>>282032461
Fate and Hayate is what I personally prefer, but if Nanoha wants to join I would not complain.
>>282032571
Basically impossible.
Nanoha is a strange spin off of an ero game featuring a single Nanoha scene while the older brother was the Mc and the older sister one of the main targets.
That alone make it's conception as a work already strange.
Strikers ruined it, because the time skip was too extreme.
Instead of easing in with like a season of them as teens and another as military trainees we went too deep in.
Force was garbage that while trying to ride on the franchise abandoned what made it special to begin with (the only worthwhile thing it did was give us a rough estimate of how fast Fate really is, base form Fate was able to move FTL).
Vivid was a cheap way trying to go back to the roots with characters that lacked the same pull, the characters feel like cheap rehashes of what we had, it also had an insane power creep issue.
Like originally the appearances of talents like Nanoha, Fate and Hayate was something special, something that you see only every few centuries.
Yet Vivid shifted the power scale so horribly it became irredeemable.
Then they tried that soft alternate universe timeline reboot, which also not worked, even with the addition of dark copies of the main trio.
Yet what is worse is what came after it.
Madoka
Madoka has like one of the worst fan bases ever, they always pop up when it is about a magical girl show and will compare it to how much better Madoka is because it deconstruction and it was the first magical girl show to have dark and gritty stuff and actual deaths that were not undone or comedy elements.
Which obviously is not true, but I remember a time you hardly could make a Nanoha thread without them popping in and spamming how much better Madoka supposedly is.
