>>23586109 (OP)
It doesn't deserve the hate it gets in /m/.
But it also doesn't really deserve the praise it gets elsewhere.
It has a lot of great stuff, but it has very big detrimental flaws as well.
It really pisses me off that we didn't get a better look into Hathaway's philosophy/ideals and what motivated him to study, and later agree with, Char. I hope the 2nd movie touches on this and fills in with the stuff we see in the novels.