← Home ← Back to /v/

Thread 723011720

102 posts 52 images /v/
Anonymous No.723011720 >>723011974 >>723012028 >>723012193 >>723012262 >>723012346 >>723012350 >>723012636 >>723012748 >>723012789 >>723014658 >>723015575 >>723015774 >>723015787 >>723017008 >>723017920 >>723020896 >>723021354 >>723021694 >>723023225 >>723027848 >>723028332 >>723028405 >>723028735 >>723032175 >>723032283 >>723035535
What's the best soulslike ever made?
Anonymous No.723011905
King's Field IV
Anonymous No.723011974 >>723017974
>>723011720 (OP)
Another Crab's Treasure
Anonymous No.723012028 >>723012252 >>723028057
>>723011720 (OP)
DaS1 if including actual souls games.
Lies of P, if you mean games that aren't made by From.
Anonymous No.723012185
What was the verdict on ACVI FOR, Soulslike or not?
Anonymous No.723012193 >>723012303 >>723023607 >>723031079
>>723011720 (OP)
Depends what you want out of the genre, it's gone in a few different directions and it's hard to say any of them are objectively the "right" choice over the others. Something like Nioh or Khazan focused on having more involved combat systems, Wuchang having more involved and challenging levels, or a lot of the more modern games, arguably including From's, having a more heavy focus on the boss fights.
Personally my favourite is Wukong.
Anonymous No.723012238
Dark Souls
Anonymous No.723012252 >>723034681
>>723012028
DS1 has a good first half but everything after Anor Londo is complete dog shit
Anonymous No.723012262
>>723011720 (OP)
Anonymous No.723012303 >>723012347
>>723012193
Wukong isn't a soulslike, idiot bitch.
Anonymous No.723012346 >>723016287
>>723011720 (OP)
Let's be honest and drop the meme answers for a second.
Everyone and their dog knows it's elden ring.
Anonymous No.723012347 >>723015861 >>723018682 >>723031079
>>723012303
Why not?
Anonymous No.723012350
>>723011720 (OP)
Nioh 1 & 2 are better than most Souls games
Anonymous No.723012636
>>723011720 (OP)
I think Rise of the Ronin or Nine Sols. Sekiro's up there too. Wuchang was a lot of fun but I don't think I would rate it as high as Dark Souls. Stranger of Paradise was a little below Wuchang but I'm not sure how everything really lines up other than that.
Anonymous No.723012748
>>723011720 (OP)
nioh 2
Anonymous No.723012789
>>723011720 (OP)
How can she wield such heavy weapons with arms this skinny?
Anonymous No.723012801 >>723013269
Every single game with a female protagonist should give you the option to completely remove your clothing at will.
Anonymous No.723013269
>>723012801
have sex, incel
Anonymous No.723014658
>>723011720 (OP)
Wuchang
Anonymous No.723015575
>>723011720 (OP)
Anonymous No.723015774
>>723011720 (OP)
Bloodborn
Anonymous No.723015787 >>723017093
>>723011720 (OP)
Wizardry 4
Anonymous No.723015861 >>723016845
>>723012347
NTA but it's more like an action game than a souls like. Your character improves in a very linear way with little deviation on how you play outside of some skills. You can't change your weapon and can only change your heavy attack. It's level based with more of an emphasis on bosses over level design and enemies. You don't really have builds. No penalty for dying either.
Anonymous No.723016287
>>723012346
Unironically not even top 10
Anonymous No.723016845 >>723018732
>>723015861
Outside of the penalty for dying it's really almost the same as Sekiro. If someone is of the opinion that Sekiro isn't a Soulslike then I can understand also not considering Wukong one, but generally I see most people put Sekiro within the group and I can't really see any arguments for one being a Soulslike and not the other.
Anonymous No.723017008
>>723011720 (OP)
combat wise its thymesia for me. Its a soulslike, but with sekiro combat mixed in it and their own unique spin.
Anonymous No.723017017 >>723017093 >>723018061 >>723019124
>lies of piss
>nioh
>sekiro
>chink shit

ladies and gentlemen, nu/v/.
fucking grim.
Anonymous No.723017093
>>723017017
>>723015787
Anonymous No.723017920
>>723011720 (OP)
Wuchang
Anonymous No.723017974
>>723011974
THIS THIS THIS THIS
Anonymous No.723018061 >>723020234
>>723017017
>WAHHHH STOP HAVING FUN! :(
You're dumb and you're butt hurt!
Anonymous No.723018682
>>723012347
It's not like souls
Anonymous No.723018732
>>723016845
I don't think sekiro is a souls like either, but the genre has no real definition anyway.
Anonymous No.723018783
Lies of p is underrated
Anonymous No.723018845
Any soulslikes inspired by the first Dark Souls/Demon Souls? Every single one that I try is inspired by Dark Souls III, you only roll and shields are useless (if they even exist)
Anonymous No.723019124
>>723017017
All better than souls games. Imagine creating a subgenre and being one of the worst at it
Anonymous No.723020234
>>723018061
Shut up
Anonymous No.723020896
>>723011720 (OP)
https://streamable.com/khu1fi
Anonymous No.723021220
Is Sekiro a souslike?
If yes, then it wins by a mile.
If not, then Bloodborne.
Anonymous No.723021354
>>723011720 (OP)
Objectively its Bloodborne
Anonymous No.723021356
I just want to play a realistic knight in a dark fantasy world not this ching chong walla walla bing bong or high fantasy nonsense.
Anonymous No.723021434 >>723021621
I somehow finished Asterigos despite barely being a 5/10 at best, is Wuchang better?
Anonymous No.723021621 >>723025460
>>723021434
>is Wuchang better?
Significantly. Although, patch 1.5 kinda ruined the the message of the story and made certain enemies and areas easier. The only reason they made it easier is because people weren't utilizing disciplines more. Post-1.5 has better performance but pre-1.5 has the actual vision
Anonymous No.723021694 >>723021883
>>723011720 (OP)
Why did chinks hate it so much and the devs ran off and were never heard from anymore? Did the commies sent them to camps?
Anonymous No.723021883
>>723021694
They just made a patch the other week though and the topic why the ming babies were upset has been talked about to death
Anonymous No.723021979 >>723022207 >>723023827
no one has been able to answer me this yet

something puzzling me on the last level, you go through the whole level and reach the storyteller then you jump down.... back to the starting bonfire, and there's a path further down the level. was this path always here? I don't remember opening anything, it's a cavern without a door. I looked at multiple guides and no one mentions it
Anonymous No.723022095
Wuchang looks better than all Fromsoft games. I much prefer it since it doesn't look like shit and runs better which makes combat more satisfying.
Anonymous No.723022207 >>723022839
>>723021979
What are you talking about? That's how it looked at launch
Anonymous No.723022815 >>723025724 >>723028269
I thought Khazan would be more remembered than Wuchang since it has the more complex combat, but i see way more threads about Wuchang around here (i prefer Wuchang as well). Also no one mentioned Dolls Nest yet.
Anonymous No.723022839 >>723022956
>>723022207
I am asking if you can enter this area and go down the ribcage path, from the beginning of the level
whats the point of going all the way up to the storyteller
Anonymous No.723022947
Outside FromSlop games? Lies of Sneed by far.
Anonymous No.723022956
>>723022839
Yes, you can go down there immediately. Have you never just turned around from the shrine??? The point is for story and there's also stuff you can get going through the level and I believe there's something in a chest right by Duryal to upgrade your flask.
Anonymous No.723023023 >>723023129
Nioh >>>>>>> From Games >>>> Lies of P >>> Rise of the Ronin >>>>>>>>>>> Rest
Anonymous No.723023129 >>723023231 >>723025298
>>723023023
Lies of P clears all Fromsoft games.
Anonymous No.723023225 >>723027185
>>723011720 (OP)
I fucking loved AI Limit. and its still my GOTY. Everyone go play it. its getting DLC eventually
Anonymous No.723023231
>>723023129
stark balance issues with weapons holds it back and it leans too heavily into parry slop
Anonymous No.723023607 >>723026018
If we’re not including Fromsoft, then Lords of the Fallen (2023) unironically mogs the rest and I’m tired of pretending it doesn’t.

If we’re including actual Fromsoft games, then Dark Souls 1 is the best.

>>723012193
Wuchang is absolutely not focused on the levels bruh. Its level design is as uninspired as the rest of the modern souls slop. It pales in comparison to Bloodborne.
Anonymous No.723023827
>>723021979
>was this path always there?
Yes, you could go straight to the ending if you bothered to look behind
Anonymous No.723025298 >>723025825
>>723023129
Maybe to redditors. To regular human beings, LoP is obviously a pale imitation of fromsoft’s games that severely misses the point and thinks the genre is about the boss battles, the biggest cardinal sin in making good soulslikes.
Anonymous No.723025460
>>723021621
Censorship sycks but i can understand making it somewhat accessible for more players. Khazan did it after terrible sales, and even Elden Ring does it through their rebalance patches
Anonymous No.723025570
>no mention of hellpoint
interesting...makes me even more excited to finally play it soon
Anonymous No.723025724
>>723022815
Heck even AI limit seemed to be more successful, the dev team of Khazan failed properly calibrating/naming their difficulty options. Should've gone with hard and normal, instead of normal and easy
Anonymous No.723025825
>>723025298
Am i miss remembering BloodBorne or something?
Anonymous No.723026018
>>723023607
>Wuchang is absolutely not focused on the levels bruh. Its level design is as uninspired as the rest of the modern souls slop.
What? This is interesting and the opposite of what ive heard about the game. Now Im curious whether you even understand souls level design (and by that, i largely mean DS1, since its not the...only one with actual level design, theres one other, but its the one with the best level design) So Im asking. What do you think makes souls level design good? Ill admit its kind of "complicated" to spell out, only because technically every souls game has the basic features of level design, but the difference is more of an essence thing than characteristic thing.
Anonymous No.723026303 >>723026858 >>723031671 >>723031819
>No-one mentioning that Italian souls game
Was it that bad
Anonymous No.723026546
Anonymous No.723026858
>>723026303
Italy can't build a bridge that doesn't collapse in a few years, you want them to make video games?
Anonymous No.723026919
is there a mod to fix Wuchang's china censoring?
Anonymous No.723027045 >>723027170
Anonymous No.723027170
>>723027045
I also beat these guys bare-handed it was pretty satisfying roflcopter.
Anonymous No.723027185
>>723023225
Best soulslike by far
Anonymous No.723027241
Wuchang and Eve walk into a bar
Anonymous No.723027323
Actually its the ffirst Surge
Anonymous No.723027512
wuchang and lies of p already surpassed dark souls and elden ring.
Anonymous No.723027558
Putting the SOUL in soulslikes
Anonymous No.723027568 >>723027604
Chinese wives
Anonymous No.723027604
>>723027568
Wuchang needs a good dicking
Anonymous No.723027659 >>723027972
Elden Ring is the obvious non contrarian answer it's literally everything Fromsoft set out to do since Demon's Souls mostly perfected and is an insanely massive amount of game and content for the purchase price to the point it started getting scary when you realised it just kept fucking going. The expansion was the same.

All these Wuchang wukong ding dong games don't compare, they are cookie cutter shadows. Lies of Piss is a dodgy clunky unreal game with a completely lifeless static world where you can't even break boxes or clutter in the environment, it feels like a student game, there's even awful animation hickup shit that happens on roll like a university students game, it's amateur at best.


Elden Ring for overall package.
Dark Souls 1 for very specific 'feel', nothing quite matches it and it's sombre and less grandiose approach
Sekiro for outright combat and narrative

Bloodborne is far and away the best for the actual combat, music, level design and lore, but it's story is a bit wishy washy and not much replayability, not as RPG deep, but it's own thing. This is the one most of the games are still trying to capture the magic of. If Fromsoft re approached bloodborne but with their Elden Ring knowledge and had an open world city with seamless sewers and labyrinths connected to the tombs and rest of the world, more playstyles and builds and things this would be the best game they could possibly make.

Dark Souls 2/Nightreign are best respectively for multiplayer (PvP/Coop)
Anonymous No.723027848
>>723011720 (OP)
>best bosses
Wukong
>best story
Stranger of Paradise
>best dungeons
AI Limit
>best overall
Bloodborne
Anonymous No.723027972 >>723028279
>>723027659
ER is too copypasted. Once you see the same ruin 50 times the idea that you're playing the best game ever kind of goes away
Anonymous No.723028057 >>723032098
>>723012028
I thought this was a shitpost at first
Anonymous No.723028160
Elden Ring (with mods)
Anonymous No.723028198
Arissa thread
Anonymous No.723028269
>>723022815
Something something big tits, something something chink censorship.
Anonymous No.723028279
>>723027972
I would admit the reuse of environment pieces isn't ideal, but people way overblow how much this happens in actuality. Yes, the same wooden shack thing is used alot but it's never of any importance and is always tweaked and different, the ruins are all made of the same pieces and architecture but they are all different. For an open world game you have to develop like this otherwise the game would take literally 10 years to make.
They had to pick their battles where they reused and instead focussed on having alot of enemy types and bosses which literally every other open world game is the opposite. Breath of the Wild has like 5 enemy types in the entire game, just literally all Bokoblins and shit. GTA is all humans. Skyrim is like 12 entities that aren't humans.

Elden Ring has more enemy types just in the first 30 minutes than all these games have their entire runthrough. That's where ER has it's appeal. You look up the wiki page for creatures on ER compared to any other open world game and it's a horrific mogging.
Anonymous No.723028332
>>723011720 (OP)
Going by the retarded, insanely loose definition of Souls-like, it's Nioh 2
It has infinitely more depth and player expression than all the other Souls-likes combined.
Anonymous No.723028334
i like salt and sanctuary
Anonymous No.723028405
>>723011720 (OP)
Its undeniably kinda shit but my favorite so far is AI limit
Anonymous No.723028735
>>723011720 (OP)
AI Limit. And Arrisa is the best souls protagonist
Anonymous No.723030801
CHADrammelech did nothing wrong btw
Anonymous No.723031079
>>723012347
>>723012193
wukong is a generic action game, zoomer faggot. play more games
Anonymous No.723031671 >>723031819
>>723026303
yeah i feel bad for the devs, it's a solid game idk why people were so harsh
Anonymous No.723031819 >>723033860
>>723026303
>>723031671
wtf is it called
Anonymous No.723032098
>>723028057
One is my favorite Souls game.
The other is my favorite souls-like.
That means they are the best.
Anonymous No.723032175
>>723011720 (OP)
Well for me, it's that one.
Anonymous No.723032283
>>723011720 (OP)
nioh 2
Anonymous No.723033860
>>723031819
enotria
Anonymous No.723033995
all time: demon's souls o dark souls 1
recent times: lords of the fallen 2.0
Anonymous No.723034605
Other than actual From's games it's a mix between Nioh 2, Lies of P and Wuchang for me
Anonymous No.723034681
>>723012252
Anonymous No.723035535
>>723011720 (OP)
Demons Souls and Lies of P. Sekiro and Nine Sols if you expand your definition of Soullikes. Finally enough the actual Dark Souls games are the worst excluding Elden Shit
Anonymous No.723035540
you posted it
I would play more soulslop if you could play as a cute with with a perky ass and wear slutty clothes