Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:02:12 AM
No.64432358
[Report]
>>64432318 (OP)
I've been waiting for this day for too long
>>64432318 (OP)
Canister shot was probably never intended for "anti-infantry" use.
Imagine this; there's an ATGM team in a brick house 200 meters away
Do you A) shoot a sabot and create a four inch wide hole in the wall
B) shoot a HEAT round and create a 5 foot hole in the wall
C) shoot an HE and blow down half the wall
or D) shoot a canister shot and shoot a thousand holes in the wall
It's not really about "shred this one infantry soldier with extreme prejudice" but "destroy this lightly fortified emplaced enemy position with low margin of error".
Why would you shoot a dude with a tank shell anyways when you could just cut him in half with the coax?
>>64432364
Canister was for clearing large masses of troops. You just need to fire one round down a street.
I thought it was for helicopters
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:25:45 AM
No.64432425
[Report]
>>64432436
>>64432384
You assume weapon characteristics from marketing headlines.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:26:55 AM
No.64432429
[Report]
>>64432424
>In 1865
Speaking of that, we need to bring back double canister as a capability.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:29:47 AM
No.64432436
[Report]
>>64432425
From talking with a co-worker who was a former gunner.
He said canister was his favorite. Said it would cut a 100yd swath at 500.
>>64432424
Modern canister was a direct result of the Japanese tactics in WW2. Extensively used during Korea.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:30:11 AM
No.64432438
[Report]
>>64432422
there was a driver tracks car moment in a thread last week sometime
>tfw you're an artilleryman and you hear, "INFANTRY! 200 METERS! DIRECT FIRE! HIGH EXPLOSIVE!"
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 6:05:29 AM
No.64432500
[Report]
>>64432424
And what? It suddenly stopped working?
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 7:56:03 AM
No.64432758
[Report]
>>64433961
>yfw you're a machine gunner and your WSL yells FREE GUN
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 8:01:42 AM
No.64432769
[Report]
>>64432424
So what? Nothing ever becomes truly obsolete.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 11:28:15 AM
No.64433060
[Report]
>>64432364
canister shot is for when the Chinese send two infantry divisions to take the 2km of line you're overwatching, that's otherwise covered by a platoon of marines, hopes and prayers
>>64432758
Is "free gun" roughly the equivalent of "weapons free"?
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:58:21 PM
No.64433989
[Report]
>GUNNER, SABOT
>REPEAT
Is the scariest.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 5:59:27 PM
No.64433993
[Report]
>>64438862
>>64433961
I think that's bong for runaway gun, where the action gets so hot from firing cyclic that the sear fails and the gun keeps shooting after you let go of the trigger.
SOP is to break the ammo belt and just ride the lightning until you're out of ammo.
Expert pro tip: you can't snap the belt of a Mk19, the 40mms are too fat to wrap your hands around as it moves. If it's mounted on a humvee turret, whatever you do don't unlock the turret ring before hand and jerk the gun up in shock, as a stray 40mm could fall down into the engine block of your PL's humvee and brick it.
source: was retarded as a private
>>64432318 (OP)
>GUNNER, SMOKE, BUILDING!
Easily the most diabolical one.
>>64434037
Guessing the result is anyone in the building piling out looking like picrel?
>>64434037
Thanks for reminding me that the rewatch is only a couple months away
>>64432318 (OP)
Canister shot is still a thing? I thought that that was what the coax MG was for
t. non-tankfag
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 7:20:25 PM
No.64434255
[Report]
>>64432364
>was probably never intended for
There's literal FMs and other such doctrine you can read, instead of just making it all up in your head, kid. Suck less.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 7:33:18 PM
No.64434290
[Report]
>>64434207
The GWOT saw the standardization of the M1028 120mm canister round. Handy in urban areas.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 7:36:57 PM
No.64434303
[Report]
>>64434207
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cgn1nhUEgo8
I remember watching a thing about this stuff saying it was made to "shoot down helicopters", but no helicopter is retarded enough to get that close to a tank without firing an ATGM.
>>64434207
https://www.gdots.com/munitions/large-caliber-ammunition/120mm-m1028/
More reading material. Even General Dynamics states it as being "anti-personnel" and for "assaulting infantry and RPG ambushes".
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 8:06:49 PM
No.64434405
[Report]
>>64434178
>rewatch
on /a/? i need to watch this series again someday it was great
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UOuQRNNWE_I
>>64434355
Sora no Woto
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 8:11:26 PM
No.64434422
[Report]
>>64434561
>>64434178
>rewatch
on /a/? i need to watch this series again someday it was great
>>64434355
Sora no Woto
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 8:16:49 PM
No.64434451
[Report]
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 8:42:45 PM
No.64434561
[Report]
>>64434422
Yeah /a/ has an annual rewatch stream/ party in early January. It's good fun
>>64434590
Modern handheld smoke grenades don't use it but the smoke launchers on a tank and smoke rounds from large guns tend to. Aside from being a sneaky way to keep WP in stock, they tend to create a much quicker and thicker burst of smoke as soon as they're deployed, which is what you typically want from an emergency smoke screen or long range fire of one.
Still gotta be careful with hand-thrown though, it's an exothermic reaction so those fuckers get hot.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 9:13:25 PM
No.64434700
[Report]
>>64434621
UK tankers still keep 120mm WP shells in stock.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 9:40:07 PM
No.64434801
[Report]
>>64435927
>>64434740
if you know you're going to be engaging almost exclusively armor it's better to not have any HE in your vehicle at all in case you get penetrated
American HE is remarkably insensitive but it's better not to risk it, and canister is inert and also useful against infantry and light vehicles
>>64434740
Fortunately, you no longer have to choose. Now it's sabots that are useless and taking up space.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 9:53:37 PM
No.64434837
[Report]
>>64434037
Plenty of 75mm sherman do this to german tanks that they can't pen.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 9:56:22 PM
No.64434847
[Report]
>>64434867
>>64434740
Why? Because i love the smell of red mist in the morning.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 10:02:54 PM
No.64434867
[Report]
>>64434847
Maybe I'm a gigantic faggot, but I don't think I could ever look at a bottle of Pace again if I ever saw what happened after a M1028 was let loose on infantry.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 10:37:11 PM
No.64434990
[Report]
>>64434740
Because 7.62, .50 and HE doesn't skip off the ground, walls and through most thin skin vehicles and still continue on down the street for another few hundred yards.
Anonymous
10/23/2025, 10:52:06 PM
No.64435049
[Report]
>>64434807
>Now it's sabots that are useless and taking up space.
Wouldn't hurt anything to keep two or three on hand and it's not like you're going to come up against an entire armor division alone so you don't need more than that.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 12:08:12 AM
No.64435285
[Report]
>>64435372
>>64432412
Helicopters means switching to first echo, sabot round, keeping the heli steady in your sights, quick lazering with human validation, firing, and hopes and prayers.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 12:41:54 AM
No.64435372
[Report]
>>64435285
Pretty sure that's a death sentence too, since knocking an enemy helicopter out of the sky with a sabot round will probably cause the entire tank crew to drown in their own cum.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 1:42:09 AM
No.64435523
[Report]
>>64436149
>>64434621
I seem to recall the Marines getting their peepees slapped during the battle of Fallujah for calling in smoke rounds from artillery directly onto buildings. When journalists ran stories saying they were smoking insurgents out with WP the Marines just said "it's for concealment :)"
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 1:51:09 AM
No.64435542
[Report]
>>64439192
>>64435115
It's not a warcrime if nobody's watching.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 3:57:56 AM
No.64435927
[Report]
>>64436532
>>64434801
>it's better to not have any HE in your vehicle at all in case you get penetrated
>canister is inert
propellant, broheim. propellant.
>>64432318 (OP)
Was canister used in Iraq? I can't actually think of any widely spoken of instance of it being used. I know the Mexican army used 90mm cannister on some narcos in the 2000s and people got butthurt about it
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 5:23:13 AM
No.64436149
[Report]
>>64435523
Yeah you're absolutely not meant to do it, and I don't think a modern smoke shell would be designed to be as effective as a weapon, but you still couldn't pay me to be in the intended splash zone of your 'concealment' smoke fire mission.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 7:14:29 AM
No.64436532
[Report]
>>64435927
yeah, that's what the blow-out panels are for
there's no explosives in the round, just propellant, which can only burn and not explode
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 7:34:08 AM
No.64436569
[Report]
>>64435985
>Mexican army used 90mm cannister on some narcos in the 2000s and people got butthurt about it
Holy shit they did?
That's amazing. They should do more of that.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 7:43:36 AM
No.64436592
[Report]
>>64437365
In basic back in 1990, after the Drill Sergeants finished up explaining the finer points of the proper construction and use of a fighting position and grenade sump, they asked if any of us had any questions.. I immediately raised my hand, DS Jackson had the "oh shit, him, this is gonna be good." And DS Bowers had the "oh no, what nightmare is Private Anon going to give me now?". DS Ammon had this "yep, as expected" look.. DS Bowers: "Yes Private?". I stand to attention, go into parade rest and ask: "If the enemy throws a white phosphorus device into the position, other than getting it back out of the position, is there anything I can do to make their attack more survivable?". All three of their faces turned pale, eyes wide. Quite a feat for DS Jackson as he's Black.. DS Bowers, his eyes locked on mine, saw I was honestly asking. He answers: "No Private, you already have the only solution, and the man attempting to throw it back out will likely not survive the incoming fire with the enemy that close. The sump and anything you have to put it under is useless against willy pete. The smoke will also overwhelm you and kill you. It's why doing that is a war crime, but yeah, it happens.".. Everyone in the room was dead silent. Later, a friend of mine mentioned it: "Damn Anon, what tortured fucking childhood did you have where you think about shit like that?". My childhood was different, even by X'r standards.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 4:44:43 PM
No.64437365
[Report]
>>64438956
>>64436592
Everyone in the room probably thought that you were going to be the guy who ends up on the news as a fucking serial killer.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 4:58:51 PM
No.64437399
[Report]
>>64432486
Fuse setting? I think you will like Killer Junior, if you haven't already heard of it
>>64435985
>I know the Mexican army used 90mm cannister on some narcos in the 2000s and people got butthurt about it
Pics/Story. Now.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 5:24:37 PM
No.64437470
[Report]
>>64437530
>>64432364
During the Korean war we had cases where Chinese infantry was able to rush US tanks with such numbers that we couldn't kill them all with MGs before they were climbing the hulls. We started using Cannister after that.
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 5:49:20 PM
No.64437530
[Report]
>>64437470
Why didn't they invent tread shot?
Anonymous
10/24/2025, 11:32:12 PM
No.64438862
[Report]
>>64432412
I miss BF3.
>>64433961
>>64433993
It means full cyclic and release the T&E stops.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 12:26:30 AM
No.64439018
[Report]
>>64432424
what worked then works now
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 1:21:19 AM
No.64439192
[Report]
>>64435115
>>64435542
Remember anons: as with all other laws, you only violate the Hague and Geneva Conventions if you get caught.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 1:21:32 AM
No.64439193
[Report]
>>64439223
>50 rounds, 15 inch, rapid fire
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 1:45:46 AM
No.64439267
[Report]
>>64439601
>>64432424
doesn't hurt to have one as a treat
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 3:23:56 AM
No.64439591
[Report]
>>64441492
>>64434207
They also make one for the Carl-G
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 3:26:43 AM
No.64439601
[Report]
>>64439695
>>64439267
>>64432364
Two days later and my post is finally vindicated kek
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 4:03:34 AM
No.64439695
[Report]
>>64439726
>>64439601
No, you are still retarded.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 8:48:54 AM
No.64440411
[Report]
>>64434621
Just regular smoke grenades are nasty to breathe in outdoors, indoors there's a real asphyxiation risk, as best you'll be choking on the floor still when the guys come to clear the room.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 2:05:49 PM
No.64441030
[Report]
>>64441036
>>64432318 (OP)
There's worse commands you can hear as a tank crew.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 2:07:04 PM
No.64441036
[Report]
>>64441121
>>64441030
I posted it a second time because tanks have two tracks.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 2:12:54 PM
No.64441055
[Report]
>>64441059
>>64432318 (OP)
imagine being the gunner in an ontos
and having 6x105mm flechette beehive tubes ready
to clear the jungle 1/4 mile deep
imagine the nastyness
the pink mist
mixed with the shit spray from desintegrated guts
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 4:53:50 PM
No.64441492
[Report]
>>64441572
>>64439591
How long until we get canister shot AT4, or equivalent? There's already experiments mounting LAW72s on drones, but I'd imagine having some sort of one shot recoilless gun using canister shot would be useful in a lot of scenarios.
Sometimes when FPV drones get close to the ground and their targets, they lose connection and accuracy, they might also get shot down in the last 20-30 meters if the opposing side have some shotgun skills.
I guess grenade dropping drones still work, but they're not as accurate on moving targets or targets aware of being attacked.
It just seems like canister shot recoilless rifles could fit a niche on the drone battlefield. They would also be useful in counter drone operations.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 5:14:58 PM
No.64441535
[Report]
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 5:36:15 PM
No.64441572
[Report]
>>64441492
Considering the AT-4 is just a disposable tube for Carl-G HEAT rounds, or at least started out as, it shouldn't be much of a problem, the question is it there is enough interest to get it into production.
Anonymous
10/25/2025, 6:47:21 PM
No.64441844
[Report]
>yfw you're a T-72 crewman (T as in totally doomed, 72 as in how many friendlies you've dropped off and watched immediately be chewed up into ragged chunks by auto-cannon fire, or accidentally ran over) and you hear "ROOSTER, MOUTH, COCK"