Thread 720631646

>A
>actual monster with a non-humanoid design which could be interesting and opens new game mechanics
>0 to no sex appeal except to freaks
>B
>girl with halloween makeups
>fucking boring but appeals to the general audience
which design is better for the following roles in a game?
>MC
>NPC
>enemies
>Bosses
>Love interests

>>720631646 (OP)
>A

>>0 to no sex appeal
now i must disagree...

that aside, whoever convinced /v/ en masse that there can be one overall solution and the other one is always haram, ie "a female character must ALWAYS bee sexy and never weird, ugly or monsterous" has effectively proven that people here are often simpleminded unintelligent idiots who cannot see a real issue so instead they latch onto patterns they understand and disregard context
this really depends on the game, either design could work in any of the roles you mentioned, it has more to do with the style of the game itself and the motif of the character
it's not just a matter of how the design looks or whether or not it activates your cockpenis, it's also about what it evokes, it the character supposed to be scary? cute? gentle? tough? maybe its appearance is meant to juxtapose that instead of matching it, maybe the character is intentionally made ugly and horrific to hide a soft sider, or made to look like a cute anime girl to hide the real monster within
this has more to do with than just one factor, so many different decisions and intents go onto this

Theres a balance.

>>720631646 (OP)
>which character option is better for a monster girl in games?
Neither because monsters should stick to being enemy mobs I'm sick of the tendency of humanizing these fucking ugly monster characters about how no no wait they're actually cool and profound and edgy. No they're not. If a baby would cry if it walked into the room then it should have a health bar and be evil. How simple could this question possibly be.

The only time being a female would be relevant to a monster is if it's some horrific denmother beast demon thing. Anything else with the B design having to do with "monster girls" is just kitschy thematic anime girls in an attempt to make porn interesting

>>720632265
Boringggg

>>720632265
You might possibly be gay anon, wanting to kill babies simply because is extremely homosexual and jewish.

B with A head

>>720632337
I get doing it once but when you start to expect it then that's what's really boring. Every demonic killer beast monster thing now has it's own sad backstory about how it's a misunderstood dindu nuffin and actually it's the evil of humanity that forced it to be this way. It's getting old. This trend has been around since the 90s and 00s

>>720632456
Haha now that ones getting a gold and an upvote from me kind stranger

>>720633003
>gay jew who wants to kill children is also a redditor
Man, do you troons even try to hide your motives anymore?

>>720631646 (OP)
>MC
A
>NPC
B
>Enemies
>Bosses
A
>love interest
Both.
>>720632242
That's a furry.

>>720633226
Human enough

>>720632265
female monsters absolutely can exist outside of being just mothers
lorelei is a good example of a female monster
>>720633226
>That's a furry.
and we love her for it

A every day of the week.

>>720631646 (OP)
Fixed it.

>A
>no sex appeal

>>720633494
both of those groups are monster girls
neither kemonomimifags or teratofags want to admit that though

>>720631646 (OP)
Best monster girl is dead monster girl.

>>720633454
>a siren
I would call that an exception
It literally exists to lure you to your death

>>720632242
/thread

Depends.
Which one has a tighter pussy?

>>720635210
A

>>720633494
bottom is literally just top with a slightly different head
no wait, the bodies are actually MORE humanoid than top

>>720635747
This

>>720632242
wheres the other pic

>>720637475
I will warn you now, it sucks compared to the other one.

>>720633226
>That's a furry.

Nun

>>720638174
nun

>>720632242
Ambatukam

yikes

>>720631646 (OP)
>>720632265
We fuck monsters here

see you again

>>720637839
An anime website.
Furries are fucking pricks

>>720631646 (OP)
Option C
The design of A but with a feminine figure

>>720641089
Did you seriously look at OP, open the thread, and still think you WEREN'T going to see a furry?

>>720641459
This is a monster girl board

>>720631646 (OP)
A, fuck normalfags and their dogshit boring taste.

>>720641510
>This is a girl monster board
ftfy

>>720641603
>she isn't a loli
If you're going to stay here, at least be a pedo furry...

Gamers only want one thing.

>>720631646 (OP)
These is a ragebait thread as both are not monster girls
One is 100% monster and the other is 100% girl
Both answers are fucking wrong meaning everyone is just going to argue

>>720641930
Sorry lad but I can't get off unless she can choke the life outta me with one hand
Maybe some day you'll understand

>>720642072
the horn

>>720642127
>what is a headband?
also they're antlers

>>720642072
100% wrong brcause both are girls except one appeals to men of higher taste.

>>720642342
So if they're both girls then what is a monster girl?

>>720642072
better?

>>720642516
marginally?

>>720631646 (OP)
Both, but B is due to your mind being fucked with

>>720642580
i gave her a hairpin representing what she is now.
better?

>>720642413
A monster that happens to be a girl, what are you fucking stupid?

>>720642735
Amelia's human form btw

>>720642862
Good thing the internet only draws her best form.

>>720642717
Her shirt should be colored black to match.

How do we stop innocent human men from being harassed by horny monsters?

>>720642862
Furchads make everything better

>>720631646 (OP)
B that turns into A when you have sex with her

>>720631646 (OP)
You don't make your characters sexy, you makes em sexualizable.
You give something for the furries to work with, but at the same time make it innocent enough anyone can play the game.

>>720643443
Now give both of them cute looking glasses with left having some tape keeping them on.

>>720643060
>good thing, death of the author!

>>720643435
Alicia is DUMB!

>>720631646 (OP)
Make A but with giant tits

>>720631646 (OP)
A is an incredibly loud minority that's half insincere shitposters and half insecure hipsters.
I'm part of that minority, A, but with long hair, eyelashes, a pretty dress, and catfishes you with form B.

>>720631646 (OP)
It's B facade who only shows her true form A to someone who she implicitly trusts. She has a lot of baggage about former "companions" running away screming after they saw what she really is.

>>720643740
One form is unique and cool (and hot for furries).
The other is a character of limbo of the lost.
It don't even get close to fair.

i prefer these

>>720644085
I hate this trope.

>>720644478
>Normal girl with crazy head
Call me a normalfag but i like this

>>720631646 (OP)
A for love interest, I am a freak

I think we all know the answer

>>720632242
tpbp

>>720632265
>If room temperature water had a personality

>>720644724
What's the answer?

>>720632265
Insane, unhinged, based post.

>>720643740
>>good thing, death of the author!
Unironically yes. I have seen multiple creators take to twitter in some vain attempt to control the narrative of discussion around their works. It never works.

>>720631646 (OP)
Option C.
Psycho bitch that transforms into a monster.
Best fit for every category.

>>720645010
Falling in love with big female monsters

>>720645198
How do we make this more popular to be included in video games?

>>720631646 (OP)
>fucking boring but appeals to the general audience
Kemonomimi is great when the girl still acts like an animal. Kemonomimi is great in general.

>>720645375
We just need to support projects with monsters

>>720633226
Doesn't MGE already have furry mamonos because of westerners?

Feral with zero personification. NO tits, NO eyelashes, etc. Pure relationship without any raceplay shit. Take it or leave it

>>720645742
>feral
Cringe, go away degenerate animal fucker.

>>720645742
At that point you start getting into "dating a cripple" territory in terms of the work you'd have to do just to function in normal society.

>>720646014
malo my beloved

>>720646137
I don't want it to be normal. I'm not normal, and I never will be normal.

>>720646870
Based realist.

>>720632265
cringe

>>720646870
No I mean do you have any fucking idea the amount of work it would take to live with say an intelligent cow just as an example?

>>720646776
Kissing mal0's pretty skull face.

>>720643870
Left having glasses is actually a major design change, since it's a very obvious cue that it's an intelligent being instead of a mindless animal.

I'm not passing a value judgement, I'm just commenting on how it affects initial impressions.

Seriously? Thread about deer monsters, and no mentions of HER?

>>720645742
i don't actually want to fuck a dog anon

>>720632265
>The only time being a female would be relevant to a monster is if it's some horrific denmother beast demon thing.
Nah. Even the wholesome mama bear archetype can be scary (as seen in Jurassic Park 2 & 3)
Also, xenomorphs are usually all described with female pronouns to liken them to bees/ants, which is another angle for female monsters.

Reminder that THIS could be under your feet right thus second

>>720648636
Impossible, unless she can burrow through rock and concrete.

B if it's an erotic game, A in all other cases

>>720631646 (OP)
>monster girl
I prefer just monsters

>>720648328
Dess is DEAD

>>720648735
They can! Quite easily too.

>>720631646 (OP)
Stays in A most of the time, but uses magic to disguise as B in normalfag muggle areas.

>>720648636
Imagine having an almost completely useless gf that you have to do all the handywork for.

>>720648949
Even in death she still molests

>>720649203
Baxxid are quite capable and extremely intelligent. They just need a helping habd occasionally

>>720632242
The best option but stuck in the eternal purgatory of being considered too boring by teratofags and too degenerate by normalfags. (Even OP forgot they exist)

>>720632242
Sexxx

>>720647523
I don't see the problem if she's sapient

>>720648328
>>720648949
>>720649237
UOHHHHHHH ROTTING DEER CORPSE PUPPETED BY DEMON HEART -USSY UOHHHHHHHH

>>720650026
Even if she's intelligent having the body and physical needs of a cow would be an insane detriment to both of you. From size, to diet, to even basic cleanliness, everything would be a challenge.

>>720631646 (OP)
B because there is nothing feminine about A. Monster girl game implies some sort of romance and it takes a special kind of autism for someone to want to have sex with something non-human. If it was a *monster* game? A is the better character design.

>>720649506
Idk I'd rather prefer having a rat gf, they have hands and aren't almost completely useless.

>>720650393
I think you're lost buddy

When will we get a proper monsterfucker game /v/?

>>720651519
Unironically never ever. It's a cursed genre and every attempt ends in failure and bitter disappointment.

>>720631646 (OP)
B is better because she has a full blown faun ass under her waist. (Not pictured because OP is being disingenuous)

>>720647014
>turns her into a human
tired of this shit

>>720652353
I think we all are.

>>720631646 (OP)
A for a porn game, B for a serious story

A but with feminine features like wider hips, breasts, lighter voice.

>>720650519
>picking filthy scavs over baxxid
Sad

>>720653110
Filthy scavs? Absolutely not! I only desire the matriarch goodness.

>>720648636
>accidentally kills you during sex

>>720650694
Shanefrost is the original monster fucker. He walked so others could run.

>>720653464
Worth the risk

>>720631646 (OP)
B if you're a tasteless dev angling for normalfags
A if you're willing to be more niche

>>720653771
When will devs start doing more of A?

>>720654679
You think you want mass adoption but you don't, just look at what happened to anime.

>>720654780
But I'm tired of all the content being produced by internet schizos that always implode or fall apart halfway. Monsterfuckers deserve better.

>>720653559
>He walked so others could run.
He's still in a dead sprint last I checked

>>720655218
This artstyle is repulsive. Imagine jerking off to 2006 low effort Newgrounds flash videos.

>>720655340
You're out of your depth here man

>>720655713
No I just don't find the artstyle of baby books to be very appealing or attractive, this artstyle is repulsive.

>>720655218
>>720655713
Shane Frost is total dogshit and you need to stop spamming him

>>720656320
>>720656595
You can bitch and moan about his art all you want but Shane is a pillar of monster fucker art and nothing will change that.

>>720633494
>Western gooners vs eastern gooners

Its all hyper sexual coomer slop

>>720657045
>but Shane is a pillar of monster fucker art
He is as obscure as his dogshit deviant art tier sesame street ass drawings would imply. The only thing notable about him is the sheer volume of his work, and that's easily explained by the simplicity and lack of effort he puts into them.

I have to go B because it's gonna piss you and others off. I really have to look down on you looking down on me for not being the same kind of degenerate. Honestly anything else would be a better reason.
Also
>implying it's a binary and not a spectrum

>>720631646 (OP)
Whichever makes your dick harder.
But if your're doing it just for the money go with B or better yet, B that can turn into A, this way you can eat your cake and have it too.

>>720657432
Anon the entire fucking genre is obscure. You're a man lost in a desert and you're throwing a tantrum because the oasis you just found doesn't have the right kind of flower in bloom.

>>720631646 (OP)
just do both and make a selectable option in the settings, which NG+ option for a per-character basis

>>720644634
How do you know her head is crazy?

>>720658261
This isn't a flower, it's a turd. It's repulsive.

>>720658261
bikesexual

>>720631646 (OP)
'B' isn't bad, but I think 'A' is potentially more interesting. 'B' has already been overdone. But in the end it really depends on the type of game you want to make.

Now for the other questions:
>MC
I feel like B would be easily accepted by the general audience, and would make the game more easily marketeable.
>NPC
depends on the type of NPC. I think a wise sage type of NPC could be 'A', and 'B' could be like a villager, a vendor, or a half-monster that is ostracized by society.
>Enemies
'A' definitely looks more like a classic monster enemy.
>Bosses
'A' also definitely looks more like a classic boss, although I suppose 'B' could work as some sort of last or secret boss, an 'enlightened' being of sort.
>Love interest
Both could work. Like I (and (You)) said before, 'A' is more unusual and potentially interesting, but 'B' would be less odd for the more general audience.

Then again, people liked the fucking bear in BG3, so having a monster companion shouldn't be much of a issue either, by the same logic.

>>720649708
That’s just not true. That is usually the design used in media. Kemonomimi is actually pretty rare outside of anime and gacha games, even with the influence anime has Kemonomimi remains relatively rare in media outside of Japan.

>>720633512
>>720642072
Yes, this is the way

>>720662121
Fucking dogshit game bro
this is still the video game board

>>720662192
I have never played it

>>720658230
I'm glad this dev isn't dead

>>720662297
>

>>720658261
Then I will just fucking wait for something good and not simply lower my standards like some bugman

>>720662481
>>720662192
You seem overly upset

>>720659863
>>720662587
That's nice anons

>>720631646 (OP)
>A
>A
>A
>A
>A
SEX SEX SEX SEX

Do kemonomimi count as monster girls?

>>720663156
Bad taste AND a passive aggressive fag, what a combination

>>720664203
no
it's not a monster girl unless she's truly monstrous (on the outside)

>>720664203
They are at best, a gateway drug.

>>720631646 (OP)
A when casually hanging out
B when hunting
(not a typo)

>>720631646 (OP)
I just made it 200% better

>>720664237
I notice you dont actually seem to be posting any monster fucker art. In fact you just seem to be a whiny bitch.

>>720665831
Not beating the normal faggot allegations my man.

>>720666516
I had to really search for blue board images

>>720658230
>>720662378
What's the sauce? Google and yandex failed me and nothing really came up by googling "monster girl/wendigo skateboarding game"

>>720667028
Morgan's Skate Club

>>720667290
Thanks, looks cool.

>>720667028
the wendigo trend really sucks
what a way to faggify the genre with tepid bullshit

Here's your monster girl bro.

>>720631809
I thought Bowser only liked human women

>>720631646 (OP)
Option A and B can both be all of those things. The only caveat is that you shouldn't attempt option A if you intend on getting and head injuries.

>>720670189
Nintendo says otherwise

>>720631646 (OP)
Right is the love interest. Left is her mother and secret alternative love interest

>>720662121
I miss Evolve so much. Kneecapped before it could get into its stride. I hope the corporate suits kick themselves seeing how DBD took off.

>>720631646 (OP)
>>MC
A or B, depending on either who you're trying to appeal to or what your vision is
>>NPC
A, with some scant few B exceptions
>>enemies
A
>>Bosses
B, with some cant few A exceptions
>>Love interests
50/50 or 60/40

>>720645198
>French werewolf
Tell me more.

>>720670832
Hon Hon Hon Awoo Baguette

>>720631646 (OP)
MC is a depressed girl/boy in type B haloween makeup pretending to be a monster going on an adventure with type A monsters who pretend not to notice until the very end where they tell MC they knew all along but they were playing along to cheer them up
there is no sex in this game
there is megaviolence however and the mc becomes a true monster at the end

>>720652353
>>720652463
Boy do I have a movie for you guys.

>>720650274
Kris...

>>720673548
YES

>>720675365
No.

>>720673548
Sorlag if she purple

>>720673548
>>720675365
Imagine being the meat in the Suselle sandwich. Turning the lamest form of love (yuri) into the most based (harem).

>>720677783
Surely you meant "netorare"?

>>720677969
No. I will possess Kris during the Noelle's daily chair session, and drag her into bed with me.

>>720670832
She's a good girl

>>720665014
there's got to be an anime like that

>>720665014
This will just lead to all the romantic scene only happen when the monster is in their human form.

>>720680119
is this from an actual book?

>>720681342
Web novel. Its currently on hiatus but still reportedly being worked on.
https://sharkrags.itch.io/mob-mentality

>>720680272
It's, like, one of the most typical fairy tale scenarios.

>>720681882
>Novel
>itch io
weird

>>720631646 (OP)
Depends on the game. Usually I like to take B and add a bit more of monster elements, but keeping the sex appeal of the girl. The most important element imo is the feminine shape, so it doesn't really matter how far you push towards A, as long as you keep the feminine shape you can get away with it still being appealing.

It's kind of a shitty drawing, but this is one I've made for a game I'm working on, the monster elements add some spice to the girl elements.

>>720682730
I like your BS drawings drawfren.

>>720684026
Thank you fren, don't know how you recognize my style, but I appreciate it!

>>720680272
Something like that
>>720671619

>>720682730
What do you think about this?

>>720631646 (OP)
A with big breasts and slightly chubby, oh yeah.

>>720684568
Would probably work for something horror themed. Too animal-like for my tastes, also the exaggerated and exposed bones and muscles give it a creepy vibe. The thing I associate with femininity is both softness and curves, and that's usually how I approach things.

>>720684568
hot

>>720684568
>>720685602
Actually pretty cute.

>>720666565
clean this disgusting furshit porn dump thread already jannoid, do your fucking job.

>>720685602
Needs bewbz

>>720680272
Shrek

>>720684568
are those balls?

>>720684568
>>720685602
Could work, but may need some silky fur on some parts like the limbs and tail

B

>>720691823
>>720684568
>>720685602
These are pretty cool, it just needs a few adjustments to make it a bit less extreme

>>720645010
>What's the answer?
AB

>>720693414
C

>>720694493
A secret third thing?

>>720695228
yes

>>720696991
No

People who get off to pyramid head are weirdos on the same tier as the freaks who find jeffrey dahmer hot

>>720699406
well i got off on the bubble nurses from that one clip on tv. they looked so hot man

Either make her a monster, or don't waste my time pretending she is one.

>>720699817
Bubble nurses are different (they're hot till you have to fight them, FUCK THEM THEY CAN GET A CHAINSAW TO THE TITS)

>>720631646 (OP)
Context matters on said narrative of the game. Besides, Dullahan girls are objectively based as love interests, MCs, and NPCs because I said so

>>720701857
What if it's is serious

>>720702025
In most cases design A works.

>>720631646 (OP)
Half of the people that chooses A only would only get turned on if it had the body of a bimbo in fanart,just like how people that get turned on by early fnaf animatronics do since they're fucking ugly

>>720631646 (OP)
B seems to be a safer option.

>>720702869
Those are just type B's pretending to have taste.

>>720633512
I want to fuck C so fucking hard

A as the husband and B as the wife

>>720633512
A or C is pure sex, nuff said.

>>720704958
Reverse

>>720631646 (OP)
B with A as battle mode.

>>720633494
Both you fucking faggot

>>720670832
loup garou has filed all the appropriate monster forms with the guild of terrorizing stupid peasants and wishes to be taken seiously

>>720707697
Who

>>720632265
I don't want to fuck a monster girl, I want to fuck a girl monster you gigantic faggot.

>>720689238
Canine vulva

>>720709093
Anon......... How do you know that

>>720709194
Personal experience let's just say

>>720709194
I know many things, the source of such knowledge does not matter.

>>720709661
you fucked a dog didnt you

>>720710864
I did stick my dick in quite a few things, but not in a dog.

>>720711273
:((

>>720631646 (OP)
>A
Her true form.
>B
Her human(ized) form when in public to avoid a scene.

>>720713038
THIS

bing.com/create

Tan

>>720631646 (OP)
this is very easy to answer.
A is going to get you 130 downloads if free from itchio, because steam will ban it.
B is going to get you 1300 downloads for 10$ on steam.

>>720642342
I made this image, never thought i would see it again lmao

sex

Br

/thread