Thread 17939734

Now that the dust has settled, who was actually in the right?

The Bourbons

>>17939734 (OP)
The revolutionaries were cringe redditors but supporting the monarchists is cucky. So idk

They are both wrong
Just eliminate the King and have a new one

Rebel victory ALWAYS results in an all-out massacre as infighting occurs to replace the power vacuum

I am not saying do not support rebellion. I'm saying that even the most corrupt dictator has incentives to pummel down criminals. The goal is to improve the government, not destroy it

>>17939740
In their defense, the whole upper class was made up of cringe redditors and people who had been trained into Chatbots.

>>17939747
>Rebel victory ALWAYS results in an all-out massacre

>picrel didnt even enforce universal white male suffrage after winning a war based on abolishing monarchy

based and trvthpilled, maybe the fr*nks are incapable of self government?

>>17939753
They did not really "abolish" monarchy. George Washington was being offered the new role of King.

He just refused.

In essence, in their view, it was a coup by the existing noble households, who then created a new form of oligarchy, but still oligarchy

>>17939734 (OP)
>>17939738
>>17939740
>>17939747
>>17939752
>>17939753
>>17939756
bruh imagine being the mayans and seeing this shit come off the ships

>>17939734 (OP)
England

>>17939753
>Immediately starts murdering innocent whiskey farmers

>>17939774
In the Founding Father's defense - those Whiskey Farmers were poor, smelly and the rich distillers had requested a favourable tax code for themselves.

Don't be not rich.

>>17939753
>>picrel didnt even enforce universal white male suffrage
Well yeah, that's why they didn't devolve into a clusterfuck of warlords slaughtering eachother. They explicitly transfered power from the elite to a smaller group of elite. They never had any delusions about "every man a king".

Except quantum mechanics is very powerful

>>17939740
Join the Girondins!

>>17939734 (OP)
No one really. In the end it was just the frogs chomping out and slaughtering each other.

The revolution was necessary, they just got a little carried away.

>>17939747
This