Thread 149287647 - /co/ [Archived: 514 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/6/2025, 3:17:46 PM No.149287647
images - 2025-07-06T231601.338
images - 2025-07-06T231601.338
md5: 7ff971d0257b4fd81a0927e1b70953ac🔍
Believe it or not, part of the reason it works so well is because it's very wordy. It's just that the words are really good. The meme that comics should never be wordy comes from the fact that most comics writing is SHIT and people don't want to read SHIT.
Replies: >>149287948 >>149288927
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 4:04:59 PM No.149287948
Watchmen tier list
Watchmen tier list
md5: f7622b2808a2f13dbe4ed8599a919f2a🔍
>>149287647 (OP)
It is good because a stringent story, mystery, the end is worth, the drawing is good, lots of easter eggs, consistent/extensive wordlbuilding, well choosen writing and right pacing.
You can read it again and it is still,a good and entertaining story.
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 6:09:32 PM No.149288927
>>149287647 (OP)
I agree, though mostly from my own tastes, since whenever a writer has something worthwhile to put to paper I'm willing to read as much as they have to say to get a full understanding rather than just what is acceptable. For example Manhattan's reflections on his perspective are fascinating even if they don't move the story forward, Veidt's philosophy is interesting to frame his intentions even if his actions are ultimately deranged. If either were boiled down to just illustrated feats of power and plans like in Doomsday Clock the original series would have been less for it even if it saved on text.

But I also agree because I absolutely detest decompression, whenever I can tell a writer is stretching out an idea to reach a higher issue count so a run or event seems heftier with less work I'm immediately dissuaded from purchase. It's another reason why I'm so impressed with Watchmen, it packed so much about so much into 12 issues instead of trying to go for 50 or 100 just to coax collectors into assuming length = significance. Don't get me wrong, this isn't to suggest any long running thing is worse than shorter ones, it's about the content and density therein, not just duration.
Replies: >>149290185
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 8:37:16 PM No.149290185
>>149288927
Good points. There is a difference between filler and worldbuilding. One is just fast food without any substance.