← Home ← Back to /his/

Thread 17917457

26 posts 18 images /his/
Anonymous No.17917457 >>17917532 >>17917739 >>17919175
what were some of the worst designed medieval weapons? Pic related
Anonymous No.17917532 >>17917700 >>17917739 >>17917977
>>17917457 (OP)
I just don't like it, bros.
Anonymous No.17917700 >>17917742 >>17917853
>>17917532
>stab
>catch weapons
>hook and slice
Yeah bro, you're retarded.
Anonymous No.17917739
>>17917532
shit taste
>>17917457 (OP)
even worse shit taste
Anonymous No.17917742 >>17917747
>>17917700
Other polearms can perform such functions too and don't look stupid.
Anonymous No.17917747 >>17917822 >>17918143
>>17917742
Anonymous No.17917822 >>17917970 >>17918011
>>17917747
Wtf is scythe sword
thats just a sabre
Anonymous No.17917853 >>17918253
>>17917700
Looks really flimsy
Anonymous No.17917970
>>17917822
Not him but looks like it was made with an actual scythe blade? Look at the edges. The sharp one is on the inside of the curve.
Anonymous No.17917977
>>17917532
I get it
Anonymous No.17918011 >>17918143 >>17919898
>>17917822
its not a saber which is thinner and longer. as the other anon said its an actual scythe fitted to a sword hilt. the runic inscriptions along the blade were common with german peasants in those times, they operated as calendars if i remember correctly. thomas muntzer was a leader of the german peasant bands of the badly failed attempted rebellion of the 1500s
Anonymous No.17918143 >>17918171
>>17917747
>>17918011
There is no indication that Thomas Müntzer actually participated in any battle or even owned a sword.
This piece as a whole is also rather funky as the blade is far older than the hilt and the blade is even mounted the wrong way around.
And the rune calender has a medieval origin - they even became fashionable decorations in the 18th century.
Anonymous No.17918171 >>17918196
>>17918143
>At length, on 11 May, Müntzer and what remained of his troops arrived outside the town of Frankenhausen, meeting up with rebels there who had been asking for help for some time. No sooner had they set up camp on a hill than the princes’ army arrived, having already crushed the rebellion in southern Thuringia. On 15 May, battle was joined.[26] It lasted only a few minutes, and left the streams of the hill running with blood. Six thousand rebels were killed, but only a few soldiers. Many more rebels were executed in the following days. Müntzer fled, but was captured as he hid in the upper storey of a house in Frankenhausen. His identity was revealed by a sack of papers and letters which he was clutching. On 27 May, after torture and confession, he was executed alongside Pfeiffer, outside the walls of Mühlhausen, their heads being displayed prominently for years to come as a warning to others.

you are probably right that the sword was never used in battle however and might not have even belonged to muntzer, it was probably a ceremonial piece or something symbolic. such types of swords were somewhat common among the peasant rebels, but more as desperate measures than anything else. scythe blades dont really make effective weapons since theyre usually very thin, which is good for efficient harvesting but bad for extended combat.
Anonymous No.17918196 >>17918242
>>17918171
Müntzer was a theological and political figure. Not a soldier - so while he was present at the Battle of Frankenhausen he most likely didn't fight.
>such types of swords
Are there more examples like the "Müntzer" sword? I only know of this single one.
Anonymous No.17918242
>>17918196
I dont remember finding any pictures of them during my german peasant war tism phase. I would assume that such weapons probably didnt last long, both being fragile and probably repurposed as scythes against as soon as the revolts were over.
Anonymous No.17918253 >>17918279
>>17917853
halberdiers were reportedly very "flimsy"
Anonymous No.17918279 >>17918303 >>17919170 >>17919183
>>17918253
What are the disadvantages of Halberds vs Spears?
Anonymous No.17918303 >>17919178
>>17918279
The spear can stab and do a little bit of blunt damage. The halberd can stab, cut, hook, pierce.
Anonymous No.17919146
This is disgusting
Anonymous No.17919170 >>17919526 >>17919532
>>17918279
looking cool and drippy
you're using as much metal/blacksmith labor hours as a sword, defeating the purpose of a polearm
you'll see lots of fabulously dressed depictions of overpaid mercs or palace guards walking around with halberds, and few actual soldiers.
s No.17919175
>>17917457 (OP)
Would you rather fight against 10 guys with swords or against 9 guys and 1 guy with a mace? Maces are good against armor and are good at "zoning".
s No.17919178
>>17918303
The spear is lowest maintenance, easiest to make, versatile as a tool, and light to carry and can be used as a walking stick.
Anonymous No.17919183
>>17918279
The halberd is more cumbersome, meaning the spear will either be VERY long, and just as not-super-nimble as the halberd, or VERY nimble, if of a similar length.
Anonymous No.17919526
>>17919170
The purpose of a polearm is to give an advantage in reach and leverage.
And the fabulously dressed mercs are actual soldiers.
Anonymous No.17919532
>>17919170
Old shoes always seems so uncomfortable
Imagine marching in that shit
Anonymous No.17919898
>>17918011
Action/Articles/and Instruction/as undertaken by all bands and groups of peasants/who have committed themselves in loyalty/1525.
Interpretation