Thread 723674308

played the first 5 hours or so of this and I just don't get it, why is this considered the greatest vn of all time? Unless it completely subverts everything, feel like it's incredibly normal

When did anyone say it was the greatest vn of all time? It was cool for the early aughts and people like to meme about it, that's all.

>>723674308 (OP)
The original Tsukihime is well written for a doujinshi release of its time, and catapulted Type-Moon guys into a fame for good reason, and it is at least partially to thank for (or to blame depending on your views) for visual novels picking up in West.
...But I have no idea if Remake is any good at all.

>>723674308 (OP)
You were supposed to get witch on the holy night

>>723674308 (OP)
Normally because of the 2nd half of stories that have not been updated yet.
Y'know, the ones with the rape and schizophrenia.

>>723675414
He'd find that even worse.

Kinoko Nasu slop is way too verbose to be considered the greatest of anything.
If you want some quality VN, you should start with classic stuff like Chunsoft's sound novels series. 428 is a great starting point.

>>723674308 (OP)
Because you picked the wrong one.

>>723674308 (OP)
Yo OP should I read this?

>>723674308 (OP)
the remake is trash because nasu got hollywood brain.

>>723674308 (OP)
I have a few spoiler-related questions for those who have read remake and og:
1.-How did Akiha resisted Arcueid's storage event in Ciel route? If she was who they were alluding to.
2.-Are Idea Blood/Principles gonna replace Reality Marbles now for the Tsukihime world?.
3.-Is it explained why Sacchin could skip the stages of vampirization and instantly become a fully-fledged dead apostle?.

>>723674308 (OP)
you picked the slop version instead of the original

>>723674308 (OP)
>why is this considered the greatest vn of all time?

It's not. Even Type-Moon fans generally prefer F/SN over Tsukihime. And the highest rated VN in the world is Muv-Luv Alternative.

>>723674308 (OP)
Anime writing has very, very low standards.

Sex with Arcueid

>>723674308 (OP)
>why is this considered the greatest vn of all time?
Every VNtard that tells you this has only read one VN in their entire life

>>723674308 (OP)
>he played the rewrite

>>723677958
>highest rated VN
what, on vndb?
the highest rated VN was 13 Sentinels on there but the trannies didn't like it usurping muv luv so they ruled that it didn't count as one

>>723674308 (OP)
The original is considered one of the greatest. The remake is basically an entirely different story.

>>723680216
So far, the remake is better, but the original had a better atmoshpere.

>>723680097
13 sentinels is not a vn, never was and never will be.

Don't mind me, just dropping in to say that Umineko no Naku Koro ni is the greatest piece of fiction in humanity's history.

>>723674308 (OP)
>feel like it's incredibly normal
Because it set the standard that every VN for the past 25 years emulated or was inspired by

>>723674308 (OP)
did you get to the part where vlov hits shiki with fullscreen unblockables

where does the fighting games fit in this?

>>723680613
OG Melty installments take place a month after Kagetsu Tohya.
Type Lumina's stories tend to vary, sometimes they take place before Shiki's arrival to the tohno mansion and others happen during the routes in the remake.

>>723674308 (OP)
What chapter are you on? I'm halfway through Ciel's route and I'm having a good time with it.

>>723674308 (OP)
read the one with awkward nasu rape, at least it is mercifully short

>>723680470
it is genuinely written like shit, the best parts are the music and some of the characters, plot is dumb as shit and episode 7 and 8 feel like filler

>>723682002
>disliking part 7 in 2025

>The shit back at the mansion with Akiha in the maids is way more interesting than vampire hunting with Arc and Ciel
>Nasu gonna edge us for another decade before finally explaining whats the actual deal with Joshua Graham and Spidertits

Nothing with the cancer known as (((bisexual))) representation is good.
Avoid any multimedia series with at least one entry featuring that garbage.

>>723685175
lol

>>723685175
Don't play anything, got it.

>>723685305
There's plenty of video games.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Video_games_by_year
Pretty sure that 99% of them don't have that cancer.

>>723685175
what is wrong with you?

>>723674308 (OP)
>why is this considered the greatest vn of all time?
it is? wtf

>>723685175
holy autism

>>723685175
Least interesting type moon schizo by far, like you unironically get mogged by fgona seanigs regularly

>>723685759
It's literally not even, the highest rated VNs are Muv Luv and SG.

>>723685472
Well, I like Dark Souls, Senran Kagura, Melty Blood, Madoka Magica: The Battle Pentagram, Scott Pilgrim vs the World, and VA-11 Hall-A, and there's nothing you can do about it.
t. straight, White male in his early 40's

>>723685759
absolutely not, everyone knows Umineko is the greatest VN of all time