Thread 724082979

Yoshi bros... how we feelin'?

what do yoshi's eggs smell like?

>>724082979 (OP)
It looks good, but it's not something that's going to make me go run out and grab a Switch 2 though.

>>724082979 (OP)
Trash shovelware

Let's hope it's OST can rival Yoshis New Island.

>>724082979 (OP)
Of all the fucking art styles they could bring back for this franchise, they went with the one from THE 3DS GAME???

>Another YI/YS rehash with an artsy visual style
Yoshi really needs a DKC or a Wario Land and break away from Mario. All these titles after YI have been nothing but gimmicks, half-baked or just outright mediocre. Really put the effort into making Yoshi a strong brand with its own world, cast and setting.

Yoshis games after Island genuinely feel like actual baby games.
Like something you give to a toddler. Not like the typical "fun for every age" type of Nintendo game.
And it doesnt give you anything fun to toy with like the other Nintendo baby series (Kirby).

>>724083719
like all nintendo games

Seriously, was this game just a fluke? How did they make one piece of absolute kino 30 years ago and then nothing but shit for the rest of the franchise's history?

>>724084264
What'd you have in mind?

>>724084264
>Yoshi game with cute art style as it's selling point
It's bizarre isn't it? Miymato bangs on about doing things new and different and not being interested in continuing a franchise unless he can do something new with it, yet keeps making more and more Yoshi games riding off the same old gimmick. Weird congnitive dissonance. He uses this excuse for not making new F Zero games, yet is happy to keep making new Mario Kart games that just have skin deep new gimmicks as their 'something new'.

Too soon to say. If its half as good as Wooly, we're golden.

Or at least not as boringly repetitive as Crafted.

>>724084264
>Yoshi a strong brand with its own world, cast and setting.
You're right, but how would they do this? The entire concept behind Yoshi is that he's always Mario's horse, even in his own games.

>>724085367

Already did with cast and setting, at least. He has Dinosaur Land to run around in, his sidekick Poochy, and his main arch enemy is usually Baby Bowser and Kamek.

>>724084838
I'd say Wooly World and DS are worthwhile plays. The problem is that they insist on making the Yoshi games with a preschooler aesthetic, and then don't give them the depth and surprise difficulty that something like Kirby gets to pull in the older crowd. And when they try, we end up with abortions like Yoshi Story's 30 Melon challenge where you need a strategy guide to stand a chance at pulling it off.

>>724082979 (OP)
I'm not buying any more Yoshi games until the game has the same level of difficulty as Island.

>>724084839
SMW had four Yoshis, you can make them the protagonists, but their have their own look and abilities.
>Green is the main Yoshi
>Red looks like a Rex, breathes fire
>Blue is sleek and slender, can fly
>Yellow is large and husky, causes tremors
You can even bring the other Yoshis in as supporting characters. A new villain that isn't Bowser or Kamek is a good way to start, and shedding its Mario origins outside of the Yoshis themselves.

>>724085367
Expand on his projectile-based gameplay. Off the cuff, maybe something like a watered down Contra with different eggs having different functions (Rapid-fire, blast, etc.). I admit this is a lot harder than I thought but how the fuck did YI simultaneously start and peak the franchise at the same time? I know that quote from Miyamoto about DKC is bullshit, but I wonder if he really feels a certain connection with Yoshi and opted to not let him go like he did with DK?

>>724085879
Miyamoto worked on Story, I believe. But never after that. They always farm it out to someone.

>>724085580
Wasn't DS widely disliked? I haven't heard about the game in years but I seem to recall that being the prevailing opinion when it was current.

>>724086024

Its pretty much love it or hate it these days.

Yoshi games are absolute trash. The last three were so boring and baby easy that they weren't even worth pirating. Imagine paying full price for that shit

>>724086221
It's pretty much only hate.

>>724082979 (OP)
don't know what to think

at this point the series is pretty much a succession of 6/10s and I don't think this game has shown anything that implies it's going to change but it also looks pretty good, I like that they're going back to a more "traditional" artstyle at least instead of the wooly and crafted stuff

>>724085879
I like the descriptions, kinda like how King Boo in Luigi's Mansion looks different from the King Boo in Mario Kart. I can see a run and gun Yoshi game working, big eggs can explode, smaller eggs are thrown faster and you can carry more of them. The other Yoshis could have different stats and a time attack mode for each stage.

>>724086024
>>724086523
>the second most sold game console
>everyone hates it
???

>>724087987

Not the system. Yoshi's Island DS.

>>724088182
oh sorry, i can't read

>>724084264
If I remember correctly the croc devs were originally planning to make a yoshi game which certainly would have been something

>>724085879
Love these ideas, hell bring in Boshi as a Rival for some fights.

>>724089278

Yeah, Croc started life as a 3D Yoshi platformer on SNES.

>>724082979 (OP)
Honestly if you're going to recommend anyone play a Yoshi game, the original SNES game is still the best one by a long shot. Even if you've already played it, replay it.

Its annoying that Yoshi is just stuck being the game that just tries to be the original YI over and over while swapping the art style around.

I do not care for the egg throwing mechanic.

>>724084838
This game ruined Yoshi forever.
It turned him from a badass dinosaur buddy to a fucking crayon baby. I know people like this game a lot, but it was the beginning of the end for my man.

>>724085879
>A new villain that isn't Bowser or Kamek is a good way to start
What about Wart? He's the perfect foil for Yoshi.
>reptile vs. amphibian
>both are long-tongued
>fruit-lover vs. veggie-hater
And that's really all you need

>>724084264
It’s crazy that they haven’t made a 3D Yoshi yet. He really needs that breakout hit like Kirby got with Forgotten Land.

>>724086221
It has been a long time since I played DS, but I don't remember anything overtly bad about it. Then again, I don't remember much about it at all besides being able to switch babies, future Bowser taking over the plot, and the introduction of Baby Wario.

>>724091267

Difficult curve thats a brick wall, mediocre level design

>>724084838
Do you not realize this was made by the Mario devs? Does no one on /v/ have the brain capacity to put two and two together?

>>724091491
Nintendo's biggest mistake with Yoshi was the amount of times they let fucking Arzest make new Yoshi games. Peak retardation on Nintendo's part since Arzest has been shit since coming into existence. Genuinely baffling how those shitheads haven't been shuttered yet especially after the Balan fiasco.

>>724082979 (OP)
Crazee Dayzee looks like that?

>>724082979 (OP)
That's one bland as fuck title. Could they not think of a more interesting word than book?
>Yoshi and the Mysterious Tale
>Yoshi and the Mysterious Tome
>Yoshi's Mystery

>>724082979 (OP)
This looks fucking gay.
They ruined Yoshi. It's all toddler trash now.
The teletubbies of vidya.

Why is everyone doomposting about the new game? The focus on cataloguing enemy/world interactions has the potential to be genuinely difficult for 100%ing

>>724092325
>Yoshi's Manuscript