← Home ← Back to /int/

Thread 213988843

122 posts 34 images /int/
Anonymous Portugal No.213988843 >>213988953 >>213989018 >>213989145 >>213989194 >>213989290 >>213989946 >>213990102 >>213990372 >>213992488 >>213994787 >>213994972 >>213995177 >>213995422 >>213995504 >>213995635 >>213996226 >>213997247 >>213997599 >>213997648 >>213998079 >>213998465 >>213999371
genuinely fucking sad what is happening to the greatest continent on earth
Anonymous Argentina No.213988874 >>213988909 >>213989064
At least you got a pat on the back from the declining american empire (who couldn't even stop the Russians from bitching you around) and boomers got some gibs innit
Anonymous Norway No.213988909
>>213988874
>A pat on the back
More like cum on the face.
Anonymous Turkey No.213988953 >>213995329
>>213988843 (OP)
>societies
You mean economies
There's a reason the only ones who have children are the ones hooked up to 10k euro welfare every month, and even they magically hit native European birthrates when they get denied that
Anonymous Canada No.213989018 >>213989126 >>213989261 >>213989418 >>213989668 >>213989718 >>213989767 >>213990478 >>213990961 >>213994295 >>213994700 >>213994919 >>213995453 >>213995465 >>214002773 >>214003622
>>213988843 (OP)
capitalism is a death cult. this is what happens when everything you need to raise a family, like housing, healthcare, food, education, is turned into an investment commodity. Under the ussr the Birthrate was at a consistent 3 birth per family for soviet bloc countries. Then 1991 happened and the birthrate across Europe collapsed. The liberal democracies of Europe no longer needed to provide an alternative to disenfranchised workers and instituted neoliberalism/thatcherism on a massive scale privatizing the entire continent.
The population of a lot of Eastern European countries peaked in the 80s and immediately dropped in the 90s due to the soaring death rate. the fall of communism and the institution of privatization, western companies and oligarchs buying up the SOEs for pennies on the dollar. was a massive humanitarian crisis.

So it's funny to me how right wingers, instead of looking at the bigger picture. Blaming income inequality and privatization, they instead fall for right wing populism, and institue more privatization reforms. America under Trump last election is a great example.
>already have the most expensive most inefficient healthcare system in the world with the lowest life expectancy of any g20 nation
>let's slash what little medicaid we have (which is already a ponzi scheme to funnel public money to private billionaires) because Trump will deport the brown people.
>so that the investor class can commodify more of the economy, buy up more houses to rent out on the private real estate market.
>HURR WHY IS IT 30 THOUSAND DOLLARS TO GIVE BIRTH IN THIS DAMN COUNTRY WHY IS A NEW HOME 300 THOUSAND, WHY DO I NEED A CAR LOAN TO GO TO WORK, BUSSES AND TRAMLINES ARE COMMUNISM!!!!
Anonymous United States No.213989064 >>213989181 >>213989193 >>213989328
>>213988874
America and Russia are dying too. So is Latin America. So is Asia.

Unironically, the only growing continents/countries are Africa, Israel, and India. Petty shit like your post is ignorant to the actual blight we are quickly approaching
Anonymous Brazil No.213989110
it's expensive to have children everywhere
the average person can't afford to procreate unless they're ok with their kids having the bare minimum, maybe even less
Anonymous Argentina No.213989126
>>213989018
Nk is not capitalist and has a whit birth rate.
The issue is that people reinvests their labour at producing more commodities and the system is more efficient by removing children from the equation and effectively integrating working age people

The main issue is that child labour is no longer a viable investment and thus children, in a urban society with liberated females, represent a burden and not helping hands.
Capitalism is a death cult but it's not the core issue here.
The core issue is abundance which makes of non-reproduction still a viable strategy and permits sterile ideologies to keep growing via grooming, lack of child labour, etc
Anonymous Sweden No.213989137
Take everything from boomers
Anonymous Israel No.213989145 >>213989178 >>213993033
>>213988843 (OP)
>In 2023, just 4.09m babies were born in the EU
how many of those are actual europeans
Anonymous United States No.213989178
>>213989145
3 and im not talking about percents
Anonymous Argentina No.213989181 >>213989206 >>213989418
>>213989064
All westernized places that accepted american NGOs to spread their liberal-democratic progressive kumbaya psyop are in decline
It's retarded to deny american cultural exports played a crucial role in the political, social and cultural erosion of their hostage societie
Feminism, LGBT, progressivism, humanism, technocracy, Zionism, negrified culture, etc.
All largely american cultural viruses
Anonymous Costa Rica No.213989193 >>213989206
>>213989064
Europeans are much older on average, they're gonna collapse sooner than any other region
Anonymous United States No.213989194
>>213988843 (OP)
im on the ffence is it purely material lack or is there a social snowball effect where the idea of children becomes more and more forigh to ones goals? or maybe both are intertwined. but in the animal of slow nation death is the tail wagging the dog or the other way around?

Also i dont know if others agree but any overall trend or statistic in society is only going to shift if the effort to change the cruve is effortless. you cannot 'will' a revolution with minimal material change. that is even a 50% subsidy with a 50% attitude change is useless . yo ucannot half bribe an official more then you can anyone else, the dollar amount bribe must be great from the outset no smooth words will it. maybe the bribe can be social pressure but juggling jargon and ideology seems a weak medicine in an era of automatic weapons and jet travel.
Anonymous United States No.213989206 >>213989249
>>213989181
yeah except Russia and China are dying too and they havent accepted globohomoization either
>>213989193
yeah, but what’s the real difference between being the first or third domino if we’re all falling anyway?
Anonymous Costa Rica No.213989249 >>213989271 >>213989612
>>213989206
the first one will serve as an example on what not to do
Anonymous Ireland No.213989261
>>213989018
I don't remember Tomoyo saying that
Anonymous United States No.213989271 >>213989317 >>213989349
>>213989249
>what not to do
which is…?
nigga we’ve already seen you can’t reverse declining birth rates. people kept saying japan and korea would stabilize but they keep setting records every year
Anonymous Canada No.213989290
>>213988843 (OP)
Too developed, too irreligious, too expensive to raise families in
Anonymous Costa Rica No.213989317 >>213989379 >>213989612
>>213989271
>you can't reverse declining birth rates
yes you can, you just need a radical change in the zeitgeist and socioeconomic system of the world, a new era of change like the enlightment, the industrial revolution, etc
Anonymous United States No.213989319 >>213989541 >>213996268
> have a college degree
>don't have a college degree job

I tried, that's all I can do
Anonymous Poland No.213989328 >>213992549
>>213989064
India will fall below replacement in like 5 years max too
Anonymous Argentina No.213989349 >>213989364
>>213989271
>we’ve already seen you can’t reverse declining birth rates
I swear some people is genuinely too stupid to exist
Anonymous United States No.213989364 >>213994676 >>213994719
>>213989349
show me one modern country that has had a successful, sustained fertility rebound after falling below replacement rates
Anonymous United States No.213989379 >>213989444 >>213989550
>>213989317
>yeah dude! it’s easy! all we have to do is undo the entire past 600 years!
Anonymous Serbia No.213989418
>>213989181
>negrified culture
Should this increase TFR
>>213989018
My parents are getting indebted to buy a 60 m2 shitbox in mid part of Belgrade for 140k dollars while earning 6 times less than ameriKKKans
Anonymous Costa Rica No.213989444 >>213989469 >>213989612
>>213989379
exactly, it's what most likely will happen, all the signs are there. History isn't linear and there's been many civilizational collapses and there's no reason to believe the same won't happen in the modern era
this is not a conspiracy theory chud post, it's genuinely where the world seems to be heading
Anonymous United States No.213989469 >>213989510
>>213989444
well then yeah i agree with you, and what’s worse is in the west, we’ve imported the most violent, mentally ill desperate psychos from the third world to fight over scraps with when this happens
Anonymous Costa Rica No.213989510
>>213989469
yep, western countries are gonna become a mad max tier battle ground just like medieval europe after the roman empire fell, but instead of european tribes fighting each other, it's gonna be what remains of whites and brown, black and asian immigrants all fighting for resources
Anonymous United States No.213989541
>>213989319
We're probably one of the most overeducated generations in history and we're being used to sell fast food and pack groceries.
Anonymous Argentina No.213989550 >>213989588 >>213989905 >>213994772
>>213989379
Birth rate decline happened hundreds of times across history and almost always finished as the declining sector of the population and their ideology with them were removed via natural selection, some other times it
Happened to go much faster

Nazis raised germany birthrates from under raplecement to somewhre arround 3.0 to 4

A culture or civilization that is not expanding is contracting and there is external and internal forces ready to overporwer them,
The dominating culture will begin losing power as it is subjected to recurrent falseation, attacks and "trial and error" from iterations of competing cultures, as these begin developing subsistance mechanisms and economic support network to "counter" it, the dominating culture will remain in erosion until its fall as the competing culture garners sufficient labour, momentum and power to lead a revolution, normally what accumulates sufficient labour to change the zeitgeist is a change on the productive structure

For example, the bourgeois revolutions entailed the accumulation of induatrial labour and agricultural produce in enriched peasants and bourgeoise, this led to an accumulation of capital (exchangable labour) that would eventually permit a replacement of the previous economic-productive structure (feudalism, which divided the Managerial classes, property ownership/war means and subsistance farming to lock this developement)
That and, you should juat de-emancipate women and make child labour more economically viable. Also the collapse of the pension system will require people to seek alternatives like gettig taken care of by kids
Anonymous United States No.213989588
>>213989550
I do not feel safe in Argentina
Anonymous Dominican Republic No.213989612 >>213989697
>>213989249
>>213989317
>>213989444
I understand your point but it's very difficult, microplastics are everywhere now in non-fourth world countries, we would basically have to start living a varg type life, which would be impossible to feed a population of over 8 billion humans, also, the liberalization of women is another key factor in low fertility rates, once women acquire rights in a country it is extremely difficult to take them back, practically an Iran type revolution would have to be done in every country.
Anonymous Canada No.213989632
Yeah well you know what women owe me sex
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213989668
>>213989018
>Blaming income inequality and privatization, they instead fall for right wing populism, and institue more privatization reforms. America under Trump last election is a great example.
THIS! I fucking hate th*tcher and low IQ right wing lower class so much it's unreal
Anonymous Costa Rica No.213989697
>>213989612
>practically an Iran type revolution would have to be done in every country.
when material conditions go to the shitter, so do liberal ideologies, unfortunately to increase birth rates life must become shitty again
Anonymous United States No.213989718
>>213989018
The USSR collapsed economically due to retarded central planning decisions and a cascade of environmental disasters caused by the state cutting costs and prioritizing profit over everything else. And China and North Korea's birthrates are plummeting just like everywhere else.
Perhaps the problem isn't the "capitalism" boogieman, and instead retarded elites?
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213989767 >>213995220
>>213989018
I don't know what the solution is, but there really is something evil about the present system, where you can effectively buy stocks in companies that pay dividends from the rent that people pay to them. You can basically become so rich that you can force poor people to give you their money for doing nothing other than being rich.
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213989846 >>213989912 >>213989929 >>213990355 >>213994746
Why are you guys worrying about declining population anyways? Youth unemployment's already like 15-25% in most of western countries because of AI and automation. Capitalism doesn't need youth/people anymore
Anonymous United States No.213989905
>>213989550
>Nazis raised germany birthrates from under raplecement to somewhre arround 3.0 to 4
show me one source that shows they were below replacement.
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213989912 >>213990035
>>213989846
>Why are you guys worrying about declining population anyways?
Because it's going to put severe strain on government finances, i.e. life is going to become very hard for us by the time we're pushing our 50s and 60s (unless you're a richfag, as always).
Anonymous Portugal No.213989929
>>213989846
i actually wouldnt worry about it so much, since it is normal for populations to fluctuate over time...Except that our governments have decided to replace us with violent low iq brown subhumans
Anonymous Brazil No.213989946
>>213988843 (OP)
India can fix that, just open borders for them and all your problems go away.
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213990035 >>213990082 >>213990091
>>213989912
>life is going to become very hard for us by the time we're pushing our 50s and 60s
Why? I really don't understand this either. Aren't we paying for our own pension from our salaries anyways? It's not like we're asking for alms from government. The pension we get after some certain age is our own individual money

Also, Chinese established dark factories where literally zero people work in them. We can do the same. We no longer need human power at the age of AI
Anonymous United States No.213990082 >>213990134
>>213990035
it’s either your pension of the NHS. if trends continue, the number of working people in the UK paying taxes to fund YOUR pension will be HALF of the number today, and there are already a shitton of issues with the current order already.
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213990091 >>213990134
>>213990035
>Aren't we paying for our own pension from our salaries anyways?
No. The taxes you pay right now go towards current retirees' pensions. The idea is that by the time you retire, the next generation of workers will be paying your pensions with their taxes. Of course, this gets harder and harder to do as there are more pensioners and fewer workers.
Anonymous Argentina No.213990102 >>213990242 >>213993033
>>213988843 (OP)
Reasons for less births:
>comfort of a childless life
>western women are evil whores
>economy is fucked
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213990134
>>213990082
>>213990091
I'll try to cancel my pension scheme tomorrow
Anonymous Portugal No.213990242
>>213990102
trvke
Anonymous United States No.213990355 >>213990439
>>213989846
if it doesn't need people then why are they letting in millions of jeets and ngobos every year
Anonymous Norway No.213990372 >>213990427 >>213997623
>>213988843 (OP)
>old people dying off
>this is bad
...
Anonymous Portugal No.213990427 >>213990443 >>213990459
>>213990372
where are the young people to replace them mark...
Anonymous United States No.213990439
>>213990355
They like seeing people suffer o algo
Anonymous United States No.213990443
>>213990427
they are waiting for their visa being approved.
Anonymous Norway No.213990459 >>213997139 >>213997623 >>213998498
>>213990427
>where are the young people to replace them mark...
kids will come after old farts are dead and buried, their money and property inherited and some space freed
Anonymous New Zealand No.213990478
>>213989018
Pick up a history book you dumb fucking troon
Anonymous United States No.213990725
With how rationalized the whole economic field has become, almost everything need to be calculatable and quantifiable. If rational agent theory is right, maybe checking out of society is the most beneficial action to be taken.
Anonymous United States No.213990961
>>213989018
>Pathetic Cucknadian crying about “““Capitalism””” again while ignoring the birth rates of non-Capitalistic countries such as Cuba, NK, and others
Fags like you are extremely pathetic. Letting you live in the system you complain about is a waste of space. Go live in Africa already. Don’t why you redditards/xiggers continue whining here.
Anonymous Sweden No.213992458
Europeans lost WW2 and we've been occupied ever since. Its more clear in places like Japan or South Korea, but the root cause is the same. We don't have any political or economical power, we're slaves and we have to start realizing that so we can start fighting.
Anonymous Poland No.213992488
>>213988843 (OP)
>what is happening to earth
FTFY
Anonymous Poland No.213992549
>>213989328
What 5 years? It already did.
Anonymous Canada No.213993033 >>213994368
>>213989145
>>213990102
You’re Latin
You don’t suffer
You have some the hottest women rivaling Ukraine Colombia or Korea
Anonymous United States No.213994295
>>213989018
very based and true
Anonymous Argentina No.213994368
>>213993033
>hurr you don't suffer because your women are hot
Doesn't mean anything as most women here are cunts, whores and insufferable AND they're not going to have sex with me or talk to me, they're only going to fuck a selective group of men and even if you got to date one she'll cuck you and humiliate you
Also they're not really hot, most are average
Anonymous Sweden No.213994398
up those numbers
KILL 'EM ALL
Anonymous Bangladesh No.213994676 >>213994719
>>213989364
Love from kazakhstan
Anonymous Hungary No.213994700 >>213995147
>>213989018
inequality is not that much of a problem when life quality has gone up a lot
100 years ago most apartments did not have central heating, plumbing, life expectancy was much lower, etc.
a lot of things are wrong in life and should be improved a ton but whining about inequality and making it a central part of your life is just resentment and nothing else, it is a personal issue you should deal with instead of trying to make it everyone elses problem
Anonymous Australia No.213994719
>>213989364
>>213994676
Mongolia also
Anonymous Bangladesh No.213994746 >>213994803
>>213989846
True. But good luck living in a society were the olds and the elites control everything even more.
Anonymous Poland No.213994772
>>213989550
How is it to be a midwit incel nerd in a Latinx country like Argentina where all your friends and acquaintances are having sex on the beach and dancing to reggaeton right now? Genuine question
Anonymous Ukraine No.213994787
>>213988843 (OP)
Import more monkeys
Anonymous Poland No.213994803
>>213994746
>But good luck living
That's the point, no one has to live there because no one gets born. We are just the last generation and can sacrifice our lives for the good of future generations by not bringing them to this world
Anonymous Sweden No.213994919
>>213989018
Capitalism is a broken system. The Chinese system is the best.
Anonymous Canada No.213994972
>>213988843 (OP)
So just under a million euro babies are born then
Anonymous Indonesia No.213995087
It's over
Anonymous United States No.213995147
>>213994700
Whenever you hear someone say "material conditions" there is a damn good chance they're about to complain about social status
Anonymous Russian Federation No.213995177
>>213988843 (OP)
>the greatest continent on earth
Don't get high on your own superbia, Anonymous.
Sumer alone existed for much longer.
Anonymous Russian Federation No.213995220 >>213995453
>>213989767
Capitalism isn't intrinsically a death cult, like he says. It's just a formalization of certain power acquisition mechanics that normally happen, but turned into a ideology that easily puts the ruthless and the cunning unto a path.

Either way, the solutions are numerous.
Anonymous Sweden No.213995278
Is there a good argument you can make for why the average non-nazi person should have kids?
Anonymous Latvia No.213995329
>>213988953
>and even they magically hit native European birthrates when they get denied that
No they don't.
Anonymous South Korea No.213995422
>>213988843 (OP)
Literally every single downfall of western society started from giving women right to vote. End of
Anonymous Malta No.213995453 >>213996263
>>213995220
>>213989018

We call it capitalism but like less than 2% of the population are capitalist. The rest are workers who own no capital. Yet we call it capitalism.
Anonymous Latvia No.213995465 >>213995484
>>213989018
I call bullshit. The birth rate was trending down and fell below replacement in commie times too. The reason it collapsed in the 90s was because post Soviet economies needed time to readjust to a new system and the birth rate has been recovering ever since.
Anonymous Poland No.213995484 >>213995529
>>213995465
>and the birth rate has been recovering ever since.
not a case here
different countries are different apparently
Anonymous Finland No.213995504
>>213988843 (OP)
Are you really. Have you all been brainwashed by natalist propaganda on your X feed. Europe will have hundreds of millions of people. Same with Japan.
Anonymous Latvia No.213995529
>>213995484
The exact curve of the graph is different but the trend is the same.
Anonymous Sweden No.213995548
This society is rotten to the core. Let it die or build something better.
Anonymous Finland No.213995579
you people fell for the 1/3 of gen Z has been aborted stat
Anonymous Brazil No.213995635
>>213988843 (OP)
The world is overpopulated
Maybe it's time to stop growing
Anonymous Spain No.213996226
>>213988843 (OP)
It is worst than that since probably 1 million newborns are descendants of africans and muslims.
Anonymous Russian Federation No.213996263
>>213995453
Because capital owners are still capitalist. They chose to run the system unjustly, but the mechanics are still capitalism-based.
Anonymous Norway No.213996268
>>213989319
me too
Anonymous United Kingdom No.213997139
>>213990459
give ONE (1) example of a country where this has happened or is happening
Anonymous Malaysia No.213997247
>>213988843 (OP)
Bringing in more refugees will fix this
Anonymous France No.213997572 >>213997645
I have put my penis in my wife's vagina several times and now we have two children (we are both ethnically French) I see the big picture and I know what is going on but frankly on a personal level I have a hard time understanding what is stopping other white people from doing the same.
Anonymous Israel No.213997599
>>213988843 (OP)
not my problem plus they voted for it
Anonymous Finland No.213997623
>>213990372
>>213990459
SAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
RSAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A.
A
A
A
A
R
Anonymous Germany No.213997645 >>213997682
>>213997572
Maybe educate yourself about the reasons
Anonymous Austria No.213997648
>>213988843 (OP)
the solution is genocide
no one is ready to hear that though
Anonymous France No.213997682 >>213997721
>>213997645
Just put your dick in some greta's vagina hans how hard is that
Anonymous Germany No.213997721 >>213997775
>>213997682
Here, maybe you understand:

Ranked by weight of influence (based on demographic research):

Economic factors – high living costs, housing market pressure, job insecurity.

Social factors – later family formation, individualization, priority on education/careers.

Structural factors – insufficient childcare, poor work–family balance support.

Demographic factors – shrinking cohorts of women in prime childbearing age.

Health-related factors – reduced fertility due to later childbearing.
Anonymous France No.213997775 >>213997817
>>213997721
Like I said I know all of this. Now just put your dick inside some bochette and cum inside then you will have boches babies. It's really that simple.
Anonymous Germany No.213997817
>>213997775
thanks for the heads up
I didn't know that the act of cumming inside a vagina is somehow not linked to the factors I mentioned
Anonymous United States No.213998079
>>213988843 (OP)
It's true that societies are child unfriendly, but that statement has nothing to do with that graph.
Deaths exceeding the birth rate can't tell you anything about children.
And what does child unfriendly even mean?
That they die?
That they can't go outside?
That they have no future?
Anonymous Poland No.213998336 >>213998433
If not for the fact that I want to see how this shitshow will unfold I would have probably killed myself by now.
Anonymous France No.213998433 >>213998919 >>213999098
>>213998336
Wanting to turn violence against yourself rather than against those who hate you is typical of the modern white mental illness.
Anonymous Vietnam No.213998465
>>213988843 (OP)
>What they expect
when Europe shines, I'm happy
>In reality
when Europe falls, I'm happy
Anonymous Greece No.213998498
>>213990459
>kids will come after old farts are dead and buried, their money and property inherited and some space freed
haha
lol
lmao even
Anonymous United States No.213998670 >>213998762
retards think it’s because of capitalism or whatever but the truth is women just simply refuse to have kids
Anonymous France No.213998762 >>213998835
>>213998670
>and then in the 80s women- for no reason whatsoever.. simply refused to have kids anymore
Retarded incel
Anonymous United States No.213998835 >>214000706
>>213998762
oh there was a reason but you’re to unknowledgeable to know about it
Anonymous Poland No.213998919 >>214000706
>>213998433
I'm not white
Anonymous Germany No.213999098 >>214000706
>>213998433
I bet you are arab
Anonymous Israel No.213999180 >>213999209
Imagine if they were to have another world war on their soil lol, truly that would be the final nail in the coffin, if that nail hasn’t already been hammered shut long ago
Anonymous Germany No.213999209 >>213999440
>>213999180
I wonder who is behind all this
Anonymous Portugal No.213999371
>>213988843 (OP)
This would be possitive if Europe had closed borders and there was a zero browns policy and if pensions were cut to half, boomers dont deserve them.
Anonymous Israel No.213999440
>>213999209
>mossad made me not cum inside my gf withot a rubber o algo or however the plastic around the bottle is made
Anonymous France No.214000706
>>213998835
>you’re to
Kek nigger
>>213998919
Kys then
>>213999098
Im 100% euro though
Anonymous Austria No.214000876
What if Europe is fucking full
Anonymous Norway No.214001713
The solution? Import japanese women, not muslim fighting age men.
Anonymous Italy No.214002773
>>213989018
The decrease in birth rates has to do with better living standards and acess to proper education, which push for more individualistic lifestyle since kids are seen as a burden in order to pursue a career or simply being able to freely enjoy life, or as a great responsibility which can scare many. The birthrate decline is happening everywhere, even in Africa, because the poverty rate and living standard have been consistently rising since post ww2 everywhere in the world. The pie doesnt stay the same size, it has been getting bigger.

Also, investing in commodities have always been part of human society, the idea of accumulating resources and investing them existed even 2000 years ago. The fact that we're not having it as good as our grandpas because of certain policies and corporate lobbying, that's simply an another thing.
This kind of nonsense rethoric constantly using capitalism as the boogeyman is getting tiresome to listen to. Always using this vague concept, never once you hear some clear definition.
Anonymous Cyprus No.214003622
>>213989018
trvth nvke
women's suffrage was not a free money cheat, it upended the foundation of society for some quick profit and now that its grinding to a halt they try to plug the hole with immigration