That was pretty bad.

>>101462291 (OP)
Turns out Raora and CC can't sing for shit, GG is only kinda passable and you can't get a group song solely be carried by only one legitimately good singer.

>>101462291 (OP)
eh not as bad as country roads.

>>101464190
Who's the legit good singer because you're delusional and tone deaf if you think the brit bitch is even more than decent

>>101464259
you took too much drugs bro.

>>101464246
Country Roads isn't an original MV.

>>101464190
All their singing was good in Renegade, especially compared to their singing in Above Below, but Renegade's lyrics suck and the melody's nothing to write home about.

>>101464190
>Turns out
That was clear from the start. But the song itself is also kinda bad, regardless of singing

>>101464979
>All their singing was good
kek

And yet CC hasn't done shit in her channel with her supposed musical prowess, what a fake.

>>101465190
Her musical prowess was never in singing

There's not a single good hololive EN song produced by cover.

>>101462291 (OP)
it's still in my head though
maybe because i also like geometry dash music

>>101465486
He probably means stuff like playing the violin more or composing music, which she did but only rarely.
I don't blame her though, it's evident she's in burnout with all the group Hololive projects.

>>101462291 (OP)
listened to this for the first time. I kinda like it, but its more of a production problem than a singing problem. its mixed like shit and the beat ( which is good) is super under mixed. the vocals clash with each other and its just creates a low sound. if the vocals were mixed higher and the beat was deeper and louder it would be great.
the 303 acid stings and the drums and claps are way too low. I hope cover sees this and can act accordnigly. this song should be more early 2ks trance with super hard beats and soaring vocals, but in 2020s kpop production it just doesn't work
get DJ SHARPNEL in! he could make this go insane

>>101465588
rebellion is good

>>101465644
For holoEN standards, maybe.

The production side of hololive is fucking emberassing, idk where they keep finding these jobbers who can't mix for shit

>>101464190
Ah hell nah, CC is amazing but this song was ASS. Literally made for 1-2 people max, this was NOT a group song.

>>101465593
What are you people on about? She was fucking goated in the last two double covers she did with Gigi. Yeah she doesn't have many songs but go listen to those covers, she's good but COMPLETELY misused by Cover thus far.

Time for the reminder about who's making these bait threads.

>>101465904
/#/?

>>101465839
You might be tonedeaf

>>101464190
Raora's ECHO cover was fine, although it had lots of post-production vocal alteration. The mixing was just ass on this song

Definitely a step backwards from Above Below.

They did the same thing last year with Advent releasing Sirens before Breaking Dimensions. Thankfully someone had enough sense to stick with Rebellion for the group song at the concert then.

>>101465839
>by cover
like it isn't her own fault she doesn't use her violin

>>101462291 (OP)
>me be silent on every other song I didn't dislike
>me be vocal when I hear one song I don't like

retard. kys.

>>101462291 (OP)
I blame the producer, the song was shit, the lyrics were good though. They should have done an eurobeat song.

200k for an original en Song yeah Holo live is cooked

>>101466092
that's how shit works, welcome to the internet

>>101465839
Atleast siren has 1.6 million after 10 months

I don't think this crap will cross 1 million even after a year

>>101466146
I blame the singers tbdesu

Can we stick to the guns on this and blame whoever wrote this song instead?
It's so fucking boring to listen to, they didn't work with the talents' strengths at all and forced them to sing together just to push this retarded "Advent vs Justice" thing again.
They could've made a good song even with someone who has an accent as thick as Raora. They just chose to not work with the talents at all on the direction.

>>101465633
>get DJ SHARPNEL in
damn, that would be based

>>101462291 (OP)
It was ok. From best to worst
ERB
GG
CC
Raora

>>101467769
These people approved the absolute trash that is flowglow 's first song, what can you expect

>>101467769
Addendum to this the first 10 seconds of the song literally invert your genitals with how bad it starts. Who the fuck listened to this and went "YEAHHH THIS IS HYPE", like... fuck. It's so bad. Is this the shit sub-zero IQ gym bros listen to when they hit up the club?

I just want you guys to know that I love Cecilia Immergreen

>>101467769
THIS
Above and Below was great despite the singing talent of Justice, hell two thirds of the girls in Hololive don't go above average in singing and they more often than not make it work with a little autotuning and catchy songs, Renegade was simply shit and composed by a hack.

>>101464190
CC can do fine with decent direction
It's just that a good chunk of the music producers that Cover works with are actual dogshit and unfortunately somtimes they get rolled
Well over half of the music people Cover works with only get work because of nepotism which is very unfortunate

>>101467830
I punished myself and listened in, it's just gangster garbage again. Vtubers need to gtfo of gangster aesthetics, it's like watching a Pomeranian throw gang signs.

>>101462291 (OP)
HoloEN is the solo leveling of vtubing

>>101467914
that's the joke retard and it worked well with team tomadachi, even frighteningly so

>>101462291 (OP)
was there any good og song in vtuber history? (maybe except mori's end of life?)

>>101468433
Fuck off ESL retard

>>101468467
Name a good song produced by cover. You can't.

>>101467900
Reminded me of Anya's rigger who still got work from cover after that atrocity.

>>101468484
The Cocoon and the Heart

>>101468595
Actually Anya's outfit was the last thing they worked on

>>101462291 (OP)
200k seem to disagree

>>101462291 (OP)
Mid song for a mid gen

>>101468609
lmao

>>101468897
200k played it one time to see it's shit.

>>101468897
200k likes? we have a banger on our hands

Raora and ERB were the only good ones.

CC sounds as monotone as one can be, I don't even know why she sings like that.

>>101469367
>ERB
I'm so tired of people pretending she's a good singer, this is mori all over again

>>101468897
Yeah with this speed they will achieve 900k in tomorrow

>>101469565
she is a good singer though

>people glazing rebellion when it sounds cringe
>people hating sirens when it sounds kino
this is why i can't trust /vt/.

ERB absorbed her entire Gen's singing abilities (except Raora, I have a soft spot for her that occasionally becomes a hard spot)

>>101470108
that explains why she sucks, there wasn't anything to absorb

who were they even trying to appeal to with this song, it sounds like an English dub opening theme of some shit anime

>EN
>good at singing

>>101462291 (OP)
There isn't even a single part of the song that is remotely interesting. The lyrics are esl nonsense that doesn't flow. Music is dull and forgettable throughout. They do nothing to hide the poor singers and/or have them do something that lets them be part of the song while not bringing attention to their poor singing ability. Like Raora's "line-up" yip in Above Below, or how they have Shiori sing the utlra-simple parts that are close to speaking in advent songs.

Didn't we already have a thread for this yesterday? Are brats just trying to deflect off the bratcord drama?

>>101470318
erb and irys are better then azki

>>101470958
How

>>101475326
When they sing it sounds better, you know?

>>101462291 (OP)
hololive can't hire good talents anymore

I don't like this song it doesn't even enable the best parts of each memeber
ERB belting
Roara raspy voice
CC & GG reduced to adlibs.

>>101465644
meh it's okay, overrated for sure

I think mori and erb are good singers

>>101462291 (OP)
Oh mama I'm in fear for my life from how bad this song is

>>101470050
>another siren enjoyer
Truly one of the best holo songs to be conceived

>>101464190
Who expected Raora to be able to sing? She sounds like your middle aged aunt that molested you when you were ten

I hate the lyrics and the melody, I hate the idea and the concept of it all, I really expected more, maybe Above Below fooled me

>>101470318
Most of EN were better singers than JP

>>101489521
there's like 3 good singers in en max

>>101495809
3 more than jp

Raora's voice isn't even passable for talking much less singing

>>101469565
She's got good fundamentals, it's just that she sings like a theater kid. Personally I don't think it's that bad when she does more professional songs like this but it's also why I don't step into her Karaoke streams that often lol

>>101462291 (OP)
HoloEN has NO good group orisongs or covers. NONE. Not even one.

>>101464190
>legitimately good singer
>Liz

>>101470050
>>101484846
Man I fucking love Sirens.

>>101499035
>i don't like her, so she can't sing
its so obvious with you browns

>>101499237
95% of vtuber fans are browns. 99.9% if you count the japs who aren't exactly white either. What's your point?

>>101495809
Can't name a single JP one though

>>101499237
I dont like Bae, she can sing
I dont like Liz, she can't sing
I do like Fauna, she can't sing
not everyone is as pathetic as you, who will champion a terrible singer to own the chuds or whatever fucking retarded idea you have

>>101465588
What is S-Sirens

>>101465904
FUCKING PHASEPAGGERS

>>101462291 (OP)
It was fine

>>101464190
>GG is only kinda passable
Debatable, the gremlin was AWFUL in Odyssey. Calli at least knew how to handle Roara and Cici's parts when she was producing the song.

>>101504033
So you are trying to own the libtards then? I what way can this woman not sing?
inb4
>Muh belting!

>>101499003
They had several only last year niggerfaggot

>>101462291 (OP)
the whole generation is shit mate

how did Liz have such a successful PL with song covers when her voice is about the level of a bar karaoke singer? She had millions of views on her covers too.

>>101510387
>Muh belting!
preemptively stating the reason why she is a mediocre one-trick singer doesn't make it any less true

>>101511453
You don't even know what belting actually is otherwise you wouldn't act like its a throat condition, she sings without it all the time, it's something she does on purpose to have fun during karaoke

>>101462291 (OP)
No idea why they let Raora sing she should be doing chorus or back vocals or mumbling shit like Shiori does in advent songs, I also expected way more from Cecilia she hasn't improve at all.

Who even started the belting bad meme? Several famous singers do it to sound more soulful (literally like black niggas in church)

>>101462291 (OP)
The music in holo just gets more and more boring by the year
There were like 2-3 decent songs in the entire fes this year

>>101511635
meme? it's bad if it's the only thing you ever seem to do.

I don't even think the song is that bad. I like the idea of the law and order group disobeying orders like the Hero Killer arc from MHA. But am I crazy for saying I can't hear Gigi in the chorus at all? I can pick out every voice but hers.

>>101464246
Take me home

>>101468433
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCsWgOMu4_8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtgME6MJpk4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysV01Wj-wHM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ci_zad39Uhw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0jE3O_3deI

>>101470050
Rebellion < Sirens < Rebellion (Ludokano mix)

I like above below better, but this wasn't terrible. I do think the mixing could have been worked on a bit nore.

>>101462291 (OP)
>Do something innovative and recruit a gen based on entertainment ability first and idol abilities second
>Huge success, everyone loves them
>Force them to make music anyway
>It's bad
>