Thread 281354090

I know this is something /a/ probably doesnt want to hear, but a Haruhi remake makes a lot of sense for a lot of reasons.

>unify the art style between season 1 and 2
>make endless eight one episode
>fix pacing with the sigh arc
>make a proper chronological telling of the story that follows closer to the night novels
>adapt further light novels into
>ect

Its one of the few anime that could justify a remake imo. The only issue is that turning disappearance into a normal anime arc would be a massive downgrade.

>ect
Opinion discarded.

You need to understand that most anime are just glorified ads for popular light novels or manga. No one is going to remake anything unless Tanigawa gets of his lazy ass

>>281354224
there's like a gorillion haruhi light novels that were never promoted because they were written after the anime ended also haruhi is a merch machine or could be if they wanted to drum up hype

There's plenty of manga and probably LNs that got worse adaptations than Haruhi (or they were different enough that a close adaptation might as well be its own thing) that could use new anime. The issue for me is how hit or miss new adaptations can be. So there's a 50/50 chance you could get something worse than before.

Are the issues you're pointing out really big enough to warrant a new adaptation that's going over much of the same material? In some cases it would just be better if they made more, adapting more of the source rather than risking making a worse version of existing material. At the same time though that's apparently hard to justify since it would be hard to market a sequel to a decade or 2 decade old anime, which makes it hard for new people to get into it.

>>281354090 (OP)
>make endless eight one episode

>fix pacing with the sigh arc
What's wrong with the pacing?

>>281354376
>Are the issues you're pointing out really big enough to warrant a new adaptation that's going over much of the same material?
Yes, imagine watching haruhi as a zoomer. The watch order shit is confusing, the episodes changing art between seasons is jarring, endless eight is a huge roadblock for most people. Its an anime that actively turns away people from becoming fans and buy merch unless they have a oldfag chaperone.

>>281354436
It sucks, its padded out. Its a boring premise and it lasts way too long for how simple it is.

>>281354090 (OP)
>>unify the art style between season 1 and 2
Fuck off.
>>make endless eight one episode
No point now that people can just watch it in one go or skip most of it.
>>fix pacing with the sigh arc
That's a (You) problem.
>>make a proper chronological telling of the story that follows closer to the night novels
Nobody cares about your sourcefaggotry.
>>adapt further light novels into
After spending 3+ years making worse adaptations of the already adapted arcs?

I would rather wait a little longer, thanks.

>>281354376
>At the same time though that's apparently hard to justify
FMP got a new season after 13 years. Just re-air the OG show on TV.
>The issue for me is how hit or miss new adaptations can be.
Fair. Never forget a freaking sticky

>>281354090 (OP)
Nothing would "benefit from a remake." Remakes are what you do when you're a fucking hack with zero original ideas. The fact that we're swamped in remakes is just proof the industry is circling the drain.

just adapt the later novels in a more modern style

>>281354864
>Fair. Never forget a freaking sticky
Well that's a different issue. That wasn't a new adaptation of something that was already adapted, it was just a shit adaptation.
>>281354911
People on /a/ really never separate "remake" from "new adaptation". Remakes generally don't serve much purpose but there's tons of manga that got shit adaptations even 30+ years ago that it would be nice to have a good adaptation of. Having a good adaptation is far from guaranteed though so it's still a risk.

Hell, people still call the 2017 Kino no Tabi anime a remake despite it being essentially a sequel (though it did readapt a couple stories). I've also seen people on /a/ call CCS Clear Card a remake despite it being all new content.

>all these people saying they should just make season 3

Youre asking for a third season to an ancient show that is extremely convoluted to get into. KyoAni will never work on Haruhi again and itd be retarded to ask a new studio to pick up where they left off. It would only make sense to start over with a new studio to get new people into the haruhi fandom.

>>281355034
Remakes and new adaptations are not different in this regard.
Also, I would rather they'd made a new season of the OG Spice and Wolf instead of making a remake.

>>281355041
KyoAni WILL work on it again.
We WILL get a season 3.
We WILL wait a little longer.
And we WILL be rewarded.

>>281355034
A "continued adaptation" of the parts of the story that haven't made it onto the screen yet is distinct from a "remake" which is a retreading of those parts that have. This is not complicated.

>>281354090 (OP)
>Remake anime for zoomer braindead freaks
No.

>>281355126
Cope harder
It'll be a remake one way or the other
KyoAni or not, the style will change. The industry is moving away from full drawn and it shows in the amount of slop that gets released every season.

>>281354493
Sounds like the gatekeeping is doing it's job.

>>281355099
>Remakes and new adaptations are not different in this regard.
A remake is a one to one recreation of something that already exists. A new adaptation goes back to the source material and sticks to it instead of whatever retarded bullshit they decided to do with the original adaptation. Hope this helps :).

>>281355133
Apparently it is complicated considering how many people on /a/ don't understand the difference. And depending on the original adaptation, the "parts that have made it onto the screen" could be extremely different from what the source actually is, to the point where a new adaptation might as well be its own thing. In some cases it's not even possible to do a continued adaptation off of the original anime because of how different it is.

>>281354090 (OP)
>>make endless eight one episode

>>281355396
It's a remake because they are remaking the anime, even if this time they are doing things differently.
Also, following the original doesn't necessarily make it better, retarded sourcefaggot.

>>281355432
>7 more episodes for snowy mountain syndrome
dont be contrarian

>>281354090 (OP)
No, there is no demand for Haruhi remake or even season 3. That's the real blackpill here.

>>281355570
just because it seems like a never ever thing
if it were announced itd create a titanic wave of hype

>>281355475
>It's a remake because they are remaking the anime
But they're not.
>even if this time they are doing things differently.
That's specifically why it's not a remake.
>Also, following the original doesn't necessarily make it better, retarded sourcefaggot.
I don't care what braindead animefags like you think. Getting a new adaptation that's closer to the source doesn't suddenly make your anime writer fanfiction that you like not exist. Maybe you should consider that making a living off of twisting someone who is more creative's vision also doesn't automatically make for something better either. But you obviously don't have the intelligence to think about something like that.

>>281355582
No, it would be like that Lucky Star manga sequel, most people wouldn't case, they had a lighting in a bottle but after over a decade it's just gone.

>>281355607
Still a remake.
You're still a retarded sourcefag.

>>281354090 (OP)
I do not want remakes of anything.

>>281355632
>sourcefag
It's funny how you think this is an insult.

>>281355616
a shitty licensed spin off is not the same as the return of an anime

>>281355570
The crowdfunding campaign raised nearly 600 thousand dollars for three shitty music videos. Imagine how much they would've pulled in if it had been to fund a third season. There's definitely still demand for more Haruhi.

>>281354090 (OP)
Fuck you, they would never make it as good as KyoAni

>>281354436
>>281354535
Zoomies hate it but the Sighs are is really solid. First two episodes are a bit slow but then it gets really good

>>281355671
It is in the sense you're being a faggot about it.

>>281354090 (OP)
And Kyon could be black!

You’d get a complete Haruhi adaptation with the original voice actors, but it wouldn’t be made by KyoAni - instead, a C-list studio like Passione, with a style similar to the recent Spice & Wolf remake. Would you accept the deal, /a/?

>>281355876
can kosaki do the music? thats all the matters to me

>>281355779
>Fuck you, they would never make it as good as KyoAni
Never said anything about quality, just said it'd make sense from a business perspective.

>>281355914
His services are pricey, so please understand. But Evan Call is free!

>>281355813
Not any more of a faggot than you saying nobody can ever re-adapt something regardless of how shit or unrelated the original "adaptation" was. As if doing so is a personal affront to you for some reason.

>>281354090 (OP)
you know it would be worse

>>281354090 (OP)
There are a lot of identical series that are just better these days. No remake or sequels are needed

>>281354090 (OP)
>>make endless eight one episode
stopped reading here

>>281354090 (OP)
No, just adapt the rest of the books for the love of fucking Christ.

>>281354090 (OP)
worst take on /a/ in a long time

>>281355034
>calling it "content"
Opinion discarded

>>281357947
>getting triggered by normal uses of words
I guess that's all you have left when you're incapable of addressing my actual post.

>>281357143
Its better than nothing

>>281357279
>There are a lot of identical series that are just better these days.
Ah yes, this old myth. Name 5 series as unique or high quality as Haruhi.

>>281357517
Its not even a take, its just objectively true. Kyoani is making more Haruhi ever. A new haruhi product will be a remake if it ever happens just like spice and wolf and countless other classic series.

>>281354402
So what??

>>281356289
Haruhi wasn't shit and doesn't need a remake.

>>281355616
Gundam Seed just got a movie almost 20 years after the series ended, that's a sequel to 100+ episodes of material and it still managed to be a hit. Never underestimate the selling power of nostalgia.

Why can't OP stop being such a massive faggot?

>>281359231
you are tho

>>281354222
Don't tell me you wouldn't enjoy electroconvulsive therapy administered by Haruhi.

>>281358815
exactly needs remake

>>281354090 (OP)
damn what an old image

>>281354327
>there's like a gorillion haruhi light novels that were never promoted because they were written after the anime ended
This is false, volume 9 came out in 2007, that was the first hiatus, and it got the boost from EE and Disappearance. Surprise also came out not long after the Disappearance movie and sold incredibly well, topping the LN sale charts. Only volume 12 never got any promotional benefit from an anime and volume 13 is just a collection of old short stories.

>>281354771
>Nobody cares about your sourcefaggotry.
That's the funniest part, literally the only thing to complain about in terms of staying close to the source is EE adding a few thousands to the final loop count so I don't think OP even read the novels.

>>281354090 (OP)
There's nothing to remake. Just adapt the rest of the LN's.

>>281359691
Thanks, Yuki.

12 hours to go until the final MV
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDTb57G0FxU

>>281354090 (OP)
>i know this is-
shut the fuck up you baiting retard, and no there won't be a remake, go get a job.

a remake would probably be morally compelled to pay homage to kyoani which would probably distract the studio from just making a new haruhi anime with its own vision

>>281362934
What are the chances that this music video ends with a season 3 announcement?

>>281363060
Zero
On the other hand, what are the chances for a "wait for more news!"?

>>281363048
the major people involved with the haruhi adaptation were sacrificed to the fire. Haruhi demands a sacrifice.

>>281363150
No they weren't, the director is still there.

>>281363060
you have to let go
yhtlg

>>281363595
ehh...I'm reading through the adapted LN's. soon to be unadapted LN's

>>281363748
are they any good?

>>281358169
>Ah yes, this old myth. Name 5 series as unique or high quality as Haruhi.
There's nothing unique about it. It's just a generic school show that we get 20 versions of every season for decades

>>281363944
Ches they are.

>>281354911
There are great remakes/reboots retard but haruhi doesn't need one, it needs a new season by Kyoani.

>>281354090 (OP)
I enjoy endless 8. I like looking at the differences between episodes.

>>281363595
>yhtlg

>>281355761
I think it also blew any expectations they had for that campaign out of the water, same the music videos are just 3D trash though

>>281364701
it helped you feel what Yuki suffered through.

>>281354327
>there's like a gorillion haruhi light novels
that's old stuff, it doesn't work like that.

that haruhi hunting thing was 10 years ago right now, I dont remember when it ended but it was during the summer
probably shouldn't have cheated at the end, was funny though
that als guy is long dead too
strange how time is, 10 years before the haruhi hunting thing, haruhi didn't even exist (as an anime)

Can you?

>>281354090 (OP)
>I know this is something /a/ probably doesnt want to hear
Correct
>>unify the art style between season 1 and 2
This doesn't matter
So many anime have inconsistencies between how characters are drawn from episode to episode, like Azumanga Daioh for example
Unless they're incredibly off model, which in Haruhi they aren't, then it's a non issue
>>make endless eight one episode
Kill yourself, including anybody that genuinely recommends people to skip Endless Eight
It pains me to know that there are people who missed out on one of the most unique experiences in anime because they listened to faggots telling them to skip it
>>make a proper chronological telling of the story that follows closer to the night novels
You watched Haruhi wrong if you didn't watch s1 in broadcast order
>Its one of the few anime that could justify a remake imo
I disagree completely
It is one of the highest quality tv anime ever made
The best Kyoani could do is match it's quality or make it slightly better
but realistically it'd be a mixed bag
better than the original in some ways, but worse in other ways

>>281355432
The novel got it right, just one chapter featuring the final iteration. There wasn't any need to have 8 episode slots wasted for a meme

>>281366091
you didn't watch the show

>>281354090 (OP)
>waa waaa please my tantrum and 5yo whims waa waaaaa
remake cunts are the worst cancerous scum ever. you fucks destroyed gaming, and now you cunts want to destroy anime too??
haruhi is haruhi, a 2010 anime. THATS ALL
it was what it was. period.
changing shit is cancerous. if you change it then it'll be another thing, it wont be haruhi. because haruhi was that 2010s anime
keep your whims to yourselves

works are things of their own eras/time periods. fuck you remake cunts you killed gaming get fucking nuked cunts
thats the reason why videogames arent considered art, because you fuck yourselves dont even respect it. the art, the art of being genuine and being 2010s

>>281355570
Nah there is still a huge fandom out there. I draw fanart from time to time and never went past a couple likes posting my work on twitter. Tried hoping into current trends like gacha games but nothing stuck. Then one day for the fuck of it I made a Mikuru piece that got me more than a hundred likes in a day which is not a lot of course but most people who liked it were accounts completely dedicated to the Haruhi franchise so the fanbase really is there.

>>281354224
>>281354327
It's that and the entire otaku popular art movement that Haruhi was a part of is long dead.
Look at Boogiepop's sales these days for what was once a series in the eye of the storm of the zeitgeist, and what numbers it does now. There's really limited motivation for all parties involved to do more novels, adaptations, etc when Haruhi ain't the %current_thing no more.

Friendship ended with Sekai-kei, now Narou-kei is my best friend.

>>281364004
You say this but I have failed to find a work with a character as endearing as Yuki in the past decade and half. They just don't make kuudere's like they used to (or make them at all these days).

>>281354090 (OP)
You probably should have said "re adaptation" instead of "remake" not to trigger anons around here.

>>281354090 (OP)
The so awaited revival will end up being more like Twin Peaks The Return

Haruhi remake but characters are designed by Watanabe

I remember someone asking why the series died compared to contemporary ones. I don't remember my exact response, but I can share the thoughts of the chief editor of the sneaker
https://note.com/samansa007/n/n7eec80ea5eec
I think his response is far more complete and has more weight behind

>>281366211
>changing shit is cancerous.
Uh oh, that's not the narrative pushed by annoying "anime studios know better than the original creators" people.

>>281366211
>changing shit is cancerous
That's why we should hope of a new adaptation that follows the source material closer.

>>281354090 (OP)
Absolutely not
It would lose all charm and character (see the Spice & Wolf remake)
Though maybe a remake would finally push the author to write the books that are remaining, it's been so long and the series still isn't finished

>>281366551
that's less of an answer of why it died rather than why hasn't there been another like it for a while now

>>281366551
I'm pretty sure the only thing he says about Haruhi is "massive series like Haruhi and Sword Art Online don't come around as often as they used to". Then the rest of it goes on to talk about how hard it is to promote modern LN compared to back then.

>>281354090 (OP)
>KYS
>KYS
>KYS
>KYS
>KYS
>etc

>>281366883
>how hard it is to promote modern LN compared to back then.
Going after inoffensive isekai slop every time might have something to do with it.

>>281366907
>>281366883
The real problem is that it takes 10 years for anime to get made from a ln these days. Mushoku being the most obvious example.

>>281366916
So why does it take longer now? It's not like anime in general looks really better compared to old ones and they have more advanced tech at hand.

>>281366960
Too busy fapping to csam I presume

>>281354090 (OP)
>>281366091
As I said

>it cannot be overstated just how much of an improvement to Yukis character having the endless eight be more than 1 loop like in the LN is.

>In particular the contrast between her clearly enjoying herself in ep1 of endless eight, vs. the sheer desperation on her face in ep2 singlehandedly manages to make her an actual good and compelling character where otherwise she would be rather egregious case of telling instead of showing, and the fact that we see her being desperate in slightly different ways each episode adds overall to her character by making it clear how much of a longstanding issue and development on her part.

>In general 3 episodes is the absolute bate minimum that I would consider acceptable, though in reality 4 episodes is significantly better as it adds to that longstanding desperation I mentioned, though realistically if the episodes were of higher quality overall all 8 episodes would most certainly be the best choice.

>However taking into account the quality of the existing episodes, it is my opinion how the ideal watching experience for endless eight is to watch episodes 1,2,5,7,8 as all of these add something significant to the viewing experience, I already mentioned episodes 1 and 2, and episode 8 should be self explanatory as the ending episode, episode 7 is simply really good, on par in quality with episode 2, and there is scene in that episode which adds again substantial characterization to Yuki via continuity from a scene in episode 1, episode 4 also does this, but it is of a significantly lower quality, and lastly episode 5 I bring up for 1 scene in particular, the stargazing scene in that episode is amazing, and absolutely worth a watch, however I could understand if someone chose to only watch episodes 1,2,7,8 instead.

>The reason for excluding the rest of the episodes is because they are significantly weaker in terms of showing Yukis desperation than the ones I mentioned and drag the experience down.

>>281366960
because it's become more of a rat race with everyone being overseen by production committees, with the actual animation studios needing to take on as many anime productions at once each year as physically possible just to keep up with the competition, so a lot of them already have their schedules booked solid ten years in advance

I wish Amazon allowed what ZenMarket does, and that is offering you to buy a product, and being able to ship it the next month. I could easily afford that.

>>281354090 (OP)
No need to "unify" anything. Just make season 3
>>281362047

>>281354090 (OP)
>make a proper chronological telling of the story that follows closer to the light novels
The LNs aren’t in chronological order. And the anime is a very faithful adaptation that already enhances the content of the early volumes. There’s no need to remake it. It would be a waste of time when what they made was already good. Just continue on to adapt Intrigues along with the other short stories. And Dissociation and Surprise 1 & 2 could be a film trilogy like Kizumonogatari. Season 4 can be Theater and Indignation.

>>281362047
>this wizard

it's the biggest piece of dog shit that I've ever watched

>>281354090 (OP)
there's no point doing anything new with haruhi until the author figures out the ending and wraps it up
even then it'll probably just be met with a "wait, that was it? I've seen this kinda story a hundred times already' like Helck got instead of ushering in a new wave of Haruhism

>Season 3
Snowy Mountain Syndrome Part 1
Snowy Mountain Syndrome Part 2
The Melancholy of Mikuru Asahina
Intrigues I
Intrigues II
Love at First Sight
Intrigues III
Editor in Chief Full Speed Ahead
Wandering Shadow
Intrigues IV
Where Did The Cat Go?
Intrigues V

>Movies
Dissociation
Surprise Part 1
Surprise Part 2

>Season 4
Random Numbers
Theater I
Theater II
Theater III
Theater IV
Theater V
Seven Wonders Overtime
Tsuruya’s Challenge Part 1
Tsuruya’s Challenge Part 2

How does this sound? What changes would you suggest?

>>281366257
Can't say I ever found her or anyone else in this to be very memorable

>>281368191
I dont think season 3 needs to be out of order, as the main reason as the pacing of the stories in chronological order as it is, is already good enough, and the only change I would make is put Snowy mountain syndrome before Love at first Sight.

In particular shoving Melancholy of Mikuru Asahina inbetween Snowy Mountain syndrome and the prologue to Intrigues, as well as placing Love at First Sight after both of those stories is just terrible pacing wise.

There is also no reason to put where did the cat go as the 2nd to last episode, its perfectly fine being placed after the prologue to Intrigues, but before Melancholy of Mikuru Asahina as it is in the LNs.

Making 3 movies fully adapting the Dissociation and Surprise storylines is a mistake IMO, I would much prefer if Dissociation was season 4, alongside some of the other stories, like having Editor in Chief be only 1 episode is ridiculous IMO, and you could adapt a story like Random numbers into it as well since it chronologically takes place before Dissociation.

And as for Surprise, I believe how trimming it down to where it would be able to be adapted as a single movie with similar length to Disappearance is a far better choice than trying to shoehorn a full adaptation of a double LN that already just didnt quite need to be as long as it did.

Lastly, I am a fan of having Theatre be the first new adaptation before anything, else for the following reasons.

1. It takes place chronologically before Disappearance and is relevant to that story

2. It would work as great promotional content for the LNs as it would be adapting and drawing attention to the most recent release

3. For the majority of the story, until the very end, the story of Theatre is essentially an elseworlds story that seems to have nothing to do with the main plot, which makes it work great as a standalone thing which would help draw people in without requiring them to watch the rest of the series first.

>>281368222
Can you elaborate, because I find her story of being a quiet person who never puts her thoughts and feelings out on the open for everyone to see, causing others to assume she doesnt have those things and fail to recognize and act as she becomes more and more depressed and miserable, until she eventually snaps and creates a a world in which she can live out all her fantasies without needing to worry about any of the things that caused her pain ever again, including changing herself into someone fundamentally different, to be a quite compelling and memorable story, its literally the lynchpin of the entire movie alongside Kyons epiphany towards Haruhi.

And as for the other characters, surely at least Haruhi is quite memorable.

>>281368023
that wizard looks trustworthy
I think she'll guide me well through the installation

>>281354090 (OP)
why? s3 would be a million times better than the same shit again

>>281354090 (OP)
>remake
it's an adapation. it is not the original work. you want another adaptation not a remake.

>>281354376
>adapting more of the source rather than risking making a worse version of existing material
that's what I thought they should've done when I heard about the new Ranma anime and I thought I'd hate it but I actually liked it quite a bit, dunno how well it did though

>>281369591
>why? s3 would be a million times better than the same shit again
ideally it would get there

>>281355876
Is Passione bad? I think they're okay, but not better than the top studios.

>>281366551
lmao he made a discord server following this

>>281373131
They really butchered higurashi. Far worse than deen ever did.

>>281354090 (OP)

Remaking a bad anime will not make it good, OP. The other problem is that remakes also suffer from excessive commercialization. So here's what you'll actually get:

>Overall major downgrade for animation FPS
>Oversaturated computer colors, nothing at all drawn by hand
>Soundtrack downgrade (it was not good to begin with, but you won't even get the equivalent of God Knows this time... Or, insultingly, you'll only get the original audio for God Knows in order to save on costs.)
>Kyon (or Mikuru) will be made black

Endless Eight will STILL be bad, even as one episode, and the cultural hype around this mediocre SOL will be over. Nobody will buy the DVDs/ BluRays, excepting the world's biggest homos, and it'll be almost as big of a wash as the Laughing Salesman remake.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDTb57G0FxU
nagatummy

>>281375564
Damn, Aya still got it.

>>281367016
>1,2,5,7,8
nigger just watch all of them at that point god damn
if you're gonna watch the show just watch the fucking show

>>281367016
Honestly they could have shoved all that into 2 episodes (first and last loop).

>>281354090 (OP)
anon
that is exactly what was discussed in the board room when shinji came
we live in a timeline of shit where haruhi will never get anything again

>>281377527
GET BACK HERE

>>281378469
Fuck off.

>>281378538
no.

>>281377328
I was strictly looking at the artistic merit of the episodes from the perspective of properly fleshing out and exploring Nagatos mental state and her budding motivation that eventually resulted in her changing the world, and in that case I came to the conclusion that episodes 3 and 6 in particular actively hamper the experience due to how poorly they showcase her suffering, and I excluded episode 4 as an example of providing a bate minimum watching framework that doesnt actively hamper the experience, I personally would watch 6 episodes because again episode 3 and 6 just take me out of the experience completely.

>>281377370
Not true as I explained in this part

> though in reality 4 episodes is significantly better as it adds to that longstanding desperation I mentioned

Though to elaborate on this part, I believe how it is incredibly important to have an episode which showcases her actively suffering throughout, that ends badly with time looping again, to properly establish what the status quo that she is experiencing throughout the endless eight is, which is that of hopelessness, where you know that despite what you/her had to endure throughout this loop, it was all for nothing, and you will have to do it again, which is why 4 episodes is also significantly better than 3, as it adds to the persistent nature of this status quo, as it makes this type of episode the plurality within the arc, and why 5 episodes is also an improvement on that as it establishes these episodes as the majority within the arc, which manages to make the final episode all the more cathartic, and her actions in Disappearance all the more understood and fleshed out.

>>281366330
In that moment, we were all Kyon

>>281377328
make sure to also watch at 1.25x speed to save time

>>281366330
>>281366551
I love how awful she can be. It makes her cuter. You’ve got fans drawing her getting beaten, but you know they still like her. She’s a cute little tyrant.

>>281378976
Meant to reply to this for the second one
>>281366511

Your amazing and smart brigade chief

>>281355041
rozen maiden jumped right into s3 with little introduction and a 7 year hiatus, haruhi can do the same

>>281368083
You must have been lucky enough to watch only the finest anime in existence then

>>281378469
We're tired of seeing your abomination gens, wanschizo.

>>281377437
Sometimes I feel like a lot of people here have literally deleted that from their memories and discuss things as if it never happened.
I don't even like to bring it up most of the time. Because if that's the world they live in, I don't even want to pop their bubble...

>>281378469
kys

>>281354090 (OP)
Kill yourself. I just watched it for the first time ever like a week ago, in the original order, and all the endless 8 episodes, plus the movie. It was kino. I'm going through the novels right now. Fuck outta here with this normiefication of anime. Haruhi is a one of a kind experience and shouldn't be touched in order to make it more accesible to newcomers. You either like it like it is or you don't.
Fuck you, I am mad.

>>281379464
>I don't even like to bring it up most of the time.
I do, I love raining on the parade of sentimental retards.

>>281379533
based

>>281378469
>yuki touching haruhi's bubble butt

sexooooooo

>>281379638
You are Indian

>Went through over 15000 loops
>Can also apparently erase memories based on what she said in the rooftop scene
What has she done with Kyon?

>>281379533
The thing is, back in the day Haruhi WAS pop culture.
I don't have much of an opinion. But the people who want to bring it back, just want to bring it back to the status quo so they can get the rest of the content adapted.
Girls in Japan were recording themselves dancing in the street(which would be called a tiktok dance today).
And even in the west, Haruhi was #1 on MAL iirc.
So it's not like it was or was ever really meant to be some underground thing.
Some people might argue(not me, I don't care) that Haruhism is meant to be spread fundamentally.

>>281379417
Why are you projecting your schizophrenia onto others, anon?

>>281379464
Back in 2019, people often said that Maidragon S2 wouldn't be released because of the fire. Not only did it eventually come out, but we also got Hibike S3.

>>281380008
AI Sloppa...SUGOI

>>281380011
Yes, that's true.
I would think the fire makes things less likely, but you could also argue that it gives people an even deeper motivation to continue affected works(probably true).

>>281380008
just need the extended version where she takes off her panties too.

>>281378469
>AI still doesn't get Yuki right
Surprise surprise.

>>281380895
YUKI, STOP SMILING

>>281379374
One would think a 7 year hiatus is not the same as a 15 year old hiatus.

>>281380930
Stop posting your AIslop.

>>281380961
no

>>281354376
>risking making a worse version of existing material
It's not possible to make a worse version of season 2

>>281381220
I think you underrate (overrate?) modern anime studios.

>>281354771
>I would rather wait a little longer
It's been 19 years

>>281380930
Keep posting your AIgold.

>>281381399
Are you sure?

>>281381399
>>281381434
Off yourselves

>>281381469
Sorry,
*off yourself
You've been known to samefag and respond to yourself enthusiastically, so it's safe to assume you're doing it here too.

>>281381248
It's simple not possible

>>281379374
FMP jumped into season 4 with little introduction and flopped hard though

>>281380942
>15 year old hiatus.
That was no problem in the case of Panty and Stocking,

>>281381434
Imagine what we'll be capable of generating in one or two years...

>>281381434
>>281380930
>>281380008
YOU KNOW WHAT THIS MEANS, GUYS!?
With AI we can get the missing 14992 endless eight episodes!!

>>281379917
>Girls in Japan were recording themselves dancing in the street
>these girls are 30-year old hags now
>some are even married

>>281382150
The same exact low quality slop? Yeah, fascinating. Kill yourself.

>>281382227
I wonder, how do we feed the 8 episodes we have into AI for it to learn?

>>281382316
You say "here comes the airplane" and then shove all the haruhi meat in as soon as it opens it's slutty AI mouf.

>>281382248
I'd say that the quality has improved at a rather rapid pace in the past few years. As of now, it's still not at an incredibly satisfactory point, but eventually, AI-generated art will become indistinguishable from human-produced art.
Really, as long if something looks good, I couldn't care less who or what produced it.
The biggest problem with AI is just that it's being crippled with moralfaggotry. If it wasn't for that, then we could have a tool that, unlike artists, will never back down and apologize for creating something "problematic".

>>281382861
Don't bother friend, you're replying to a known schizo.

>>281382891
Why do you call everyone schizos?

>>281355041
Just replay the first 2 seasons before season 3.

>>281366226
everything in this anime/manga/LN world is all about timing, so it's safe to say that all this shit was over when they hired the wrong fucking voice actress who fucked the entire franchise

>>281354090 (OP)
>dude just remove all the soul to make it lgbt zoomer friendly
no

>>281383656
My wives.

>>281379741
poor quality repost thanks to Bandai Namco Music Live Inc.
Hare Hare Yukai
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7mDGtDKKHM
Her most popular video, Luka Luka Night Fever from 2009:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpoR_xlslLI

girls just don't dance the same in 2025

I love aliens.

>>281384082
I haven't watched the others but you can still clearly see Yuki is the best one

>>281354090 (OP)
College Haruhi when?

>>281384164
I like her hair

>>281384261
Her dumb big hair is cute. Kyon even takes note of how stupidly voluminous her hair is. She’s supposed to be kinda uncanny and fucked up unlike the Data Overmind interfaces.

>>281384234
all of them are from Haruhi

More novel propaganda. Want to know who the mystery girl on the left is? You have to read. Get to it.

>>281380930
fuck off

>>281386273
nah

Haruhi is a relic of the past, the anime will be 20 years old next year and it simply doesn't have the popularity it used to with younger generations.
Hirano is voicing a cute girl this season at least.

>tfw we're all shitposting in the discord server
I love you faggots

>>281386808
This is her sister Michiru.

I wonder what Taniguchi’s lowest ranked girl is. Who’s his pick of the F-tier ho of North High? Kyon should be asking him for this information.

Best girl

>>281355934
KyoAni Haruhi set a precedent, no one will live up to it so it's pointless for anyone else to try

>>281354090 (OP)
No. It needs to be a continuation
The original was already near perfection it'll be a waste of resources to do a remake

>>281386676
Yep. Kinda wild we have an official haruhi discord now

>>281354090 (OP)
>Haruhi is one of the few anime that would benefit from a remake
It's literally the opposite. The Haruhi anime is one of the best LN adaptations out there. Most LN authors wish their works could get anime this good and faithful. The average LN-to-anime adaptation tries to cram an entire book into just two or three episodes, often skipping most of the inner monologues, world-building, and character interactions.

I don't care there's an official Haruhi server, I'm not creating a Discord account
i hate the antichrist! i hate the antichrist!

>>281389240
Hold the line. Stay here with me on /a/. All the Haruhi discussion you need is right here.

>>281384255
Adult Haruhi when?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2LAWFWKsGY

Nice...

>>281389380
>>281389240
I'm doing both. It's not a bad idea...

>>281389593
Gotta learn nip to play all the weird Haruhi vidya. At least the DS and Wii game are getting fan translated.

>>281379330
Is that Yui from K-ON!?

>>281389980
Season 2 Haruhi is Yui when viewed from a distance.

>>281354090 (OP)
wat

>>281389380
Thank you. I don't think there was much I could discuss, anyway. Not until I can buy more light novels.

Why doesn't Yuki ever get dragged into the cosplay shenanigans?

postin haruhi things in a haruhi bread!!

>>281392682
because that's Mikuru's job

>>281355041
>Youre asking for a third season to an ancient show that is extremely convoluted to get into.
Watch the show in chronological order and BOOM you're done. It is not that hard. Broadcast order is only worthwhile if you're watching it as it airs.

>>281392769
kyoani likes this kinds of closeup shots

Fine I will read your LN harui, I already pirated it. I watched you when you first came out and was posting on /a/ when long cats were long. I think i should at least offer you tribute desu

>>281393964
They're super moe if the girl is cute

She sleep

so what is haruhi, anyways

>>281382248
it isn't low quality, you're just one of those buttmad tree huggers who seethe at technology

Haruhi is impossible to remake. It's an icon of its age. You had to be there to experience it.

https://youtu.be/C337shIT9LI?si=gVqE7QyngYfTpNnU

>>281394724
>20000 word reply

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2aGaTbTGAKA
i do miss the old artstyle

>>281382150
AI should be used for inbetweening while still controlling the main flow of animation by hand, instead of having it generate everything from zero to make these pyschedelic uncanny valley horrors they do now. We could get quality animation 100 times faster than before, instead of waiting for the improbable holy grail of machine spontaneously developing good taste

>>281354535
yeah endless eight is the reason i never once considered revisiting this show in the past 16 years.

>>281395492
By the fifth episode of the same, I went from the biggest Haruhi fan to completely wiping this series from my memory for 10 years. Baffling decision.

>>281395532
>biggest haruhi fan
>can't handle watching multiple completely different episodes of the series he is the biggest fan of
come on

>>281395545
Probably the same type of person who unironically believes this sentiment >>281357279

>>281380008
imagine posting this 20 years ago

>>281396315
In 2005? It would become legendary footage because Haruhi aired in 2006.

>>281395545
I just don't eat shit, no matter who gives it

God this thread went to shit after the first 100 replies, just people shitposting, or posting bad takes that were addressed earlier in this thread or just people posting random references to events in the anime or later LNs without any further insight into them other than letting people know they exist, with a few posts being the exception that end up being completely ignored.

>>281398694
What we need is more AI.

>>281398701
Yes, more AIgold please

>>281354090 (OP)
Haruhi isn't like Batman or Spiderman, or Gundam or any famous shounen series. It's a product of its time.
Remake this and the people will just say, "Oh it's that anime 20 years ago."

>>281354090 (OP)
it will look like this, no thanks.

>>281398840
haruhi is batman?