>protagonist is actually outgunned by the antagonist that has bullshit quickdraw powers.
>still manages to complete his mission in arresting him
You don't necessarily need the hero be the best shot to have a compelling Western.

>>713659374
You're better off adapting the 3:10 to Yuma film with Bale and Crowe. At least that has an antagonist that can be reasoned with despite being the evilest motherfucker in the West.

Westerns died because it's been subverted too much.
Pic literally has the villain walk away scott free despite the film framing him as the evilest motherfucker that walked the earth while the protag gets gunned down to the dirt.