Thread 543082442

Welcome to the Sonic General! Here we discuss all things Sonic!

/sthg/ #8741 - Kiturge Edition

==NEWS==
>Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds - Accolades Trailer
https://youtu.be/C6BSu_x0gcE

>SAGExpo 2025
https://www.sagexpo.org/

>Mobile card game Sonic Blitz
https://rentry.org/sthglinks#sonic-blitz-apk

>Sonic Rumble Global Launch Delayed
https://sonicrumble.com/GLDelay

>Sonic the Hedgehog 4 to release on March 19, 2027
https://variety.com/2025/film/news/sonic-4-release-date-march-2027-1236280697/

==Comic Release Dates==
Sonic the Hedgehog: Chaotix's 30th Anniversary - 22 October 2025
Sonic the Hedgehog #82 - 19 November 2025
Sonic the Hedgehog #83 - 17 December
Sonic the Hedgehog #84 - 14 January 2026
Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds (oneshot) - 28 January 2026
Sonic the Hedgehog: Chasing Shadows - 4 March 2026

==GENERAL INTEREST LINKS==
https://rentry.org/sthglinks
>/sthg/ OP template:
https://rentry.org/sthgtemplate
>Milestone pastebin:
https://pastebin.com/LJCfZhY4
>Sonic Game/Mod Recommendation Spreadsheet:
https://rentry.org/sthglinks#sonic-gamemod-recommendation-spreadsheet
>Perfect System Collection:
https://rentry.org/sthglinks#perfect-system-collection
>Sonic comic scans:
https://grabber.zone
https://tails.kicks-ass.net/
>SatAM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MUxzf7qw1J0&list=PLVLLjN9wKHROAG1F4wnFFqp-cie7Wa-S0
>AoSTH
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IitAAlElX4&list=PLySo2SlSHPSOOGZM3_2Qun52hCaRNYW9y
>X Dub
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=9CGih4gMRlk&list=PLPklMlGd9gwLRxf-3TJ-6GWsKUpgtQpss
>SAGE
http://sagexpo.org/
>SHC
http://shc.zone/
>#10000 Project
https://pastebin.com/Fb8Bt4ru
>/sthg/ booru:
https://sthg.booru.org/
>/sthg/ OCs:
https://sthgoc.tumblr.com/archive/
>/sthg/ CyTube:
https://cytube/r/sthg
>/sthg/ Pixels:
https://ourworldofpixels.com/sthg

Previous Zone: >>543055636

Why is Cream obsessed with Taisdoll?

>>543082568
OOC.
SatAM Sally isn't like this.

>>543082325
Imagine thinking he deserves pity after everything he’s done. He bought it upon himself and could never shut his autistic little mouth about stupid bullshit no one cares for just to mask his vapid, depressing life.

sex with Sonic

>>543076538
I started watching SATAM TODAY! I had a total misconception of what the show was especially what Sally's character was. I understand now why so many people like her.

I probably will end up watching the whole series but will not care when it ends

Douge

>>543082842
Damn it well I HAVE to do this now

>>543082842
human Shadow is hot, could you drop the Catbox link to nude human Shadow if you have it

Sonic and Knuckles having bro time exploring more of Sky Sanctuary

>>543081841
>>543081946
Thanks. Nothing has happened yet, but since people still keep talking about this, who knows.

Sonic x Silver Generations

>>543082752
Yep. It's a good cartoon. Not better than the games, but a perfectly respectable alternate take on Sonic. Sally is a very likeable character.
>>543082912
Really cute!

>>543082970
I understand why Flynn and Stanley try to remake her

>>543082441
I agree, Fang getting the equivalent of a magikarp (a powerful partner that not really as useful as he would want) through Trip feels on-brand for his character.

I can see Trip still occasionally working with Fang or at least having active interactions with him; Sonic characters usually pair up based on what games they debut in.

WOAH

>>543082958
Fuck no

Blaze with Silver? CRINGE!
These two together? BASED!

Sad Shadow Chao feels outcast

>>543082752
>>543082970
No way slashy is the sallyfag now everything makes sense, by the autism powerlevel

>>543083374
Hey that's not Mephiles

I miss Duofag's Shadally

Honestly, SatAM is an example of an unbuilt trope in regards to the resistance fighter Sonic premise. Like yeah, the show had Sonic running around with the Freedom Fighters doing guerrilla warfare against Robotnik's regime, but here's the interesting thing. The actual characterization of Sonic in SatAM wasn't even that different from game Sonic. He took situations seriously when they needed to be serious, he wasn't just cracking wise 24/7 or lusting after ladies like everyone remembers.

The real problem is Archie completely poisoned the well. Everyone thinks SatAM was this heavy freedom fighter drama because Archie ran with that concept and turned it into something way more serious and melodramatic than the show ever was. People literally think SatAM is a romance drama when it had LESS romance drama than fucking Sonic X. That's how much Archie warped perception.

So you've got this show that introduced the freedom fighter concept but kept Sonic's personality relatively intact and had a humorous, often whimsical and fantastical tone, and then it gets buried under years of comic book baggage to the point where people can't even remember what the actual show was like. The trope got built up in everyone's heads through Archie, Forces, and IDW instead of what SatAM actually did with it.

And now? The idea of Sonic being a "freedom fighter" is considered retarded by most people here because of how Archie handled it, not because of what SatAM originally presented. The whole concept got so overcooked and taken too seriously that it became a joke. Total unbuilt trope had the foundation but never got to properly develop on its own terms before getting demolished by outside forces.

>>543083547
Look lanolin became a stealing thug.

jaleel white should voice surge

>>543083651
Racism isn't funny.

>>543083606
Mommy Sally...

>>543083547
Look Lanolin can survive in the sun now.

>>543083692
I want to spank Maria

>>543083641
No way you think someone is gonna read that wall of text.
>>543083653
Cute pic.

>>543083692
Lazy AI gen, but not bad either.

>>543083653
Imagine Sonic trying to have sex with Surge only to find out she has the BBC and is about to get Blacked Raw

Duofag Shadally
Hyoumaru Shadally
Scribbles Shadally

>>543083641
>unbuilt trope
That doesn't mean anything.

>>543083374
Man I miss this bromance, I miss too leeta and lyco, they got updated to look like sonic characters just for preboot to die.

what would it take to Free Knuckles from Master Emerald Guard Duty

>>543083641
That is not how the unbuilt trope works at all. The way SATAM is the unbuilt trope is that Sonic's WAY PAST COOL attitude is a coping mechanism from having his life upended by Robotnik whereas Pontaff and Flynn crap ust has the Japanese Sonic, the confident and unaffected Sonic, making those same jabs and same braggadocius attitude despite never going through the horrific events so it comes off as grating.

Also Robotnik is not as capable as later versions of Eggman where he struggles to maintain control of a city (I mean there is wreckage everywhere not cleaned up) from people who live in huts and do not have access to his level of tech aside from Nicole.

>>543083413
I’m not a furry but

I wanna see this furry butt

>>543082752
When we say Archie is OOC for all characters that includes the satam characters

>>543083978
Break the master emerald into pieces. No master emerald to guard == a free knuckles.

>>543084126
Yeah Flynn is Archie pilled not SATAM pilled.

>>543083547
Montan the Sheep. She's super nice and genuine and not schizophrenic. She's also a good leader who listens to her team and would not think of playing favorites or abusing them over a disagreement.

She has carried out multiple successful missions for the Restoration rebuilding homes and providing relief aid all over Sonic's World. She is good friends with all the Game cast and they all know her name.

Lanolin *hates* her.

>>543084152
The Master Emerald means nothing. You need to destroy Angel Island to free Knuckles

>>543084126
Satam is occ for all the game characters, the same as underground.
It doesnt change anything.

>>543084225
>reddit pacing

>>543084225
Amazing.

is the sonic franchise good again yet

>>543061510
Now post the nonedited version

>>543084225
Kys woefag

>>543084267
Of course it does. The smart thing is to acknowledge that Satam itself is ooc for the game cast. Meaning it can be used as a character reference for Sally and Bunnie, but not for Sonic. Archie definitely cannot be used as a resource for Sonic.

>>543083606
wow this is trash

>>543084320
There isn't an anthro Dinosaur in the games yet so on the fence

>>543084430
Shadally is based

>>543083653
Surge always looks cute with her hair down for some reason.

>>543084548
Kinda true.

Husband

>>543084528
Yeah but the pic is shit

>>543083978
death

>>543084581
Why?

>>543084320
Yes, but this place will tell you it massively sucks, just to be contrarian.

>>543084270
>>543084273
>>543084361
She really want's to be Lanolin's friend, but every time Montan tries to reach out to her, Lanolin passive aggressively pushes her away with her plastic cordiality.

The wisps like each other though.

>>543084574
Wife

>>543084669
It's horribly off model and scale

>>543084512
I know vanilla is still a womanlet compared to humans, but she somehow looks shorter her.

>>543083606
Kr*ck will attack anyone who makes Shadally content except Scribbles. Sladhy's fault for failing to deal with her.

>>543084818
Sally belongs to Sonic.

>>543083606
You can tell the poo that made this has never played or read Sonic.

>>543084706
Well he's gay so yeah.

>>543084706
Reminder Blaze is shit at cooking. Probably shit as other manual labours too

>>543084361
Nta, this guy's keeps appearing and I dont have any idea what a woefag is.

The same as that violet poster talking as if he was always here, but I never saw posts of that attention whore until recent times, got worse when he started to defend Ken penders.

>>543084818
Woah how is this my fault?

>>543084818
>Sl*shy shill
ew

>>543084818
>Characterfag gets mad at everyone who mischaracterized their favorite

Wow what a shock

>guys think about how namefag would think about this an-
KILL YOURSELF

Is the Espio being a Weeb been a thing since 2000s? Cause I only seen it recently but back then Espio is mostly serious.

>>543084574
I can't belive this place is ignoring the dact we officially have blobian earbuds,
When the whole fandom always wanted to know how could they work on different blobian animals.

>>543085238
This is cool

>>543084965
It's completely in-character tho, I don't see a problem.

What if Tails was taller than Sonic?

>>543085256
Espio a weeb? he's still a real serious ninja.

>>543084883
>Human

>>543085326
He’s a fox, he will be when they’re both adults

>>543085264
Violet predicted this with her Surge design!
>>543083653

>>543085347
Damn, that sucks for free bros.

>>543085256
I always thought Espio just was actually a ninja from Japan with a clan that we just never saw except with the rendition from the Archie comics.

>>543085325
This is a really impressive AI gen, I wonder which model was used. The stuff on the blackboard in the background is almost coherent even.

>>543085114
You are the one that made her go defcon five with your failed redemption attempt.

>>543085325
Shame it looks like aids.

blobian furgonomics

>>543082542
Girls like weird creepy shit for inexplicable reasons.

Anyone know any good alternatives to Civitai when it comes to genning NSFW content?

(Sorry, I forgot to ask my question.)

>>543085601
Try jscammie

>>543085601
Get out

>>543085556
That was nothing related to me, she was largely disinterested in it she even said so.

They should hire this band to do Team Chaotix covers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yv6shy_9KVM

>>543085601
NovelAI has a good NSFW image generator. It's stable diffusion based and has some cool features. It also knows how to draw Sonic characters out of the box.

It's okay. Characterfags won't attack you unless you have an encyclopedic knowledge on the japanese version of the character! That's not too much to ask right?

>>543085325
This is some of the worst looking AI i've seen.

>>543085659
Whats up with the suddenly finally posting here, is Archie started to be accepted again.
Ironically, the archie days were our most happy times, we even used to have storytimes here, without people loosing their shit.

>>543085743
Thank God our worst characterfag is suspended and got tired of this place already.

>>543085743
I feel torn on which is more authoritative, the Japanese or the English text, if they differ. Sonic is made in Japan, but he is designed specifically for the West.

>>543085556
Also I was trying to find her a new place to complain about trans people and not assume Sonic Twitter represented the left.

>>543061694
>canonizing rings as a currency
THEY ARE CURRENCY YOU FUCKTARD, PLAY THE FUCKING GAMES FAGGOT
PLAY THE GAMES, FAG
PLAY THE GAMES, FAGGOTRETARD

>>543085961
Sweetie we are coming to understand SATAM. Archie lead to garbage like IDW and Forces. Please understand.

>>543085659
Human Fi is no good because she lacks the fur to stink as strong.

>>543085961
Archie always had a place here

>>543085961
We're not accepting Archie. We're just accepting SatAM.
Archieslop is still terrible and gets EVERY character wrong, ESPECIALLY the SatAM cast.
Sally's father isn't a RACIST MISOGYNIST.
Sally Acorn isn't UPSET THAT SONIC LIKES TO GO ON ADVENTURES AND WOULD NEVER SLAP SONIC FOR BEING HIMSELF.
Antoine is not a HYPE MAN AND AURA FARMER, he is a FUNNY COWARDLY FRENCH BETA MALE.
Robotnik does not KILL PEOPLE.

>>543086156
But Bunnie is still good right?

My main gripe with satam/archie is the character Rotor. Just.... his entire character. I don't want him to exist. He was created to replace Tails for whatever reason, and that was unnecessary.

>>543086156
>Sally's father isn't a RACIST MISOGYNIST.
Lame

>>543086206
I can't think of anything egregiously OOC about Archie Bunnie on the top of my head.

>>543086229
Tails replaced Rotor and Sally and Bunnie and Nicole.

>>543085989
I'm gonna try and give an unbiased answer.
It depends on the era. In the 2000s (everything before Colors. The japanese dialgoue is canon.

You can tell because every game is written by a japanese writer and then localized by people who aren't writers. That's why there's so many odd little mistakes in the games leading up to 06. There is no real artistic intent in the english dialogue lines, they were (mostly) just translating it and embellishing it.

"Si that what Chaos Control is?" can't be a canon line. Shadow knows what Chaos Control is. He wouldn't speak like that.
On top of that, the continuous games of that era completely ignore the english dialogue.

In Heroes, Sonic says "Talk about Stubborn and Full of surprises!" this is a reference to a line from SA2. That line isn't in the english dub of SA2. It only survived into the heroes dub. This means Sonic Heroes regards the japanese version of SA2 to be canon.
This obviously doesn't hold water for the 2010s games who have their script and animations tied to the english dialogue. Japanese Frontiers is almost incomprehensible in its forced attempt to keep all of the characters within Sonic Team's preferences.

The japanese version of Shadow Generations does not translate back Shadow and Sonic's referential dialogue (A date to die for) because the japanese writer did not recognize the reference Ian was making because that reference was to the english version of SA2.

So really, make of it what you will.

>>543086229
Americans didn't know tails was a super genius it's not readily understood. Most people figured he was there to give people's kid brothers something to do while they played the game and so he just became the annoying kid brother character.

>>543086282
>Tails killed the Freedom Cucks
Tailschads, I kneel...

>>543086347
AOSTH, which aired around the same time, let Tails be a genius and there were no problems.

>>543086062
Don't talk for me, satam is as shit as archie, all the DIC cartoons were.

Knuxougefags would never let you destroy angel island or the emerald because it's the only thing that keeps him semi-relevant for rouge. Take the big rock away and she has no reason to be around him.

>>543086385
I am sure Violet will back this up.

A consequence of getting windfags to like Satam is that they would become characterization purists for the freedom fighters (Including Antoine) while also viewing Satam Sonic as a western abomination

>>543086206
nta but Bunnie can do no wrong.

>>543086434
We lost Slashy to the SATAMcucks. I thought he was too autistic to be converted.

>>543086156
Fuck you, SATAM and underground were as shit.

>>543086434
I'm out of the loop. What's a windfag?

>>543086438
Where is her knotted top?

>>543086347
>Americans didn't know tails was a super genius it's not readily understood.

This is a mixup. English Tails was portrayed as a genius before Japanese Tails. In season 2 of Satam he hacks one of Eggman's computers and in AOSTH he can work machines just fine.

In the original japanese manga (which continued to AFTER Satam was over) Tails is not a genius at all. While it might have always been part of his game incarnation, the japanese did not actually show off this character trait until the OVA.

>>543086397
>AOSTH, which aired around the same time, let Tails be a genius and there were no problems.
That was only sometimes, he's still just the kid character

>>543086569
The OVA is the first time all the characters resemble their modern counterparts.

>>543086229
Didn't rotor predated tails? he was even. Based on joe sushi. Genuine question.
He was just the same cliche as tails, that's it.

Can any Sonic games run on TempleOS?

>>543086581
Yeah but he was still likable In that show

>>543086563
You prefer the Japanese characteistics of Sonic the Hedgehog. Where sonic is often described as being "as free as the wind" in reference to his carefree, follows his own rules, Nature.

>>543086563
You prefer the Japanese characteristics of Sonic the Hedgehog. Where Sonic is often described as being "as free as the wind" in reference to his carefree, follows his own rules, Nature.

Last year, we promoted The Year of Shadow, influenced by the movie, but I'd like to choose a theme each year and spotlight different characters.

I think we can predict which characters will appear in the upcoming movie, so I'd like those characters to play an active role.

>>543086563

A windfag is a jokey, catcs Sonic. They may like characters such as Lanh-all term for someone who prefers the videogame characterizations for the Sonic characters. Simply put, they like how Sonic acts in the games, and dislike how he acts in things such as Archie. They consider that "out of character" for deviating so strongly from the source material.
Archiie Sonic is the go-to example. He has a romantic relationship and is vulnerable to emotional damage. Two things that are strictly considered impossible by Sonic Team and therefore disregarded as "OOC garbage" to a windfag.

A windfag is not the same as a jp purist. A windfag may enjoy western media, but they will not recognize Movie Sonic as Sonic. They will NOT recognize Archie Sonic as Sonic under any circumstances. They may enjoy characters like Sticks, Sally, Rotor ect but they will not accept deviant versions of the Videogame characters as decent interpretations.
There are japanese instances of Sonic being out of character. For example, Sonic is afraid of water in Sonic X, while he is outright stated not to be afraid of water in the games. A JP purist might find this tolerable, but a windfag will not.


Windfags are human, so naturally their behavior is not 100% consistent.
Of the known windfags on this general (Krack, Violet, Randomfox, Scribbles, Sparky)) two of them are completely tolerant of western media two of them hate all western media, and one of them is Sparky.
I've seen debates about if Scribbleanon (The anon who made the Shadally parody) even fits in this category, as he is an "everythingfag" who openly enjoys things like the movies and isn't known to get vicious with fans of the comics.
Similarly, Violet is a huge fan of Sonic SatAM, which is generally reviled among windfags for being the origin point of most of Sonic's western traits. Violet also hates most of Archie for portraying both Sonic and Sally ooc.


Yes I am here every day.

Aosth sucks
satAM sucks
Archie sucks
Spinball isn't canon
Ian is a shit writer
Sega JPs word is law
Burado ovu koraji is sonics best comic characterization
Sonic is the wind
Amy has always and will always love sonic
Knuckles chuckles
Tails is a little kid first and a genius second
Cream is the wind

If you disagree with any of this you're not a true sonic fan

>>543085505
He can't be because he wasn't a ninja in Knuckles' Chaotix. He was a detective.

>>543086671
I think Tails predates Rotor by a month? I did a little bit of investigating and Rotor's first appearance seems to be the archie comic issue 1/4, but I couldn't find a publication date for it. Apparently the back had the publication date for issue 0, which was november 1998 (Tails' first debut was october 1998).

>>543086763
I moved my mouse and accidentally rearranged some sentences in the first passage.

I meant to say it's a "Jokey catch all term for Sonic Characterfags"

People who complain about characters being OOC are OOC.

>>543086774
Blade of Slop is cringe and nobody in Japan cares about Shitnic

>>543086569
AoSTH is the first piece of media to refer to Tails as a genius. Before the Japanese.
https://youtu.be/gHdV3zMUTDo?si=RsUVISUalbj8Z4Nm&t=442
Tails being a mechanic/tinkerer was well established already in 'early western cartoon' Tails.
Him being a super genius wasn't.
Since that was not Tails' character in either Japan or the US at this point.
Tails' character in Japan was pretty undefined outside of the 92 manga where he's depicted as more of an extroverted 'cool dude'.
In fact, AoSTH is the first time in any Sonic media that Tails is called a 'genius'.
One could argue that Adventure 1 even took the idea of Tails making a flying machine for Sonic from AoSTH.

>>543086709
>>543086718
???

>>543086763
>>543086718
Thanks for filling me in. This seems like way too much mental effort and strife over Sonic's characterization. I always just figured Sonic is Sonic, he's going to be a little different in various medias and interpretations. This makes people upset enough to make a fuss about?

>>543086774
What about Evan Stanley and Daniel Barnes

Shadamy is red pilled, and the tears of autistic cucks who thought she would stay loyal to Sonic and put up with his shit, and not have fun and be happy with Shadow at al, is are cathartic

>>543087045
I love shadamy so much. It brings me joy imagining them happy together.

>>543086802
I mean that could still be the case if being a detective was a cover for him being a ninja and being overtly a ninja is a cover for him now being a detective. Though maybe Espio just watched to much Ninja Slayer so who knows.

>>543086963
>Sonic is Sonic
That's fair but I can understand why these conflicts happen. Sonic is a videogame character. The videogames put forth things that are contradicted in the comics.
>Sonic doesn't cry
Allegedly from Iizuka
>Sonic would NEVER get married
This is from Naka.

You can imagine why people who become attached to this character would scoff at this similarly to how people scoff at the idea of a Goku who doesn't fight.

>>543086884
Why do SATAM fans and AOSTH fans fight with each other? They should have competing views on Sonic.

>>543086925
Bad connection

>>543087142
>They should have competing views on Sonic.
That's probably why we fight.

>>543087212

Sorry meant to say don't.
>>543087142

>>543087142
SatAM and AoStH are polar opposites. They straight up don't have the same audience.

>>543087142
Satam fans see aosth the way Sonic 06 fans see Sonic Colors

>>543086521
How can we keep the music playing?

>>543086763
>Krack, Violet, Randomfox, Scribbles, Sparky
The worst posters of the general?

>>543087251
If you're wondering why there's not more fighting, probably because there's not much to fight about. Both shows had their run over 2 decades ago.

>>543087330
Remove Scribbles and you'll get the worst posters of this shithole.

>>543087142
They're old as dinosaur fucking dirt, just let them have at it until they're buried.

>>543087269
I just realized that Buttermoth and Duofag have an identical taste in shipping.

Shadally, Sonurge, Silvisper

I wonder if-- oh wait. Buttermoth is a woman.

>>543087045
The artist did a nice job of projecting knuckles onto shadow.

I did frankly think SatAm Sally and Archie Sally were the same until around early this year when /sthg/ brought the topic up.

>>543087392
Stop being transphobic

>>543087330
Scribbles won't chew your head off for liking west stuff since he's a everythingfag. Sparky at least tries to be nice. I don't know what to say about Violet. Krack and Random already have their reputations.

Secret Rings had absolutely great level themes, Skeleton Dome, Dinosaur Jungle and Pirate Storm are top tier.

>>543087559
This. So happy it got representation in Crossworlds.

>>543087462
To be fair they are at various points of archie. The tone and characterization changes so often it's hard to keep track.

>>543086884
AoStH was also the first western Sonic media to call Robotnik "Eggman" even though it was just an insult.

>>543087643
I've read Archie at least two times. Sally was definitely more bossy in Archie compared to SatAM.

No windfag/jp fag likes Mania

>>543087462
I don't remember which page it is so I can't actually prove this argumentatively, but Ian actually broke Sally's character in a significant manner in late-preboot.
He has Eggman describe Sally as the one who controls Sonic and keeping him coordinated. Without Sally Sonic is aimless. Sonic needs Sally so he can have better judgement.

This is the exact opposite of the "original intention" as windfags here would put it. Ben Hurst said outright that Sally can pitch ideas to Sonic, argue with him, and hope he agrees. She cannot order him around. She cannot control Sonic. Knuckles is a good example of the kind of character he has in mind. Sonic makes her angry, but it's so the audience can laugh at this self serious person trying to understand a free spirit. Archie interprets this as drama.

>>543087045
>noooo.... Amy stop..what are you doing...nooooo
>she's just GIVING her BODY away.. LIKE THAT?..For HIM?...I can't guys, how could she? >She was supposed to be a good girl ,not like the others, what a fucking slut..
>she is just using him, she isn't genuinely happy, I mean look at her, she is so fake
>Its just the beach, she is being social, she still cares about (you/Sonic)

>>543087617
Yeah seeing that purple horned Tyrannosaurus appealed specifically to me as someone who played that game way to much growing up and was blind to its control flaws. I still love that games story, presentation and aesthetic alongside it's bosses but I've yet to replay or even get the final world ring yet so might have a go at that sometime when replay rest of the games to.

>>543087860
I just think Mania didn't do anything unique because of fangames having long beat its shtick to the punch.

GoodNiGHT, /sthg/

How often do fanfic writers come through here nowadays?

>>543087963
Almost never

>>543087330
I don't know if I would compare the rest to Randomfox. Krack can be a jerk but her entire morality revolves around Shadow. Violet is obviously shitposting. Scribblefag is harmless and Sparky wouldn't hurt a fly.

Randomfox will make it his mission to shame you if you make the make the "mistake" of thinking Sonic is cocky. If you like Archie then you're already worse than a nuclear bomb to him. He openly wants the comic writers to die in real life.

>>543087865
>She is not supposed to be into this kind of thing
>She never acted like this around me
>How could be so friendly with someone like him, does she know what he has done
>what the fuck his hand is right there near her and she doesn't care at all. its over. look at her legs and feet

Taxman, Hesse and Tee Lopes are as bad as Ian and Evan

>>543087863
I got it right here.

R*ndomfox makes multi hour youtube videos shitting on random normies for saying something wrong about Sonic. IT's amazing how the biggest fans of a character like Sonic are practically hostile religious zealots. The fact that they're fans of gamenic, who is this nice humble jesus-like figure who is always morally right. His fans want to tear your eyes out of your face for writing him "incorrectly"

>>543087330
Scribbs and Sparky are some of the best people here.

>>543088156
>Krack can be a jerk but her entire morality revolves around Shadow.
Newfag or just retarded? She's also one of the most obsessed and autistic jp fags out there.

>>543088064
A seed has been planted in my head for a fanfic, and I'll probably share it here when I'm done. I remember this place had some fanfic writers a long time ago. Are european hours still the best time to post things like that?

If they are so hated why they still post here

>>543088331
Meh. She wants Shadow to be in-character. She hates people who openly disrespect his character. Simple as that.

>>543088325
It's funny because their perception of gamenic isn't even true. They just made up a mary sue in their head and projected it upon sonic.

>>543088418
what's the fanfic about anon?

>>543088436
Did you read my post? Shadow aside, she's openly hostile about any interpretation of Sonic that isn't japanese.

>>543088453
can you just tldr this fucking autism i don't have time for this shit. i've been trying to keep up with the thisfags and the thatfags but it's gotten to terminal mental illness levels of absurdity to please.

Archie sonic actually had pathos and things to fight for. He actually wanted eggman dead at a certain point. He's one of the best interpretations of sonic.

>>543086693
aosth tails also had way more screentime than satam tails

>>543088319
Yeah this is (apparently) not how Sonic and Sally's dynamic is. I don't really mean to shit on Ian but this is an area where Satam got it right and Archie got it wrong. Sonic isn't Sally's Pikachu, he's her Charizard. The best she can do is hope he's interested in her idea. That's where their disagreements come from in the cartoon.
As someone pointed out earlier though, most of this is moot since if we're applying this rigid standard to Archie, we have to apply it to Satam. Sonic isn't in character in Satam anyways.

>>543088474
Shadow kills Tails. This happens very early on in the fic, the story itself explores how Sonic handles this. I don't know if I can pull it off, Sonic's character wasn't designed for this kind of thing, but I think that's what makes it interesting. Usually when I write a fic I wing it as I go along, but for this one I'm trying something different and planning out a story structure from the very start.

>>543088545
I miss non-moralfag protagonists

"sonic shouldn't have family sonic shouldnt cry sonic shouldn't show weakness"
your ideal for him is a bland gary stu who appeals to nobody.

Even mario has a family and tries to kill the shit out of bowser. Even mario cries in the golf sidegame when he gets BTFO brutally.

I want sonic to show a crack in his armor and get really fucking bad, but in a quiet rage sort of way. Movie sonic wanting to kill the shit out of shadow was the most based he's ever been, and it made his decision to spare him that more meaningful because it shows he's willing to be a true hero even if it goes against his personal emotions.

This doesn't mean turn him into an uwubean crybaby, but he shouldn't be an emotionally lobotomized retard either

Let me see your OCs.
>inb4 fuckoffwoefagtard

>>543088564
Yeah Tails was super underused in Satam which is a shame, honestly he could've easily filled the role of transporting the cast that Dulcy took. AOSTH also had a lot more fun with it's weird yet extremely memorable one shot characters, with Satam the only really major one shot character I recall liking was Naugus but that's also cause Archie really gets milage out of him as a villain. Though as a whole I like both shows quite a fair bit for what they do respectively....don't expect me to have any biggest of kindness for Underground though.

>>543088685
aaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAGH WHOT THEUFKC????

>>543088453
You just reminded me that Random will arguie incessantly that Sonic KILLED Perfect Chaos and that Sage would kill herself if Eggman was ever defeated.

I think Surge mindbroke a lot of windfags because Sonic DID kill Erazor and did TRY to kill king ARthur... Erazor was literally an abusive murderer and King Arthur was fake. Obviously there's some dissonance there that makes a solid "no kill rule" a bit corny but come on. Those are the examples?

I get it. I totally get it. Sonic has shown intent to kill before so him being "no kill" is wrong. But they act like Sonic said "I DONT KILL I NEVER KILL, I WOULDNT EVEN KILL SOMEONE IF THEY WERE GONNA RAPE AMY IF I DIDNT KILL THEM"

>>543088783
Yes fuck off with your off-topic shit.

>>543088764
I think windfags are IDW'fs fault. I'm not saying they're right but IDW pushed things too far in one direction and created a counter culture in the process. Everyone knew Archie Sonic and Game Sonic weren't a perfect match befroe but nobody was in a vomiting rage over Archie (which was amore ooc than IDW by FAR).
IDW starts showing thte "softer side" of characters over and over until it stops being subversive and starts becoming a major part of their character and that poked the autistic bear.

>>543088783
Ocs aren't sonic, unless they are sonic ocs.

>>543088764
Mario is a bigger Gary Stu than Sonic. He is constantly the chosen one. A chick magnet. Can solve every problem. Inspires everyone he meets and can turn some bad guys to good guys. Can wield any kind of power as if he trained with it for years. Every time Mario has a weakness exploited or discovered, he quickly overcomes it. You're bullshitting. Sonic is just some dude in comparison.

>>543082442 (OP)
Just blow my load to Kit x Futa Surge sfm porn.

>>543083750
what has she done to deserve this

Remember when Tails was cool by being Sonic's active sidekick carrying him through falling debris and a genius? Sonic Team doesn't.

I'm OOC

>>543088841
>TRY to kill king ARthur
He outright killed King Arthur even thought it was an illusion. Sonic didn't know that. He thought he slayed him.

Sonic isn't supposed to have hangups about killing some of his enemies. Ian is quite literally the only person who introduced this to the character.

>>543089353
SONIC HELP ME

>>543087330
>Krack, Violet, Randomfox, Scribbles, Sparky
>The worst posters of the general?
Slashy and Randomfox

I'm always perfectly IC

>>543089419
Include Krack

>>543089370
Hot

>>543087382
Scribble skates by on a technicality. His sonic behaves like windnic but still has siblings. The wind doesn't have siblings. .

>>543089145
Naturally that's what I meant given the thread.

>>543082958
FFUCK YES NIGGA

>>543089352
She allowed too many images of her to circulate online for AI models to train on.

The french comic is not ooc

>>543089484
Then I'm gonna post my OC!

>>543089393
Sonic Team approved it

>>543088841
I think IDW has some flaws but the fandom bitching about him lecturing surge is one of the most retarded outrages this fandom ever had. Of course he's not going to merc some random girl with obvious severe mental issues. It's obvious how badly sonic outclasses surge, even when she was powered up.

IDW's main problem stems from shadow's flanderization (which sega is guilty of too because they are conflicted on where shadow's character should go or if he's allowed to be friends with team dark. Shadow trying to relate to surge or vice versa should have been an obvious plot point given how they both have vaguely similar origins (engineered by a robotnik/apprentice of, amnesia, anger towards the world and sonic's loose approach to everything)

>>543089012
Windfags were born from Archie. IDW was the thing that made them vocal because the comic started calling itself canon while the characters notably acted wrong and its fanbase trying to gaslight people into thinking that was not true or that it was just the natural progression for the game cast before the manga came out and one of the people who are involved in IDW (Daniel Barnes) basically agreeing that the comic writes the characters wrong.

>>543089403
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAUyGpA-Sqw

>>543089012
I think it's cool of sonic and the gang show more than one emotion in their adventures and the boring monotonous shit they do in their day to day can be saved for random art drops on Sonikku channel. Just give me fun, exciting shit also I don't need a fucking 4 page therapy session of the FUCKING diamond cutters crying.

>>543089594
>Then Evan admits Sega can't flat out review everything because Sonic is a big franchise and IDW isn't top priority.

>>543089603
I think Ian's verbosity is the second issue. It's just a fact that Sonic doesn't speak that much in the games. Most of his dialogue in a Sonic game can be stuffed into ten minutes. It's difficult to imagine him going on speeches or elaborating his reasoning.

What everyone likes to forget is that he has done this in the games once. Exactly once, in Forces.

Reminder that Sonic's wild guesses are always right because he's Sonic. Sonic's judgement is perfect.

>>543087330
>all the worst posters are windfags
Really makes you think

FRENCHING SONIA'S FRENCH MILKERS

>>543089393
Even with Dr Eggman, Sonic has been fine leaving him to die before. Like I enjoy a bit of Ian's work but this killing/no kill debate has been awful, I hate it being brought up in Superhero comics, enjoyed how Rurouni Kenshin handled it and hate it brought up with Sonic. Like I'm quite pro keeping villains alive but I never want to hear about this thing even again from fans or writers.

I like Scribbles. He's a windfag?

>>543089603
That's not why people are outraged by the speech. Not only is Sonic even lecturing someone about his philosophy in a condescending manner, he outright tells Surge he's not gonna do anything about Starline or Eggman no matter what they do because that would take away their opportunity to change and he would stop HER from doing anything herself as well. All that did was make Sonic look like a sociopath.

>>543089902
He's the ultimate everythingfag

>>543089012
Windfags were born out of transgenders drawing zippertits on Sonic chest

If you were a namefag what would your name be?

>>543089880
It shouldn't be brought up in a kids series that's supposed to be endlessly running. Ian writes Sonic like it's supposed to have an endgame in mind, completely ignoring that fact that Sonic NEEDS to keep the status quo and character quirks. Sonic isn't a novel. There isn't a "conclusion".

every time you draw sonic doing something ooc you create another windfag. by "create" i mean you change another person. someone who only played the games and has no real experience with the comic. sure you probably thought your picture of sonic kissing jewel the beetle was cute, but a gamefag saw it and just didn't know what to do with himself after.
the windfag's instincts start to flux. like a bee feeling a threat to the colony. they feel that you have disrespected sonic's character and that you must be destroyed for your hubris. they aren't doing it on purpose. they have already lost control.

>>543089880
>enjoyed how Rurouni Kenshin handled it
Tell me more about this

>>543089975
Bullshit, the ultimate everythingfag is joeadok.

Auraverfans were born out of IDWfans who thinks canon silver is cutie bubbly wobbly woobie

The ultimate everythingfag is One Brand.

>>543087330
sparky is nice

>>543090210
Both are great.

>>543090185
Come at me bro

>>543090243
Auraverfans were born out of hatred for Sonic Team's choices after 06

>>543090325
>3
there's more? what is this mythical pairing

Eggman should be killed in the final game/issue.

>>543090243
It's funny how IDW basically killed Uwuver to a lot of Silverfags. They were all happy with it before then.

>>543090325
Duofag needs to make more of these

>>543090209
Kenshin is a pacifist. He fights with a reverse sided blade because he killed SO MANY PEOPLE as a rounin that he got sick of it. So he tries to give people the benefit of JUST catching an ass whooping. iirc. He tries really hard not to kill people

>>543090426
Mommy Rouge with small Silver.
>>543090479
I really need to take a break to do more.

>>543089982
It bothers my autism because sex changes or even species changes would not leave scars in the sonic universe (they have better healing properties/physical resilience, higher levels of technology) therefore it is OOC. If you're going to draw something it should at least be logically consistent with the level of technology shown in the series.

You can probably turn humans into mobians or vice versa. Or turn people into mindless combat slaves with cybernetics. And many other things that can't be shown with an E10 rating.

GUN is shown to have a massive starfleet. The sonic world is at least 50-100 years ahead of us in technology at MINIMUM.

The Sonic Bible matters

>>543090479
nah this shit looks gay

What happened tot he old days when there were a bunch of Sonic fansites like SonicHQ around?

>>543088453
I honestly think the problem is that this subject shouldn't have been brought up. The comic isn't equipped to discuss it in a smart way.

Okay so Sonic hates killing. I really don't care about if it contradicts the wind or whatever. So Sonic stops Surge from killing Eggman because he hates killing so much.
I get that too. A kids comic can't just say "murder is the answer". But now here's the problem . Batman and Daredevil and Spider-man do not kill. They are the characters most known for this specific behavior of trying to stop villains from murdering other villains even if the average person would agree with the villain.

What do Batman, Spider-man, and Daredevil do to irredeemable killer villains? They put them in JAIL. Something Sonic doesn't do. So what's Sonic's answer? That Eggman should be free and that he should... wait for Eggman to become better?
So now things are confused. Killing the villain is not an option, but absolute freedom is?

I know we hate the west here but I think western superheroes have this figured out. Deadpool, Hulk, and wolverine kill their villains without remorse. Other heroes put the villains in jail. A character who wants the villains neither dead or in jail is a bit confounding.

Is IDW Sonic anti-Jail? Well no, he is absolutely fine with imprisoning the deadly six.
What about Whisper? Her friends are dead because of Eggman's actions. Sonic is going to protect the guy who did that?

>>543090638
this gay shit looks hot

>>543090671
social media and internet centralization. why go there when you can go to twitter or reddit?

Name a game series with more deviations?

>>543090671
Internet is dead. Everything has been consolidated into 3 or so websites and discord. The internet has become filled with hostile, stupid, and regressive people that aren't fun to argue with, so everyone retreats into their own walled garden to try to stay safe and sane from the vicious masses fighting amongst themselves.

MGS2 predicted this.

>>543090579
What the hell, that’s you Duobro? Hell yeah, do some more Silvouge, man! We love that shit

>>543088783
Why tf would you want to see OCs?

>>543090325
>>543090479
>>543090579
>>543090780
Oh no, you're creating more windfags, somebody stop duo!!!

>>543090731
I think the best way to handle this is that sonic doesn't want to kill eggman because eggman is a once in a lifetime genius who might be vital to saving the planet if a bigger threat comes along, but also he can never capture or defeat eggman because the doctor is always one step ahead with clone/fake bodies, contingency plans, last minute escapes, etc.

>>543090209
Well Rurouni Kenshin is a franchise about a former Hitokiri which is essentially an assassin of japans war before the Meiji era. Since then he's become very much against killing, his sword called a sakabato being blunt with the only sharpness being on the where the blunt side is normally on a katana. The fair few of the villains actively trying to provoke him to become a murderer again are usually unhinged maniacs, relics of the warring era and essentially the Shadow of the series named Saito Hajime who was on the other side of the war they fought actively critiques his mercy in fair points that Kenshin doesn't blindly deny even if he opposes. I think what makes it work is that it's explicitly a personal belief that makes sense from someone who had a career of taking life plus based on the events of his story, he's still quite brutal to villains who deserve it often making sure they can never hold a sword again but also being merciful enough to give those who can genuinely redeem the chance to which actually happens with several former villains so his mercy isn't unwarranted. Lastly he isn't stupid about it since he says that swordsmanship is inherently a killing art and several villains still get killed off by other characters like Saito who utterly curbstomps whoever he fights, even stabbing a guy named Usui so hard he gets torn in half.

>>543090592
What bothers me about top scar tranny sonic is that sonic is 14 and it takes about a year and a half of talks and hormone replacements and other shit to even get to the point of full on double mastectomy surgery so sonic could have been as young as 12 when they start and that's a deeply horrific idea.

>>543090638
Nah this shit is literally gay.

>go back in time 30 years ago
>give sega this
how dows the franchise change?

>>543090896
I just think it looks tacky and doesn't suit his personality without having to do any deeper thinking and get into that debate stuff on it that I'm not equipped or care enough to manuvere around.

A real windfag hates Mania

>>543090749
>why go there when you can go to twitter or reddit?

>>543090780
Yeah it's me. I don't have time for gens anymore as I'm transitioning.

Ian feels the need to constantly push the envelop to give Sega some ultimatum for where to take the series and it always falls flat because Sonic isn't the kind of series he's trying to gun for (Character development that involves all their distinguishable traits being removed, solving the conflicts that set up scenarios, wanting all the mysterious figured out and explained, subverting tropes or themes in the series and having the characters more self-aware). Dude needs to be told he's writing Sonic the Hedgehog, not The Last of Us or Invincible.

>>543091112
Sonic written like it's invincible would be kino because it'd finally get us the T rating we deserve.

It's the fucking rating holding us back. Kids love "deep" shit too, it's just SEGA misunderstanding their target audience. Kids fucking love overly complex bullshit like FNAF, poppy's playtime, sonic exe, dark souls, power wank manga, etc.

>>543091235
I'm glad Sonic isn't trying to be those things.

>>543091235
>sonic exe is more popular with kids than game sonic is
kek I hate that this is true

>>543091112
It's surprising he got as far as he did with that mindset and I think it's a sign of his immaturity.

Fuck duofag. Mentally ill slopper

>>543091328
uh oh windfag melty

>>543091304
it should be its own thing, but the series is at its best when it's in "T rated" territory. SA2 had the most mature story in the series and it's also the peak of its writing.

Sonic as a series SHOULD be edgy and a little angsty. That's what it was in the early 2000s. Shadow for his time was considered extremely over the top and excessive, but it worked out and he's by far the most popular character. The series practically belongs to him at this point.

>>543091328
We DON'T accept transphobia here.

>>543091467
Do you accept trainsphobia? I never relax around locomotives.

everythingGODS are the only winners here

>>543090325
>>543090479
>>543090579
>>543090780
get that SKANK away from blaze's manwife (silver)

I just want to remind this thread that the sonic fandom is the only fandom that I know of that tolerates Ian Flynn's mediocrity and even upholds it.
Even the Rivals of Aether fandom wholly ignores him because they don't like his writing and he's literally the only real recorded writer on the entire franchise.

How the fuck did shadow the hedgehog even get away with a E10? Shadow kills people with guns, he guns down airforce one, and he even commits suicide in one of the endings.

>>543091235
Teen titans go is 10x more popular than normal teen titans ever was so you're wrong. Kids like entry level "deep" stuff, which is basically "make up a bunch of bullshit lore and shove it in the background so that Timmy can watch his favorite YouTube analyst explain it (read:also make shit up) and pretend they're appreciating content on a deeper level". That's how you make sonic popular, give YouTubers with big audiences a reason to make a 45 minute deep dive into why Bean the dynamite is actually secretly a trickster god.

>>543089902
>Is he a windfag

On one hand, he uses the underground family and Tania which is anti wind behavior. Sonic doesn't have a family.

On the other, there's nothing outwardly ooc with how he uses Sonic. He also tends to avoid lampooning the actual game characters compared to the western characters. That is windfag behavior.. Most windfags don't hold the comics with any regard at all. He knows a ridiculous amount about all of the comics. The average windfag can't stomach Archie or Fleetway.

>>543091531
But trains deliver sluts.

>>543091694
A cleaned up archie adaption could achieve this if it focused the echidna autism on everything else instead.

Was... ken penders simply ahead of his time?

>>543091664
Cause the aliens only bleed green and no humans are shown getting killed emphasis on shown since enough implied with the Eggman gets killed endings or the Eclipse cannon shooting a city.

>>543090780
>>543090579
>>543090479
>>543090325
Looks like dogshit, stop posting this trash.

>>543091763
I feel like this is the first time in my life I've ever said fucking based out loud.

>>543091593
Because we have low standards and mentally can't accept getting anything better. There is also this very scummy aspect to the fans that only like Ian because they see him as a doorway to the inner-workings of the franchise as an "insider" and as a opportunity to get involved in the franchise themselves; because these same people who laud Ian literally don't give a shit about his non-Sonic work, including his original work.

>>543090780
>>543090579
>>543090479
>>543090325

I couldn't give less of a shit about silvouge, but silver is drawn really cutely in these.

These are...stupid...ideas, guys. They're stupid ideas.

>>543091765
>there's a timeline where kids are watching 5 hour youtube essays combing over the deep race war lore in Sonic Mobius: insSURGEncy

Look, I'm creating windfags!

>>543091664
>>543091795
Shadow's game was almost a T but they backed out. The Black Arms were actually supposed to be bleed reddish/pinkish blood, but they turned it to green.

Jason Griffith also revealed they had him do lines that involved him saying "Fuck" and "Shit", but I don't know if that was ever actually going to be in the game to begin with. But Sonic was gonna say something about not "pissing off" GUN in the actual game, but that lines was changed to "ticking off" GUN of something..

>>543091957
"Every war crime committed by the echidna people part 1 of 32"

The only time I interacted with Scribbs he said he liked Sonic Prime (Hi Scribbs) isn't that anti wind?

>>543091923
Thanks, I gen'd them to look as gay as possible.

>>543092092
Hopefully the upcoming shadow the hedgehog game (?) that sega teased while talking about "taking the series in a new direction" (paraphrased) will be T rated.
Shadow telling someone to fuck off would be kino as hell.

The existence of everythingfaggots confuses Sonic the Hedgehog General on this day

sleepy boy

>>543092092
Man, if they actually aimed for the T rating then that would've made my years playing that game as a kid even more interesting lol. I remember Sonic Shorts and Sonic RPG being my intro to swear words.

>>543092471
Saying the F-word and the S-word would give the game an M-rating.

>>543092426
living the neet life

>>543092534
>"Silence, you furry little faggot!"
Eggman went over the line here. What the hell was he thinking saying that to sonic, just because he's a little zesty?

>>543092616
That's the F-SLUR, not the F-WORD, silly anon.

>>543092724
>and then Shadow was awoken by someone who looked a lot like Maria

>>543092534
I remember recently watching the Speed Racer movie which had some fun with light swearing and one flip off. Though the best part of that film besides the incredible cinematography is the main villain Royalton and his incredible speech
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EG3rq-M7uMc&pp=0gcJCR4Bo7VqN5tD

A new windfag is born

I dream of a Sonic franchise that is consistently great, where Sonic Team is forced at gunpoint to stay consistent and improve upon previous entries

>Sega goes full retard and shoots past T and M straight into AO
>It's a cream spinoff game

>>543093310
>i'll never get my m rated 100 hour jrpg in the archiekino setting made by the greatest rpg developers of all time in their golden age because SEGA fucked up the saturn and went full retard with the sega CD & 32x
Even if sonic becomes the largest franchise in the future, it still won't change the past....

>Get a T-rated Sonic game announced
>It's a Zavok spinoff

>>543093535
>100 hour jrpg in the archiekino setting made by the greatest rpg developers of all time
You can play Sonic Chronicles right now

>>543093684
>it outsells every other game combined and zavok displaces shadow as the new protagonist of the series
>it becomes a cultural phenomena on the level of fortnite, labubus, etc. and you randomly see people with zavok shirts and dolls IRL
Things could always be worse, I suppose.

>>543093684
Meanwhile, Zor would get an M-rated Sonic game where he talks about depression, cutting, death, and suicide, and just lists off all the abominable things people have done throughout history.

>>543093769
I wouldn't actually mind it as I've slowly become an unironic Zavok fan lol. Could have Zazz and Zeena as other playable characters for certain parts though wether the game would be a prequel to delve into how they met/formed the Deadly Six or just them in a villain pov adventure away from Sonic's world is up to personal preference.

Why is raising someone else's kid seen as a cuck thing? It is the most direct and aggressive form of dominance out there. You are literally stealing someone else's flesh and blood and indoctrinating them from birth to view you as their parent instead

>>543091694
Kids can like more than one thing. Sonic, originally, was more on the serious side than comedic. Well, personally I don't mind Sonic & Friends. I think both styles can coexist in the same series.

I fused ken penders, hideo kojima, and gen urobuchi into a single writer and now he is responsible for directing all sonic games, and has an unlimited budget to express his depravity and daring plots

Check out this Sonic game.

Evan Stanley cannot draw human women.

>>543091694
>
Lmao

I wish human women were real

Evan Stanley cannot draw humans

Evan Stanley cannot draw human men

This is the best decision Iizuka has ever made.

>>543095857
It's happening

Crazy that we got the year of blaze, the month of knuckles, the decade of Kitsunami, the fortnight of tails, and the century of Surge before we got the year of silver

>>543097040
Why did Tails stay behind instead of running after Sonic to help

>>543096830
We'll get Year of Silver in like 2029 and it will be a flop.

>>543096830
Silver doesn't mind waiting because he ahs all the time in the world

You're right about me, sthg.

>>543095857
>>543096095
You guys realize the next movie is focusing on Silver right? Amy and Metal can't carry the hype for that long, especially not after Shadow

>>543097472
he will make a cameo for the fith movie, with silver there are too many new characters

>>543097472
Nah. They want movie 4 to be a romantic comedy.

Why does Sonic have to add new characters to have new adventures? Why can't the movies just do their own thing and build hype around that? Why does it need to be a game of "Which game character gets in nexT" . That format only has diminishing returns. Once you use Shadow it's literally all downward.

>>543097561
They're not doing two time travel movies back to back. Amy and Metal were just for the initial hype.

>>543095857
You might have to pair some of them up for full mileage.
>Year of tails
Tails might have enough popularity to carry a year by himself but it'll work better with sonic doing some heavy lifting
>Year & Knuckles
Bring in the entire Knuckles echidna official mythos. The nux show set a strong base interest and could be a good way to bring back Tikal or chaos or do something interesting
>Year of Jubilee
Neither Amy nor Cream could carry a year alone (cream might if you go full baby mode and make kiddy games with her but nah). They'd work better as a pair
>Year aura
Obligatory Blaze and Silver year probably the most hyped but least lucrative year
>Year of the Hooligans
Instant bank breaking success. Fang gets his own spinoff series, bean voted sexiest cartoon bird alive. Bark is also there.
>Eggman year 1
Formula shake up. Eggman wins for once, sets up long formula for the next like 5 or 10 years. Billions die to sage. Metal finally gets his sauce back. World rejoices.

imagine Year of Silver but it's just a reintroduction with the story of 06 again but Silverfags still aren't happy because it didn't "develop" his character beyond Silvaze

They should have draw her in her running outfit from Mario and Sonic Olympics

>>543097617
Unclear how long these movies will he profitable for.

>>543098142
the sonic movies have been getting better with each entry, but paramount already ruined transformers by the third movie. it took them ten years to make a movie that is actually decently written and not just a loud mindless action movie.
then they made a canon-accurate movie that nobody watched

>>543095857
They did Amy for origins already. Don't think it helped sales cause of all the bugs and bad press.

>>543098485
Ugh I hate those ugly little black spats man I see them everywhere now.

>>543098306
>>543097798
who hurted you?

Sonic should have writing like Scooby Doo.

>>543098649
Yep, killed Amy's whole appeal. Caused Superstars to flop as well.

>>543097629
I don't think the story won't inolve time travel. I also think we'll see Sonic Adventure adapted before 06.

>>543098751
>he didn't play sonic cd
secondary

>>543098751
???

Silver looks like that?

>>543098925
this is waht happens if silver doesn't fix the timeline

>>543098852
I just don't think it will be a time travel movie per se.

>>543098904
Accidentally used a double negative.

>>543098708
Silver. He's a slop character.

>>543098925
How would Silver get mischaracterized if he were female instead?

>>543082442 (OP)
So… the 06 recomp. If it essentially works flawlessly except for flickering in cutscenes, the lack of options menu and some audio popping, why isn’t it publicly released?

>>543099693
Sega would do the same they are doing to Amy right now

>>543099693
I think female Silver would be too different. Probably
>shipped with Shadow or implied to be his daughter
But then it's a franchise for boys, as it should be. The story would go differently. Femsilver would not ever be able to beat Sonic and the story would be completely different with Mephiles perhaps not even bothering to trick Silver into trying to kill Sonic, so maybe the first two assumed fates are completely wrong

>>543100174
It's public. They just aren't done with it yet, so they don't talk about it much, and haven't given a proper download link yet.
https://github.com/sonicnext-dev/MarathonRecomp

How's my favorite schizo general today?

>>543100372
Actually, now that I think about it Mephiles would totally be the ship for Silver. Maybe she'd even try to redeem him in the story, maybe she'd succeed, who the fuck knows, femSilver wouldn't be written the same as the real one but one thing I'm completely sure about is that she would never be allowed to beat Sonic

>>543100372
FemSilver would just look like Lara Croft

>>543100767
Just another schizo day

>shadow kills eggman in the ps2 game
>eggman screams AFTER shadow gave the final blow
Wtf?

'ge

R.I.P. /sthg/ You're only good for drama now.

>>543096830
>Crazy that we got the year of blaze, the month of knuckles, the decade of Kitsunami, the fortnight of tails, and the century of Surge before we got the year of silver
>year of blaze, the month of knuckles
why would the comic locked green sludge and blue tails get anything more than 3 days, idwfag
I just noticed you gave only the idw shit multiple years,
Knuckles, Silver, Tails, and Blaze would get multiple years before the idwshit ever got scraps, even with blaze being the most game vaulted of the four.

the millennium of lien-da is happening and you WILL be happy

>>543096830
Eternity of Metal Sonic is the best timeline

>>543100767
>>543103216
>fuck electronics, gunsmithing is the way

>>543103642
>shadow sempai please notice me uwu

>>543103642
Who's that OC shadow is holding?

>>543104138
Memphis Tennessee the hedgehog

>>543086438
when you've stopped drinking but the screaming bunny skulls won't leave you alone

Skibidi dum dem dum ba ba, skibidi dum dum bum bah!

Skibidi bum bum bam, yes yes yes...

i can't take it anymore, i have to feast

>>543104348
we eat here

let eat

HERE I COME
ROUGHER THAN THE REST OF THEM

i'm listening to Sky Chase, actually. doo doo doo doo doo doo dooooo (doo doo doo-doo doooo)

Based. Sonic adventure 1 doesn't miss with its entire soundtrack.

My body is a machine that turns dicks into sucked dicks.

Anons pick one between cutie honey, or cardcaptor sakura

>>543104861
honey my love

>>543104861
honoy

>>543103642
Fangs

>>543105529
I told her to not play with the task manager.

>>543096830
>year of blaze, the month of knuckles,
I don't charachterfag but you guys are beyond delusional at this point if you think this is remotely close

and yes, i want to see that inside that. no, try again without the LOL FUNY. that's right.

>>543095857
Would a year of Amy even be remotely successful? She's not exactly a popular or demanded character besides being the obligated token girl.

>>543107684
she would if they made her sexually appealing

>>543107684
No, it's not happening. Sonic as a franchise is innately designed for boys and Amy can't carry a year by herself without hurting the brand. It can be a Metamy or Knuxamy year, maybe even Tailamy, but she can't do it by herself.

>>543106839
Specifies accurate ship.
In the current Calendar she's glancing at him in the cafe as she jogging (how did he get to the Sol Dimension).

>>543105529
- rouge is viewing adult videos in the workplace
- there are no adults in the videos!
- there are no adults in the videos...

ya ever have one of those days where your sweat smells kind good

>S' il vous plait monsiour, L'Soon?
>Oui monsiour, L'Soon

>>543109684
>the sonic franchise
>doing something you like
lol
lmao

:'(

Test

Did the site break

>>543106073
fangs are mandatory

Do these taste good?

Shadally

Silver fans walk among us
https://youtu.be/b2G30XQQyhM

Real!

Remember the year of Fang walked so the year of Shadow could run

>>543115894
>Fang WALKED so future character years could RUN
KINO as FUARK

It's pretty wild that in 2025 the most officially supported ship is Vectilla

>>543116783
*Shadouge and Silvaze

what do we think about this ranking?
https://share.google/8yiqaoYjwKS1b1LyY

>>543101120
Classic "yes, I'm robbing ancient cultures for the thrill of it, I'm not sorry" Lara or Crystal Dynamics nuLara?

>>543117463
>yes, I'm robbing ancient cultures for the thrill of it, I'm not sorry
Don't be silly. I don't think she ever said that, or even implied that.

>>543117231
>Silver and blaze anywhere near top ten
Shit list

Sonic=Superman
Shadow=Batman
Silver=Wonder Woman

Have a lovely morning and weekend, /sthg/

>>543118136
Nigga Das Nuts!

>>543116942
not even close

>>543118475
I hate that reboot Sally's design works perfectly in this outfit and thety still put that stupid blue jacket over her

>>543116783
>It's pretty wild that in 2025 the most officially supported ship is Vectilla
Just wait, it gets better
it will come out that they have been dating for years and Vector is the Dad

>>543118052
At least pick a psychic super hero you secondary

>>543118052
Uh no?
Sonic is Flash
Shadow is Batman
Silver is Green Lantern
Do you even read the crossover?

Capeshit is cringe. Watch more anime please

>>543118551
They're afraid of the reader getting a boner

>>543118824
Cringe OOC. Silver is the blonde guy with attitude

>>543118657
>>543118789
It's mostly in how they are treated by ST. Silver's mishandling over the years is very comparable to WW's.

>>543118657
Get her away she makes people gay

>>543118551
It's been 10years get over it grandpa

>>543118052
>Silver=Wonder Woman
That tracks. They both suck.

>>543119273
I'm 23 fuck you buddy fuck you fuck your mother

>>543119178
WW got a film and a cartoon show to push the GIRLS STRONG! propaganda. Silver will never get that

>>543119178
It really can't be understated how WW was mishandled. She had writing like this for 20 years.

>>543119102
The zesty boy?

>>543119178
Oh, sorry I thought you were one of those Silverschixos who’s hell bent on feminizing Silver. Wonder women sucks though fr no hate

>>543119632
Silver had Archie and his heavily pushed in IDW.

Also,
>WW got a cartoon

She got some animated specials from nuDC that people barely remember or care about. They were okay

Opinions on this custom outfit I'm wearing?

>>543119910
Like WW, Silver is a complicated character with convoluted a mythology. Writers/designers have to somehow justify his time travel and work with his overpowered, but ill-defined powerset. All on top of a shaky foundation most people try and ignore.

Maybe one day Silver will find his Perez.

>>543118551
Jackets are cool.

>>543120320
We have to discuss the "everything sonic" rule. We have to put a limit to Roblox

>>543120447
This looks better

>>543118551
>>543120447
It's de jackeeeet

WHITEBOARD
https://magma.com/d/YcazD9qkG6
https://magma.com/d/YcazD9qkG6
https://magma.com/d/YcazD9qkG6

>>543119178
Where was Silver mishandled outside of IDW?

>>543120329
Perez run sucks.

Oh look, it's the shitboard

>>543120320
You will get molested.

Has Chris-chan ever posted here?

>>543120885
no

>>543120635
Why can't you faggots just do this on twitter?

>>543120693
A lot of Silverfags on here swear that Silver is held back by his English voice direction throughout all his appearances. There's also the whole Eggman Nega confusion.

>>543121051
Why do you hate fun?

>>543120635
Have fun

>>543083810
how would (You) make it less lazy

>>543120729
Has WW had a good run?

>>543121112
Gee, I don't know. Maybe it could be the fact it is made up of twitter fags, and run by people who sniff their own asses.

Whenever people talk about the "Mount Rushmore" of superheroes, it always ultimately boils down to Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman and Spider-Man. And so when people think about the top THREE heroes of all time, it's basically just Spider-Man vs Wonder Woman.

But all I see when I look at it is a fight over whether Tails or Amy fits best with Sonic & Knuckles.

>>543121439
and this effects you how?

>>543121485
The answer is Shadow

>>543121527
Not even denying it anymore lol

>>543121217
hope you're doing well amyanon

>>543121527
It is not a general thing anymore, its a twitter and shitcord thing. And it needs to fuck off.

>>543121846
it is a general thing though, isn't that why the link gets posted here?

>>543122010
Clearly not, and you know it.

>>543083810
Reminder that this Aifag spams Peach gens over at /smbg/, and I heard he does this in several other generals with their characters as well. That bitch is not a fan of anything.

>>543121748
I have been dealing with some stressful stuff lately but I am okay. I hope you are okay too, anon!!

>>543122010
ignore him, anon

>>543122010
Because you retards keep pushing it yet nobody gives a shit all the time

How would you rank Sonic fan spaces?
>/sthg/, Twitter, Reddit, Tumblr, Sonic Stadium, Newgrounds

>>543121673
>>543122087
Get Alota's dick and Hotshelter's & Bobo's cooch out of your mouth, shill.

>>543122136
NewGrounds feels like old deviantart with flash games
/sthg/
reddit
twitter
tumblr

>>543122078
sorry to hear that, hope things turn around for you real soon. I'm fine just really busy.

>>543122385
I'd put Tumblr above Twitter and Reddit. That's where those anti-Ian texts that used to get posted here came from.

>>543122136
all of these places suck honestly, Newgrounds isn't what it was back in the early 20s

>>543122618 (me)
*meant to say early 2000s

>>543122469
most of the anti Ian shit I saw here was focused on shipping slop so tumblr stays in the bottom.

>>543122737
Then you must be pretty new.

>>543122087
I just wish this general wasn't so hostile to contentfags, It's nice whenever someone shares art and other stuff.

>>543122871
I have been here for a couple of years and I got a huge filter. threads are occasionally 30% to 50% collapsed when too much autism is going on. I don't care what you nerds seethe about.

>>543122995
Said contentfags don't even post here, or care about what we discuss here. They mostly draw garbage for themselves

>>543122995
>this general
It's just a couple of guys who do this. The majority of anons are chill.

>>543122995
The hostility they get is deserved.

Nic

>>543123229
why?

The Psychic Boy

>>543123076
>or care about what we discuss here
what does get discussed here besides namefag/twitter drama?

>>543123417
shipping

The Fire Girl

>>543123279
They always eventually show off their true colors as faggots, who use anons as their defense squad just because they make free art.

>>543123558
This is a cute Blaze.

Why is this general so slow on euro hours? Is there really that few non-american sonic fans?

>>543123720
Wanna discuss SatAM and Archie?

>>543123417
>west perspective
>east perspective
>characterization
>shipping
>comics
>mangas
>anime
>games
And that was just yesterday, are you sure you visit this place very often or are you here just to attention whore with your shitty whiteboard?

>>543123720
i was busy

>>543123827
>SatAM
I confess, I never watched SatAM
>Archie
I read it ages ago, I barely remember anything.

Pass me the Torx.

now i can post my fav hog again

>>543123852
I'm not the person who makes the whiteboard anon, I just asked because every time I visit the general it seems anons are just arguing about namefags. I've seen people talk about the comics and manga but that usually just amounts to "the comics is shit and you're shit for liking them" type posts. As for shipping, is just the same anons posting them same images over and over again every thread, that isn't discussion thats just lazy spam

>>543122136
>Tumblr
Probably the best since it never really had the "Modern Sonic sucks, his friends sucks, I want Classic Sonic back" crowd. It was pretty much praise for the Modern Sonic series while having tons of memes, comics, and fanart(Also porn if you're into that).
>Newgrounds
Decent. Many influential Sonic fangames had their start here, like Sonic x Final Fantasy, Sonic RPG, Sonic Flash Ultimate, and Sonic Boom. It was the perfect place for children that wanted to play Sonic games but didn't know how to use a emulator.
>Sonic Stadium
It's...okay? It was alright for discussion of the Sonic franchise, but you had to deal with many SatAM and Classic fans that would post the most shitty takes while begging for characters like Cream to get vaulted.
>Reddit
It dependent. There's funny memes and legitimate good discussion to be found for the Sonic franchise. But there's extremely obnoxious people on there and a subreddit that's pretty much "ERMMMM THE 2010s WERE A GREAT TIME TO BE A SONIC FAN".
>Twitter
Awful. Legitimately the worst. For a very long time, the Sonic series was nothing but a punching bag while the official Sonic twitter account went "LOL SONIC IS FUCKING GARBAGE AND CRINGE, DON'T YOU AGREE?" for awhile.

>>543124359
>every time I visit the general it seems anons are just arguing about namefags
Thanks for confirming that you're not a regular here. Opinion discarded

>>543124562
NTA, but I've been a regular here for half a decade at this point, and that is in fact the current state of this general.

>>543124298
he has a long torso

>>543124562
so because I don't live on the general 24/7 like you I'm not a regular here?

I could suck his royal cock every day
ngggh

>>543124693
My first real nut on the sonic franchise was on that shitty russian "vk" site and it was amy... i used to love amy a lot, and i can't find all those pics anymore. Actually it's sad that a lot of content got washed away after more than a decade.

What I hate about the drawfag clique is how fake they are.

So he could've escape right if Pikachu had been a foot or two closerby, right?

>>543125026
meant for >>543124536

>543124752
Yesss anon, your opinion gets shittier the more you post.
>>543124693
Namefaggotry aside, like Violet literally using a name Sparky reddit spacing or Krack signature posting, they do discuss Sonic stuff that you could say, shapes the culture of this general and can be debated at a certain degree. It's worth noting that bringing up a discussion about something that has been talked about a dozen of times might lead to shitposting, which is why a lot of anons are fed up with Sparky already

>>543125147
No, Sakurai wanted to jerk off Kirby so they'd be hit no matter what

New Kurimu!

>>543125147
Sonic would have gotten hit regardless due to Sakurai heavy bias towards Kirby. Or more specifically, HIS version of Kirby. Not the actual modern Kirby.

>>543125412
She becomes a roastie.

>>543125601
i always crack when this artfag draws surge in every background

>>543125137
Same, they act like unhinged twitter circlejerks.

Why is Uncle Chuck Sonics best relative?

>>543125147

Like these two anons said
>>543125342
>>543125625
But I don't know why he wants to jack off his version of kirby so much when it isn't even the best one.

>antoine makes it
>she doesn't
imagine that

>>543125923
Like how do you be that shallow? when I see them draw our ocs, it feels so hollow and their weak way to go and say “SEE we’re one of you!”

damn, this is how frontiers look on switch?

>>543126874
woah, is that the same plastic character model that was recycled for a decade?

>>543127059
this too but i mean the background

>>543126592
Good timeline. That dumcumpster needs to stay out of this franchise. Add in HONI ZA KATTO

I didn't realize so many people lusted for Zavok

>>543126874
Nice PS3 tier graphics. Oh wait, PS3 at least had Phantom Pain on it, guess it's PS2 tier in that case?

>>543127120
That looks like a ps2 game background.

>>543127198
Crashdow rapefic made me like him

>>543127172
this person is violent

>>543124840
We need more Elias contentfag

>>543126703
Ok fine, they might not be the most skilled artists in this medium, but the main problem is their lack of creativity, they never try to draw something unique or fun that’s actually worth a laugh or a giggle. Drawing a shitty OC in a generic pose feels more like watching someone practice art than someone trying to create something special for others. That’s why their art feels shallow. That’s why Bobo’s art is stupid, Mina standing there with a dumb engagement ring isn’t compelling at all, if anything, it's pathetic, like hotshelter believing she can marry Espio thus drawing him 10000 times. Meanwhile, Realdash has more potential but wastes it on ocfaggotry. If our drawfags were more like drawchad (picrel), in terms of creating something wholesome worth reposting, they'd be more fun to have around.

>>543127496
A drooling rapist retard.

Can't believe they made her leader.

>>543123370
Focking cool mate

>>543127613
Bobo is such a one trick pony, not even a good one at that. Shame that guy stopped, he was unique.

>>543125387
Silver should move to the Sol dimension.

>>543128526
It smells like ocean garbage and fish

>>543125298
The reason I use a name is because if I didn't, people would still call out my posts as belonging to a name anyways. I also don't always use a name, I frequently post as Anonymous.
It wouldn't make a difference if I used a name or not since Sparky and others would continue to call me by said name and bring up my identity in arguments with me rather than debate the merits of my posts. Sparky will frequently bring up irrelevant shipping discourse in contexts where I'm discussing characterization which is... tiring to say the least.

>>543124298
This is mina point of view.
She really wants this guy to ride her up

>>543129281
Who can blame her? He's a cute boy. Very cuddly.

Imagine if Cream gave you a blowjob and you know it was her first time but she still gave you the most insane nut churning cock flexing eye rolling toe clenching mouth gaping back arching ball draining blowjob known to mankind.
That would be kinda cool huh?

I like how most of the responses for who should get a year are either just Amy or Silver.
https://x.com/soniccitynet/status/1979453374715302379

>>543129481
Don't touch kids.

I killed the thread again.

>>543130087
Fiona said this.

>>543130161
>got called out too

>>543130301
the climax of archie's shipping era

>>543130301
my god this was a mistake

>>543130301
BUNNIE MAH BELOVED

>>543129641
Silver can’t pull it off.

>>543130301
Hot take, but bunnie should have stayed as sonic love interest, and evolved into his main girl whe she broke up with antoine, before they tried to retcon it into being patch.

>>543130493
>Mistake
Archie Sonic ran for over 300 issues and simultaneously maintained several side series during its over 25 year run.

>>543130662
Explain your reasoning behind this anon.

>>543130301
>all the Archie OCs have hairy ass cheek tufts
>not a single Sonic Team female has them
What did America mean by that

>>543130748
Then got deleted without a trace

>>543082442 (OP)
Jesus Christ, why is this doing it for me?

>>543130606
Amy can't pull it off, but CHADver most certainly can.

>>543089352
Wait, I need a reason to spank girls?