Most Overrated Military Commander?
Napoleon? Alexander? Rommel? Who gets way more credit than they deserve for their "genius"?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 6:32:15 PM
No.17956544
>>17956517 (OP)
Idk about overrated, but underrated would be Nader Shah
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 6:38:56 PM
No.17956560
>>17956702
alexander
wouldnt have done half of what he did without daddies fresh new elite army and generals
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:06:16 PM
No.17956627
>>17956517 (OP)
Vo Nguyen Giap or Quang Trung
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:11:56 PM
No.17956647
>>17956706
>>17956621
why do you think he is overrated?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:13:23 PM
No.17956654
zhuge liang
you dont control the wind nigga
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:18:30 PM
No.17956673
>>17956680
>>17956695
Napoleon is actually underrated if anything.
But otherwise yeah, Alexander, Rommel (any German general in ww2 is heavily overrated), Lee, Wellington, basically anyone who built a cult of personality around them.
Underrated: Rokossovsky, Prince Eugene
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:19:44 PM
No.17956678
>>17956517 (OP)
Rommel, nigga couldn't win
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:26:04 PM
No.17956695
>>17956846
>>17956673
>Underrated: Rokossovsky, Prince Eugene
Radetzky von Radetz and Alexander Suvorov were top commander
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:28:55 PM
No.17956706
>>17956647
He made bad decision going east instead solidifying control and divide Anatolia bey (warlords)
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 7:49:22 PM
No.17956771
>>17956843
>>17956517 (OP)
Nah that would be Julius Caesar.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 9:00:28 PM
No.17956936
>>17956943
>>17956843
Can he clap Rustaham Suren?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 9:02:45 PM
No.17956943
>>17956936
plapped by 50 daggers before he had the chance
but probably not horse archers are a cheat code
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 9:40:30 PM
No.17957036
>>17957048
>>17956843
You forgot he got plapped literally too
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 9:48:26 PM
No.17957048
>>17957036
gayshit was super common in antiquity who cares
