Thread 102444386

Its amazing how one talent can destroy everyone else at singing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGDznl7PAFI

>>102444386 (OP)
Yeah, Mint is an incredible singer.

>>102444411
Why are you lying? She shouldn't be reading this

>>102444386 (OP)
erb really slaped her cock on the table for this one

>>102444386 (OP)
No

>>102444386 (OP)
sucking homo cocks for those singing lessons really paid off for erb.

>>102446132
Careful anon, we can see your jealousy from space.

Honestly what does ERB do besides weird twitch rpg streams? Gotta be a nepohire or some shit idfk

>>102445185
Uh yeah actually

>>102444386 (OP)
IRyS is better at singing than ERB

>>102444386 (OP)
Beware incoming niji melty

>>102444411
fpbp

>>102444386 (OP)
Stop comparing her with holoroasties

>>102444386 (OP)
>>102435896
Why did this need a second thread?

>>102452557
People love pretending mint is good at singing

>>102444386 (OP)
ERB should graduate and do covers with Mint full time

we're still pretending erb has a good voice

>>102454987
Better than Mint

>>102444411
yeah she's pretty good, I loved her jazz karaoke

>>102444386 (OP)
ERB isn't even close

People still can't bear to accept ERB can sing, tragic.

>>102444386 (OP)
Going absoutely crazy like this in a casal duet is pretty rude, honestly. It's not like it's done on accident either. It's like getting invited to throw a baseball with your cousin and throwing it at 100mph and breaking their wrist because you're a professional and had to show off.

>>102456478
Mint was happy to get mogged thoughever.

I don't see the point of this thread. Mint is an objectively way better singer than erb but the bar is buried underground

>>102444386 (OP)
meh

erb does too much honestly

oversinging is not a talent

this thread again? erb is fucking obnoxious

>>102444386 (OP)
Too bad she sounds like a wine aunt.

>>102458015
Enough about mint

>>102461276
Mint doesn't ruin any song she touches by growling and belting

>>102446757
She's an extremely accomplished singer and I think VA?
Pretty sure one of her songs is the most viewed song of any holomem past or present, even more than IRyS, (whose cover of Renai Circulation is so fucking big that it completely dwarfs Suisei's bibbidiba)

>>102456602
No? Mint is okay but nothing special.

I don't care for ERB but the people who try to argue she can't sing are actual fags

schizos need to get their brain and ears checked. Mint and ERB are great singers. It you heard them sing at a karaoke bar they'd literally get cheers and drinks bought for them all night by strangers

>>102464955
That goes for most even half-decent singers, including the people this board shits on for being "generic" singers
As long as you're passable and not awful people at a bar will like you

>>102464100
It's always failed music grads who never made it that also make the exact same criticism.
>MUH BELT

>>102461355
This one?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AibtyCAhyQE&ab_channel=TheLivingTombstone

>>102466161
So why should the standard be any different for a chuuba?
If they wanted to be a proper singer, they wouldn't be streaming as an anime girl. If people like it enough they can sell a cd. I'd personally never buy a vtuber album, because they're not even in the same conversation as an actual recording artist or band. But I'd never say that the ones who are decent to good at singing actually aren't because...reasons?
Some people are so fucking retarded

>>102466526
Oh I don't disagree but singer tierlists are a staple of this board for some reason and I've seen every decent singer called shit by one person or another

>>102444386 (OP)
Good cover but I prefer this one
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OURdJ4WJyek

>>102464955
I'm a game developer and I've worked with hundreds of vocal artists over the years.
ERB is quite shit, I would never hire her. She's an idiots idea of what a good vocal artist is.
There's a reason you never heard of her before hololive. Even people like Nerissa have more of a footprint than ERB has managed to make at almost 40

>>102466721
ERB's music footprint is way bigger than Nerissa's though, she was basically a e-celeb in the board that can't be named

>>102444386 (OP)
Gura/Saba = Moom > IRyS > Kronii > Nerissa > ERB = Mint > Bae > Kiara

>>102464100
yelling at you mic doesn't make you good at singing no matter how much you cope that it does. her entire gimmick is that she is loud and normalfags think that makes you the best singer ever. besides that she cant sing in japanese for shit

>>102466933
mumei is extremely mediocre and I dont understand why people think otherwise

>>102466770
that's like arguing Yuko Yurei is a big name because she had weirdo creeps on /k/

>>102467042
If that's how you hear her singing then I don't think your ears work very well if at all.

>>102466933
this is a pretty good ranking, Bae is an odd one because she actually CAN sing epic ballads really well but chooses to only sing shitty pop songs most of the time

>>102467100
No it's not like that at all

>>102467111
my ears wouldn't work if i kept listening to her dogshit singing more than once, maybe that's why retards like you think she's so good

>>102467078
listen to her before the coof? idk maybe you need ears

>>102467111
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rAQwtvYccVk
You don't think she's shouting in this? You're deaf AND retarded

>>102467078
She is pretty good but inconsistent. However that applies to most vtuber singers who haven't had proper training which is why when you have someone who is properly trained and consistent like ERB they tend to stand out.

>>102467136
kronii over ERB and rissa is hilarious, she can't sing for shit live and just spends months in post production

>>102467042
Exactly as >>102466223 predicted btw

>>102467209
why do retards always use this appeal to authority, they do the same for Clara from phase, who is also shit

Post your vocal credentials first before arguing about anyone's singing

>>102467233
What authority am I appealing to here?

>>102467230
>failed music grads
i don't need to study music to know i don't like her music retard, that's like saying you need to be a chef to know the food tastes like shit

Shakira belts and she's regarded one of the best singers.

>>102467259
You're deaf

>>102467294
i accept your concession

>belting BAD!
Meanwhile opera singers:

>>102467309
oh I was talking to actual retards.

ew it replied to me

>>102467259
you don't need to study music to like or dislike her music, that's fine

I just know that you DID study music, and you DIDN'T make it, and you're mad that ERB did.

So none of you actually have a real educated reason her singing is bad other than you just don't like her understood.

>>102467477
now you are just contradicting yourself like an idiot, the absolute state of ERB fans JFC

>>102467529
>erm you have to be a movie director to say the movie you just watched is complete shit
that's what you faggots sound like

>>102467569
Reading comprehension chama...
>>102466223

>>102467631
oh the irony of mentioning reading comprehension to me when you didn't even understand what i said, how do you even function when you're this retarded? I'm genuinely curious

>>102467611
No you can't have your cake and eat it, if you're going to try and critique her singing on a technical level then yes you should know what you're talking about.

>>102467791
faggot that's argument from authority fallacy, by your logic no one can ever say they dislike anything because they are not experts in the field of what they dislike. get the fuck outta here with your retarded logic.

>>102467611
No retard the reason people prefer you give an objective answer on why you dislike something is because arguing over taste is entirely fucking pointless.
>I like this hammer because it is red.
Cool? I guess you like red? I'm not going to sit here and argue your favorite color is wrong.
>I like this hammer because it is made of a quality alloy that is resistant to wear.
Now we can debate whether that alloy is actually better for hammers.

>>102467259
I don't have to be a chef to know a well crafted and presented meal when I see one.

>>102467934
your logic here is still fucking retarded because i can like red and also have that as a preference when i pick my high quality hammer, so as a result i will I will prefer a high quality red hammer over a non-red one. ERB simply doesn't have that red therefore i don't like what she offers.

>>102468046
>[blah blah blah] ERB [blah blah] i don't like
See now you're getting it buddy. You don't like ERB. Good for you.

>>102467611
>Her singing is bad because I simply don't like it
An acceptable criticism
>Her singing is bad because [pseud-virtuoso rambling]
See, now this is where you need to actually back up your critique with objectivity.

>>102468105
so that's the angle you use when you can't cope with the fact that people find her singing as shit huh, what a sad a delusional retard

>>102468153
Okay but why is it shit, or more pertinently how is it shit? Objective answers only.

>>102468150
I said from the very beginning that her singing is shit because i didn't like it, you're the faggot that started trying to argue from authority because you couldn't cope with that fact

>>102466504
Disgusting.

>>102468187
NTA, pal. I just wanted to point that out.

>>102468214
Read the comment chain then instead of spewing irrelevant bullshit

>>102468229
You sound mad.

>>102468247
Go back tourist

>>102468275
lol I'm a tourist now? You're the one getting your panties in a twist because of ERB.

>>102468303
>you sound mad
literal tourist posting, first day on 4chan newfag? did i hurt your feelings?

>>102468356
Buddy, you're the only one ITT getting triggered kek. You throwing out accusations of newfaggotry only serve to prove me right.

>>102467833
You can have a personal opinion no one here is denying that privilege, but if you want to argue on a technical level then yes you should have a degree of education on the topic especially when it comes to something like singing which is such a technical art.

>>102468404
So i did hurt your feelings, sorry you can't cope with me not liking your oshi's shitty ass singing newfagchama

>>102468448
Alright but next time try typing that out without staining your keyboard with tears.

>>102468432
>but if you want to argue on a technical level
>>102468187

>>102468153
You're not saying shit man. You're just a retard saying THING BAD THING BAD. For the record I've not watched more than an hour of ERB. Because she generally streams when I'm asleep. Look buddy, right there! An objective reason why I don't watch something. Wow!

>>102468540
(You) brought this up >>102467042 so clearly you were going for something more than "her singing is disagreeable to me"

>>102468589
I simply don't like her style of singing, why is that so hard to understand?

>>102468556
Give it up, man. That comment about being a failed music major gave that anon massive asshurt. He's actually genuinely upset.

>>102468627
That's not what your post is trying to convey.

>>102468523
Cute newfag, hope you won't lose too sleep from how butthurt i made you

>>102468275
>>102468356
>>102468448
Galactic level projection kek

>>102468697
thats you misinterpreting things then, i listened to her karaoke once and didn't like the way she sang it's not that complicated

Can you guys wrap it up soon, the board is going to need more space for vshojo bait threads now.

>>102468772
Pussy. At least own up to your mistakes rather than furiously backwalking like a coward bitch.

>>102468303
>>102468404
>>102468523
Where do you newfags even come from?

>>102468772
That's fine, you're more than welcome to have that opinion but that wasn't what your post was conveying.

>>102466933
lol not even close. the fact you rank nerissa above erb is a huge tell. and while gura sound good in her range, that's all she has, anything she goes outside it, which she really never does she's not good. very much like marine. and yes, erb is by far objectively speaking the best singer in EN and even hololive. Fucking retards

>Actual opinionated LARPer here
It's the whiny nasally mixed tone she uses for high notes that really tires out my ears after one song, I can't listen to her karaokes because it's just too much all the time
When she actually goes soft and opens her throat she actually sounds really good. Like in OP's example for the most part.
It's things like this that sound impressive for like 5 seconds but they get tiring very easily. Like chill out for a bit...
https://youtu.be/4S481KPPXZ4?t=263

>>102468851
Why did you samefag me thrice?

>>102468847
kek faggot now you're just mad because you can't cope with the fact i simply don't like the way she sings, if you thought otherwise you would explain why my post was a technical critique and not just my preference but you can't because you realized you read into something that wasn't there. hold that L

>>102468975
That is one long run on sentence I'm not reading, pussy. Calm down and try again. With some punctuation maybe?

>>102468895
if you don't like the way she sings then that's that, you don't need to prove to anyone why you think her singing is dogshit tier if you don't like it

>>102469138
now say that without crying and shitting yourself retardchama, sorry you found out you were a being sad presumptuous faggot all this time

>>102469226
>already copying another anon's clapbacks ITT
you're not going to make it

>>102469226
The problem here pussy is that you've already proved yourself to be a contemptible coward bitch, so any further ranting is just going to invoke further laughter. I'm honestly not even reading your posts now. I assume its just all wet vagina noises.

>>102469161
But he said her singing is good? This is literally the answer this thread has been trying to get for the last half an hour, he gave his personal opinion but still gave a solid technical thought about her singing.

>>102469328
>not even the same sentence
I accept your concession faggot

>>102444386 (OP)
erb is shit at singing and a disgusting human being
disgusting cunt
fat disgusting hag for real
and br*tish

>>102469363
I'm not reading all that faggot, you already lost and now you're just mad because you got assblasted. keep holding that L

>>102469602
Cmon bro that dude called you a talking wet vagina and you're clapping back with outdated generic zoomer terms? At least try. It's embarrassing right now.

>>102469831
Now you're samefagging kek and I thought you can't be more pathetic than you already are

>>102469960
This is getting sad to watch man, just leave it be.

>>102466504
Suisei could never

>>102466721
>She's an idiots idea of what a good vocal artist is.
She can impersonate people at the drop of a hat, anon. Her voice control is incredible and you're a liar.

>>102471309
That doesn't really invalidate the phrase you quoted, I knew a person that could do amazing impersonations and he couldn't sing to save his life