Thread 103318619

Final HoloEN 3D showcase ranking (as of 2025)

>>103318619 (OP)
Nah

>>103318619 (OP)
What makes Ame's so bad, she had a flying Bubba, she did a gunfight, she had Mel and Haachama, she did a game with Zeta Mumei and Anya to guess what pose she was doing (one of them was the Kiara kick).
I frankly remember everything so well

>>103318619 (OP)
>putting raora on S
>putting fauna on D
bait thread

>>103318619 (OP)
Gura's was one of the worst in Hololive history

>>103318619 (OP)
What did Irys do to make you think it was worthy of being "S" tier?

>>103318869
IRyS is the best, but OP is still a schizo faggot

>>103318761
Shut up. This is my ragebait thread.

>>103318619 (OP)
>putting fauna and ame in D

Literally ZERO taste

>>103318619 (OP)
It's not fair to put FWMC in S. They have two talents to work with so they can do stuff a solo talent can't really do.

>>103318619 (OP)
Gigi is who Ame wishes she was.

>>103318619 (OP)
all of them in F tier

>>103318619 (OP)
Gura should be in her own F tier, it was like 99% Kanauru slop. The only memorable thing about it was the math skit.

>>103318619 (OP)
>>103318776
Gura's Ai LIKE Hamburger was the only performance that displayed the heart and spirit of idoldom
Gura's Nippon Egao Hyakkei was the only passable performance that demonstrated otaku culture
Most of the rest is zoomer/pseud trash.

Don't bring your crap opinions into it.

>>103318619 (OP)
Gonna be honest out of all the HoloEN 3Ds, I can remember maybe 3? Most of them were generic and cringe with everything being far, far too exaggerated and forced. It seems to be a trend for 3D debuts in general.
The only 3Ds from any group I've ever actually laughed or was sucked into for the whole stream was probably Bettel's for the old youtube humor, and maybe Shiori's for being a quiet, interesting story.
The rest I just got bored like half an hour in and tab out. Admittedly I haven't seen Raora or Gigi's though so I'll probably check them later.

>>103320464
Hololive won
Saba lost

>>103318619 (OP)
recency bias is showing but actually not a bad list

>>103320813
how are you going to say 3d debuts are cringe and then praise shiori and bettel

>>103320813
I remember the wrestling, Kiara cleaning up a KFP killing chickens and making burgers, Bae playing a boardgame in a theme park with some JP's, and Biboo fighting Kaela and losing. Not counting anything in Justice because it's too new. I give zero shits about their song choices outside of them doing a new orisong inside the actual 3d debut.
If your skits aren't interesting or complicated, I won't ever remember them, nor will I care about your 3d.

>>103320813
The song and dance segment with the wizard in Gigi's was peak you don't really need to watch the rest if you don't like cringe.

>>103318619 (OP)
The only 3D debut I'll probably remember by the next year is FWMC's, Gigi's and maaaaybe IRyS's. So I guess this tracks?

>>103320850
lmao won what? holodrones can't even stop tearing each other apart, I'm talking about the Liz drama

>>103321087
if you like liz youre a fake hololive fan in the first place. every single one of them cant stop talking about how much they hate hololive

>>103321087
Real idols arent quitters

>>103321431
She didn't quit and is planning to release her original songs (along with her new outfit) soon. Prepare to take the L again holodrone.

>>103318619 (OP)
>Raora
>S
should be at the BOTTOM. down there with Gura.

>>103321817
She quit 3 years prior to official announcement. Everyone and their grandma was expecting her graduation. Only retards trying to argue it was a complete surprise

>>103318619 (OP)
CC was exCCelent, GG was great, Raora was good. Didn’t watch ERB.

>>103321431
A real idol puts fans first, and does everything for the sake of making their fans smile in reciprocation for their support.
If she quit for her fans sake, and Saba fans have faith & believe in that then she did good by idols.
It's all about faith.
You can betray the whole world as long as you stay true to your fans.

>>103320813
>old youtube humor
Definitely watch Gigi's 3D then. it reminded me a lot of classic Adult Swim / Tim and Eric. Especially the bits with oji-chan and the children's choir.

>>103318619 (OP)
Only thing good about Raora’s was Korone and Kronii’s fat milkers

>>103322121
>>103321024
That actually sounds perfect. I really should be watching Gigi more.

Was Kronii's the one where she played different versions of herself? That was S-tier. Only other opinion I really have is Gigi's was the best.

>>103318619 (OP)
Best list out there

>>103320813
Don't use my Oshi to suck your talentless homo's dick
In any case, he's going to graduate (with the blue) after their 3D live

>>103325168
Two more weeks, I'm sure.

>>103321231
>we like everyone... except that girl she's weird
None of you have any testosterone. You sound like high school girls

>>103322084
Don't use Kanata to shitpost, ENShart

ERB 3d had only 1 good thing going for it.

>>103318619 (OP)
Move Ina up to A and I agree