist on are selling that much mate.
Anonymous No.718437815 >>718439340
They should re-release Xenosaga I&II
Anonymous No.718437929
OP is a retard and this thread is worthless trash
Anonymous No.718438132
>>718435906
It would benefit them the same
Anonymous No.718439340
>>718437815
Sadly that's Namco Bandai's decision.
Anonymous No.718439963
Monolith made Breath of the Wild's world using what they learned from making X. Breath of the Wild then created a massive open world trend that inspired an entire console generation. It also notably inspired Genshin Impact, which has led to a Renaissance in gacha shit and/or big titty anime girls from China and Korea.

The last 10 years of video games all descended from Xenoblade. They could sell zero copies and still be worth it for the R&D.
Anonymous No.718440564 >>718441387
JRPG's for the people who hate JRPG's, that's why your crap doesn't sell.
Anonymous No.718441320 >>718442087 >>718442958
>make a fully openworld RPG with giant robots that gets posted constantly as what Nintendo consoles are capable of (ie in response to Pokemon graphics, etc), on Wii U
>doesn't even sell a million on Switch when every previous Xenoblade on Switch did
>the people who LIKE Xenoblade didn't even show up for the one that's meant to be the proof of their amazing arcane technological wizardry that they sprinkle in every first party Nintendo game
Anonymous No.718441387
>>718440564
That's called Pokemon
Anonymous No.718441631
>>718409729 (OP)
Monolith games aren't supposed to be system sellers they're meant to up the prestige of the system so people can see it's home to acclaimed JRPGs even if they themselves don't sell that much. And Monolith is a co-developer on open world Zeldas which Nintendo takes into account when allocating budget for Xeno games. Monolith is safe.
They're in similar situation HAL was with Kirby before Forgotten Land exploded in popularity.
Anonymous No.718442087 >>718442453 >>718444952
>>718441320
The mmo influence was turned up to 11 for this game. The main story and characters are very weak for series standards (and no, side quests don't make up for that), NLA is literally incomplete, and there's no quests you can do to change that, terrible grind, forced online integration and character customization means the protagonist has no character.
Anonymous No.718442215
>standards
Anonymous No.718442234
I still think they're working on a new IP that is "targeting the global market" as they said in the original recruitment page and we should see it soon

I still haven't seen any counterargument to the game existing besides the fact it hasn't been shown yet which is meaningless especially now that we know switch 2 launch year games like MKW and DKB started development roughly at the same time as this project
Anonymous No.718442453 >>718444952
>>718442087
This. For a series praised for its great use of cinematic choreographed cutscenes to deliver an epic story, it falls wide of the mark. The added chapter is more of what people want though (the writing just wasn't it).
Anonymous No.718442613
JRPG players like Magitek, not Gundam. X could've been successful if Skells looked more like Mechon, Artifices, Levnises, etc.
Anonymous No.718442947 >>718443001 >>718443091 >>718447551
https://x.com/MONOLITHSOFT/status/1957608588396150954?t=VZgvOG2abRVmHjv41bhs4g&s=19

Monolith resumes operations today.
Anonymous No.718442958
>>718441320
XCX is only REALLY good on a blind playthrough. It could have been fun to replay with the semi-randomized loot but unfortunately party members don't matter and skell combat sucks dick anyway
Anonymous No.718443001
>>718442947
>japanese companies get summer vacations
what the FUCK bros
Anonymous No.718443064 >>718443247 >>718443247 >>718443247 >>718451952 >>718455830 >>718456205
>>718409729 (OP)
>Will Monolith Soft ever make a game that sells at least 5 million or even a 10 million seller?

Why? There's nothing in those games that warrant even 1 million. XB2 only sold 2 million because of all the coomer shit.
Gameplay wise their games are good for "jRPG standards" but really bad overall.
Lore is nice but isn't really that deep, just unnecessarily overconvoluted. And it's also full of inconsistencies and contradictions. None of the worlds they create really makes sense if you think about it, even for fiction standards. And whatever is good about the lore is ruined by the awful shonen/children anime plot delivery. Playing those games feels like if Pokemon anime was set in the world of GitS + Evangelion.
Graphics and music aren't bad but nothing special. The soundtrack is above average I guess.


If Nintendo really wants to make money from Monolith they should just ask them to make some xenogatchashit instead of xenoshit.
That'd probably print money.
Anonymous No.718443091
>>718442947
I'm not at all scanning the room behind Eunie and Mio...

A nice small peek into Monolith's Tokyo studio.
Anonymous No.718443247
>>718443064
>None of the worlds they create really makes sense if you think about it, even for fiction standards.

Neither does the fucking Mushroom Kingdom mate but people still love it.

>>718443064
>awful shonen/children anime plot delivery

Sounds like it fits right in with Nintendo then.

>>718443064
>Playing those games feels like if Pokemon anime was set in the world of GitS + Evangelion.

This sounds cool.
Anonymous No.718443486
>>718409729 (OP)
They could start by making games that aren't shit again.
Anonymous No.718444350 >>718444374
Kill retards like OP
Anonymous No.718444374
>>718444350
:(
Anonymous No.718444453
>>718409729 (OP)
Honestly I don't really care. If they can maintain what they do now as well as helping out Nintendo with their bigger games, I'll be happy.
Anonymous No.718444625 >>718444761
>>718409729 (OP)
>>718399352
>1.2 million
Is this some schizo retard? XC2 has sold over 2 million.
Anonymous No.718444648
>>718430445
> their games will become shit

Too late
Anonymous No.718444761
>>718444625
I fucking hate jannies

they instant shitcan threads about certain ecelebs and let garbage like that reach bump limit
Anonymous No.718444882 >>718454834
Monolith still busy working for the LOTR mines?
Anonymous No.718444952
>>718442087
>>718442453
the entire company is praised for its environments and technological wizardry and neither of those did jackshit for their own title where they shine most
Anonymous No.718447551
>>718442947
I wonder how many Miofags are in Monolithsoft.
Anonymous No.718449472
I want an all new cast for the next game with no ties to previous characters.
Anonymous No.718450249
>>718409729 (OP)
Soma Bringer remake
Anonymous No.718450280
>>718414374
>>718414374
>>718414374
/thread
Anonymous No.718450370
>>718412552
It's on a separate recruitment page from their Zelda page. You know this.
Anonymous No.718450528
>>718409729 (OP)
Only if they accept being better off with working on more "mainline" Nintendo franchises like they did with Zelda. The true strategy behind hard-catering to weebs like they pivoted towards with XB2 has almost always been quantity of games (or content if gacha) sold, not high quantities of copies per game. They're not as large in numbers but are still painfully easy to milk. MonSoft is still figuring that bit out, and considering they helped with both Zelda Asscreed games, which were 30 mil sellers, I wouldn't count on it.
Anonymous No.718450602 >>718452165
>>718430596
>3’s censorship
Didn't happen, you're trolling.
Anonymous No.718451952
>>718443064
>if Pokemon anime was set in the world of GitS + Evangelion.

The inverse version of this that isn't teenaged retardation sounds like a baller idea that I'm upset isn't a thing.
Anonymous No.718452047
>>718409729 (OP)
Nothing good can come of chasing casual and mainstream audiences for money

Stop being such a greedy fag, there's more important things than sales and money
Anonymous No.718452165 >>718460730
>>718450602
>Didn't happen
Maybe so but the designs were lamer.
Anonymous No.718454834
>>718444882
Sorry you had to find out this way but Monolith is dead. WB killed them through chronic mismanagement.
This thread is about Monolith Soft.
Anonymous No.718455665
>>718409729 (OP)
>Will Monolith Soft ever make a game that sells at least 5 million or even a 10 million seller?

of course not. gotta do something about the gameplay loop first between the battle system and not loading up their game with fetch quests and they might have something to work with.
Anonymous No.718455830
>>718443064
>GitS + Evangelion
Those are good inspirations though.
Anonymous No.718456205
>>718443064
>Playing those games feels like if Pokemon anime was set in the world of GitS + Evangelion.
That sick actually.
Anonymous No.718456314 >>718460603
>>718409882
>>718414186
This early art looks like a monkeypaw just like Metaphor did, I'm pretty sure they gonna change it to something faggy
Anonymous No.718456735 >>718456852
>>718409729 (OP)
Maybe if they stop with the uber dogshit braindead auto attack combat system that is worse than WoW at launch in 2004?
Anonymous No.718456852
>>718456735
Never
Anonymous No.718459202
bros...i miss endless frontier gang...
Anonymous No.718459959
What's woth all the anti-Xeniblade spam recently?
Trannies getting uppity.
Anonymous No.718460197 >>718460674
>>718409729 (OP)
Why would I care? For me, they can just continue making games as is.
But to answer your question, they would need to make it more accessible. An action RPG with anime toned down would do that, but do we want that?
BTW, 7 million is a lot of fucking sales. It would make it one of the biggest games in the world
Anonymous No.718460603
>>718456314
It's a recruitment poster, just like the one from Metaphor.
In both cases not even a single line of code existed for the game existed when the poster was made.
Anonymous No.718460674
>>718460197
ethel owes me sex
Anonymous No.718460710 >>718460958
>>718409729 (OP)
>>718410287
Their games don't sell because they make the most blatantly worthless coomslop for waifubrained retards. Anyone without autism takes one look at Japanese Humor.webm and swears off the game forever.
Anonymous No.718460730
>>718452165
>lamer
But more in-line with Saga/XB1&X designs, you goddamn 2-secondary
Anonymous No.718460958
>>718460710
I'm trans btw
Anonymous No.718461281
>>718433651
Pretty much, Xenoblade is still too animu with barely any memorable scenes