Thread 282249664

How can I tell if an anime is good or not?

>>282249664 (OP)
If you like it

The fact that you posted a pic from Monogatari series while asking made me lol irl.

>>282249720
If you want to reference it alot

>>282249720
But I like 99% of anime

>>282249664 (OP)
There are certain elements that you have to look out for.

>>282249720
This

>>282249760
That's fine

>>282249664 (OP)
if it has ntr bait or ntr scenes, then it's a 10/10. otherwise, no

>>282249819
But 99% anime can't be all good

>>282249866
you must be a pseudo-intellectual/poser to think this. anime is a 99.99% good. people put their heart and soul in it, and it takes a lot of effort to generate one unlike burger media and shit

>>282249664 (OP)
If /a/ hates it.

>>282249878
Ok then I guess it is

>>282249878
YWNBJapanese

I've become able to tell after becoming a wizard and in a way it's a terrible curse. Scenaristic and animation errors, narrative weaknesses, failures of characterization, cinematography, timing, pacing, editing, storyboarding, sound design, themes and metaphors, comparisons to contemporary works.
All of these details jump into my face unprompted. It's not comfortable.
I truly had no tastes when i was 20 but i did collect excellent anime, and a couple of doozies, by trusting /a/'s tastes even if a vague sense of enjoyment was all i could garner at the time.
Thank you /a/ for all the anime & manga.

>>282249664 (OP)
all the lolis. everything that readdit and tvtropes banned.

If it shows loli nipples and shota dicks then it's good.

>>282249664 (OP)
Always listen to your penis, he will never lead you to the wrong path, whenever you are in doubt, just ask him, he will never lie to you.

>>282249878
>people put their heart and soul in it
doubt

>>282250798
there is a way to fix this

>>282250187
to this day i still dont know why westoid goyim treat this as an insult

>>282249664 (OP)
you ask /a/

>>282249664 (OP)
You have to trust me and only me.
And remember that my tastes are forever, so if I said mainstream-shit was best anime ever decades ago, then it is forever true even if you discover other animes existed back then and anon pretend it is much better.

>>282251059
>ESL can't distinguish what is a joke or not
it happens a lot

I'm worried anon,
Your standards doesn't change with time right?

>>282249664 (OP)
If it makes a long lasting impression on you. It's when you want to talk about it all the time.

>>282251130
I think you have a branching point after the peak second path where you step back and only partake in the good media ignoring the consumption based tripe

>>282251001
It doesn't lower my awareness, it increases my critical thinking to the point i become able to understand any foreign language, perceive unreal creatures and even cast actual curses.
Beware if i ever show up drunk in your thread.

>>282251130
of course your standards will change
but you will come to realize something doesn't have to be objectively good for you to enjoy it

>>282251164
i'm more likely to talk about bad anime

>>282251194
You should know that the consumerist tripe becomes the only thing left to see.
After seeing all the classics, all the hidden gems and all the mud. Only unique creative ideas can spur such full hearts, an anime's worth is no longer about quality, all the quality has been mined up.
As we're entering the second half of our decade, expect masterpieces of a new kind.

>>282249664 (OP)
having a brain helps

>>282251130
mine get higher over time

>>282251342
eventually you also realize objectivity in media is also a lie perpetrated by the 10s equivalent of modern 20s grifters so you listen to their essays for ad revenue

>>282251524
No

>>282251621
you will get there eventually
anyone with a brain eventually grows out of their objectivity virtue signaling teen phase

>>282251636
Anyone with a brain knows there is a certain framework for which our minds work, and we can create an objective system based on that.
Read Kant's Critique of Pure Reason.

>>282251687
>Anyone with a brain knows there is a certain framework for which our minds work,
yeah, the "did i like it on a personal level?" framework
>and we can create an objective system based on that.
again, you will grow out of your virtue signaling eventually

>>282251387
>expect masterpieces of a new kind.
What do you mean?

>>282251734
I don't know the future.
I meant unexpected anime, the trend changed after 1985, it changed after 1995, it changed after 2005, it changed after 2015, it will change after 2025.

>>282251719
No really, go read Kant. He does a good job at solving the Rationalism versus Empiricism debate.

>>282249664 (OP)
old good new bad

>>282251870
Kant tried to reconcile religious morality with reason. His objectivity is a result of him struggling to reconcile his rejection of superstition with his core religious moral values. He was a product of his time, when empiricists were chipping away at the supernatural. He is not the be all and end all of the objectivity question

>>282249664 (OP)
Good: It's good
Bad: It's popular with normalfags

>>282252842
Incorrect. All the great classics are popular with the masses whether they understand what's good about them or not. You are clearly capable of genuinely telling us that Gunbuster, Akira, Eva, Cowboy bebop, Lain, Haruhi, Monogatari, Steins Gate, K-on, Tatami Galaxy, Made in Abyss and others..ARE PLAIN BAD.
Tell us then, reveal your very lack of critical thinking.

Entry level? Yes of course. Great classics are always given out at the entrance of any media space. We even give children dusty old stories to read in school.

>>282252842
I protest!
Even unwashed peons can appreciate a masterpiece, even if they can only grasp but the superficial aspect of it.

>>282251947
>when you like an anime but it turns into rage inducing shit after each season

>>282249664 (OP)
If the number of loli main characters is higher than the number of hags

>>282253379
Damn

>>282249664 (OP)
The only categorically bad anime are One Piece and nuruto. If you're 100 episodes/chapters into OP you'll realize it gets formulaic. It's not that good. nuruto...yikes, it's not good either. Even if it's better than cape. That is why battle shonen is considered the bottom genre, as a general rule.
What makes a good anime, then? It depends, the answer varies, the short answer is, anything that isn't One Piece.

>>282249720
fpbp

>>282253440
Kircheis is spiritually a loli.

>>282253589
My favorite anime isn't the best anime. Statement by the utterly deranged. Fags, both of you.

>>282253695
my favorite anime is Non Non Biyori and I think its the best anime but lots of people will disagree.

>>282253775
Best anime when Renchon the main character, clearly, switches between nostalgic self insert and in-universe character according to some random pattern? Adult or little girl, smart of dumb, a writer must choose. The anime's moe line was barely kept straight under control. For example: Baby Renchon was not cute but instead hateful like a real baby.
My favorite anime is the Monogatari Series and it's not the best anime. By looking at it instead of looking at the subtitles one realizes that the picture is not even animated most of the time.

>>282253974
I want a 1/4 ounce of whatever you are smoking

>>282254159
Damnit. Again. What is wrong with my post.

>>282249664 (OP)
if you wanna watch the next episode, then it's good

>>282253055
>All the great classics are popular with the masses
Not really. That said most of those anime you listed are good, only Steins;Gate and possibly K-on are bad.

>>282249664 (OP)
If it's unsafe-horny it's good
If it's safe-horny it's bad

>>282254374
Admirable post for not writing "samurai champloo's bad because hurr it's for plebs".
Isn't S;G and excellent adaptation? I find it hard to forsake the anime in favor of the VN. The game has more content but seeing it animated on a timeline with such care and respect is a joyful experience.
I omitted two dozens titles on my little list anyway. I meant that specific anime of objective high-quality keep on appearing on people's lists as long as the person bothered to go beyond shonen anime (this type of mass need not be discussed).

>>282254374
>K-on are bad
opinion discarded

>>282249664 (OP)
It's pretty always obvious

samurai champloo is for plebs

You can just kinda tell when a piece of human soul was put into a work. I go by feeling alone.

>>282249664 (OP)
Ask Chat gpt.
To be frank, this is not entirely my personal opinion; I asked Chat gpt and that was the answer i received.

>>282249664 (OP)
It's easy.

>>282262292
His country's reputation hinges on this product.

>>282262102
>ask chatgpt
>it tells you whatever you like is classic and the best

>>282249664 (OP)
if it's a seinen with all female main cast it's shit

>>282249878
kek

the characters have a nose. I don't watch moeshit

>>282263339
good point, dot noses are fucking ugly

>>282249664 (OP)
It always gets good right after you drop it.