Thread 719737387

This was from 2008, what has changed since then?

>>719737387 (OP)
/v/'s top game now is some gacha

>moviegames and rpgslop
/v/ always had shit taste

>>719737387 (OP)
>all of those ties
like 10 people probably voted on this, who cares

I'm guessing Smash bros brawl just came out and they were still riding the hype of it granted Brawl was the pinnacle of a hypetrain with all the info we received before it was released

>>719738061
Brawl would have been one of the greatest games ever if Sakurai didn't sperg out and ruin the gameplay

>>719737387 (OP)
Holy shit. Somehow even with the absolute pleb tier state of the site today, the oldtrannies actually had worse taste in games. Was this board just always shit?

>>719737387 (OP)
>worst mainline pokemon game (in 2008)
>best game of all time
/v/ has always been retarded.

>>719737387 (OP)
Did anyone that didn't obsess over Nintendo's shit vote here?
Jesus.

>>719738429
yes they voted for metal gear and starcraft and deus ex and so on, you can read the results here >>719737387 (OP)

>>719737387 (OP)
modern /v/s list would be full of gacha games

>>719737387 (OP)
remove the blizzslop and I'll agree

>>719737387 (OP)
Honestly? It's a lot more quiant than some enlightened list clearly produced by a higher caliber of anon. Pokemon that high is fucking crazy. So I Brawl over Melee. And MGS4.

Most of the rest is perfectly agreeable but obviously pretty surface level

>>719738061
Pretty much.

These days I evaluate top-anything lists as such:
If there's nothing I hate, the list is fine even if I don't agree with it.
If there's something I hate, someone must die.

This list is fine.

>>719738557
There's a reason why VP exists.

>>719739282
So someone can take the president's place in the event of his death?

>>719737387 (OP)
the biggest offense I take is a pokemon game being #1 when pokemon games have never had good gameplay

people born in 2008 are 17 years old.

>>719737387 (OP)
Pokemon Gen 2 is objectively the worst before it went 3D and Brawl is shit. Doesn’t really differ from any poll made these days though

>>719738348
>gsc
>worse mainline

most of the old good charts you see were made by oldfags

most threads in this goddamn board nowadays with 200+ replies are guaranteed to be about politics one way or another

I've been here for 15 years and I still don't understand /v/'s obsession with Nintendo.

lmao why is mgs4 there

Who has the best Top 25?

>>719737387 (OP)
I don’t agree with the list at all but there’s no truly bad games on it so its fine.

>>719739885
Contrary to what some say, /v/ loved the game back when it was released

>>719739885
It had a good online multiplayer and it does do some interesting stuff.

i forget how much of a chokehold pokemon had on vidya back then
im glad people woke up and realized they were just children

>>719737387 (OP)
all of those are extremely solid games
wow /v/ not being full of faggots for once

>>719737387 (OP)
We hate Pokemon, MGS4, Chrono Trigger, and MM, and OoT now.

Nearly every game on this list is either mediocre or terrible.

>>719738348
Shut up Hoennbabby

>>719739919
Me nigga

>>719738348
In 2008 worst mainline was Ruby and Sapphire. They were public enemy #1 for not connecting with GSC

>>719740931
they will forever be public enemy #1 for me for that reason. I hate that they got rid of so many features, pokemon, locations, etc etc

>>719740782
>transistor
>3rd best game ever made
LMAO
It's not even the 3rd best game from Supergiant

>>719739919
Dam blizzard really sucked so much in recent years that warcraft 3, starcraft, and diablo 2 all got taken out

>>719740782
>Gravity Rush 2

I mean its a pretty looking game but its pretty fucking boring bro

>>719737387 (OP)
Huh, old 4chan really was just proto-reddit.

>>719741406
Red a cute and the combat is transcendent. The Turn() mechanic that lets you queue up actions is genuinely one of the most interesting and well designed mechanics I've ever seen introduced to an action game. If you're good enough at Turn() the game transforms from an action game into a puzzle game because you can actually 1 Turn() many of the encounters with the right build and game plan. Plus the art and the music and narrative are all second to none. There's quite literally nothing better than a woman who is still devoted to the love of her life when he's lost everything, even his physical body, it's the type of pure love most men don't even let themselves dream of. It's an absolutely beautiful game from the mechanics to the story to the music, art, everything, just perfection.

Tldr post yours then faggot

>>719741819
t. Gravitylet, you can do insane things with Lunar and Jupiter added onto the control scheme from the first game

Granted, I'm sure the amount of fun is diminished without the online, since that was a really great outlet for all of your gravity shifting tech between the races and treasure hunts. But I played it before it lost features so I get to rate it accordingly

>>719739705
>shit pokemon distribution
>terrible plot that ends with anticlimactic battle against a literal who admin who doesn't even get a name until the equally as shit remake 11 years later
>most gym leaders don't even use the new Pokemon
>elite 4 starts at level 40, not only making it the lowest elite 4 start by 6 levels, but meaning that you wont be able to use some of your favourite pokemon (ex Dragonite) until half way through the postgame without sweeping every gym
>evolution item distribution is terrible
>still fighting level 25 shitmons in the grass all the way through the postgame kanto
>Kanto is barren as fuck with most things gutted outright and the gyms are a cakewalk
GSC are absolutely the worst, it's just going though a little short boring region full of Kanto shitmons

>>719737387 (OP)
>one of the worst pokemon games
???????????????????????????????

>>719743352
I can hear angry horns through the internet lmao

>>719737387 (OP)
>what has changed since then?
Gen z got older. Most weren't even born yet.

>>719743352
Same old meme arguments from those gay video essays that started to pop up in the late 2010s

>>719737387 (OP)
Pokefags got their own board.

>>719737387 (OP)
Damn thats redditcore as fuck.

>>719737387 (OP)
>what has changed since then?
4chan is brown now

>>719737387 (OP)
>v's top games
Nobody asked me

>>719743352
100% correct on everything here except the plot, yet GSC is still the king.

>>719737387 (OP)
Worse top video games of all time poster i ever seen who the fuck made this shit. Not even mentioning any COD game like it didnt up lift gaming wtf

>>719744357
People have always bitched about the level curve and shit encounter tables in GSC. You being being a barely sentient retard until 2018 doesn't make the games good.

>>719739502
Jesus Christ man

>>719743352
>plot in pokemon
>he thinks the radio tower is the last boss
Retard

>>719739919
2012 /v/

boomers actually liked Gen 2?

>>719737387 (OP)
No one on here likes Pokemon anymore and it's considered cool to shit on about half of these and claim they were never good and that /v/ always hated them

>>719737387 (OP)
Why 28?

>>719739919
IGN Reader Highest Rated Games (End of 2004)
98 – The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998) (10,000 ratings)
97 – Chrono Trigger (1995)
97 – Half-Life 2 (2004)
96 – Metroid Prime 2: Echoes (2004
96 – Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2004)
96 – Super Metroid (1994)
96 – The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past (1992)
96 – SoulCalibur (1999)
96 – GoldenEye 007 (1997)
96 – Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (2004)
96 – Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal (2004)
96 – Panzer Dragoon Saga (1998)
96 – Radiant Silvergun (1998)
95 – Perfect Dark (2000)
95 – Metroid Prime (2002)
95 – Final Fantasy VI (1994)
95 - Metal Gear Solid (1998)

>>719748661
>IGN

>>719748661
>Ratchet and Clank 3 above 2
So tired of this garbage take

>>719739206
I like this perspective anon. I too will start looking at lists like this the same way

>>719739919
Everything sucks

>any zelda above any ff game between 4 and 10
LOL, LMAO EVEN

>Pokémon #1
>mgs4 ranked at all
>no ff7 anywhere
troll list

>fallout 2 instead of fallout 1
awful

>>719738262
It's a fake list, /v/ at the time basically shat on Nintendo non-stop for being casual kiddie shit, it was mostly a PC board

>>719737387 (OP)
>most of current /v/ is too young to have played any these

>>719737387 (OP)
Fallout 2 should be switched with Fallout 1

>>719737387 (OP)
best (nintendo) game of all time, /v/ grew up

>>719739502
>we are closer to the year 2050 than 2000

>>719737387 (OP)
>Team Fortress II
>System Shock II
>Fallout II
>clearly have 2 in the title, not roman numerals
>HL2 and SH2 are fine
why

>>719737387 (OP)
>>>>Pokemon
stopped reading

>>719737387 (OP)
Red = ones I didnt play.

>>719750972
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA TAKE ME BACK

>>719737387 (OP)
dark souls came out and mogged oot

>>719752296
you should really play starcraft and diablo 2, they're both excellent games

>>719752296
Don't play any of the goyslop you missed. PC gaming is pretty much a meme until like 2011 and then its really only good for the best version of multiplats

>>719739919
>no twilight princess no where to be found
>w*nd waker shows up on /v/ 2012 top 25
Thats it i think im finally done with this site. Was a good run yall.

>>719737387 (OP)
That is a terrible fucking list good lord. Nintenbabies and Kojima wankery. Insufferable.

Brood War is still the best RTS of all time

>>719752296
Youve never played tf2? Well damn. Nows not a great time to start but its hands down the best multiplayer fps ever made. Just dont touch casual mm that shit is what killed the game

>>719753302
I dont really play online games. I pretty much only play single player games

>>719737387 (OP)
>GSC over OOT
I love Gen 2 but fuck that is a weird placement.

>>719745464
>always
An annoying vocal minority like you perhaps but not enough people to turn them against the game itself. The trolling only became even more apparent once those video essays took off.

>>719750192
>>no ff7 anywhere
fucking retard. ff7 was gamefags shit. mobile killed this website

>>719741406
Spine of the World is the best song ever composed for a video game.

>>719755754
whatever you say newfag

>>719758076
>cloud and his big buster sword is so cool xD
kys

>>719752756
Silence, consolebaby. The adults/white people are talking.

4chan used to be an american website
These are games Americans like

>>719737387 (OP)
Obama

>>719758836
Brown internet theory is true. Grim.

>>719737387 (OP)
All the older PC gamers left and "Gameplay above all" came into vouge.

>>719737387 (OP)
I thought Shadow of the Colossus was disappointing. There's so little content that you had fans speculating there were hidden secrets.

(I think there was but nothing significant)

>>719737387 (OP)
Gold & Silver deserve the win.

>>719737387 (OP)
Gen2GODS reign supreme.