← Home ← Back to /his/

Thread 17904940

23 posts 14 images /his/
Anonymous No.17904940 >>17904970 >>17905184 >>17906504 >>17906620
Why don't blacks play the banjo anymore even though it was created by blacks?
Anonymous No.17904966 >>17906815
Because it has been replaced by the guitar for the most part. Bluegrass is the only music genre that still extensively uses the banjo
Anonymous No.17904970 >>17905252 >>17905972 >>17905978 >>17906815
>>17904940 (OP)
>banjo was created by blacks
Anonymous No.17905184 >>17906506 >>17906815
>>17904940 (OP)
There’s been a revival of interest in the banjo and traditional black string band music by artists like Rhiannon Giddens, not much different from white hipster revivalists. The banjo fell out of favor with folk musicians of all colors once cheap mass produced guitars became available, and for blacks there was both the cringe association with minstrelry in the past and the perception that it was now a hillbilly instrument.
https://youtu.be/x20E5BL1aBI?si=xT_JpztCSMpHCBSv
Anonymous No.17905252 >>17905972 >>17905978
>>17904970
Kys
Anonymous No.17905972 >>17905978
>>17904970
>>17905252
I don’t get the black banjo origin denialism, when there’s accounts in the Americas starting in the late 1600s of blacks playing “banjars” and there’s plenty of West African antecedents. When white minstrels took it up in the 1830s it was a signifier of authentic blackness. It’s not like claiming they split the atom, just a drum on a stick that became more sophisticated with mass production.
Anonymous No.17905978 >>17905981
>>17904970
>>17905252
>>17905972
>they heckin created this iconic piece of Americana that means you must put up with them stabbing kids in the heart
I think we should kill them and steal their banjos
Anonymous No.17905981 >>17906250 >>17906379 >>17906497 >>17906561
>>17905978
Okay, timmy. Kill me and steal my banjo. I'm waiting
Anonymous No.17906098 >>17906319 >>17906815
>WE WUZ [insert music]
>black culture abandons it immediately
>every single innovation the genre is made by white man
Anonymous No.17906250
>>17905981
The Breaking squad is on their way Tyrone.
Anonymous No.17906319 >>17906358 >>17906815
>>17906098
Blacks don’t do nostalgia or genre revivalism. You’ll see some classy older black couples at jazz and blues performances but it’s mostly white dweebs. They’ll bring up Chuck Berry and Little Richard to bitch about Elvis but don’t actually listen to rock. Now it’s we wuz country but no one’s sampling Charley Pride or DeFord Bailey, just throwing a bit of shitty pop country into r & b. It’s easy to imagine hip hop as a totally white genre in a few decades.
Anonymous No.17906358
>>17906319
>Blacks don’t do nostalgia or genre revivalism…It’s easy to imagine hip hop as a totally white genre in a few decades.
I’d love to see the finest white music academics doing their best to recreate Gucci mane’s trap house 3
Anonymous No.17906379
>>17905981
Holy based.
Anonymous No.17906497
>>17905981
Is it a vintage Gibson Mastertone? If so I’m on my way.
Anonymous No.17906504
>>17904940 (OP)
Because white music publisher decided that they needed two types of nigger music - Blues and Country.
Anonymous No.17906506
>>17905184
Fucked up sound mixing.
Anonymous No.17906561
>>17905981
>Black anon here!
Anonymous No.17906620 >>17906621
>>17904940 (OP)
110 years ago
>misgenation
Anonymous No.17906621 >>17906624
>>17906620
moar
Anonymous No.17906624
>>17906621
another
Anonymous No.17906719
The market for banjos pretty much died after the roaring 20's, as they were upstaged by guitars.
Anonymous No.17906815 >>17906827
>>17904966
Yeah basically during the great depression guitars became cheaper than banjos because they were mass produced while most banjos were custom made

>>17905184
Yep basically

>>17904970
They directly resemble African lutes and even their styles of playing are similar to styles from places like the Gambia as described by contemporary accounts.

>>17906098
Not really no a lot of you just copied what other black artist were doing its why the majority of British bands for example either toured with or talked extensively about black artist who they treated like how weebs treat anime and manga creators

>>17906319
This is completely false theres tons of black people in their own regions still playing these genres, commercial revival isn’t the same as preserving traditions you can still see blues in juke joints, gospel in churches, jazz music all across New Orleans, in black communities its just we don’t make the white washed versions you see as definitive of the genres
Anonymous No.17906827
>>17906815
>They directly resemble African lutes and even their styles of playing are similar to styles from places like the Gambia as described by contemporary accounts.

they couldn't invent a chair, so no, they did not invent anything like a banjo.