Clio is a bigger hit than any recent debut from Hololive, Nijisanji, or Vshojo

I don't watch males but good for him

good for him. it's honestly nice that phase is moving away from pippa and her dogshit fanbase

hag summer

didn’t know phase had a male. that’s really awesome.

Thats just from 1 guy who watches every stream.

>>102969977 (OP)
How the FUCK when every other tranny crashes and burns

>>102969977 (OP)
if it really is a troon its the only troon ive been able to stomach watching for more than 5 minutes so theres that

>>102969977 (OP)
thanks for sharing phasecuck

>426x before Phase
I wonder how that was achieved.

>>102969977 (OP)
please stop posting my wife thank you very much

>>102969977 (OP)
popular demand, many people are saying

>>102969977 (OP)
does he even realize how much he gets botted?

>>102970497
So if I'm reading this chart right are this chick does like 12 hour streams and your shocked viewership starts to drop off after 6 hours?

Botconnect

>>102970828
Since she got fired from her Uni job streaming is all she does for work now

Shilling this dude this way isn't going to get me to watch him

>>102969977 (OP)
Those hours would mean ~2500 ccv average and she was a mid to high 3view before phase so I don't know where it's getting that % from unless she took a long break beforehand that I missed.

>>102969977 (OP)
How is that even possible?

>>102970828
A few things
>76 people were waiting for her to start the stream
I challenge you to find another streamer anywhere on Earth where the peak of their stream is 180x the amount of people waiting for them to start the stream.
>those lines
Every single straight red and green line you see is her viewership falling off a cliff or spiking to exactly the same number and returning in seconds.

>26k ccv after 5 hours of mapgame
sus

>>102969977 (OP)
>Realize you fucked up
>Treat talents better
>Talents all love you and wish to make your company better
>Become second biggest EN vtubing company, soon to be first
It's that simple

>/#/ bots people then accuses them of botting
woooow

>>102970896
>fired from her Uni job
She fucked a student, didn't she?

Is Clio really a male?

I stopped watching because I thought she was a disgusting homosexual but if it's a babiniku I think I can watch him.

>>102970591
that's MY cute hag wife, thank you very much

>>102969977 (OP)
I find it weird that, out of all corpos, Phase would be the one corpo where a tranny would successful

>>102971273
Yeah this but unironically. They always need a talking point and if its not about a Holo, they will bot someone else. Just like they randomly botted Sara Nagare that one time. A girl that was barely hitting 100 ccv got like 43k ccv during one stream.

>>102970828
NTA, but actually, yes. Not that
> viewership starts to drop off after 6 hours
but viewership actually managed to keep inclining for 6 hours (closer to 7 in that graph). Outside of very special events, most people don't keep continuously gaining more viewers in any notable manner over 6 hours. Even continuously inclining over more than 3-4 hours in a normal gaming stream would've been extremely rare enough

>>102971313
>Is Clio really a male?
no

i miss when IP counts were a thing

>>102971470
Guess that vile homosexual stays blocked then

no one actually thinks she isn't botted constantly right?

>>102971032
That channel was up since 2023 but she only uploaded some VODs now and then (roughly once or twice a month). I assume it was her VOD channel before joining Phase. The % was probably in comparison to her pre-debut stats

>>102970253
Clio's secret is not mentioning it. 90% of them fail at this.

>>102971273
>>102971427
Interesting theory, let's explore it. Where does /#/ get the money to bot all these vtubers? Half of NijiEN and HoloEN and a handful of NijiJPs and HoloJPs also get botted. I thought you said /#/fags were all poor third worlders? It is factually impossible for them to be mass botting people, they do not have the money. This is not one person being botted, it's dozens of people every day for months now.

>>102970226
Zentraya exists.

>>102971427
>A girl that was barely hitting 100 ccv got like 43k ccv during one stream.
that's fucked up. she probably had a moment where she actually thought she was blowing up only to realize none of it was real

>>102971313
Can someone actually explain this "male" meme?

>>102971502
>no one actually thinks she isn't botted constantly right?
Most people do, actually
Realistically, casual viewers (which is probably the large majority of VTuber fanbases) don't care to look into graphs and stats and whatnot like numberfags in /#/

>>102971513
>I thought you said /#/fags were all poor third worlders?
I personally never said that and that is very wrong since they had some whales and concert goers posting there. No one that is "poor" flies across the world to see a hololive concert and spends thousands of dollars in just a few days.

>>102971660
A three day trip to Japan from the US is what, 2500?

Nigga that's nothing, especially considering the age bracket of hololive fans.

>>102971280
That'd be a lot hotter but it was just due to covid.

>>102969977 (OP)
Why is every corpo vtuber such a numbernigger?

>>102971793
>Why is a member of an entity that is specifically numbers concerning themselves with numbers?

Also name one streamer who doesnt care about numbers

>>102971793
Because their livings depend on those numbers?

>>102970042
>>102970054
>>102970080
If Clio is a male then so is Kaela, Raora, and Towa.

>>102971745
You said third worlder poorfags. Third worlders certainly cant afford that trip. Unless our definitons of what "poor" is are very very different.

Who is botting these niggas

>>102971273
>>102971427
These are the same wholesome dindus who would never harrass streamers, correct? Absolute subhuman behaviour.

Two things. Her views line up very closely with the wests sleep schedule. General theory is that her vod channel tends to algorithmically get auto plays of people who sleep get dumped there. Naturally transfered to her streams when she started streaming on what was her old vod channel. If you notice her views during day time it lines up pretty normally. They spike when people sleep. And leave when people wake up. There's also no strange bot behavior in her graphs. Very smooth and natural.

>>102971531
Pretty much she has a deep voice and people wanted to start shit. I don't ever recall even one reasonable rat on this theory. She doesn't resemble a pickme and is into all this nerdy guy shit, and likes to room alone on trips. That's it from what I can tell from the schizos who thinks she's a man. no clips Or anything

>>102972003
How much do yt bots go for anyway? It can't be too much these days.

Someone post the going rate.

>>102971502
99% of people don't even consider the possibility, they just watch streamers that they enjoy.
Myself included. I forget about the topic entirely except when I occasionally see it mentioned on /vt/.

0.6%

>>102971513
Look up Ennaschizo and you'll understand what the tip of the iceberg looks like.

>>102970054
Posts like this are particularly baffling because they're rightfully shitting on Pippa's fanbase but also doing the whole, trans panic, deathly afraid of literally everything on the planet being secretly trans, kind of thing which is ironically something that is equally common in the actual Phase fanbase.
Makes you realize it's just /pol/tards fighting /pol/tards at this point. These people will destroy each other without our help and all we have to do is wait, then swoop in to pick up the pieces. I always thought it was going to be a hard fight. I guess not.

>>102972044
>Two things. Her views line up very closely with the wests sleep schedule. General theory is that her vod channel tends to algorithmically get auto plays of people who sleep get dumped there. Naturally transfered to her streams when she started streaming on what was her old vod channel. If you notice her views during day time it lines up pretty normally. They spike when people sleep. And leave when people wake up. There's also no strange bot behavior in her graphs. Very smooth and natural.
This cope makes no sense given how shapely her graph looks, not to mention that she is hardly the only EN VTuber stream at those hours and others don't experience the same thing (unless they got botted)

>>102972044
>General theory is that her vod channel tends to algorithmically get auto plays of people who sleep get dumped there.
This has happened to me. About six months ago I accidentally enabled autoplay, probably while fumbling through the UI to change quality on mobile. I woke up to a four hour history lecture from her, and it's all I had seen of her until she joined Phase.

>>102972186
Why isn't her stream right now being botted then? She's at her pretty normal 2-3k CCV range right now. It makes sense auto play dumps a regular number of people into a long form video as the night gets later and later. Humans follow a natural curve like that.

>>102971861
Not gonna watch your tranny beggarkek

>>102971861
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/qbqe8_51vUw
listen to those voice cracks and try again. Kaela, Raora, and Towa are capable of singing as well as talking louder than normal speaking volume, something Clio clearly can't handle

>it's bots! it's bots!
more pebble projection as always

>>102972226
Her viral lectures were probably thr trigger of this behavior of the algorithm

>>102972292
She can very well being botted right now. It just hasn't gone on long enough to make it looks more obvious.
>She's at her pretty normal 2-3k CCV range right now
Who said that's her "pretty normal" range, though? Being botted doesn't mean getting 10K+ CCV. Many NijiEN members get 2-4K with bots, too

>>102972317
idk I don't see sleepy and mari getting along with a troon

Can't remember last time pippa and clio interacted thoughbeit

>>102969977 (OP)
She's just fun to listen to, prime second monitor material. I always out her on when im programming

>>102969977 (OP)
Nice botting Phasekeks
be sure not to make the same mistake as Gunrun with that dwindling amount of funds you have

>>102972292
>Humans follow a natural curve like that.
Humans "don't follow a natural curve like that". Most people turn their PCs off when they go to bed, that's why you see most streamers - big or small - losing viewers as the night (in their timezonew) goes on
Again, if it's some sort of YT algorithm that pushed her more viewers, we'd have seen much more similar cases. Doesn't help that her graph's shape looks exactly like Biboo's when the latter was botted either

how was she doing before phase?

>>102972606
600-800 CCV on twitch. 0 YouTube presence besides vods and some viral lectures

>>102972338

>>102972606
By her own words, 800CCV on Twitch

>>102972729
that's not what a botted stream looks like

>>102972927
>Wave bots
It's not 2024 with Ennacuck behind the botting any longer

>>102972927
I think you don't understand bots.

>>102972984
>1.8k to 19k
kek

>>102969977 (OP)
>12 hour stream
>6.3k peak ccv
>only 778 people seen in chat over the course of 12 hours
lmao

>>102973236
I usually tab out for most of her streams, and have her on as background noise

>>102971861
why Kaela?

>>102973236
>Sending chat messages in a vtuber stream
faggot

>>102969977 (OP)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8eyjHtqgkw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8eyjHtqgkw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8eyjHtqgkw

>>102973236
she's a great second monitor streamer, very chill

>>102972292
Explain this graph then

>>102973663
What's there to explain? There isn't enough to tell if it was botted so I'd assume that it wasn't botted (although the initial incline does look somewhat suspicious), and that stream was raided twice which bumped its peak up by several hundreds

>>102972729
So this phase girl got hit form the same bot that did holo & niji? correct?

>>102969977 (OP)
Nobody cares about this male

>>102969977 (OP)
she was deleting comments and lecturing people about numbers talk, why is she now signal boosting numbers talk

>>102971531
She has a slightly deeper/raspier voice than the average pick-me vtuber.

The sad part is that clio's real numbers are likely perfectly fine. She used to be a mid-high 3view who could be 4view with the right raids, and I don't doubt she's probably around the 3/4view mark, if not a consistent 4view.

Whoever has been botting her is a piece of shit.

>>102974413
Some people are literally just saying "She can't be a woman because she plays good games"
That's their "evidence". Hilarious

>>102971531
She has a low, raspy voice
That's literally it

>>102974509
I think she's a solid 2k now-a-days that'll decline a little in the upcoming months. She got a boost off of a bunch of viral clips but wasn't able to keep generating them.

>>102971509
even if clio was secretly a guy behind the scenes i wouldn't care
when i found out a vtuber i really like watching was secretly a guy (but never mentioned it) i didn't really care and i still watch her

>>102973663
that's called getting a raid

That's wild to me. Her friend Miia just hit 1m hours today after streaming as a 3-view for years.
Kind of mogged her unintentionally(?) kek.

>>102974940
Yeah I'm a big fan of Lily Hopkins as well.

>>102969977 (OP)
How does this number compare to the public "stat"?

>>102970828
>this chick does like 12 hour streams and your shocked viewership starts to drop off after 6 hours?
What's shocking is the EIGHT (8) hours of viewership incline (without a raid), and her losing more than half viewership in about 5 hours, that's typical a sign of getting botted
Normally what happens to most streaming is they incline rather rapidly within their first 2-3 hours, plateau, and then slowly bleed out until they start to stabilize again

Can someone give me a rundown on Clio? She seems really cool

>>102975927
Irish hag living in Australia, plays autism map games, streams for long hours

>>102973410
She was sleeping with Kronii

>>102975927
irish-australian
mid-late 30s
former history professor, loves strategy and map painting games
wanted to be a wrestler when she was a teenager but got injured
voice got fucked by roiding up in her late teens
bi
is terrible at reading romantic hints (ask her about the mirror story)
usually streams for nearly 12 hours, used to stream longer when she was indie but phase wants her to multistream on youtube which fucks up vods that are longer than 11 hours 55 minutes

Is he still openly horny about gimp suits?

>>102972292
>Why isn't her stream right now being botted then?
It's botted

>>102975956
>>102976027
If she's Irish how come she doesn't have an Irish accent at all? In fact she doesn't sound Australian either, she sounds kind of British?

>>102976027
Why do I keep falling for bi women? It’s consistent. Love an intelligent woman though that’s sexy

>>102976607
she lived in England for a long time too

Clio gf is mandatory, the star will be refired

>Anyone holodrones dislike are troons

>>102976027
>irish
>~30
>bi
>wanted a career in academia
If I had a nickel for every time I fell for a chuuba like above I’d have 2 nickels which isn’t a lot but it’s weird it happened twice

>>102972292
> Why isn't her stream right now being botted then?
It's botted on youtube. On twitch she is barely a 4view

>>102976910
NTA but I don’t use twitch and a lot of other people are in the same boat

>>102969977 (OP)
Do fags really like that obvious tranny?

>>102974964
Yeah, you can tell by the spikes in chat.

>>102971085
^

>>102976910
Twitch is a dead platform that requires botting to begin with. It's more likely the youtube views are organic, because humans actually use youtube.

>>102977360
SEA cannot watch Twitch, though, so Twitch is the superior platform by default (also the reason why SEAfags in /#/ keep seething at Twitch)

>>102977396
is there a worse general than /#/

>>102969977 (OP)
happy for you anon, but i could never watch a troon

>>102972317
>open video
>obnoxious cussing for no reason
Thanks for helping me filter this trash vtuber out.

>>102977138
It's me. I'm the guy named Spike in chat

>>102972317
Watching this old ass clip makes me realize even Clio used to put on the cutesy vtuber voice that everybody seems to do, her voice now sounds much different from this.

>>102971273
Incroyable

>>102969977 (OP)
She streams like 12 hours everyday

>>102971085
You think I'm WAITING to see her spend an hour yapping before loading into a map painting game? I'm elbow deep in a machine letting this shortstack aussie run her mouth about unimportant things while I work.

The only people who don't understand Clio's success are the unemployed. Unironically no cap frfr deadass homie.

>>102979158
What kind of job lets you be elbow deep in a machine but also listen to streams?

>>102979572
90% of mechanical jobs. Unless I need my ears, all we do is listen to podcasts and music and streams.

>>102969977 (OP)
There's a reason she's popular among Phasecucks.

https://www.youtube.com/live/ElF1IxjmZMQ?si=2tJdLBCj0C4lNycl spiff is trying to break things right now. Testing retention and stuff right now.

But yeh here's his testing on sleep content https://youtu.be/8iOjeb5DTZI?si=s83dPMvfKOhFfQDa the theory is sound. It just doesn't make sense to spend that much on botting.

>>102973236
>>102976371
It's been 5 hrs. We are in the sleep cycle auto play growth has basically gone into effect now. Low chat speed lines up. It's 5am on the east coast.

>>102979827
Honestly sleep redirects also track with what has been happening to my indie oshis streams. She usually gets 100-200 ccv but on some specific game streams like Fallout her numbers shoot up to like 800-1000 ccv with no noticeable increase in viewer interaction. She thought this was weird so she looked into her analytics and for those streams with the ccv spikes like 80% of viewers came from autoplay compared to like 20-30% of viewers coming from autoplays for the streams with normal numbers.
Adding to that she has also getting pretty regularly some random faggots in chat going "what the fuck is this, why did youtube send me here?"

>>102969977 (OP)
Botconnect

>>102979998
I have no idea how there are so many people that don't bother turning autoplay off, but then again whenever my mother watches Instagram or Facebook shorts or whatever, I notice she always watches the video loop a few times before going to the next one, so maybe most people just don't interact with any buttons on any websites at all so if the option is on by default, things like this happen.

>>102969977 (OP)
>2M watch hours in under 90 days
I didn't know we have this kind of stats from Hololive and Nijisanji to compare them.
Fucking numberfags are always so fucking bad with numbers, jesus

The numberfags fear the Clio

>>102980102
Just believe in the BIG numbers, anon
2 MILLION IS BIG

>>102969977 (OP)
clio + zen collab soon?

>>102971531
sounds like your usual tranny, there is something unnatural about the voice
doesn't necessarily mean she's a tranny but this is the internet
at the end of the day, it shouldn't matter if you enjoy the content

>>102969977 (OP)
>the literal bot tranny

>>102973236
they are all watching from their smart fridgers and smart toasters

>>102969977 (OP)
Clio is literally just male. An "extremely ugly" male, in his personal words.

https://files.catbox.moe/3nihtf.mp4
https://files.catbox.moe/9jcvux.mp4
https://files.catbox.moe/fkj6fz.mp4

>>102969977 (OP)
Does liking Clio not make you gay? Is he the most popular male vtuber?

>>102971861
People like you clung to the idea that Fartemis wasn't a troon in defiance of blatant evidence.

>>102981084
Yep, clearly a tranny.

>>102981084
Fuck, the last one sounds exactly like how a troon might sound

So either she spent all the streamer dosh on the best voice trainer known to man or her 'girl' voice sounds like a troon. I am going for the latter.

Sakana said no males so Clio isn't a troon.

>>102981647
Did he also say that transwomen are not real women?

>>102971085
>Every single straight red and green line you see is her viewership falling off a cliff or spiking to exactly the same number and returning in seconds.
the most retarded comment i've read here, that would mean she's buying bots to decrease her viewership, it's just a visual bug in the site

>>102981768
He wouldn't need to with most of the other comments he's made on "culture."

>>102981768
>>102981988
Idk what he's said on cultural stuff but he's a middle aged, married Chinese man so he can't be very "woke".

>>102971273
Not even from /#/ but yes she is definitely botted. You can tell because all her streams have this bizarre pyramid shape that no other streamer has. Her numbers are not even that bad, she was get 1-3k before the botting started + another 1k from Twitch. But it's kind of odd for her to be bragging about her Youtube hours when she either knows or should know that every stream is now botted.

>>102981084
>Clio is literally just male
Who cares? PC is a company with no standards and full of whores and e-thots anyway. I'd rather watch a male than a whore

>>102977526
God isn't real

Her model is good but her voice is a turn off.

>>102982242
she also has a rule against numberfagging and even explicitly said that she doesn't want chat to point out the viewership number

>>102979998
>Adding to that she has also getting pretty regularly some random faggots in chat going "what the fuck is this, why did youtube send me here?"
Clio gets those too, almost every stream.

>>102972317
That isn't her normal voice, and regardless, it's too high pitched for most trannies to do.

>>102971085

She streams daytime Aussie hours. Most people probably put her on and go to sleep, then turn her off when they get up for work.

>>102982242
>all her streams have this bizarre pyramid shape that no other streamer has
Do you think she is the SINGLE botted streamer in existence in the world?

>>102972182
I literally have no program with trans people. I grew up wanting to fuck linetrap and think it's great that a medium sized corpo has a trans talent.

>>102969977 (OP)
Who could have predicted that streaming 8 hours every day would pay off?

>>102971861
None of those sound like men, so no.

>>102972182
>t.samefagging tranny

>>102984814
It'd be cool to be able to see where her audience is tuning in from, I catch a lot of her streams in the morning here in the EU purely because there's nobody else on

>>102984931
No? But none of the other botters do it like this. Whoever bots her literally just styles on her and produces comically nonsensical pyramid charts. Ennacuck's bots made a sine wave, King Engine almost looks real but produces impossibly consistent rises across the whole stream, Clio's bots make a pyramid.

>>102985655
so it doesnt look like other botted streams, got it

>>102969977 (OP)
I have no context for these numbers but good for her I guess. Or him if the tranny accusations are real but they seem like bullshit to me, trannies don't have the self-control to not reveal themselves.

>>102982242
it looks like that because she streams for 12 hours

>>102981534
>fool me? impossible, this could only be done by the best voice coach known to man

>>102981084
Yucky

>>102969977 (OP)
botted tranny

>>102981084
phasebros...

https://x.com/ClioAite/status/1951302457432080850
MUH CANCER MUH REAL CANCER!!

>stream for 10+ hours several days a week
>have insanely high watch hours
literally that simple

>>102984931
>>102985701
Where the fuck are you newfags from? Her botted graphs look exactly the same as niji, the main difference is she streamed for 12 hours so she fully bleeds out the bots

can someone post the woman cosplaying her on that weird "red carpet" like thing.

I can't imagine what kind of stress this streamer must be under to see clearly fabricated viewership, see a chat that is completely dead (1 whole chat message per minute when there's supposedly 8000 viewers watching) and then just truck along as if there's nothing wrong.

>>102989813
That whole group of australians (clioaite, makofukasame, jeanfaymas) got denied partner multiple times on twitch for viewbotting

>>102989813
>look mom, i drew a tsunami!

>>102972182
>fight

>>102989813
Considering the tweet she made in the OP, she probably thinks it's all real

Let me lean out of a window here, I don't care for phase, I hate the dregs Pippa brought here, I don't want to watch Clio and I think she (yes she) sounds indeed a bit like a tranny BUT you know what? She streams all the autism games none of the other girls have the patience for aside from maybe Kaela but even then it's not the same kind and she is indo.
What I'm using way to many words for is, she has a good niche, I'll give it to her.

>>102969977 (OP)
>recent debut from Hololive
There are no recent debuts from Hololive...

>>102990072
I think it's more that the streamer is attempting to "fake it until you make it". In other words, by propping up fake numbers the streamer is attempting to boast about fake numbers in an effort to attract real people to want to watch.

>>102989813
What is even the purpose of obvious bots like this?
Do you throw them at the streamer for a month, and then blackmail them? Threaten to report them for the situation you made unless they pay you?

>>102990761
It's probably a phasechud that hates troons.

>>102981084
>"SHE JUST HAS A DEEPER VOICE THAN NORMAL VTUBERS"

>>102971313
Apparently a woman having a non-high pitch voice makes them a tranny, but Mori and Marine are excluded from that

>>102981084
>>102981255
>>102990897
>>102981534
How do people interact with so many with trans people that they can reliably know what an average one would sound like? Not calling bullshit, I'm just surprised that so many people on /vt/ have so much experience with this. I've met three or four across my entire life, and spent maybe six hours speaking to them, in total, across all three or four.
Is it a zoomer thing? Something like 15% of kids are trans now, but because I'm old, none of my peers were trans and I don't have the experience?

>>102991286
because they have been propped up and shoved down throats for the last 5 years in all media?

>>102991317
Oh. I've not owned a TV since I moved out of my parents' house at 19, and I'm 35 now, so maybe skipping the last 15 years of "media" explains my experience gap.

>>102991286
Literally any person on the street could listen to those clips in >>102981084 and say "yep, that's a gay man". You're the naive one whose autism makes you unable to detect obvious frauds.

>>102991286
>How do people interact with so many with men that they can reliably know what an average one would sound like?
fixed it for ya

Clio is botted, who is botting Clio? NijiEN.

>But why tho
Because, on the early days of the viewfarm, the line just went up permanently and created such a bloated graph that everyone would have caught noticed sooner or later, so now the viewfarm grows after a certain point of time, then it goes down and the spillage sticks to other streams, it can be Holo (Bijou and Mori), it can be Phase (Clio and Eepy Sleepy), it can be Indies (Doki, Mint, Peo, Lillith O'Leerie) depending on the time the Niji streamer ends.

>Is it really Niji?
Well, Niji is the only one bragging on interviews about their supposed recovery in the EN scene, so, yeah.

Niji goes down, Clio goes up. Clio gets it the worst because all Nijis end around him/her/it, benefits of a 12 hour stream.

>>102992325
>View farm
HoloEN was botted years before NijiEN was
>But they bragged
Hololive has been bragging about it's view count in every report
>All Nijis end around Clio
Literally made up

>>102969977 (OP)
who?

Sounds like paid chink views.

>>102993041
you lost sister

>>102993041
A) The Ennacuck waves are not the Engine of today

B) Even then, Luxiem was botted a full year before the first reported case (Mumei in March 2023)

C) Look at the graph nigga have some decency

>>102993185
Isn't it likely the botters are the same person/people, just more advanced and on a much bigger scale? The same channels "ennacuck" targeted are also targeted by the King Engine, but also other people as well. Whoever's doing it just upgraded their tech.

>>102972317
She actually sounds more feminine here outside of the voice crack. Whatever she was on, she needs get back on it.

>>102993185
>Luxiem was botted
there's no credible proof of that though, certainly nothing near the level of the current industry-wide botting
there was a notable case of holobronies from /#/ botting millie around that time, clearly demonstrating that they were both capable and willing to use bots (you can easily find this in the archive)

Playboard superchats for Clio: $2500/mo
Average holoen gets 4x that

Divide average holoen ccv by 4 to get Clio's real ccv

>>102993704
So like 1-1.5k (plus another 1.5k Twitch)? Sounds about right.

>>102992130
Thank you for restating my post while adding nothing.
Suddenly, I am enlightened.

>>102993704
>$2500/mo
I'm surprised map game autists even pay that much kek

>>102993327
You said it yourself, this is much more advanced and onto a much bigger scale, a scale that no singular person could cover.

>ALL of NijiEN
>Half of NijiJP
>Day after day since at least October 2024

Plus, Ennacuck's intention was always to fuck over Fauna and IRyS, and the King Engine instead has botted Nimi and IRyS.

>>102994261
Let's assume ennacuck is really behind the bots and not simply someone who latched onto it for his own purposes (never proven though I admit lines up with his previous intentions). It's entirely possible at some point the botting simply became an end in itself, he got bored with targeting specific people he had a grudge against and just decided to all out and ruin the horserace at a large scale. He may not even have fixed intentions beyond that at this point. I haven't seen one of his wave patterns in a long, long time, so if it's not him he seems happy enough with what it's doing to not bother botting himself anymore.

As for whether one person can do it, well, there's LLMs and they get better by the day, it's possibly entirely automated at this point. He may have gotten more people on board as well.

>>102991286
You never heard a man trying to imitate a girl? No matter how much they try, you can tell something sounds wrong.
Now I'm not 100% sure if Clio is a man or not, but that's the thing, I'm not 100% sure, there's suspicion.
I can listen to Towa and Kronii (examples that phasefags try to deflect to) and I can tell that they are women with deeper voices, there's no doubt there.

>>102994841
I know this isn't true because I know for a fact a certain vtuber is a troon and no one ever calls >her on it.

>>102994920
Who?

>>102994841
she's mentioned a few times that her voice is due to abusing steroids when she was younger, around the time she wanted to become a wrestler

>>102969977 (OP)
>Meme levels of life experience
>Legitimately intelligent for a woman
>High tier yapper
>Consistent, ultra long streams
>Niche games, but occasionally plays normal stuff too
>Tastefully sexy model
>Knows what viewers want
I'm not surprised. The main thing holding her back was Twitch.

>>102994961

>>102994942
Well it ruins it if I tell you, now doesn't it?

>>102995056
Is it someone famous in the vtubing world?

>>102995019
i have a grandma who has a similar deep and gravelly voice to clio, though she was a smoker

>>102981084
fucking lol'd at the "just trying out my vocal training guys" voice

>>102995019
You just have to take her word for it on that front

>>102995089
it's not deep and gravelly at all though. it's nasally and sounds like a man who went through the usually tranny vocal fry voice training.
for the record i don't even think clio is a tranny but i don't get anons who can't admit her voice sounds extremely similar to the typical tranny

>>102995069
3view ligger

>>102995203
I can do that, It's not like I want her to be a male or trans or whatever, it doesn't affect me in the slightest. Just giving my impression from listening to some clips.

>>102995210
>for the record i don't even think clio is a tranny
Very naive, his streaming buddy makofukasame is a 100% confirmer tranner

>>102981084
Are these edited? I don't remember her sounding like that.
I'm watching a few old clips and she doesn't sound like that. She sounds about the same as she does now.

>>102995302
mako passes well enough that i can watch and enjoy her without even thinking about her being a tranny behind the scenes

>>102995302
i feel like if there was actual hard evidence someone would've found it already and spammed it all over /pcg/ and the catalog back when clio joined phase.

>>102995347
Those are just old clips from the clio twitch page. You might be in denial

>>102969977 (OP)
>Bot Connect
Oh no no no no

>>102971313
a troon and a transbian at that
yipee what a creature

>>102995377
I'm watching a few old clips on Twitch.
There are clips from early on where she sounds similar to now.
Then there seems to be a period where she sounds bad.
Then it goes back to normal and she has sounded about the same from then to now.
I'm going to go ahead and file it as a bad mic. You don't go from female, to troon and back to female.

>>102971861
>Towa
hey, newfag.

Sometimes I have to remember where I am

>>102995347
Do you really think antis on /vt/ would lie to you?

>>102995347
>>102995897
Here's a lecture VOD from December 2022:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIYcUfuwxmE
Here's a lecture VOD from March 2024:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2j71kgWSyR8
To me it sounds like a mixture of two factors: (1) She had a shitty mic in her first year, and (2) she was trying to fit the "I'm a cute streamer pls gibe mone" image the way JP chuubas do by using a higher-pitched character voice.

>>102972317
Literally sounds more like a woman than whatever he's doing now did he just give up?

We like older women.

>>102996636
I haven't really interacted with troons that much, but I've grown up around women who had low, raspy voices. To my ear, she just sounds like a scouser without the accent, if that makes sense.

>>102998918
She sounds like my aunt who smoked into her early 50's.

>>102969977 (OP)
clio probably has a bigger penis than the rest of them too.

>>102998918
What is a scouser?
>>102999198
If rumors are to be believed, she has a very large clit

…captcha GAYYH lol

Male vtubers dominating

>>102971280
If you don't have tenure it's hard to keep your job as an assistant junior professor. It's a little funny/sad to think about Clio-tan, 32, in 2020 having recently finished her phd and working her first lecturing job only to get laid off for being an entry level professor. Begs the question why the fuck you'd get a phd if your job security is just as SHIT as any other mcdonald's job.

>>102999876
Beacuse there's a chance your work could become famous/change the world/whatever. The people who decoded linear b/mycenaean greek, Ventris and Chadwick, are mentioned in every Greek history textbook and are practically worshiped by classicists. People like Newton and Einstein are among the most famous to ever live.

>>102971531
it's the games she plays that seem suspicious to people. have you ever seen a female gamer into history that plays civ, total war and europa universalis? im sure they exist but they're very rare.
she was a history teacher so maybe that's why she is an oddity

>>103001271
>have you ever seen a female gamer into history that plays civ, total war and europa universalis?
Honest answer is "yes", but only exactly one, and she also likes really crunchy TTRPGs. She works doing something with engineering design (?) for an oil company. Seems like she makes good money, but lives with her mom to take care of her and otherwise has the emotional intelligence of a toaster oven.
She is legitimately fun to hang out with when she isn't busy, but after many years my sense is that trying to date her would be a complete waste of time and money. Seems like she's completely asexual.

>>102969977 (OP)
Nobody watches male vtubers, fuck off

>>102969977 (OP)
congrats

>>102981084
How do phasetroons gaslight themselves into thinking this a girl? It’s clearly a man

>>103001271
You’re clearly deaf, Clio is a man on hormone blockers

Sakana said no males
ergo sum Clio can't be a tranny
Unless she's a FtM? Fuck.

>>102999705
>What is a scouser?
A person from Liverpool

>>103005500
Oh ok, thanks

>>103005302
Clio had bottom surgery, so he’s a she now, technically not a male anymore, phasebros keep winning

>>102972408
clio literally gave pippa a whole history lesson

>>102969977 (OP)
You could call her a sleeper hit.

>>103006097
No, they already have a Sleepy hit

niggas keep talking shit about Clio while hagstorians keep eating the bait up ahahahah /vt/ people are so weak-minded

>>102970828
They're consistently shocked that an ultra long stream has a smoother curve than a shorter one

>>102971861
Kaela no but Towa yeah I believe it.

>>102985585
The thing is no one else is doing the marathon streams besides Ironlung and the new JP that is in the top 10 recently. People have been saying long streams are bad for your algorithm but if you do it consistently at a decent quality then I don't see how it can be bad. Those games are also slow burners.

EVERY CHUUBA OUT THERE is sleeping on Stellaris streams. You could probably work the algo for a month of 12 hour sessions and hit the peak just by absorbing that autismo audience who would channel in an put you on the background but it needs to be yapping and it needs to be a decent slow burn game.

>>103006434
Why do you simp for a troon?

why are they botting this random tranny

>>103008061
>EVERY CHUUBA OUT THERE is sleeping on Stellaris streams
If a cute girl started doing that... I can't decide if I would get more work done than ever with her on a side monitor, or lose my job because I would play Stellaris instead while watching her on a side monitor.
Either way, I'm here for it.

>>103008453
Wait. You would play Stellaris while watching a Stellaris stream?
Just what kind of game is Stellaris?

>>102969977 (OP)
This is not only a win for Clio but for all trans community.

>>103008164
They do it to confuse you.
Yes, you. Specifically you.

>>103009252
It's like EU but in space, and better.
Or like SoSE, but better (fight me, nerds).

>>103008164
who is "they"?

>>102969977 (OP)
>0.6 was yet another holo lie after all
color me shocked

>>102969977 (OP)
holy numberfagging

>>102971861
>Kaela, Raora, and Towa.
They were doxxed and proven to be biologically female ages ago. You are retarded and championing a male tranny just because the model is nice looking.

>>102999828
Male chuubas just do it better.

>>103010115
Generic space map game can never beat historical map painting

damn, looking at the stream ccv graphs it would've been so cool if she streamed 15 hours instead of 12 hours..it would've went full circle and she can end the stream with 1 viewer like it started.

>>102972984
Okay im first person to drown any nijinigger is spot but those are raids.

>>102971520
Yea that was my first thought, that's not funny it's just fucked up, I feel bad for her

>>102969977 (OP)
I am unironically curious how the most tranny sounding member of Phase Connect is this popular. Do PC fans are all trannies too or what

>>103005500
Not telling him it's a "Liverpuddlian" to confuse him further

>>102982009
He's literally Canadian, they love that shit. He's probably also trying to rehabilitate the Phase reputation a bit because Pippa and her orbiters have created a reputation for being too based which has limited their advertising, promotion and networking opportunities. It'll be harder for OffKai staff to go rogue and take down their stream if they hire the most obvious tranny in the fucking world for their new Invaders.

>>103019750
>Do PC fans are all trannies too
They don't think it be like it is but it do.

>>102969977 (OP)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBZcesYPbkQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBZcesYPbkQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBZcesYPbkQ

>>103008123
I have yet to see anything to actually support this claim other than people being mad over a history nerd being popular

>>103019750
Map game fun, me watch
simple as

>>102969977 (OP)
>Clio is a bigger hit
more like a bigger clit

>>102975439
>without a raid
Anon Clio's best hours are always when she's doing streams and getting raided by everyone, you also start seeing autoplay watchers show up in her chat during early EU hours and they start dipping out between 10am to 12 which is when most will go to eat and when kids that watch paradox slop all night will wake up
Also you'd have to explain why she only bots that particular timeslot and only on youtube which she doesn't care about and spends her time saying you have to go on her twitch,
Now for the logical explanation : paradox fans watch 12 hours long longplays of mapslop and let autoplay on waking up later and screaming about it in her chat everyday and her high watch time makes youtube syphon a ton of sleepy people to her streams because youtube always had a watch time and retention bias

The seethe about Clio being a man is just like when anons died on the hill saying that shark chuuba was a woman.

>>102981084
Anon there's literally a handcam where you clearly see it's a woman

>>102990072
>she

>>103022706
It was funny going in the archives and seeing you screaming about her clit years ago, no idea where that one started

>>102969977 (OP)
how big

>>103019750
Older European ladies don't always have the most youthful voice, same as old Asian ladies

>>102971085
ZIGYB is much worse, 2.5k shitter without the bots

>>103025775
Yet no other vtuber 'hag' has a voice like clio and faces the same accusations, very curious.

>>102972317
This sounds like a voice changer wth

>>102972408
you don't see liberal grifter and liberal grifter getting along with trannies? huh?

>>102972408
Most of those "based and redpilled" vtubers don't actually care about that sort of stuff as much as you think they do. Even if they personally do not approve of trannies their dislike of them is not intense enough that they won't be friends with one if they get along at a personal level. In fact, that's how most people who aren't completely brainrotted by online politics behave IRL.

>>102969977 (OP)
Stop making threads to toot your own horn dude, you're a loser.

>>102991231
You're a retard. It has very little to do with pitch.