← Home ← Back to /v/

Thread 723121682

222 posts 44 images /v/
Anonymous No.723121682 [Report] >>723121736 >>723121827 >>723121856 >>723122217 >>723122986 >>723123208 >>723125473 >>723125836 >>723125883 >>723125897 >>723126381 >>723126463 >>723126474 >>723126504 >>723126521 >>723126921 >>723127458 >>723127919 >>723128040 >>723128091 >>723128812 >>723128945 >>723128953 >>723129830 >>723130805 >>723131092 >>723131478 >>723131489 >>723132615 >>723132796 >>723135101 >>723137691 >>723138046 >>723138113 >>723140268 >>723140998 >>723142770 >>723143129 >>723143193 >>723143323 >>723143391 >>723143461 >>723143674
Is this really true?
Anonymous No.723121736 [Report] >>723127640
>>723121682 (OP)
no
Anonymous No.723121815 [Report] >>723123392 >>723123498 >>723143947
>artificial difficulty
>janky rollslop
>children's moviegame
>backtracking
no
Anonymous No.723121827 [Report] >>723126481 >>723126730 >>723135797 >>723144290
>>723121682 (OP)
>Silksong
I feel like this is the 4chan equivalent of the reddit love for Witcher 3.
Anonymous No.723121856 [Report] >>723128397
>>723121682 (OP)
>Hunnigan, I appear to be in a 2x2 what do I do?
>Leon, it is other 10/10 games
>10/10? Hmmm
>Leon?
>9/10
Anonymous No.723122217 [Report] >>723122828 >>723122969 >>723132568 >>723140748 >>723141341
>>723121682 (OP)
demon's souls is 7-8 (og ds1 would be 8-9 but thinking any souls is a 10 is demented), lttp isn't even the best 2d zelda and ofc not 10, silksong is like a solid 9 but I couldn't stretch it to 10
and I have no complaints about re4 being called 10
Anonymous No.723122828 [Report] >>723127171 >>723140748
>>723122217
>Dark Souls better than Demon's
kys zoomer
>Silksong being a 9
kys zoomer
Anonymous No.723122969 [Report] >>723127171
>>723122217
>Silksong is better than Demon's Souls
die you fucking subhuman
Anonymous No.723122986 [Report] >>723131124
>>723121682 (OP)
Silksong is the only perfect 10. RE4 killed the series. Rollslop is a 5/10 by default. Zelda is overrated.
Anonymous No.723123092 [Report] >>723123136 >>723126058 >>723126591 >>723128037 >>723128175 >>723129330 >>723129617 >>723131172 >>723132670 >>723132735 >>723142610 >>723143253 >>723143267
This is my list
Anonymous No.723123136 [Report] >>723123171 >>723126705
>>723123092
the absolute fucking state of underage brown "people"
Anonymous No.723123171 [Report]
>>723123136
I'm a white man
Anonymous No.723123208 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>slop
>slop
>slop
>slop
No
Anonymous No.723123392 [Report]
>>723121815
>moviegame
Anonymous No.723123498 [Report]
>>723121815
>children's moviegame
bro what
Anonymous No.723124529 [Report] >>723126147
Almost
Anonymous No.723125473 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>mexican spaniards capture the american presidents daughter and take her to... Romania
>roll slop early access
>the goat
>the grift
Anonymous No.723125836 [Report] >>723126586
>>723121682 (OP)
Diablo, Metroid, Silent Hill, and Metal Gear Solid are franchises with multiple 10/10 games.
Shadow of the Colossus
Donkey Kong Country 2
Mega Man X
several fighting games
etc.
Anonymous No.723125883 [Report] >>723126662
>>723121682 (OP)
yeah demons souls absolutely does not belong in the same tier with the other 3, not even fucking close.
Anonymous No.723125897 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
RE4 is the only one that belongs
Anonymous No.723126058 [Report]
>>723123092
>Original HL2 > HL1 > HL2 E2
giga shit taste
Anonymous No.723126147 [Report] >>723126309 >>723128283
>>723124529
too many third person swordslops
Anonymous No.723126309 [Report] >>723126587
>>723126147
>swordslops
Name one genre that ISN'T "slop" in your opinion, so we can namecall and berate (You) and (You)r shit taste and call it sloppa.
Anonymous No.723126381 [Report] >>723137607
>>723121682 (OP)
Where are Rayman Origins and Legends?
Anonymous No.723126463 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Spyro the Dragon for PS1 was 10/10 and I will not be told otherwise. Also would say Shadow of the Colossus was a 10/10 and again will not be convinced otherwise.
Anonymous No.723126474 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
None of these games are perfect.
Anonymous No.723126481 [Report]
>>723121827
are you implying that silksong isn't more reddit than witcher 3?
Anonymous No.723126504 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Only if you're born after 2000
Anonymous No.723126521 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
RE4 is the closest contender since its an extremely fun game and highly influential.
Anonymous No.723126586 [Report]
>>723125836
Fuck off retard, none of those series have a single 10/10, closest is DKC, then MGS3, Super Metroid (Prime is trash), and Silent Hill.

Mega Man X is an incredibly overrated game, play more action games/platformers/run n guns
Anonymous No.723126587 [Report] >>723126896
>>723126309
Whatever this genre is
Anonymous No.723126591 [Report]
>>723123092
All those 11s are just shit you played when you were 11 lil bro
Anonymous No.723126662 [Report] >>723126835
>>723125883
It's in its own tier far above them. It was really such a magical game and those of us that played it in 2009 are still chasing that high. Putting fucking Silksong on a higher tier than Demon's Souls is just fucking asinine and you need to kys.
Anonymous No.723126705 [Report]
>>723123136
Turn your monitor on, Paco
Anonymous No.723126730 [Report]
>>723121827
Let's not pretend reddit in 2015 was not more based than 4channel today
Anonymous No.723126835 [Report] >>723126947
>>723126662
>Im impressed by rollslop (beta)
congrats on your disability
Anonymous No.723126845 [Report]
This is the best game ever made.
Anonymous No.723126896 [Report] >>723127206
>>723126587
third-person shooting sloppa
Anonymous No.723126921 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
This board needs a primer on the subjective nature of opinion in media pinned to page 1. Would save so much wasted threads but I guess engagement is money so whatever.
Anonymous No.723126947 [Report] >>723127367
>>723126835
>MOM LOOK!!! I SAID THE BUZZWORD AGAIN!!!
Rolling wasn't even commonplace in Souls until Dark Souls 3, you underage shitstain. Vast majority of players went big ass shield and fatroll build.
Anonymous No.723127171 [Report] >>723127334 >>723127792 >>723140748
>>723122828
>>723122969
DeS is a shitty action adventure slop with baby difficulty
Silksong has 10x better combat, encounters, and level design
Anonymous No.723127206 [Report] >>723127310
>>723126896
more like third person arcade powerup collector.
Anonymous No.723127295 [Report] >>723127523 >>723127681 >>723127842
>Resident Evil 4
It's gotten a bad rap over time thanks to betraying the original premise of the RE games in favor of chasing more mainstream action game appeal, but it's genuinely a good game. QTE are gay as fuck though so it's not a 10/10.
>Demon's Souls
The thing pretentious soulsfags pretend is really good when they want to look down on other soulsfags that can't pirate. In all actuality it's an incredibly rough game with very little gameplay variation between playstyles (weapons of a same class all basically play the same, weapon movesets are pretty small and samey, spells are basic as fuck) and a very noticeable lack of polish. There is genuinely nothing here that DaS doesn't offer, and DaS has far more going for it.
>LttP
I dunno it's fine. It's the template 2D Zelda that all other 2D zeldas copy from. Good but I don't know about 10/10.
>Silksong
lmao tedious trash. Side quests are fucking obnoxious and sometimes require grinding (which isn't fun), random enemies take longer to kill than their limited movesets justify, it's just a game for people that don't really respect their own time.
Anonymous No.723127310 [Report] >>723127437 >>723137358
>>723127206
...slop.
Anonymous No.723127334 [Report] >>723127446 >>723127450 >>723127830
>>723127171
Silksong is like a solid 7/10 with shitty bossfights that wears out its welcome by the middle of Act 2.

Demon's Souls is the single greatest game of all time, the greatest artistic achievement in gaming, and the one of the most influential games of all time.
Anonymous No.723127367 [Report] >>723127418
>>723126947
>zoomie fromshit retard accusing someone of else of underage
comedy
Anonymous No.723127418 [Report] >>723127559
>>723127367
Tell us you're an ESL thirdie without saying in verbatim that you're an ESL thirdie.
Anonymous No.723127437 [Report]
>>723127310
Slop is mass produced, where are all the Dark legacy-likes then?
Anonymous No.723127446 [Report] >>723127763
>>723127334
>Demon's Souls is the single greatest game of all time, the greatest artistic achievement in gaming, and the one of the most influential games of all time.
played it, mid
OoT is the only game that can and should be considered 10/10
Anonymous No.723127450 [Report] >>723127763
>>723127334
DeS is a 6/10 on a good day. you children really need to play more videogames.
Anonymous No.723127458 [Report] >>723127718 >>723128139
>>723121682 (OP)
Zelda Ocarina of Time
Super Castlevania 4
Donkey Kong Country
Deus Ex
Shenmue 1
Broken Sword
RE 2
KOTOR

My 10/10s
Anonymous No.723127523 [Report]
>>723127295
>There is genuinely nothing here that DaS doesn't offer, and DaS has far more going for it.
The atmosphere of DeS completely blows DaS and all the subsequent games out of the water. It also doesn't overstay its welcome like DaS does. In fact it only gets better as the levels progress.
Anonymous No.723127559 [Report] >>723127705 >>723127787
>>723127418
you really burned me with that incredibly cringe redditor catch phrase. demons souls is still garbage for midwits Im afraid.
Anonymous No.723127640 [Report]
>>723121736
Fpbp
Anonymous No.723127681 [Report] >>723127739 >>723128214 >>723129259
>>723127295
Demon's Souls has miles better level design, far better pacing, less backtracking, more creative (and non-recycled) bosses, and was far more innovative. Dark Souls was two steps forward, one step back.

Each weapon has completely unique animations, reach, hitbox, upgrade path, attack type, damage type, scaling, attack speed, stamina usage, etc. Add onto that the huge amount of magic, miracles, buff/debuffs, and equipment and there is massive build variety (obviously not as much as some of the later games, like Dark Souls II though).

But even if you literally only had one sword, one equipment, and one attack type (which is extremely common, say in games like, gee I don't know... A LINK TO THE FUCKING PAST), the game would still be top notch due to exceptional level design, enemy design, hazard design, and boss design. It really is insane the double standard held to Souls games.
Anonymous No.723127705 [Report]
>>723127559
>redditor
Anonymous No.723127718 [Report]
>>723127458
Deus Ex is a good choice for a 10/10, the only one I agree with
Anonymous No.723127739 [Report] >>723127842 >>723127895
>>723127681
>two steps forward one step back
absolute retard detected
Anonymous No.723127763 [Report]
>>723127450
Post your 10/10s so we can all laugh at you faggot.

>>723127446
There is literally not even one single thing that OoT does better than Demon's Souls.
Anonymous No.723127787 [Report] >>723127909
>>723127559
>demons souls
Demon's Souls*
fixed
>Im
I'm*
fixed
Fucking thirdies. Do you eat with your right hand and wipe you your left?
Anonymous No.723127792 [Report]
>>723127171
>Silksong has 10x better combat
If you're not trivializing it with tools/spells you're whacking an overtuned boss with maybe 3 attacks 20 times. For more casual and first time players you're heavily disincentivized from using your spells because for a good chunk of the game the basic act of healing takes up all your fucking silk, which in a game as punishing as Silksong ends up feeling like a limited resource. It's better then to just sit on silk rather than risk using it up before taking an assload of damage because the boss did a double damage ram that shoved you into a double damage lava pit.
>encounters
See above, also random ass ambushes I guess because DaS2 is the best game ever made. Everything deals two damage too because get fucked nerd this game that steals the DaS "watch the boss for like 2 minutes to memorize all their moves" boss design philosophy decided it would be more fun if it made the process of learning the boss more obnoxious and punishing.
>level design
Like HK the devs are too incompetent to even program slops, everything is blocky and flat, platforming challenges are rarely interesting (like seriously, outside of Mount Fay can you even remember a platforming challenge that was worth a shit?) and they compensate by throwing random enemies in the middle of them to force you to either stop and deal with them or just perfectly run through everything.
Anonymous No.723127830 [Report]
>>723127334
it has nice aesthetics and that's it
Anonymous No.723127842 [Report] >>723128041 >>723128664
>>723127739
>>723127295
You really have to stop this shit. A good quarter of the zones and bosses in Dark Souls are abject shit, there is backtracking out the absolute ass, key NPCs, merchants, and quest givers are on complete opposite sides of the world, and the 1:1 scale open world just starts to fall apart at the seams as the game goes on, with giant empty hallways and elevators of nothingness to disguise loading screens, huge empty rooms just to make a zone mesh neatly with another zone, and multiple zones of complete filler that serve only to connect different areas together. It's no coincidence the two strongest zones by far, Sen's Fortress and Painted World, are both self-contained.

Dark Souls has some high highs, but some of the lowest lows; you could cut out a good 30-40% of the game and it would be much better for it. It's honestly the weakest of the four Souls games, unless you're just a complete sucker for interconnected metroidvania worlds to the point where you ignore its gaping flaws.
Anonymous No.723127895 [Report] >>723128041
>>723127739
Dark Souls is the worst of the series and a downgrade from Demon's
>Entire second half of game is borderline incomplete and is empty and sterile with terrible level design
>Level design in general is just a lot less consistent in terms of quality than Demon's Souls
>some of the worst environments of all the Souls games like Anor Londo, Catacombs, Ash Lake, Great Hollow, Crystal Caves, Valley of Drakes, and Lost Izalith
>godawful enemies like the bonewheel skeletons, Stray Demons, Anor Londo Archers, and Drakes
>many bosses are underwhelming or poorly designed, like O&S, Priscilla, Capra, Quelaag, Pinwheel, Seath, Taurus, Ceaseless Discharge, bed of chaos
>bosses are already starting to focus primarily on action and rolling with less focus on original and puzzle bosses
>literally recycles the same boss three times
>Hitboxes and i-frames are more inconsistent
>Retarded mechanics like curse and common consumables only sold by a select few merchants (I played 1.00)
>can't fast travel anywhere until over halfway into the game, constantly backtracking and running from one end of the world to the other just to buy an item from a shop, go to a covenant, or upgrade your equipment
>many of the key mechanics are poorly explained (lordvessel, upgrading estus, kindling bonfires, pardoning, etc)
>game world is a convoluted mess with necessary NPCs scattered into the far corners of the world (the interconnected world starts to become more and more contrived as the game goes on), again requiring a ton of constant backtracking
>dogshit platforming sections
>only basically one main path you can take that you find through trial and error and backtracking. Less flexibility in boss order
>Demon's had focus on invasions, mindgames, and power dynamics, with risk reward for human form and punishing players for soul form. Dark Souls is about "le honorable duel" and there is really no downside to hollow and you just summon at the boss door. Really devalues the whole experience
Anonymous No.723127909 [Report] >>723128232
>>723127787
>and wipe you your left?
wow amazing english saar
Anonymous No.723127919 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>LTTP
>10/10
Oh no, it's retarded.
Anonymous No.723128023 [Report] >>723128120
Why do fromdrones pretend that dark souls and demon souls have any artistic value?
They were always git-gud tryhard shit and nothing else and then they seethe because Elden ring went over the top with it
Anonymous No.723128037 [Report]
>>723123092
Are you the guy who posts his book tierlist all the time? The one that's mostly YA fantasy romance, Star Wars and baseball?
Anonymous No.723128040 [Report] >>723131186
>>723121682 (OP)
Why is re4 up there? The island alone drops it to a 3/10.
Anonymous No.723128041 [Report] >>723128186
>>723127842
>>723127895
You realize Im not defending dark souls but calling out how he used the phrase wrong you fucking imbeciles? 2 steps forward and one step back is an IMPROVEMENT. the phrase he meant to use was one step forward, 2 steps back. holy fucking esl retards.
Anonymous No.723128091 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
One of these things doesnt belong
Anonymous No.723128120 [Report]
>call OoT a 10/10 game and one of the greatest of all time
>call Demon's Souls, a game that is an upgrade in every single aspect from OoT and just an objectively superior OoT-like designed for adults, rollslop
The irony is really lost on you retards, huh?

>>723128023
>muh Souls was only ever git gud bossrush rollfests
hello underage shitstain
Anonymous No.723128139 [Report]
>>723127458
>Castlevania 4
>DKC1
>KOTOR
those alone invalidate your list. Everything else I can at least chalk up to different tastes. But having these three on your list just shows your retardation.
Anonymous No.723128171 [Report]
>these people who didn't actually read the image and think it's OoT
Anonymous No.723128175 [Report]
>>723123092
bro galaxy 1 is so damn boring and piss easy
Anonymous No.723128186 [Report]
>>723128041
It's a typo you pedantic nigger
Anonymous No.723128214 [Report] >>723128782
>>723127681
>Demon's Souls has miles better level design
It really doesn't. Outside of just having far less interesting mechanics the most daring DeS gets is making really vertical levels that are obnoxious to navigate because you don't get a plunging attack. Nothing in DeS even comes close to Anor Londo in regards to level design and interesting challenges, and you rarely have to engage with the game further than "whack thing with your stick".
>less backtracking
It's completely linear so no shit.
>more creative (and non-recycled) bosses
Yeah, I'd agree with that. I actually really like the DeS bosses, even if they're a bit too easy and you don't really get a good challenge boss outside of Flamelurker I guess.
>Each weapon has completely unique animations, reach, hitbox, upgrade path, attack type, damage type, scaling, attack speed, stamina usage, etc.
No? Weapons within the same weapon class all share animations. There's no moveset distinction like DaS has between weapons in the same class, the only difference is range and scaling, which rarely impacts your playstyle much. There are also some neat weapons that are just intentionally shit for no good reason (you wanted to use that club you found? lmao get fucked)
>Add onto that the huge amount of magic, miracles
Compared to the other souls games? The only casting style you can actually make a robust build around is Int which is basically just "fire bullet" and "murderfuck overpowered aow". Faith builds obviously exist but they're just Str/Dex builds but with a few decent healing/buff spells.
Anonymous No.723128228 [Report] >>723128775
Resident Evil 4 and Dead Space 2 are the only true 10/10 games.

There's no shit parts, the gameplay is fun, the story is good.

I wouldn't even say my favorite game is 10/10 even though I like it more than those two games. They're just incredibly good and have zero flaws.
Anonymous No.723128232 [Report]
>>723127909
I'm tired.
WITH your left*
There. I hope you're not typing with your left hand, jeet-san.
Anonymous No.723128283 [Report] >>723128378 >>723128442
>>723126147
What makes something swordslop?
Anonymous No.723128361 [Report]
Luigi's Mansion
Anonymous No.723128378 [Report] >>723128669 >>723128771
>>723128283
Being like Gauntlet, AT ALL, for one.
Those games are both swordslop and magicslop all rolled into one. Dark Legacy is the worst one with artificial difficultyslop in the form of the grim reaper's level-drainslop gimmick.
Anonymous No.723128397 [Report]
>>723121856
>10/10? Easy. That's 1. Give me harder questions, Hunnigan.
Anonymous No.723128425 [Report]
Id rather play sega saturn than demons souls

the other 3 are pretty good
Anonymous No.723128442 [Report] >>723128771
>>723128283
basically shooterslop but with swords, kill every enemy to progress, etc
Anonymous No.723128559 [Report]
Demon's souls is absolutely NOT a 10/10. It's alright but crazy to put it alongside RE4. Most of the other's souls games are better.

Also throwing SIlksong on there just seems like a troll.
Anonymous No.723128664 [Report] >>723128967
>>723127842
What does that have to do with DeS being unfinished?
Anonymous No.723128669 [Report] >>723128834
>>723128378
Grim reaper PUNISHES you, i thought fromdrones loved being assraped by games
Anonymous No.723128771 [Report] >>723128889
>>723128378
>>723128442
It seems some people don't like to be forced to engae in a difficult challenge
Anonymous No.723128775 [Report] >>723129357
>>723128228
>There's no shit parts
The island in its entirety... U-3 boss fight... unless you're talking about the remake which fixes all these problems...
Anonymous No.723128782 [Report] >>723129886
>>723128214
>Anor Londo
>example of good level design
Holy fuck you are a retard. The map that is completely rushed, sterile, and filled with huge swathes of nothingness just to make the map mesh together, the godawful archer section, enemies that hit you through walls inside the castle, and one of the absolute worst bosses in the game. It's one of the weakest areas of the game and marks the beginning of the steep decline that is the latter half of Dark Souls. The ONLY thing Anor Londo has going for it is Painted World.

>It's completely linear so no shit
It's not just black and white linear or open world. Demon's Souls has levels that range from open to winding to labyrinthine, full of multiple paths, tons of secrets, realistic shortcuts, and nooks and crannies to explore. Dark Souls is more egregious in this respect as it gives the illusion of freedom but has more strict boss order and constantly makes you ping-pong back and forth for arbitrary plot progression events. Additionally, the strict adherence to 1:1 scale leads to giant empty hallways and elevators of nothingness to disguise loading screens, huge empty rooms just to make a zone mesh neatly with another zone, and multiple zones of complete filler that serve only to connect different areas together. It's no coincidence the two strongest zones by far, Sen's Fortress and Painted World, are both self-contained (and "linear" as you call it)

>No? Weapons within the same weapon class all share animations.
Only would Souls games be held to the standard that they should have thousands of unique animation between all the weapons in the game, and hundreds of unique and viable builds; Demon's Souls already doesn't have dozens of viable weapons, spells, equipment, and playstyles, but apparently that's still not good enough. Never mind the fact that people don't even like the games with the most build variety (DkS2+3).

No one applies this standard, or anything remotely close to it, to other action adventure games
Anonymous No.723128812 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Demon's Souls yes. But Diablo II, Armored Core: For Answer, Resident Evil 2 (both or either Classic or Remake), or Nioh 2 would and should belong in those slots.
Anonymous No.723128834 [Report] >>723129013
>>723128669
It's a gimmick, though. At least in Souls games, you can recover your EXP by recovering your bloodstain. Dark Legacy's reaperslop drains your EXP, and you can't get it back from him. Even more inexcusable since it's an arcadeslop game, designed to drain your wallet dry by default, and the level-drainslop design just makes it downright predatory.
Midway has never made a good game.
Anonymous No.723128889 [Report] >>723128972
>>723128771
Elden ring is fine, Dark souls is shit because of all of it's artificial difficulty.
Dragon's Dogma is my go to game for third person swordslop
Anonymous No.723128945 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Replace link to the past with links awakening
Anonymous No.723128953 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Why is silksong here
Anonymous No.723128967 [Report] >>723130014
>>723128664
Not doing everything they wanted to do =/= unfinished. I would have loved to see the final archstone, but it didn't pan out. The game was already extremely ambitious and a flyer that was assumed a failure. For a first time player (assuming first Souls game and not glued to a guide the whole time), Demon's Souls already has easily 30+ hours of content with a high degree of challenge, playstyle variety, and replayability; if the broken archstone was never in the game, no one would be none the wiser (unfinished content that wasn't used is hardly uncommon in the slightest).

You can't look at a 10/10 and say "well why isn't it an 11/10?"
Anonymous No.723128972 [Report] >>723129082
>>723128889
What is "artificial difficulty?"
Anonymous No.723129013 [Report] >>723129131 >>723129292
>>723128834
You're right, the grim reaper isn't shit compared to those artificial difficulty slop dark souls frogs that reduce your health by 2/3 and if you don't have a healing stone you are fucked
Anonymous No.723129082 [Report] >>723129585
>>723128972
tediousness and a waste of timeness like forever lost currency, backtracking and annoying status effects, all of those are manageable in Elden ring making it decently fun
Anonymous No.723129131 [Report] >>723129232
>>723129013
by 1/2 but who's counting?
Obviously not you. Math must be difficult. Especially when something doesn't fit your narrative.
Anonymous No.723129232 [Report] >>723129292
>>723129131
Useless reply
Anonymous No.723129259 [Report]
>>723127681
Demon trannies are worse than DS2 cultists holy fuck.
>Dark Souls was two steps forward, one step back.
KEK
Anonymous No.723129292 [Report] >>723129381
>>723129232
So was >>723129013 but who cares?
Anonymous No.723129330 [Report]
>>723123092
based
Anonymous No.723129341 [Report] >>723129442 >>723131167
'94 zillennial here. Not jaded nor blinded by nostalgia. I've beat probably close to 1000 games and these are what I would consider 10/10 or close to it:

>Demon's Souls
>Divinity Original Sin II
>Fallout New Vegas
>TBoIR (and its DLC)
>The Evil Within
>Catherine
>Crash Bandicoot (1>2>3)
>Zelda ALTTP
>Cave Story
>Red Alert 2/Yuri's Revenge
>DKC (2>1>3)
>RE4
>Ratchet & Clank (1 > 2 > 3)
>XCOM
>Metal Slug (2 > 1 > 4 > 3)
>Cuphead
>Dead Cells
>Dark Souls
>LittleBigPlanet
>Sin & Punishment
>MGS3
>Red Dead Redemption
>Pikmin 2
>Darkest Dungeon
>Star Fox 64
>Halo 3
>Portal 2
>Animal Crossing
>Batman Arkham Asylum
>Rollercoaster Tycoon (OpenRCT2)
>Wipeout Omega Collection
>Mass Effect 1
>Sly 2
>Hotline Miami 2
Anonymous No.723129357 [Report]
>>723128775
>The island in its entirety
Brainlet opinion.
Anonymous No.723129381 [Report] >>723129602
>>723129292
Just stating facts
Anonymous No.723129442 [Report] >>723129926
>>723129341
That Dark Souls is supposed to be Dark Souls 3 or 2, not 1.
Anonymous No.723129585 [Report] >>723129747
>>723129082
I get the backtracking, but lost currency and status effects are just part of the challenge
Anonymous No.723129602 [Report] >>723129747
>>723129381
And I'm stating the fact that DeS soul form, DaS lizard curse, and DS2 full cursed all only reduce you to 1/2 health.
Anonymous No.723129617 [Report] >>723131398 >>723141084
>>723123092
3D Zelda is bad, so is Half-Life, and X6 is the best X game. Actually X2 is but I like praising X6 anyway because of how contentious it is.
Anonymous No.723129747 [Report] >>723129779 >>723129979
>>723129585
it's not challenging to not have a item to remove your curse, it's fucking annoying.
>>723129602
It's only in the game to introduce tedium and sloppify the difficulty
Anonymous No.723129779 [Report] >>723129879
>>723129747
>It's only in the game to introduce tedium and sloppify the difficulty
But enough about Gauntlet: Dark Legacy's grim reaper.
Anonymous No.723129830 [Report] >>723129919 >>723130551
>>723121682 (OP)
>RE4
6/10 game
>Demon Souls
4/10 game
>ALttP
8/10 game
>Silksong
8/10 game

I genuinely hate Demon Souls/Dark Souls/etc
The basic controls are just so ass, there's never a point where it becomes enjoyable to control your character. I think of my favorite games, like Jedi Academy, Mirror's Edge, Dustforce, SSBM, and the thing that makes them great is how exceptionally fun the basic way you interact with the environment and move about is...
Anonymous No.723129879 [Report] >>723129981
>>723129779
the grim reaper punishes you and leaves, just like how fromdrones like being assfucked raw and left in the snow, the lizardslopcurse lingers around you forever gnawing at your sanity
Anonymous No.723129886 [Report] >>723130487
>>723128782
Bold of you to assume I'd read the rest of your post when you open with "good area of DaS is actually... le bad."
>godawful archer section
I hate to pull the git gud card but, like anon it's a parry check following a basic logic check (arrows can't hit you if you run, wow). Just learn how to parry you fucking mongrel.

Actually something else in your post caught my eye.
>Demon's Souls has levels that range from open to winding to labyrinthine
Even if that were true (you have alternative paths that typically lead to dead ends or maybe quest triggers, maybe a few skips if you're lucky), labyrinthine isn't exactly a word I'd use to describe a well designed level.
Anonymous No.723129919 [Report]
>>723129830
>SSBM
Stopped reading
Anonymous No.723129926 [Report]
>>723129442
you just invalidated the whole list by admitting that
Anonymous No.723129979 [Report]
>>723129747
It is challenging. The curse makes gameplay more difficult = challenge. I get that it can be annoying but that is probably the point. It's subjective whether you like that sort of thing or not.
Anonymous No.723129981 [Report] >>723130230
>>723129879
>punishes you and leaves
Just like dying and recovering your bloodstain.
Except not, since you can't just defeat the reaper to get your EXP back.
Souls games at least give you a fighting chance.
Anonymous No.723130014 [Report] >>723130487
>>723128967
>playstyle variety
There's no meaningful difference between 90% of the weapons outside of optimal stat distribution (which mostly just increases your numbers), armor is notoriously pretty shit in DeS too so there's little reason to experiment with roll speed vs armor values. I couldn't even tell you off the top of my head if bonus thrusting counter damage exists in DeS. I think they have shield pokes at least, so that's something maybe if they have that.
Anonymous No.723130230 [Report] >>723130302
>>723129981
you can at least kill the reaper instantly with the 9 potions you are holding, let's say you meet him for the first time and he drains a level, you may just lose like 5% of your health, it's not a big deal.
Meanwhile the lizard curse slops up 50% of your health and now i am too weak to literally progress through the game, the difficulty has now been increased artificially thus it has become slop
Anonymous No.723130302 [Report] >>723130372
>>723130230
>the difficulty has now been increased artificially thus it has become slop
Just like what happens when you get assraped by Midway's idea of a funny joke. (level-drained by the reaper)
Anonymous No.723130372 [Report] >>723130721
>>723130302
assrape vs a light dick tingle, no one is uninstalling because the grim reaper got you once
Anonymous No.723130487 [Report] >>723131303 >>723131436
>>723129886
>>723130014
make it more obvious you are a zoomer shitstain bandwagon faggot who started Souls after PTDE and copy OP builds from your favorite eceleb faggot to trivialize the whole game.

No one playing Demon's Souls or Dark Souls back in the day parried, nor did they give a shit about autistic bullshit like thrusting counter damage, or the most optimal armor usage to stay at fast roll. Even PvP players didn't give a shit about such autistic min-maxxing bullshit.

Most players fatrolled, they used what armor they could find, they used a big ass shield, and they used whatever weapons and magic seemed cool. You cancerous esports shits who play everything glued to a guide and can't even comprehend playing a game without min-max wikia faggotry are a fucking scourge on gaming. Die.
Anonymous No.723130551 [Report]
>>723129830
Subhuman retard post.
Anonymous No.723130721 [Report] >>723130854
>>723130372
>no one is uninstalling because the grim reaper got you once
I did. CHECKMATE.
Anonymous No.723130805 [Report] >>723130831
>>723121682 (OP)
Idk I only played RE4 (original) I agree it's 10/10 not sure about the rest though
Anonymous No.723130831 [Report] >>723131703
>>723130805
>xhe never played ALttP
Grim
Anonymous No.723130854 [Report] >>723130992
>>723130721
Clearly you didn't since your only experience with it is injecting coins to play it
Anonymous No.723130992 [Report] >>723131123
>>723130854
I pirated it for my modded PS2. Snapped the disc in half after getting level-drainslopped.
Anonymous No.723131045 [Report] >>723132945
holy shit you fags get printed out of a factory.
Anonymous No.723131092 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Only Demon's Souls is a 10/10 game and that only holds true for the PS5 version
Anonymous No.723131123 [Report] >>723131481
>>723130992
Prove it
Anonymous No.723131124 [Report]
>>723122986
>killed the series

Saved the series
Anonymous No.723131167 [Report]
>>723129341
>Not jaded
You 100% are. It's way too apparent from the way that you type.
Anonymous No.723131172 [Report]
>>723123092
Why mario and sonic you fucking pedophile, let the children be.
Anonymous No.723131186 [Report]
>>723128040
...how?
Anonymous No.723131303 [Report]
>>723130487
>If you use this basic mechanic that's both really strong and also on like 90% of the shields that you'd use, you're a youtuber watching power gamer
Nigger what
>Most players fatrolled, they used what armor they could find, they used a big ass shield, and they used whatever weapons and magic seemed cool.
Putting aside the fact that you were obviously retarded (I mean I was too, my first DaS run I just pumped Int and Att exclusively because I thought hp was for faggots, it wasn't a very fun time), it just sounds like you're romanticizing a very specific way in which you played these games. It's impossible to have a meaningful conversation when that's your golden standard.
Also praising DeS for "build variety" and then turning around and shitting on knowing how to build a character is either hypocritical or obvious trolling, I'm too tired to figure out which.
Anonymous No.723131398 [Report] >>723132231
>>723129617
Well stop that faggot, because X6 is trash.
Anonymous No.723131436 [Report]
>>723130487
>No one playing Demon's Souls or Dark Souls back in the day parried
I did and so did my friends. Parrying is a basic mechanic in the games.
Anonymous No.723131478 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
It's missing Rollercoaster Tycoon 2
Anonymous No.723131481 [Report]
>>723131123
How?
Idiot.
Anonymous No.723131489 [Report] >>723131787 >>723132115
>>723121682 (OP)
>going to shit once you hit the island
>tying all sidequests to world tendency - which locks you out entirely if playing online because it evens it out for some reason
>lol lmao boring fucking game
>collect 12 rat pelts sidequests
Anonymous No.723131703 [Report] >>723131871
>>723130831
I grew up with Genesis and PS1. Never really cared about your Zelda and Nintendo games
Anonymous No.723131787 [Report]
>>723131489
>no valid criticism for ALttP
I accept your concession.
Anonymous No.723131871 [Report]
>>723131703
I grew up with both, so I never felt compelled to jump onboard with either "team's" autistic tribalism.
Anonymous No.723132115 [Report] >>723132286
>>723131489
I can't believe I've spent all this time criticizing DeS and still completely forgot to mention how shit world tendency is.
Anonymous No.723132231 [Report]
>>723131398
You simply lack the vision
Anonymous No.723132286 [Report] >>723132774 >>723133437
>>723132115
>spent all this time criticizing DeS
kill yourself subhuman retard.

>forgot to mention how shit world tendency is.
because it's basically a complete nonissue. They had dozens of extremely innovative ideas and got an insane amount right on their first attempt, so it's only natural that some things didn't quite pan out. Fortunately, WT is basically irrelevant unless you are going for 100%, and even then it's negligible once you know how the system works. It makes the game slightly harder, but more than compensates with more souls and better loot to offset it; basically trial by fire, but with appropriate payoff.
Anonymous No.723132568 [Report] >>723132760
>>723122217
The first Dark souls is legitimately at least a 9/10 it perfected the genre and everything afterwards is superficial, demon souls is objectively worse and worse for reasons of retarded artificial difficulty
Anonymous No.723132615 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>soulswank
jej
Anonymous No.723132670 [Report]
>>723123092
>h2 and oot at the top

based
Anonymous No.723132735 [Report]
>>723123092
>Last of Us
Anonymous No.723132760 [Report] >>723140554
>>723132568
>retarded artificial difficulty
holy shit you are an absolute fucking retard who just blindly regurgitates bullshit and doesn't have a single original thought in your head. Kys
Anonymous No.723132774 [Report] >>723132906
>>723132286
I'd rather they have innovative ideas that are fun to engage with (miracle synergy, covenants that add diversity to pvp) rather than innovative ideas that arbitrarily lock you out of content and that's it.
Anonymous No.723132796 [Report] >>723132870
>>723121682 (OP)
>RE4
Agreed.
>Demon's Souls
kek
>Ocarina of Time
Agreed.
>Silksong
Hollow Knight is better.
Anonymous No.723132870 [Report]
>>723132796
That's not Ocarina. It's ALttP. Ocarina was not the only Zelda game with a gold backdrop cover.
Anonymous No.723132906 [Report] >>723133410
>>723132774
>muh content!!
>I need to be able to 100% the game on my first time through with no effort!!
kys you fucking retarded fucking zoomer obsessed with muh content and muh cheevos and muh time optimization so I can tick off a box on my backlog. Fucking subhuman shitstain. Enjoy a fucking game, view a mechanic as a novel concept that changes the way you play the game instead of just a checklist.
Anonymous No.723132945 [Report]
>>723131045
imagine getting baited this easily
Anonymous No.723133410 [Report] >>723133701
>>723132906
The mechanic doesn't add anything, it literally does the opposite of adding to your playthrough. If you had meaningful ways of manipulating it that might be interesting but outside of perfect clearing stages or dying over and over you really don't.
Anonymous No.723133437 [Report] >>723133701
>>723132286
>defending world tendency
This is how you know someone is a braindead contrarian nigger who's future opinions should now be disregarded. Dark souls objectively has better designed multiplayer mechanics and systems, everyone knows it's true.
Anonymous No.723133641 [Report] >>723133764
>RE4
A 9/10. One awful level but it made up for a great experience.
>DeS
5/10. Mediocre experience and a lot of fundamental issues. The jeetshill spering out is wrong for defending overall poor design.
>ALTTP
7/10. Maybe a 9 at best when it was around but not much you can do with it as with later Zeldas.
>Silksong
8/10. Great bosses but terrible run backs.
Anonymous No.723133701 [Report]
>>723133410
You also get +WT for killing black phantom NPCs and players.

>>723133437
I'm not necessarily defending it, just saying it's way overhated. I get what they were going for, but the idea could have been implemented better.

Overall though, it's largely inconsequential unless you are trying to 100% the game blind without a guide and without understanding how it works. Back in the day, very few people bitched about WT or even really noticed it, it was just a minor feature that caused the world to change as you died, and rewarded you with more souls and better rewards for overcoming tougher enemies.

For a game that made dozens of massive innovations and had such incredible design across the board, minor stumbles here and there are to be expected.

>Dark souls objectively has better designed multiplayer mechanics and systems, everyone knows it's true.
You really have to stop this shit. A good quarter of the zones and bosses in Dark Souls are abject shit, there is backtracking out the absolute ass, key NPCs, merchants, and quest givers are on complete opposite sides of the world, and the 1:1 scale open world just starts to fall apart at the seams as the game goes on, with giant empty hallways and elevators of nothingness to disguise loading screens, huge empty rooms just to make a zone mesh neatly with another zone, and multiple zones of complete filler that serve only to connect different areas together. It's no coincidence the two strongest zones by far, Sen's Fortress and Painted World, are both self-contained.

Dark Souls has some high highs, but some of the lowest lows; you could cut out a good 30-40% of the game and it would be much better for it. It's honestly the weakest of the four Souls games, unless you're just a complete sucker for interconnected metroidvania worlds to the point where you ignore its gaping flaws.
Anonymous No.723133764 [Report]
>>723133641
Subhuman retard with shit taste, and proud of it. What a combo.
Anonymous No.723133908 [Report] >>723134381 >>723134979 >>723135080
The Demon's Souls hate is such forced revisionist history. Just yet another a symptom of Brown Internet Theory and /v/ being flooded with underage, turd worlder, sharty refugee newfags.

Back in early 2010's, Demon's Souls was universally seen as a masterpiece here, and still is today in corners of the internet not flooded with stinky brown retards.
Anonymous No.723134381 [Report]
>>723133908
Back in the 2010s everyone parroted that Mystery of the Druids plot greentext that was an outright lie.
Anonymous No.723134979 [Report]
>>723133908
>Back in early 2010's, Demon's Souls was universally seen as a masterpiece here
Can confirm, I was here.
Anonymous No.723135080 [Report] >>723142452
>>723133908
i been here since 2004 and souls shit was never liked, demons shit in particular was never talked abouted until dark souls come to gfwl years later, then snoyggys tried to do a revisionism and pretend we always liked the shit series.
Anonymous No.723135101 [Report] >>723135870 >>723137703
>>723121682 (OP)
only arcade style games can be 10/10
Anonymous No.723135195 [Report] >>723135263
Why do autists think 10/10 means perfect when that has never been the case in any rating scale for other mediums?
Anonymous No.723135263 [Report]
>>723135195
>why do autists
there's your answer
Anonymous No.723135797 [Report]
>>723121827
Silksong is reddit as fuck.
Anonymous No.723135870 [Report]
>>723135101
My nig.
Anonymous No.723137358 [Report] >>723137489
>>723127310
Sorry Bro, but Gauntlet Dark Legacy is older than you and absolute Kino
Anonymous No.723137489 [Report] >>723140643
>>723137358
I was born in 1983.
Anonymous No.723137607 [Report]
>>723126381
Based
Anonymous No.723137691 [Report] >>723137807
>>723121682 (OP)
nah silksong too hard to be 10/10. I beat the whole thing btw including act 3 so dont tell me git gud
Anonymous No.723137703 [Report]
>>723135101
fucking based
Anonymous No.723137807 [Report] >>723137884
>>723137691
>silksong too hard
Never, ever play Mars Matrix.
Anonymous No.723137884 [Report] >>723137921
>>723137807
>shmup garbage that is only hard if you go for 1cc
fuck off poser retard
Anonymous No.723137921 [Report]
>>723137884
>only hard if you truly beat the game
Grim
I bet you use continues
Anonymous No.723138046 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>Demon's Souls
Along Dark Souls 1 the only 2 games in the franchise that don't suck ass and eat stinky poopoo
Anonymous No.723138113 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
The person who made that list sucks cock by choice.
Anonymous No.723139359 [Report]
Anonymous No.723140268 [Report] >>723140639
>>723121682 (OP)
Anonymous No.723140384 [Report]
the only 10/10 game is Tetris
Everything else has faults
Anonymous No.723140554 [Report]
>>723132760
Right back at your faggot. You're out of your fucking mind if you think Demon souls doesn't have like 20% random bullshit that fucks you over.
>Flame Lurker
>Scraping Spears
Anonymous No.723140639 [Report] >>723141390
>>723140268
Every single game on here is trash
Anonymous No.723140643 [Report] >>723140795
>>723137489
then you should fucking know
t. also born in 1983
Anonymous No.723140748 [Report] >>723141169
>>723122828
>>723122217
>>723127171
*Laughs in Shadow tower*
Anonymous No.723140795 [Report] >>723142728
>>723140643
I do know that it was NOT kino.
Anyway, since we're just shitposting about our favorite games at this point, here's my chart.
Anonymous No.723140998 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
No, the only 10/10 on there is RE4.
Anonymous No.723141084 [Report]
>>723129617
X2 is fucking garbage. Go actually play it, contrarian retard.
Anonymous No.723141169 [Report] >>723141430
>>723140748
Just started playing Shadow Tower yesterday.
Demon's Souls really did borrow pretty heavily from it, eh?
Anonymous No.723141341 [Report] >>723141407
>>723122217
>lttp isn't even the best 2d zelda and ofc not 10
What is the best 2d Zelda?
Anonymous No.723141390 [Report] >>723142527
>>723140639
What the fuck games do you enjoy then brownoid?
Anonymous No.723141407 [Report]
>>723141341
Watch, he'll parrot his favorite youtuber and say Link's Awakening.
Anonymous No.723141430 [Report]
>>723141169
More than you could possibly imagine
Anonymous No.723142452 [Report]
>>723135080
Kill yourself subhuman tendiepedo
Anonymous No.723142527 [Report]
>>723141390
Roblox: Rivals. Hollow Knight. Terraria. Actual classics
Anonymous No.723142610 [Report]
>>723123092
>Fallen Order
>Jedi Survivor
>Black Mesa
>GoW 1
>GoW 2
>Gaylo 2
>Gaylo 3
>Halo Reach
>Glaxy one
>Last of us
>Horizon
Remove all of these and the list isn't AWFUL
Anonymous No.723142728 [Report]
>>723140795
>Talos principle
>10/10
Ah so you're insane, it isn't a bad game but it acts like it is so crazy puzzle game while the narrative barely saves itself from being pretentious like the witness.
Gauntlet DL is still kino. A gem of the 3D hack and slash genre, up there with champions of norrath and ahead of D&D heroes
Anonymous No.723142770 [Report] >>723142860
>>723121682 (OP)
a 10/10 has to do everything within its genre perfectly or close to on the first try, so by virtue of being patched silksong does not belong
Anonymous No.723142860 [Report] >>723142924
>>723142770
Only zelda left then since the other games were remastered with changes. The developers failed their first iteration
Anonymous No.723142924 [Report]
>>723142860
then theres your answer
Anonymous No.723143129 [Report] >>723145236
>>723121682 (OP)
I have never liked zombie garbage.
Armored Core is better than soulsshit.
Lttp? Top-down Zelda is annoying. Zelda only got good with OOT.
No comment on silksong. Don't care about and will never play it.
Anonymous No.723143193 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
no, but only because LTTP isn't a 10/10 game
Anonymous No.723143253 [Report]
>>723123092
>bing bing games
>Smelee
>best sonic (shadow) game ever made at the very bottom
>nu-wars jedi trash games over jedi academy
Anonymous No.723143267 [Report]
>>723123092
>zelda zelda donkey kong mario mario mario
>11/10
didn't bother reading the rest of your list
Anonymous No.723143323 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
Almost, but you need to replace DeS with Sekiro and LTTP with a good game.
Anonymous No.723143391 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>all Chinese trash
This board has completely been taken over by the CCP.
Anonymous No.723143461 [Report]
>>723121682 (OP)
>RE4
>OOT
>Witcher 3
>SOTN
The only real 10/10s
Anonymous No.723143517 [Report]
Resident Evil 4 isn't 10/10.
>more levels are annoying than they are fun
>quick time events
there are better Resident Evils
Anonymous No.723143674 [Report] >>723145567
>>723121682 (OP)
I think metal gear solid can be a 10/10 as well…. Just my opinion
Anonymous No.723143947 [Report]
>>723121815
I'm pretty sure anon thought that was OoT which even still would be a pretty piss poor criticism compared to loads of other noticeable issues
Anonymous No.723144008 [Report]
I respect Tokido for still attacking Lesh with 4 seconds left and a life lead. Went out like a warrior. A World warrior if you will
Anonymous No.723144191 [Report]
>Silksong
>E33
>Deltarune
We had 3 10/10s this year alone
Anonymous No.723144290 [Report]
>>723121827
it's ironic shitposting
Anonymous No.723145236 [Report]
>>723143129
>Zelda only got good with OOT.
Neck yourself zoomshit
Anonymous No.723145567 [Report]
Wrong. TimeSplitters 2 and TimeSplitters Future Perfect aren't on that pic.
>>723143674
Wrong, movie games try too hard to not be games. See also: illusion of choice.