Is it inherently wrong to remake a game?
>>724672328
one good example vs 1000 bad examples
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 12:52:45 AM
No.724672614
[Report]
No, but I'm still not going to buy them.
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 12:53:57 AM
No.724672687
[Report]
>>724672741
>>724672575
I heard the Yakuza remakes were good.
imo they should remake average to shit games.
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 12:55:11 AM
No.724672754
[Report]
>>724672575
So you agree it isn't inherently wrong
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 12:55:37 AM
No.724672782
[Report]
>>724672741
It's just what I heard! Don't hit me!
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:10:35 AM
No.724673610
[Report]
>>724671927 (OP)
I don't think so.
If they focused on remaking bad games to improve on them, that would be one thing, but they aren't really used like that.
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:16:17 AM
No.724673940
[Report]
>>724671927 (OP)
no and I think most remakes were good, but then again they weren't my childhood games.
If something like spellforce 1 got remade I would probably seethe over the bs they would change too
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:44:59 AM
No.724675604
[Report]
>>724675649
>>724675165
A Fistful of Dollars and The Magnificent Seven say otherwise.
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:45:35 AM
No.724675649
[Report]
>>724675721
>>724675604
Those weren't remakes that was plagiarism
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:46:17 AM
No.724675698
[Report]
No. I personally don't believe its wrong to remake a game. Music have covers. Films have remakes. Books have different translations. It is an inevitability and that's fine. What pisses me off is not doing anything to preserve the original in anyway whatsoever. It is the one medium where it feels like the conversation is absolutely frustrating. The remake is a separate product from the original. If this is not accepted, we can't even begin talking about the remake. It is not a replacement. RE1's remake is insanely good, to the point where its hard to recommend the original because of everything it does, but it still does not replace the fact that RE1 exists and people should and for the most can experience it very easily.
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:47:40 AM
No.724675791
[Report]
>>724675721
Nope. The Thing and The Blob are good remakes
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 1:52:29 AM
No.724676041
[Report]
>>724672328
Thats because it had the original director coming back.
Anonymous
11/1/2025, 2:22:00 AM
No.724677743
[Report]
>>724672575
Learn what "inherently" means, retard. One contrary example is literally all you need.
