Anonymous
6/30/2025, 1:34:01 AM No.17802014
Let me explain.
Most Atheists are Mechanistic Materialists, which isn't based in science but Christian metaphysics.
Mechanistic Materialism was influenced by Aristotle's concept of a substance as being a "thing-in-itself," having an unchanging "essence." The core of substance theory is that independent existence, permanence, and timelessness are the foundation of reality, with these notions mutually implying each other: what is permanent about things is what endures despite temporal interaction with the rest of the universe: what separates itself from all else.
This is also the reason why the Christian God is very commonly described as timeless and unchanging.
Descartes developed this into his substance dualism, where mind and matter are the two fundamental substances, with mind being non-physical and able to exist independently of the physical body.
The world of matter was comprised of entirely deterministic and mechanical linear cause-effect relations, such as a chain of falling dominoes. Humans were spared from the fate of determinism because they had immaterial souls. Descartes popularized the view that non-human animals were literally unconscious automata.
So therefore Mechanistic Materialism is merely decapitated Cartesian Dualism - a Greco-Abrahamic metaphysics. Therefore most Atheists are Christians. It doesn't matter if they explicitly "believe" in materialism or not, their worldview will usually be some flavor of assumed materialism.
Most Atheists are Mechanistic Materialists, which isn't based in science but Christian metaphysics.
Mechanistic Materialism was influenced by Aristotle's concept of a substance as being a "thing-in-itself," having an unchanging "essence." The core of substance theory is that independent existence, permanence, and timelessness are the foundation of reality, with these notions mutually implying each other: what is permanent about things is what endures despite temporal interaction with the rest of the universe: what separates itself from all else.
This is also the reason why the Christian God is very commonly described as timeless and unchanging.
Descartes developed this into his substance dualism, where mind and matter are the two fundamental substances, with mind being non-physical and able to exist independently of the physical body.
The world of matter was comprised of entirely deterministic and mechanical linear cause-effect relations, such as a chain of falling dominoes. Humans were spared from the fate of determinism because they had immaterial souls. Descartes popularized the view that non-human animals were literally unconscious automata.
So therefore Mechanistic Materialism is merely decapitated Cartesian Dualism - a Greco-Abrahamic metaphysics. Therefore most Atheists are Christians. It doesn't matter if they explicitly "believe" in materialism or not, their worldview will usually be some flavor of assumed materialism.
Replies: