Thread 283670172

>You can't kill the villain or it would make you just as bad as him
Why is this retardation still so common?

but they did kill the villains

but yes, the reason for the trope is that it was a popular thing to do in Hollywood movies for a long while. you see it in comicbooks because of that.

>>283670234
>Jews pushing slave morality through religion (Christianity) and now media
Well well well

>>283670172 (OP)
>I didn't get it the first time I saw it so now I will never look at this scene in good faith
Getting real tired of people pretending this scene is about "killing bad guys is bad"

>>283670172 (OP)
>You can't kill the villain because that would be boring and they should live with humiliation

>>283670304
Modern liberal interpretation of Christianity is not the same as Christianity

>>283670307
Isn't it?

>>283670420
Of fucking course it isn't
The problem with Roy is what has happening inside his own head, not his actions themselves
His thirst for revenge was driving him towards becoming a man who is controlled by his anger and would kill for it
It's not because killing Envy was wrong, it's because by going through with it in that state he was going to turn himself into Scar

>>283670172 (OP)
All media for teens are police pilled

>>283670304
>>283670342
>>>/pol/

>>283670307
>people
it’s the same faggot every time

>>283670815
they're right you know

>>283670172 (OP)
The implications is the moment you justify killing one person, then it makes it easier to justify the next person you kill.

As a "hero" whose job it is to protect the peace, at what point does it slide into unwarranted homicides and straight out tyranny through threat of violence?

They say the road to hell is paved with good intentions, a hero could easily start paving such road with the bones of his perceived enemies.

>>283670172 (OP)
One of the many reasons why FMA 2003 continues to be superior

Censorship/marketing. Making your main character a killer makes them less marketable, less sympathetic, and less "morally pure".

>>283670527
That makes no fucking sense. His anger was directed.
>If you kill a bad guy that means you'll turn into the kind of person who kills puppies!
Just as fucking nonsensical as Killing Is Bad.

>>283671156
My god the one on the left is pure SOVL compared to the bland slop on the right

>>283671191
Brotherhood also fucked up that arc, everything that's adapted from the beginning of the manga 2003 does better, and it stops following the manga when retarded shit like OP's pic rel happns

>>283671166
To answer the problem with "we should just let the evil killer go" is retarded. To treat all exploration of the problem as if they're advocating for that answer is equally retarded.

>>283671166
How do you manage to constantly take a simplified strawman of what's being said

>>283671324
>strawman
>>283670527
>The problem with Roy is what has happening inside his own head, not his actions themselves
>His thirst for revenge was driving him towards becoming a man who is controlled by his anger and would kill for it
>It's not because killing Envy was wrong, it's because by going through with it in that state he was going to turn himself into Scar
What else am I supposed to get out of this fucking nonsense? Don't play the strawman card just because you're embarrassed by your own argument LOL.

>>283670841
>May 2025
>"How long does this fucking go?"
>2024
>2023
>2022
>...
>2017

>>283671380
It has nothing to do with it being wrong to kill Envy
Envy needed to die
Roy needed to not be the one to do it

>>283671166
Roy was reveling in torturing Envy. Which is not a good quality for a leader.
Putting Envy down so that he wouldn't exist anymore and wouldn't be able to hurt anyone is fine. Riza and Edward even both offered to kill Envy themselves.
But Roy wasn't acting out of pragmatism, but emotion.

>>283670172 (OP)
Manga/Brotherhood Roy is a fag.

>>283670172 (OP)
Because they're not schizos like you due process

Killing someone who is harmless to you is murder. Murder is bad. Not that hard to understand.

>>283670234
Jews want you to think it's wrong to retaliate

>>283670172 (OP)
>This thread again
Schizo’s having a melty again

>>283671642
>Posts 2003 Roy, a bitch who ran off to Briggs by the end and gave up on his ambitions, even abandoning Riza
This is the worst version of Roy, full stop

>>283671898
What does that scene have to do with this

>>283672886
Pretty sure it's the brotherhood fags having a "melty" here, unable to acknowledge that even MAL is starting to turn on their show now, only reddit fags even like it pic rel

>>283670172 (OP)
My OTP

>>283673253
>Overrated
>Shit
>Overrated
>Great
>VN trash
Broken clock is right twice a day.

>Cringe.png
>4fu2gf0flsz21.jpg
>1728330319996.webm
>reddit.png
>funny.png
>fma is shit.jpg
>Fullreddit Alchemist.png
>Beats god with the power of friendship.gif
>Doesn't stay true to the main theme.png
>Dumb writing.png
>didyoulaugh.gif
>revenge bad... because it is okay!.jpg
>Fullredditor(1).png
>Fullredditor (2).jpg
>Fullflop Alchecrap.png
>Death.webm

>>283673253
>He’s a MAL Reddit zoomie
Of course you’d know what goes on there. Were you bullied in both places or something? All of those shows are /a too, not that you’d know lol

>>283673892
KEK he’s a faggot too no wonder

>>283673892
Are you going to start spamming this thread with shota porn like you did with other ones criticizing Brotherhood, selimfag? Stop projecting, no one wants to know how much you want to sodomize little boys, plus Selim is fucking ugly

>>283670307
>>283670850
I'm not whoever you're thinking of. That scene in the OP is ultra cringe. Just because you've rationalised it in your insular fandom doesn't mean it doesn't come off nonsensical to anyone who isn't an indoctrinated goy.


>>283670527
I burst out laughing

>>283674350
Schizo moment

>>283674350
>Funnyschizo is still trying to deflect
Lmfao you’re not fooling anyone here, especially since we already caught you gay pedo kun

>>283674603
Yeah keep shitting up the thread, you've pulled this shit before and you'll do it again you fucking faggot, you have no right to call anyone that
https://desuarchive.org/a/thread/280245427/

>>283674659
>Posts thread of his melty over being called a faggot
Lmfao, the funnyschizo is getting mad. You’re the one who exposed yourself, you have no one else to blame but you.

>>283674427
>Just because you've rationalized it
That's how I saw it on first viewing

>>283674427
Indoctrinated into what exactly?

>>283670172 (OP)
>if you kill a killer there is the same amount of killers in the world
What if I kill ten killers

>>283674898
you're now a serial killer

>>283670172 (OP)
Is it? I literally never saw a single anime that did it.

>>283671684
>graphicswhore argument
>>>/v/

>>283674898
You become Dexter