Thread 17905961

Do you think an entire race can be intrinsically evil? If they act on biological instincts, are they evil? Most mythologies have an evil race that are supposed to be killed for simply existing. If it can be proved an entire group is evil by default, would that justify extermination?

>>17905961 (OP)
Tolkien's Orcs are a bad example though, they weren't created evil, they were tortured and mind broken by Morgoth, who is the only truly intrinsically evil character in the legendarium.

/tg/ thread

>>17905961 (OP)
No because race and evil don't actually exist.

>>17906020
Also Tolkien himself considered expanding or retconning their origin later in his life, because the idea of anything sentient being irredeemable was against his Catholic beliefs.

>>17905961 (OP)
Indianan Jones shooting Nazis is a stupid example because Nazis aren't an ethnic group and Germany exists outside of Nazism.

>>17906043
That's what he's saying, learn to read

Have you read the Talmud?

>>17905961 (OP)
Historically, all dark races were associated with and identified as "evil" or if not evil, then as non-human animals without a spirit.

>>17905961 (OP)
Niggers are the ontological evil Tolkien warned us about

>>17906235
Orcs are mongoloids

>>17906235
Tolkien thought apartheid was unjust, and would be horrified that people use his work to demonize living people.

>>17905961 (OP)
There’s a certain tribe of ruthless cosmopolitan parasites who multiple civilizations over thousands of years have agreed that humanity would be better off without.

>>17905961 (OP)
>do you think........
well opinions change over time kek

>>17906280
He generally thought that all imperialism - British included - is crooked. He was an English nationalist, not UK nationalist.

>>17905961 (OP)
I don't understand this trying to tie the orcs to black people when they're just fantasy creatures and in the books there is a race of forest dwelling primitive tribal men who hate orcs and help the fellowship, those in my mind are immediately more comparable to blacks. Plus the "Easterlings" are pretty much described as morally worse than the orcs, being rampaging raiders incapable of self-governance without an outside force (Sauron) channeling their inherent hatred of the men of the west.

The founder of the NSWPP said something about this in an interview. I think he referenced some sort of outdated scientific experiment. Anyways, it's been proven false.

>>17905961 (OP)
I mean, just look at indians. Probably the most hated group, second place to jews.

>>17905961 (OP)
>We know that Germans are not, as a people, inherently evil
Do we?

>>17907132
a rabbis bris bloodied fingers typed this

>>17907141
Sorry your latest attempt to destroy civilization failed Hans, maybe you'll get 'em next itme

>>17906230
Sounds Jewish.

>>17907147
jews seem to be doing a good enough job........

>>17907147
odd isnt it germany wanted to "conquer" the world but when israel attacks iran yemen syria and lebanon its self defense...........in case you had any doubts youre ruled by jews

>>17907156
>life expectancy up
>violent crime down
>death from diseases down
>death from natural disasters down
>poverty reduced globally
Looking pretty good actually

>>17907180
give me free land subsidize me and have amerigoyys do regime changes on countries i hate and id be doing good too

>>17906280
Ok? jews are the ontological evil Tolkien warned us about.
This is true regardless of that African’s personal thoughts.

>>17905961 (OP)
I’m gonna say it

>>17907180
yeah i'm sure the life expectancy of the palestinians being genocided is much higher right now!

>>17906280
Tolkien was a passionate Frenco supporter :)

>>17906037
upvoted, fellow Redditor!