Thread 723218365

Uncharted vs Tomb Raider (reboot), which is the better action-adventure series?

>>723218365 (OP)
I only played Uncharted so I pick that I guess

>>723218365 (OP)
The one with the bro protag and no yellow paint or crafting mechanics

original tomb raiders and uncharted 1-3 only

>>723218637
Uncharted 4 is better than 3 and 1.

>>723218365 (OP)
Uncharted games are linear movie games where you walk from set piece to set piece with decentish shooting sections in between.
New Tomb Raider is hub based craft slop with crap shooting, crap puzzles and crap exploration

>>723218365 (OP)
If you are evaluating the whole series, uncharted is way better. I liked the first Tomb Raider reboot game pretty a good but but the other two in that series were awful.

>>723218816
Uncharted 4 tried a bit to add more freedom and less linearity to the gameplay. A truly linear movie game with tons of set pieces and shooting is Max Payne 3.

>>723218365 (OP)
>Remove all the iconography from IP
>wonder why people never bring up nu TombRaider in 2025.

>>723218365 (OP)
I don't understand the question. How could it be tomb raider?

>>723218365 (OP)
i liked the tomb raiders even though they are moviegames. i did not like uncharted 1 and dropped 2, never played anything beyond that.

>>723218365 (OP)
Shit raider is literally unfun uncharted with desexed lame nondescript character.
I don't like Uncharted, but it's something that i can understand why peopel may like, and it definitely has its own identity. It's not a dogshit raceswapped tombraider or a gay millennial indiana jones.

The one that wasnt' woke

>>723218803
No, the story was boring and sexist against men:

https://youtube.com/shorts/yh9_b58_JB4?si=MRO8lL82zDcDRdXG

>>723218932
I wish we got uncharted 5 6 7 instead of tlou2 abortion

>>723222452
It's a video game, I don't care about story

>>723222487
No they should have just made a new good ip, people would be tired to death of Uncharted at that point

>>723222517
But that's just it the gameplay is quite good but then we have crap like bald avatard space lezzo and tlou2 which is trash

>>723222579
I wasn't there was still life in it
Golden circle was basically just first person tomb raider x wolf x uncharted and was my favorite game of last year for the story alone. Gameplay was fun but it was a true movie game

>>723222594
Indeed

>>723222660
Sadly we will never get another good game from naughty dog with that failed wannabe stealsuckmann at the helm with his greedy kikeness
Rip ND 1995-2015

>>723222645
People already complained that 4 was unnecessary because Nathan's story already had an ending in 3. If there was an Uncharted 5 or 6 or even 7, people would complain Naughty Dog is milking the series to death. They should have just made a new IP and not make Tlou 2 either

>>723222693
Trve unfortunately

Unchated 2 is the absolute peak of "movie game" in that it feels like a movie but is also still a good game.

>>723222754
They made a new IP whatever that bald avatar aang looking bitch was and it flopped even before the trailer was out now it's vaporware they haven't even made a exclusive game for the PS5 and it's been out for almost 5 years

>>723218850
Uncharted 1 was also garbage

>>723222829
Uncharted 1 and the PSP game where decent I don't get why they got so much hate
Shame about the movie too

>>723218637
>Old good new bad

oh my gosh i can't wait till you boomers fade to dust already

>>723222831
I said a "good" new IP, and not whatever that abomination that's currently being made is. If more Uncharted games were made they would just be ruining an already existing IP instead of a new one

>>723218365 (OP)
I haven't played either

>>723222856
Worse then the first reboot? At least Laura 2 And 3 had nice visuals and some gameplay even if it wasn't great it still holds up ok

>>723219104
what iconography?

>>723222907
New good ips really don't exist anymore sadly all the talent left and it's not like they went elsewhere since tv movies YouTube and streaming is call crap now

>>723218365 (OP)
Uncharted is more spectacle(Indiana Jones, James Bond) while Tomb Raider is much grittier and violent, almost survival.

>>723222906
Have u been asleep the last 5-10 years or have you not even been alive you pluribus larve

>>723222906
the games you played as a 12 year old were/are all shit

>>723223106
Minecraft and Red Dead 2 were pretty good though

>>723223197
No.

>>723223247
Dark Souls 3 was pretty good too

>>723223197
Rdr2 was the definition of midgame and even late game padding

>>723218365 (OP)
Uncharted 4 was the reason I bought the PS4 as a kid

>>723222906
>>Old good new bad
fucking deal with it already
nothing made for your genearation wil lever be good

>>723222970
'Laura' in 2 and 3 was beaten to death with ugly and short stick and the visuals/mechanics were trite AAA slop

>>723222998
>Tomb Raider/Lara Croft
>what iconography?

>>723218365 (OP)
I prefer TR

>>723218365 (OP)
Indian Jones and the Great Circle is genuinely better than both

>>723223025
TR reboot is jsut ugly unfun woke dogshit

>>723223414
I don't think you know what "iconography" means.
btw it's not a synonym for iconic

>>723223431
found the trans
>>723223482
easily

Tomb Raider 2013 is actually a really good game.

>>723218365 (OP)
Uncharted, I don't care about Tomb Raider

>>723223514
I don't think you knwo what iconography or iconic actually means.
What I don't know is what kind of specious semantic shit you are concocting, but since I don't care there is no problem

>>723223553
too railroaded

>>723218365 (OP)
Tomb Raider came out just 2 years after Uncharted 3 and it utterly mogged it

>>723223025
Yeah Uncharted games are rated T while Tomb Raider is M rated

>>723223553
it's prime example of nondescript desexualized grimdark derivative slop with trite mechanics, on top of IP rape

>>723223825
NuRaider is derivative ugly boring dogshit. And not Tomb Raider
It's nothign compared to Uncharted... and I don't even like Uncharted