>>8912507>only ellie is hotThat's the point, Ellie should be hot and Abby should be mannish or homely - that way you end up with the classic beauty and the beast dynamic.
>>8913141>i think 22-24" in length is about the max that i like, and not much bigger than about 3.5" thickYeah, on normal-sized characters, those sizes are plenty enough. If you're working with someone like Abby in picrel, then you can stretch (heh) it out some more, providing the dong isn't longer and/or thicker than their leg or torso.
>I can take 19x2.5" currentlyOh wow. Now, I'm not a medical doctor nor some whiny prude, but I'm pretty sure that inserting anything of that size into your colon frequently enough will irreversibly damage the tissue there over time - that means you'll end up with fecal incontinence at best, and colon cancer (plus incontinence) at worst. I'd advise you to keep those sizes in the fantasy realm and away from your butt. Unfortunately, we don't live in a world where your futa hulk gf with a 2-foot dick would pump your guts full of cum every day and call you her good boy.