Thread 718976941

Did she even do anything wrong? Joel killed her dad

Yes

>>718976941 (OP)
>let me sacrifice this 100th child so far, this time we will surely create a cure

>>718978902
According to the audio logs, they’d never found a case of true immunity before. Ellie was the first. And even Joel never doubts it would work

Ah yes, another thread where the pathetic TLOUfag will spend hours arguing and trying to justify some retarded gorrila caving in an old man’s skull because he didn’t let a bunch of retarded terrorists kill a 14 year old girl for a cure they couldn’t make an knew it
>b-but he didn’t care about the cure
Doesn’t change reality or that they couldn’t have made it. The fact that cuckman had to step in and say “um ackshually they could have” is just another way of showing how ass the writing of this fucking game is.

>>718978978
But Marlene and Jerry do. Not to mention they literally go to cut her open right from jump with no tests or anything in some dirty ass hospital room.

>>718976941 (OP)
xir trooned out and had gay buttsex

>>718978978
Better yet, Ellie thought that they'd go to other places after visiting the Fireflies. Meaning, that she had no intention of dying because of her condition.

>>718976941 (OP)
No, but the cycle of violence should have continued. There was no reason whatsoever for Ellie not to kill Abby. I don't care what the consequences are, if somebody beat my father to death I would disembowel them. Anything less would be spitting on his grave, saying the life of his murderer is more important than his.

>>718976941 (OP)
killing is badong

>>718979159
Who would have given a shit about Abby at that point? The pooner? Just kill it too.

>>718979159
>There was no reason whatsoever for Ellie not to kill Abby.
Except for the fact that Abby didnt kill Ellie after she killed Owen and Mel. The cycle of violence ended there

>>718979365
absolutely retarded
>i have to get revenge for my dad but not my friend because cycle of violence is LE BAD

>>718976941 (OP)
She never once questions what her dad did to be killed. Family isn't an excuse. She should have been killed and Tel Aviv Druckmann can't write.

>>718979752
Ellie already knew Joel murdered innocent people when he was a raider. She should have accepted he got what was coming to him

Ellies community didn't do anything for her compared to abbys

>>718979229
We should fight for the opposite... gnodab

she was in a mediocre story that's what she did wrong

>>718979893
And Abby knew the fireflies were terrorists and should have accepted that her dad dying was just part of the job. Especially given how retarded the fireflies are.

Hot Take: Abby's motive (avenging her father) makes sense. The situation that allowed her to act on that motive absolutely did not. It was contrived bullshit that relied on a cucked version of Joel doing literally everything he would never have done in the first game to make it possible for her group to kill him off.

>>718979365
>The cycle of violence ended there
If somebody killed an immediate family member my new goal in life is killing them. I don't care what their reasons are or what they did in between the murder and when I finally catch up to them.
Abby is justified in killing Joel but Ellie is justified in killing Abby. If Abby had family then her family would be justified in killing Ellie.

>>718976941 (OP)
I haven't played the game yet, but how did she get a whole group of people including a fucking pregnant woman to go on a revenge quest of a murder years ago?

>>718976941 (OP)
does it even make sense that she fucking lost? she should've destroyed ellie

>>718981324
she'd been left to bake in the sun for 3 days and before that a slave for like 4 months or how ever long it takes ellie to find her

>>718976941 (OP)
it's Joelver

>>718979365
killed the guy thats fucking her but fucking another woman and that woman
tugging at abbys heart right there

>>718976941 (OP)
How would you kill Abby if you get the chance?
I would cut off Abby's fingers, drive nails into the finger stumps and then heat the nails

>>718982329
Simple gunshot. Nothing dramatic, nothing that takes any effort or thought. Then just leave her to get eaten.

>>718976941 (OP)
To me it's more weird that she doesn't understand why Joel did what he did. They were not team Good People to begin with. I don't blame her character - I blame the shitty writing.

>>718981426
My canon ending is that Ellie sees them on the cross and then walks back (to Jackson) and then I uninstall. I would've shot them both like that but the game sadly doesn't allow that.

>>718978978
They killed a hundred kids for nothing. They had to die

>>718983885
Nah. They had a few infected subjects who were gonna die anyway. No mention of children

>>718978978
She so cute :3

>>718980720
>cucked version of Joel
The night before that morning was when Ellie told him she forgave him.
He would've probably helped even a clicker.

>>718979097
she knew what she was getting into, she just didn't say anything because she knew that'd hurt Joel.

>>718980720
Tommy was the one giving their names to Abby, Joel couldn't exactly lie after that.

>>718978983
I will never play the sequel because of this
the moral ambiguity of it is what made the ending so great and to double down on it is some faggot cuck writing I hate that fucking jew as soon as he took full control

>>718976941 (OP)
>She

Roid Abby is the funniest thing ever. How are people supposed to pretend she doesn't look like a teenager boy on roids?

>>718986520
having the abby a guy would've made the story slightly more bearable (cut the sex scene too)

>>718976941 (OP)
I have nothibg against Abby. I understand her motivation. Family matters.