Thread 719161881

Whats the problem

>>719163030
there's no rhythm involved

>>719163208
There definitely is. It just also tests accuracy.

>>719163297
wrong
>combo means more than accuracy
>aim is more important than tapping in rhythm
in conclusion, rhythm is secondary which immediately disqualifies it from being an actual rhythm game

>>719163208
you click the circles to the beat anon

>>719163402
see >>719163391

>>719163391
No, I'm right. You said there was no rhythm involved. Now you're saying there's some rhythm involved, it's just ancillary. I'm not gonna get into the weeds on that because I don't care enough.

>>719163628
clearly you care enough or you wouldn't be replying
true I misspoke by saying there's no rhythm involved, however rhythm taking a secondary focus to accuracy disqualifies osu from being a real rhythm game

>>719163718
>>719163494
>>719163391
>>719163208
>>719161881 (OP)
>>get answer
>don't like it
>stomp feet, put fingers in ears, go "LALALALALALALA"

>>719163819
nice mass reply queer

>>719163872
Nice faggot thread.

>>719163939
thanks for the bump lol

>>719163718
Let me rephrase: I don't have a strong opinion as to whether or not accuracy or rhythm is more important in Osu!. What I did care about was settling the record on it testing your rhythm.

>>0719163974
>DENIES NOTHING I SAID
LMAO

thanks for the (You) lol

>>719163208
how would anyone know theres no rhythm? this is a still image. the rhythm is only a rhythm with the music

>>719163819
kek
op you can dislike things, it's okay. just don't claim that osu isn't a rhythm game just because you also need to move your mouse lmao
if every rhythm game was just clicking a button to the beat then that'd be a bit boring, wouldn't it? that's why you also autistically wave your hands around in chunithm and beat a drum in taiko.

Are rhythm games good with the use of a controller? or is keyboard the better pick?

>>719165190
Depends on the mechanics, is it like guitar hero? Gamepad, is it like OSU? Mouse, is it 'Stepmania', Keyboard.

>>719161881 (OP)
Would osu! be more interesting if there was a scoring system tied to how close to a center of a circle you tap?

>>719165443
It uses 6 buttons in total, 3 for left the rest for right. This btw
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2190220/Touhou_Danmaku_Kagura_Phantasia_Lost/
I used to play a lot of Osu! back then but I lost my edge after years.

>>719165190
Most of the fun with rhythm games comes from input method. VSRG's like stepmania, etterna, DJMAX are most straightforward with no concern for input, which are best played with keyboard. If the game has an associated input mechanism like IIDX or Popn then it's best played with it.

>>719165746
Keyboard > Gamepad in this scenario.

>>719165746
keyboard will be more comfortable than anything for 6k
I use
>a s d l ; '
for rhythm games

>>719165190
osu's great on a keyboard and mouse combo for most people, but in almost all other cases a specialized controller (like a taiko drum, tasoller or ddr mat) will be the most fun way to play any rhythm game.

>>719161881 (OP)
Osu is gay as fuck
Play the original games on DS or fuck off

>>719166026
Original games on DS (Elite Beats) don't have song mapping, thus only a set playlist of songs to master, OSU is literally any song you want. OSU is the new Audio Surf, unironically cope.

>>719166107
Enjoy your unfocused slop
Majority of people charting songs suck dick at it

>>719166182
>slop
concession accepted NPC, i'll be sure to vet the millions of songs for decent charting, while you play Canned Heat by Jamiroquai for the 50th time.

>>719166107
man, i loved audiosurf. shame the 2nd one died.
>>719165746
good pick. keyboard's the best way to play definitely.

>>719165190
You can play Groove Coaster and Muse Dash with controller, but other games are ither better on keyboard or with their specialized controllers.

>>719163208
depends on the map

>>719166107
but audiosurf is a nothing game

>>719165190
Playing with oversized buttons are the most fun.

osu is an anti-game like touhou its only played by people who are no longer human and just consume retard serum all day

I love this game more than I should. Not particularly a good fighter or rhythm game on their own, but it's an interesting experience. Bonus points if you love visual/character designs and cel-shading.

>>719165746
Good choice, DanKagu has a really good soundtrack. Keyboard definitely, the game was primarily built for keyboard and touchscreen if you play on Switch.

>>719166342
Don't be mistaken, I've long past moved on from Elite Beat Agents
There are other, better rhythm games to play than the tired old Osu format
You fuckers play one game

>>719161881 (OP)
of course it's a rhythm game, it's just a rhythm game for people who don't like rhythm games

>>719167215
It's a free rhythm game, what did you expect?

>>719167190
I liked Hi-Fi Rush, but people only fixate on one side-character's haircut to even look into it. Parappa 1, 2, Guitar Hero 1, Rhythm Tengoku/Fever and Audio Surf were my earliest. I got on my first DDR pad when I got Mario's DDR for gamecube.
OSU is just the best form of that format, and the mapping helps. The mapping helps Audio Surf or Clone Heroes, this is not a mutually exclusive pro at all. Just one that outweighs the polish EBA has, with less compressed DS audio, that's all.
I was going to get into that Dead as Disco beatemeup, but apparently the musical elements are surface level and nothing is to the beat. Right now my only 'Rhythm Game' is the DMC series.

>>719165190
project diva works really well with a controller.
you can make keyboard work with most games but your specific keyboard might not be good if it has ghosting/ polling rate issues
desu though the controller is what makes most rhythm games fun

>bro just play this game that no one plays except me and my 3 buddies from this obscure rhythm game forum, it has 30 different songs and only costs 50$, you'll also need a 200$(+300$ transport fees) custom controller from japan to play comfortably but it's not that expensive considering how high quality the game is! and if you get bored of replaying the same songs they offer map packs, 10 songs for only 20$ it's totally worth it. This game is so much better than osu, there's a little mascot dancing on the side of the screen whenever you press a key!
Thank you but I think I'll just stick to the free game with infinite content and an active community

>>719167539
>Right now my only 'Rhythm Game' is the DMC series.
Post disregarded

>>719167634
Nero's mechanics and timing Royal Guard relies on enemy/boss patterns. But you got through my post, so I'm happy still.

>>719167631
lunatic rave and beatoraja are free with literal tens of thousands of accessible charts online free of charge

>>719168082
Could've opened with that, rather than make everything a virtual toy fight.

>>719167539
based. the dynamic battle themes help with that rhythm game feel in dmc 5. i wish more action games would do that sorta thing.
hi-fi rush was also pretty great, yeah.

>>719165862
>>719166007
>>719166701
>>719167113
>>719167619
Thanks for your answers. I used to play a lot of arcade games back then, stuff like Drum Mania Step Mania and DDR. I'm just old now.
>>719165863
>>719165912
>>719166615
Noted, my thanks.
>>719167156
I kinda miss the touch controls for this one, I just need to get used to it and good in the end.
>DanKagu has a really good soundtrack
Tell me about it, I used to listen to a lot of 2hu remixs and fan stuff.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weoBi803430

>>719165190
I prefer touch screen.

>>719168389
I hope they lean into co-op play for 6, 5 was kinda co-op with the Featuring system. Wish all of 5 was duo-able.

Play IIDX

>>719168935
uhhh

>>719169228
What?

>>719168603
Phantasia Lost is the port/continuation of the mobile gacha game that got EoS'd by DeNA some years ago, but the game was very popular in Japan and it got a lot of support from both players and doujin circles, so the game ended with over 100 songs, both old and new. The PC version now has all of the songs from the original game along a whole bunch of new DLC.

>>719168780
i doubt they actually will, but it'd be pretty fun, yeah.
they did add a pretty alright co-op mode for the bloody palace in the dmc3 switch port. i hope it's a sign of things to come.

>>719168935
I do sometime at the Round1, can go up to Level 5 or so before I start to fall apart
But dance games are my true love

>>719168935
Play BMS.

>>719161881 (OP)
osu! isn't even that bad compared to shit like Geometry Dash. That's how you should really start a rhythm bait thread. "Oy bruv hit these completely obtuse frame perfect presses to be considered best in the world."
>look inside
>it's a guy tapping maybe 20 times and somehow he's rewarded with tons of street cred in whatever score system they use because they're all frame perfect presses that have nothing to do with the song in even the slightest capacity
woooooooow

>>719161881 (OP)
>playing community based "rhythm" games ever
Games like Osu make me appreciate professional charters more.

>>719165190
DJMAX Respect was designed with gamepads in mind and you can play all the charts up to MX difficulty with one. SC charts in Respect V are keyboard exclusive though.

>Want to get into game
>Feel too old to start
>Live in apt complex
>Seems high apm
fuck

>>719173757
>>Live in apt complex
why would this stop you

>>719174920
Noise complaints.

>>719174976
if people hearing you pressing keys on a keyboard through the walls, your apartment is ghetto enough that it won't matter

>>719163718
Try playing a real instrument, like a guitar. Accuracy (i.e. hitting all the right notes) is a prerequisite for keeping the rhythm. A talented guitarist will do both in that order.
Playing a song with just the right finesse while keeping the beat is a deeply satisfying experience, and is fundamentally what makes rhythm games enjoyable.

>>719163819
>LA LA LALA, LA LA LALA
>tap tap taptap, tap tap taptap
Many such cases