← Home ← Back to /vrpg/

Thread 3780626

26 posts 6 images /vrpg/
Anonymous No.3780626 [Report] >>3780650 >>3780681 >>3782585 >>3782938 >>3790692
>steals all the credit for Uematsu's masterpiece
Anonymous No.3780650 [Report] >>3780684 >>3788609
>>3780626 (OP)
?
If you mean Chrono Trigger he worked himself so hard he was hospitalized and Nobou had to come in and finish up the last pieces of music.
Anonymous No.3780681 [Report]
>>3780626 (OP)
Mitsuda is generally a better composer than Uematsu but Uematsu did better with FF9's cinematic score.
Anonymous No.3780684 [Report] >>3781838 >>3783510
>>3780650
Every great piece was made by Uematsu, including:

Tyrannosaurus Rex theme:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ltn9SmLbyDY&list=RDLtn9SmLbyDY&start_radio=1

Caveman theme:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhChHmk1o8c&list=RDKhChHmk1o8c&start_radio=1

Sewer theme:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LERK943Gvk&list=RD_LERK943Gvk&start_radio=1
Anonymous No.3780690 [Report] >>3781843
Uematsu is more kino but Mitsuda is peak comfy.
But when I discovered Corridors of Time was not wholly original it kinda soured my opinion on him.
That said still had lots of great tracks, like Secret of the Forest, Wind Scene, Memories of Green, Peaceful Days, Schala's theme

Also his work on Inazuma Eleven is memorable too (there are many others like Xeno series and Chrono Cross)
Anonymous No.3781411 [Report]
JAPAN
Anonymous No.3781838 [Report] >>3782455
>>3780684
Oh sincerely fuck right off, Uematsu fans are so fucking obnoxious
https://youtu.be/fKex3QoPc8A?si=RaYhEjfsPUzKMwOB

https://youtu.be/BXo3DrXHY8w?si=SLOeMUObmBJUNuZL

https://youtu.be/AbIwWBi1-UA?si=OTGR0vF5j_LW93pq
Anonymous No.3781843 [Report] >>3781864 >>3783313
>>3780690
Chrono Cross is one of the greatest soundtracks of all time and Uematsu is extremely fucking overrated and mainly just rips off prog rock most of the time, he isn't more kino. If you want kino take a look at Hiroki Kikuta or Masashi Hamauzu for Square composers, they're way more experimental than Uematsu
Anonymous No.3781864 [Report]
>>3781843
I don't know, ripping off prog rock is pretty much what most JRPG composer does, Sakuraba does it alot
The exception is probably Mitsuda, Hamauzu, Shimomura and Sakimoto
Also Uematsu does alot of great atmospheric music not just the proggy battle themes
Anonymous No.3782455 [Report]
>>3781838
Those are okay just a bit simplistic and repetitive.
Anonymous No.3782585 [Report] >>3783898
>>3780626 (OP)
Uematsu is one of the most overrated composers in the industry and is only elevated because he works on higher platform series.
Anonymous No.3782629 [Report] >>3782892
Uematsu is fairly rated imo
Shimomura is more overrated, saying this as a Shimomura fan
Anonymous No.3782634 [Report]
nakano>>>>>everyone mentioned itt
Anonymous No.3782892 [Report]
>>3782629
women are over-praised in general
Anonymous No.3782914 [Report]
What is it about the GOAT Uematsu that makes these people so upset?
Anonymous No.3782938 [Report]
>>3780626 (OP)
Nah. The vast majority of CT is his work.
Anonymous No.3783313 [Report] >>3783392 >>3785216
>>3781843
Chrono Cross' greatest sin is having one of the worst songs Mitsuda ever penned being played through about 50% of the runtime
Anonymous No.3783392 [Report]
>>3783313
No, it's actually not, listen to the Radical Dreamers version.
https://youtu.be/G7687ikwhao?si=UU88b2I5VZJeg_jY
The composition of the song is actually really good; it's just the choice of the instruments that was bad for the Chrono Cross version.
https://youtu.be/SbIhIRIasoE?si=Ya2xD2wK7CT_84GB
The orchestra version is noticeably less harsh-sounding, too
Anonymous No.3783510 [Report]
>>3780684
>the most unremarkable songs in the entire OST
am I being rused?
Anonymous No.3783898 [Report]
>>3782585
Not at all, he's rated fairly because Final Fantasy is a completely dogshit bottom of the barrel series outside of its music. Every single thing that makes it good or memorable is tied entirely to the music. If you have pretty much any other composer doing the soundtrack for Final Fantasy, that series does not become popular. With most other game composers, the series they worked on would lose a step with a different composer, but would still be able to stand on its own.

The only series that I can think was carried as hard by music was early Hitman.
Anonymous No.3783961 [Report]
I like his work for Shadow Hearts and Tsugunai Atonement more
Anonymous No.3785216 [Report]
>>3783313
I think chrono cross battle theme is actually very very good and I will never understand the sheer hatred it gets.
Anonymous No.3788609 [Report]
>>3780650
??? the boss theme is not even Mitsuda theme, is Noriko.
Anonymous No.3790692 [Report] >>3790701 >>3790705
>>3780626 (OP)
Why's he so funny looking?
Anonymous No.3790701 [Report]
>>3790692
I don't think he did meant to make that face in the first place
Anonymous No.3790705 [Report]
>>3790692
He looks like a combed good luck troll.