Thread 723165653

What games evoke the feeling of "I wish I could play this for the first time again" for you?

For me some of the biggest contenders are:

Outer Wilds
Void Stranger
Returns of the Obra Dinn
Disco Elysium

>>723165653 (OP)
red dead 2
botw
planescape torment
skyrim

super mario world
runescape

>>723165759
>Pesuds

>>723165653 (OP)
HOLY
FUCKING
SHIT

IS THAT
IT CAN'T BE

IT'S COOL GUY

The Forgotten City

>DID YOU SAY HECKING DISCO ELYSIUM'S?
>DISCO ELYSIUM IS HECKIN GAME OF THE YEAR LEFTYPOL SISTERS!!!!
>OMG OMG OMG OMG
>HECKING EPIC POGGY WOCKY SLUSH !!!!
>IS THAT POGGY WOGGING HECKIN WHOLESOME CHUNGUS DISCO ELYSIUM WOCKY SLUSH !!!!
>i literally can't right now!!!
>I GET SO EXCITED ABOUT IT I KNEEL! I KNEEL FOR MY BLACK MASTER! WOCKY SLUSH !!!!
>THE CLASS CONSCIOUSNESS REMINDS ME OF MY HECKIN BONGO RED DEAD 2 DISCORD CLAN.
>SUS BRO I LOVE TWITTER LMAO DREAM IS SO FUNNI HAHAHA REDDIT BRUH LMAO LIKE HIM HATE HIM HE SPITTING STRAIGHT FACTS LEL LE
> I LOVE REDDIT YALL YALL YALL HAHA SEE I WHO I GET TO SEE HAHA LMAO THIS IS JUST LIKE MINECRAFT!!!HORNY ON MAIN??
>SELFCARE CRINGE BRO BE LIKE BE LIKE HE PROTECC HE ATTACC BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY SHE REALLY SAID OK BOOMER AND THATS VALID BRO WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT SIIIIMPS! LITERALLY NO CAP
>I AM SHE/THEY ON TWITTER AN I’M BOUT TO END THIS WHOLE MAN’S CAREER MY GUY MY GUY MY GUY BORK BORK DOGGO FRFR #ACAB #BLM #PROUDFURRY JOIN MY DISCOOOOORD
>ITS SO HECKING COOL, THE MAKERS ARE EVEN COMMUNISRLTINO POG LORDS LIKE ME WHO TOOK THE KNEE FOR MR SAINT FLOYD (MAY YAKUB REST HIS SOUL)
>SUCH A EPIC POOGERS GAME I CAN'T WAIT TO POST THIS ON ®EDDIT!!! WOCKY SLUSH !!!!
>#pogchamp WOCKY SLUSH !!!!
>IT'S GOING... IT'S GOING.... AND YEEESSSSS THE BBC HAS LANDED INTO MY WIFE OH MY SCIENCE THIS IS A GLORIOUS DAY I FEEL SO EMPOWERED LETTING ANOTHER MEN FUCK MY WIFE JUST LIKE MY FRIEND SCHLOMO SUGGESTED MAYBE I WILL TAKE OUT A LOAN SO THOSE TWO CAN GO ON VACATION
>LET ME POST THIS ON MY TIK TOK!!!
>W-WHAT??? DID THAT BULL JUST MISGENDER ME??? OH NO NO NO I'M TOTALLY NOT MENTALLY ILL OR ANYTHING BUT THAT'S ENOUGH TO PUSH ME OVER THE EDGE
>I CAN'T LIVE ANY LONGER... GOODBYE *hangs himself*

FFVII.

>>723165759
>a bunch of games that don't have replay value since the magic is the first experience
>pseud
you're just retarded

Disco Elysium.
It... changed me.

sengoku rance desu

>>723165653 (OP)
Even when I've played the greatest games of all time I've never felt this. I either wanna play them or I don't, either way it doesn't matter because if they were that good I don't feel I have to replay them again. If the company has any actual value the sequel should beat it as well

>>723165653 (OP)
>Persona 5 Royal
>Persona 4 Golden
>Nekopara Vol. 1
>Rabi-Ribi
>Hyperdimension Neptunia mk2
>Doki Doki Exit Music: Redux
>Ib
>SEQUEL Blight

>>723166079
Same, for the better.

>>723166079
You want to change back?

>>723165880
Coooooooooool guuuuuuyyyyyyy

>>723165653 (OP)
IT'S COOL GUY!!!!

>>723165653 (OP)
ITS COOOL GUY

>>723165653 (OP)
>Sunless Sea
>Sunless Sky
>Hyper Light Drifter
Not so much that they have no replay value but the mystery, twists, and cool design elements that surprise me don't pack the same punch anymore on a replay. Though I'd say Outer Wilds, Obra, and Disco do the same for me also. I haven't played Void Strangers yet is it any good?

>>723166191
He misses his penis sometimes.

>>723166321
>I haven't played Void Strangers yet is it any good?
10/10 puzzle kino.

>>723165653 (OP)
Alundra.
Persona 4.
Demon's Souls.

>>723165653 (OP)
HEY IT'S COOL GUY!

>>723165653 (OP)
Persona 5
Somehow I wasn't spoiled for it (I mean besides Akechi but cmon that was obvious and I didn't get spoiled for the ACTUALLY WE KNEW twist) so every dungeon was something new.

>VTMB1
>Bloodborne
>Curse of the Golden Idol

>>723166662
>>Curse of the Golden Idol
Didn't play this yet, what's the core appeal?

>>723166735
Solving an elaborate mystery over several levels that span decades/centuries.
Or blindly guessing and ruining the experience.

>>723166735
>what's the core appeal?
WORDS WORDS WORDS
point and click logic
WORDS WORDS WORDS

>>723165791
I always thought these enemies were scary as a kid because they looked like ugly cyclops.

>>723166735
The game makes me feel smart

>723165991
meds NOW

>>723165653 (OP)
Rain World. Beating that game for the first time was so ludo.

>>723167639
the more things change, the more they stay the same

>>723165991
This. Fpbp. /Thread.

>>723165653 (OP)
Every horror game I like

>>723165653 (OP)
Pathfinder Kingmaker

>>723165653 (OP)
IT'S COOL GUY!!!

>>723165653 (OP)
there would be riots if coolguy was made in 2025

thinly veiled shill thread

>>723170361
>everything that isn't gacha, fortnite or roblox MUST be a shill thread
Zoomer begone.

>>723165653 (OP)
If I want that feeling I just don't play it for a long time, I replayed Megaman X for the first time in like 4 years and it feels brand new