Thread 17859130

Why do so many /his/lets worship steppe nomad societies when farmoid societies are demonstrably superior in every way and every single steppe nomad society other than Mongolchuds that has ever been relevant or accomplished anything of note did so when they were transitioning to being a farmoid society or directly after becoming a farmoid society?

Because he open steppe, fleet horse, falcons at your wrist, and the wind in your hair is what is actually best in life.

>>17859132
False!

>>17859133
This is why your sons will never understand you.

>>17859130 (OP)
Pastoralism is just a primitive form of agriculture.

>>17859130 (OP)
No idea I'm white my ancestors are from Europe so I identify with the farmers not some subhuman barbarians from the steppe

>>17859130 (OP)
Because of retarded pop culture shit like Conan the barbarian. In reality le based steppechads actually raided farming villages when the men were out hunting and mostly killed defenseless women, children, and elderly. This is supported by burial sites found full of said victims.

>>17859147
Yamnaya victory be like
>massacred a bunch of farmoid children
>raped corded ware cucks and sent them fleeing into europe (big mistake)

>>17859140
It's simply not true. Pastoralism is its own thing. Farmers were stuck near rivers in order to do agriculture for the longest time. They had some livestock but nomadic pastoralism was unknown to them and their ancestors never tried it as an intermediary step.

>>17859130 (OP)
Because of historylet retards who just discovered the PIE hypothesis
>>17859147
Also this
Same shit happened with vikings and mongols

>>17859169
Except that the rearing of animals and the cultivation of plants are not mutually exclusive.

>>17859130 (OP)
Because they were cool and are interesting to study? because of their profound influence on the development of the Western European knighthood?

>>17859130 (OP)
Because modern European linguistics, and all of its daughter languages, descends from the prehistoric steppe peoples. The indigenous farming cultures left no imprint behind.

>>17859368
>because of their profound influence on the development of the Western European knighthood?
They didn't have any, retard

>>17859208
>moving the goalpost
Nobody said it was. "rearing of animals" is not a sufficient definition for pastoralism.

>>17859156
Yamnaya was the offspring of Corded Ware.
Didn’t you see the most recent data?
Basal variant of Yamnaya’s R1a is about 1/3 of CWC. Some small tribe of CWC males founded Yamnaya when they discovered big booba Caucasian girls.

>>17861773
Yamnaya predates Corded Ware.

>>17861714
You're just ignorant.

>>17861714
Ever heard of the avars? the alans maybe?

>>17861775
no it doesnt.
Oldest CWC-like individual with the Y DNA found in CWC is 300 years older than the earliest Yamnaya like individual.

>>17859130 (OP)
Didn't steppe nomads have higher average lifespan?

>>17859130 (OP)
I dedicate this collage to Sanya and Dark Witch.

>>17859130 (OP)
EEF were retarded cucks, the lived in Europe for 5,000 years and all they achieved was getting their ydna replaced by whg aborigines

R1b H2

Aryan culture revered warriors and individuals and technology. This was a race destined to launch missiles at each other perhaps from other planets.
The Atlantic race was a hero cult, venerating wi(d)se women and heroic ancestors, these are the Neolithic equivalent of marvel fans.
The Kosh race of Dravidians and Semites was a priestly people concerned with dreams and spirits, totally anathema to the cold calculating warrior.
The Kosh and the Atlantic formed a kind of bugman civilization.

>>17863497
Shut up retarded cuck

>>17859130 (OP)
They were competitive for a while and had "moments" when they were relevant, but nomads have been btfo completely for the past 600 years or so and barely exist today.

It's visual verifiable that nomad civilizations were inferior. Mostly likely due to technological stagnation and extremely limited population capacity. The steppe could Bully the outskirts of the indus River Valley (5~ mil primitives) but quickly fell behind Europe (80~ mil equally or more advanced peoples in 1400)

Almost all great empires, even those started by nomads, became sedentary and agricultural over time to maintain power.

>>17863950
how is his Blavatsky-ass ancient history any less authentic than your haplofag speculations, retard?

>>17864018
And what has the so called superiority of the sedentary granted to its citizens? Misery misery misery

>>17863497
This Anon gets it.