Thread 17849650

>Iranic
no such word exists. That's Iranian.

Turkish/Turkic makes sense, because the ethnic Turkish and the ethnic Turkic are the different stuffs.
The ethnic Iranians and the ethnic ""Iranics"" are the same thing on the other hand.
>B... but, Iranians in Islamic republic of Iran are only a part of the Iranics
They have never made up an ethnicity "Iranian" to distinguish Iranians inside and outside of historical Persia.

>>17849659
stop

>>17849650 (OP)
Literally the same shit retard
Iranic are the indo aryan invaders who invaded iran and imposed them an indo aryan language
Iranians are the natives of iranian plateau who adopted an indo aryan language

Pls shut the fuck up iranjeet cuck

>>17849650 (OP)

"Iranic" is 100% a real word—used in linguistics to refer to the broader family of Iranic peoples and languages (Persian, Kurdish, Pashto, etc.). "Iranian" = citizen of Iran, but not all Iranic peoples are Iranian nationals. Same logic as Turkish (specific) vs Turkic (broad family).

Saying Iranics and Iranians are the same is just wrong—Kurds and Pashtuns are Iranic but not Iranian. The “Iranian ethnicity” is mostly modern shorthand for Persians, but historically people identified by tribe or language, not some made-up umbrella.

>>17849684
>Iranians are the natives of iranian plateau who adopted an indo aryan language
It's called Elamite.

>>17849692
So, Kurds aren't ""Iranian"" and Balochs are ""Iranian""? sounds odd.
the political term and the linguistic term sound getting mixed up at this point.

>>17849650 (OP)
Iranic is a lingustic grouping. For example, "Sogdian" is a now-extinct Iranic language.
Or at least, there is no practical difference between "Iranic" and "Iranian" when referring to languages and ancient cultures.
In fact, "Iranic" can be more useful if you don't want to confuse any part of the subject with modern-day "Iranians" or the modern-day nation-state of "Iran."

>>17849684
>Iranic are the indo aryan invaders
You are retarded

>>17850897
Iranic includes modern-day Iranians and modern-day nation-state of Iran.

>>17850899
yeah... and?