>>718223184
It depends on the genre really.
Like if I'm playing a fighting game, I'd drop that shit immediately if it presented me with 5/10 gameplay even if everything else looked and sounded nice and the story was amazing (for a fighting game) since I'm going to be spending 99% of my time playing the main fighting game.
But if it's a JRPG, I'm cool with the 5/10 gameplay because I'm playing it for more than the gameplay and 4 niggas in a row is perfectly average enough to glue everything together while I enjoy the characters and world.
But if I had to pick one, give me a Game B (racing) and I'd be able to replay that for eternity. That's what F-Zero is to me, only thing you'd need to change is that the music and graphic scores should be bumped up a couple of points.