← Home ← Back to /vp/

Thread 58128690

67 posts 10 images /vp/
Anonymous No.58128690 >>58128697 >>58128702 >>58128728 >>58128742 >>58128979 >>58129127 >>58129178 >>58129186 >>58130968
Why does the ghost typing feel tacked on?
Anonymous No.58128697 >>58128702 >>58129564
>>58128690 (OP)
i agree. i'm not seeing it. it's not built into the whole line either. though all of these are bad starters. gen 6 and 7 did a great job blending two types into the starters.
Anonymous No.58128702
>>58128697
>>58128690 (OP)
>Anons have never seen a calavera before
Anonymous No.58128725 >>58128769 >>58128922 >>58129030 >>58129045 >>58129134 >>58129616
because ghost type went from "ghost" to "animal with vague ghost theming"
Anonymous No.58128728
>>58128690 (OP)
Extremely esoteric inspiration lore you'd need to be latinx to know.
Anonymous No.58128740 >>58128791
dirge is an undeniable uggo but in fairness there's a lot of ghost types you can this this about
Anonymous No.58128742
>>58128690 (OP)
At least it has skeletal features
Decidueye is just an owl with foliage cloak
Anonymous No.58128769 >>58128781 >>58128815 >>58128942
>>58128725
I too can cherrypick examples of ghost types not having barely anything to do with ghosts
>Drifloon/Drifblim
>Spiritomb
>Sableye
>Giratina
>Rotom
Anonymous No.58128781 >>58128789
>>58128769
>fails to cherrypick examples of ghost types not having barely anything to do with ghosts
what did she mean by this?
Anonymous No.58128789 >>58128797
>>58128781
>N-nuh uh
Concession accepted, pokeboomoid
Anonymous No.58128791 >>58128802
>>58128740
>dirge is an undeniable uggo
wrong
Anonymous No.58128797 >>58128811
>>58128789
>>N-nuh uh
yes that's how it works when you pick examples that literally contradict your point
Anonymous No.58128802 >>58128819 >>58128855
>>58128791
whoa, the most popular gen 9 starter. how prestigious
Anonymous No.58128811
>>58128797
Explain how any of those are didn't the ghost types
Anonymous No.58128815 >>58128822
>>58128769
Rotom is a poltergeist and Spiritomb is literally a bunch of ghosts bound together tho
Anonymous No.58128819
>>58128802
considering the only flop is the duck (and only because of its walking animation) yes
Anonymous No.58128822 >>58128832 >>58128833 >>58128835
>>58128815
Rotom is an electric thingy and Spiritomb is a magic rock.
Anonymous No.58128832 >>58129036
>>58128822
Rotom is a ghost that possesses appliances, anon. Its first appearance was even a ring reference. Spiritomb is not a magic rock, it’s a bunch of spirits bound to a magic rock.
Anonymous No.58128833 >>58128971
>>58128822
>fails to do more than take a passing glance
>thinks he's an authority on what makes or doesn't make something its type
Anonymous No.58128835 >>58129036
>>58128822
you are retarded
spiritomb is a bunch of ghosts in a rock. It is the ghosts, not the fucking prison they're in
rotom is a literal ghost. but it's also electric type so instead of possessing humans it possesses electronic objects
Anonymous No.58128855
>>58128802
Doesn't stop there.
Anonymous No.58128922 >>58128976
>>58128725
Yamask? Chandelure? Honedge? Phantump? Sandygast? Polteageist?
Anonymous No.58128942 >>58129074
>>58128769
You joke but Drifloon's entire evolutionary line probably draws inspiration from Japanese folklore like tsukumogami where inanimate objects suddenly become living things after 100 years and play tricks on people. Drifloon and Drifblim are literally living balloons that float like ghosts aimlessly through the sky looking to snatch kids up, which checks out with their origins. Also in Japan balloons rising into the sky are sometimes used as metaphors for souls ascending, so the Drifloon line's design is actually really clever and in line with its ghost typing.
Anonymous No.58128971
>>58128833
>but that totally doesn't apply to nughosts right guise
Anonymous No.58128976 >>58128998 >>58129013
>>58128922
All proves him right.
Anonymous No.58128979 >>58129207
>>58128690 (OP)
It's literally a skull.
If marowak gets to be ghost fire so does the crocodile.
Anonymous No.58128998 >>58129100
>>58128976
explain your reasoning for each one
Anonymous No.58129013 >>58129100
>>58128976
How? Almost all of those are literal ghosts. Maybe Polteageist could be argued otherwise.
Anonymous No.58129030
>>58128725
I'm fine with all those Ghosts on the bottom, but the last two in particular are great ghosts, like jellyfish are ethereal as fuck
Anonymous No.58129036 >>58129092 >>58129097 >>58129207 >>58129587
>>58128832
>>58128835
Rotom still isn't poltergeist (or a ghost). You can repeat that statement all you want but it doesn't make it true. Thematically it's a computer virus at best, and it's explicitly stated to be shaped like a lightbulb, not a ghost.
Lightbulbs aren't ghostly, anons. Neither are fridges, fans, washing machines, ovens, lawn mowers, pokedexes, PCs, bikes or phones.
Anonymous No.58129045 >>58129118
>>58128725
>Then
Explain how sableye is in any way shape or form a ghost yawnie (you won't)
Anonymous No.58129074
>>58128942
>words words [headcanon] words
still an objectmon that’s NOT a ghost
Anonymous No.58129092 >>58129109
>>58129036
Pokemon are based on more than one thing.
Anonymous No.58129097 >>58129175
>>58129036
>This bizarre Pokémon appears to be a will-o’-the-wisp powered by electricity. Be wary, as Rotom is both smart and mischievous.
>A Will-o'-the-wisp is a folklore phenomenon, also known as ignis fatuus, described as a ghostly light seen over bogs and marshes, often leading travelers astray. These lights are attributed to various supernatural entities like fairies, mischievous spirits, or even the souls of the dead.
Try again.
Anonymous No.58129100 >>58129109 >>58129123
>>58128998
>>58129013
it's a fucking chandelier tardos
I'm not going to spell something so obvious out for your brainless zoomer asses
Anonymous No.58129109 >>58129134
>>58129092
>>58129100
Self-contradictory o algo
Anonymous No.58129118
>>58129045
Ghost is its secondary typing, to start with.
Anonymous No.58129123 >>58129206
>>58129100
It’s a ghost chandelier thobeit, it even haunts mansions
Anonymous No.58129127
>>58128690 (OP)
Because even the SV site admits it's not a ghost type
Anonymous No.58129134
>>58129109
see >>58128725
learn how to follow multiple conversations and understand the actual point of each
Anonymous No.58129175 >>58129229
>>58129097
And Solrock is shaped like the sun, said to come from the sun, and emits intense heat and light like the sun, does that make it a star?
Anonymous No.58129178
>>58128690 (OP)
It's a skeletal sugar skull croc with a will o' wisp bird, don't be retarded.
Anonymous No.58129186
>>58128690 (OP)
because they has to quickly pivot from it being a quetzalcoatl feathered dead snake god and turned it into an alligator or whatever
Anonymous No.58129196 >>58129216
I think if I ever end up playing gen 9 (I won't) I'll just never evolve fuecoco. Unless its mid evo is alright, I haven't seen it yet.
Anonymous No.58129206
>>58129123
It feeds off souls that it steals too. People don't like it because it has the gall to be original and it doesn't conform to their bumass strict definition of a ghost, but frankly what's more ghostly than a haunted house with possessed furniture?
Anonymous No.58129207
>>58128979
marowak being ghost/fire was ridiculed at the time too though lol, along with decidueye

>>58129036
anon it's the ghost in the machine. I hate rotom but its design, if stupid, is coherent.
Anonymous No.58129216 >>58129224
>>58129196
>Mid evo
How do you feel about Mexicans, Anon?
Anonymous No.58129224 >>58129237
>>58129216
Can I catch Ludicolo to go along with it? Because I think that would be funny.
Anonymous No.58129229 >>58129253
>>58129175
You're making a false equivalence. There's a difference between something being evocative of an object and something clearly intended to be that object. None of Solrock's dex entries say it's a literal star either whereas Rotom's do. You're effectively making an argument that Solrock is a plant because it absorbs solar energy.
Anonymous No.58129237
>>58129224
If you own the DLC or bring one in from Home you can, you can actually catch a Lotad really early since you can travel outside Paldea immediately after finishing the tutorial
Anonymous No.58129253 >>58129327 >>58129519
>>58129229
That's pedantic and you know it. Stop moving goalposts, Rotom is a ghost as much as Sonic's arms are blue.
Anonymous No.58129327 >>58129516
>>58129253
What goalposts are being moved, retard? You're the one whining about how the dex is wrong and making wild statements that aren't corroborated by the games. Get over your ego.
Anonymous No.58129516 >>58129550
>>58129327
>Aren't corroborated
It takes five minutes to read through all the dex entries. Pulling headcanons out of your ass isn't helping your argument
Anonymous No.58129519 >>58129547
>>58129253
>everybody is calling me a retard
>clearly they're the wrong ones
Just admit you've never read the pokedex and based you're "not a ghost" statements on appearance only
Anonymous No.58129547
>>58129519
>you're
Oh, I see how it is. I don't know what localizations you're translating from ESLanon but they're not canon if they're not in English.
>But
No. Shut up. You don't get it.
Anonymous No.58129550
>>58129516
>It takes five minutes to read through all the dex entries
Apparently not considering your toddler ass failed to read them all in the first place.
Anonymous No.58129564 >>58129602
>>58128697
gen 7 gave us an owl that is just as un-ghostly as skeledirge
Anonymous No.58129587 >>58129607
>>58129036
>Thematically it's a computer virus at best
my fucking lawnmower is not a computer
Anonymous No.58129602
>>58129564
yeah and it was so hated Game Freak replaced it after a single gen
Anonymous No.58129607 >>58129665
>>58129587
Fuck you, you seriously aren't filing your taxes on your John Deere? What are you, 90 years old?
Anonymous No.58129616 >>58129631 >>58130982 >>58131069
>>58128725
the only reason people are seething over this (correct) image is because a gen 5 pokemon is on the bottom kek
Anonymous No.58129631
>>58129616
Go failtroll somewhere else yawnigger before I put you on the bottom next
Anonymous No.58129665
>>58129607
you joke but I'm willing to bet there's a lawnmower out there that could. Everything has to be a 1000 in 1 multitool these days
Anonymous No.58130948
How is it fire?
Anonymous No.58130968
>>58128690 (OP)
Because it's pokemon #911
Anonymous No.58130982
>>58129616
way to state the obvious
Anonymous No.58131069
>>58129616
yes people indeed only like gen 5 out of all those bottom gens