Thread 96938601

Welcome to the Old School Renaissance General, the thread dedicated to TSR-era D&D, derived systems, and compatible content.

Broadly, OSR games encourage a tonal and mechanical fidelity to early Dungeons & Dragons - less emphasis on linear adventures and overarching meta-plots and a greater emphasis on player agency.

If you are new to the OSR, welcome! Ask us whatever you're curious about. We'll be happy to help you get started on this playstyle.

>Troves, Resources, Blogs, etc:
http://pastebin.com/9fzM6128

>Need a starter dungeon? Here's a curated collection:
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/80674659/#80722465

>Previous thread:
>>96907893

beautiful ruined towers edition, post ruined towers

I commend OP for keeping the old, established Pastebin, but exhort him to conform to its content in the future. Useful links:

Questions about AD&D 2e? Dedicated general here: >>96893030

Questions about NSR/ NuSR? Dedicated general here: >>96829321

>>96938365
This thread is the thread that champions the old OP text
the other thread is the hijacking revisionist thread
proof
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/search/text/from%201974%20to%201983/type/op
it only started this July
glad I could clear this up for you

>>96938642
>This thread is the thread that champions the old OP text
No, it doesn't. You've removed the "first decade" part that has been there for many years.

>>96938642
>>96938649
Proof: The /osrg/ OP has had the "first decade" qualifier since March 2019

https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/search/subject/osrg/text/first%20decade/page/30/

You're the one who's removing it.

Put "first decade back" like it has been non-stop since 2019.

>>96938668
I second the motion.

OP, you have no right to remove the first decade bit from our established general. Please stop doing this.

>>96938649
>>96938668
>>96938718
I will carefully consider your suggestion

>>96938742
Thanks for admitting that you have in fact changed the OP by removing "first decade", and are trying to hijack the thread and lying about this
>championing the old OP text
Your admission will remain in the archives.

>>96938601 (OP)
Troll thread, jannies please remove. There is already an /osrg/ up at >>96925707 whereas this one is made by an asshurt troll trying to slide the general.

>>96938668
Reminder to not feed the trolls. Leave them to jannies. Anyone got tips for running birthright?

>>96938742
Glad to see you made this just ignore any trolling and report it.

>>96938601 (OP)
How good of a megadungeon is undermountain? Does it ckmpare to stuff like gunderholfen?

>>96939263
whatever they say about 2e it sure had amazing art

>>96938742
>those three posts
LMAO
brosrg goes from anger (rage-spamming) to bargaining in one week
good to know

>one-line bumpfagging questions with no substantial replies
>obvious samefag
Come on, jannies.

>>96938641
Please fuck off forever, you worthless troll.

>>96938641
>splitting the OSR, an already slow general, into three even slower generals, and all just so you can force your bullshit narrow definition of what you think OSR is

Ignore this PVRITY troll.

>>96939263
Undermountain is easily one of the coolest dungeons. It feels like a "mature" dungeon, a dungeon in a world where things have been allowed to develop, and not just plopped into existence.

>>96939935
>obvious samefag
It's hilarious how he's obviously a samefag and simultaneously utterly unable to simulate a conversation on games, probably because he's never had one.

But yeah, this thread has to go. It serves no other purpose than trolling and samefagging.

>>96938601 (OP)
Next time, it's probably best to switch over to a new pastebin.
https://pastebin.com/q8VUJt7X

The old one has been corrupted. We need to return to a version more in line with the original /osrg/, one that uses a definition of the OSR that exists outside of the minds of a few dedicated trolls.

>>96940100
>switch over to a new pastebin
Absolutely not, we should keep the old pastebin.
http://pastebin.com/9fzM6128

You have no right to remove the references to the first decade, that have been used non-stop since 2019 in 750 threads:

https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/search/subject/osrg/text/first%20decade/

If you want to do change the topic of the general so radically that's fair enough, but you have to use another name than /osrg/

>The old one has been corrupted.
False, it only has a minor rewording that keeps the focus identical, since it revolves around the first decade condition that was always there.

You're a hypocrite. You're just looking for excuses to topic shift this general.

>>96940076
>utterly unable to simulate a conversation on games, probably because he's never had one
Yeah, that Undermountain post above yours is hilarious because it shows he can't possibly have ever read the box set.

>>96940100
Absolutely not. We have no reason to trust your pastebin. Who are you? How do we know you won't bait and switch to spam or other bullshit?

Imagine if everybody started doing what you are doing now to other generals, creating copycat threads and switching up their pastebins.

Make a new general instead of trying to steal an existing one.

>>96940168
>How do we know you won't bait and switch to spam or other bullshit?
Why would you even bother to ask this question in a thread that's nothing but an obvious troll hijacking attempt? This thread is motivated by literally nothing other than that the 2efag discovered that the mods aren't deleting duplicate OPs anymore for whatever reason. His previous attempts were shit like /todd/ because he thought he wouldn't get away with something this blatant, now he thinks he will, that's all.

Hey anons
Do you recommend getting into Shadowdark?
our group is a bit tired of current 5e direction and we are interested
also we think it looks cool AF
PS
crosspost
what's up with two generals?

>>96939142
Birthright is pretty great. I don't love all of its ideas, but it does have its excellent domain systems and tools to work with them. Sometimes I wish its politics systems didn't feel so "gamey" at times, but most of its big abstractions are pretty useful big abstractions, so I can't really hold those against it. You might want to simplify the war rules if you plan to use them, since they can get a bit complicated.

You can also just ignore all the domain/politics stuff, or at least not have your players get involved in it. I tend to find that players go in-and-out of moods, and sometimes they want to do a lot of plotting and scheming, and sometimes they just want to hunt down a monster.

>>96940200
>our group is a bit tired of current 5e direction and we are interested
also we think it looks cool AF
The marketing works.

>>96940168
>How do we know you won't bait and switch to spam or other bullshit?
Better to trust someone who hasn't yet baited and switched than someone who has.
You've lost the trust of this board. You changed the pastebin despite protest, and now you're saying "Oh, dear, what if someone else were to change the pastebin?"
>Make a new general instead of trying to steal an existing one.
You don't understand how 4chan works. This general is not your secret or private club.
In the OSR general, people will discuss OSR games, and that includes 2e. If you don't like it, you need to make a "Bitchy Retards Old School General" or something similar, and leave the rest of us alone.

>>96940229
>In the OSR general, people will discuss OSR games, and that includes 2e.
No, it doesn't include 2e. 2e is not an OSR game. That's why it's off-topic in this general! Glad we could help you resolve this little issue.

>want to run a game again after a long hiatus
>muse isn't inspiring me
>none of other people's stuff is clicking for me
It's over

>>96940200
Not a fan of the mechanics and astroturfed to hell and back but still better than MORT BORT

>>96940229
>Better to trust someone who hasn't yet baited and switched
Liar. You're the one who's removing "first decade" from the OP, when it's been there non-stop for over 750 threads since 2019.

>In the OSR general, people will discuss OSR games, and that includes 2e.
If you had a problem with excluding 2e, you should have said so in 2019. But you weren't here. You're a newfag trying to steal a general because you're unable to start your own.

>>96940200
Shadowdark is basically built exactly to try and get people like your group to play it. It's "old school style" for people for people familiar with but tired of 5e. It's pretty far from being something like B/X or AD&D, but it contains a lot of the "old school tropes" like Gold as XP, Race as Class, and WHOATHISISHARDCOREPEOPLEAREGONNADIE. As for the quality of its rules, it's not a bad game, but it's not a particularly great one.

I wouldn't personally recommend it, but I'm not gonna judge people in your exact position if they want to play it. People with 5e experience are probably going to fall into it pretty easily.

As for the two generals, a small group of trolls is trying to redefine OSR to exclude 2e, and been raging and trolling for years now about it. So, the /osrg/ has been split into people who want a more narrow definition of OSR that is generally rejected by the larger OSR community, and people who just want to discuss OSR games without all the trolling about what is and isn't OSR.

>>96940245
any game is an osr game if you play it like an osr game

>>96940306
>and people who just want to discuss OSR games without all the trolling about what is and isn't OSR
that explains why they lashed out to my crosspost
>t's pretty far from being something like B/X or AD&D
in what way exactly?
and what is B/X?

>>96940282
>2019
Oh, little bitch troll, that's how far your Appeal to Tradition goes?

You are arguing with an older and greater tradition, that goes back to the very origins of the general. No need to try and gaslight the board into imagining the /osrg/ started in 2019, or that the earlier /osrg/ threads contained your "first decade" nonsense or that it excluded 2e. The Archive proves you wrong.

More importantly, this is not a matter that could have been settled by an Appeal to Tradition anyway (though you lost on that count, just for the record). The OSR general is for OSR discussion, and nothing any of us can do or say will ever be able to change that. And, 2e is OSR. Basic simple logic, that no fallacy can even attempt to undo.

>>96940306
>a small group of trolls is trying to redefine OSR to exclude 2e
Liar. The /osrg/ OP has had the "first decade" rule, which excludes 2e, for 750 threads non-stop since 2019. Proof:
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/search/subject/osrg/text/first%20decade/

>>96940312
true true, WoD is classic osr

>>96940348
>2e is OSR
Sorry, no, this is incorrect. 2e is not an OSR game, and for this reason is off-topic in any OSR general.

>>96940348
The /osrg/ OP has had the "first decade" rule, which excludes 2e, for 750 threads non-stop since 2019. If you had a problem with it, you should have said so back then.

You can't show up six years later and create copycat troll threads just because you don't like a general's established rules. Make your own general.

>>96940343
B/X is "Basic/Expert", an early D&D made because D&D was getting a bit too complicated. It started with Basic D&D, and then Basic was expanded to Basic/Expert.

It's simpler and more straightforward than AD&D, and pretty popular on this board and used as the underlying structure for a number of different retroclones.

>>96940348
>Oh, little bitch troll, that's how far your Appeal to Tradition goes?
That anon is indeed mistaken. 2e has literally never been allowed in /osrg/, going back to its very first beginnings.

>>96940355
I can imagine VDA being played in OSR style
> Make your own general
well we did and now you are as salty as the day you had sand in your tranny vagina (poophole)
>"first decade" rule, which excludes 2e
Is that the wording in your picrel?
>encourage a tonal fidelity to Dungeons & Dragons as it was played in the first decade?
how the fuck does it exclude any ruleset as long as it can be played with the tonal fidelity of first decade of D&D?

>>96940362
>The /osrg/ OP has had the "first decade" rule, which excludes 2e, for 750 threads non-stop since 2019
Based and correct. Delete this thread.

>>96940282
>non-stop for over 750 threads since 2019
Who gives a shit? It was there for all the threads before 2019.
Retvrn to tradition

>>96940362
>first decade rule
Not a rule, you troll. It was a broad indication of style, and never forget that 2e still remains a compatible system, and that trying to enforce a strict "first decade" clause would omit considerable amounts of OSR material.
No one had a problem with it, because no one paid much attention to it or treated it as you do, and continued to discuss 2e freely in the threads, as they did well before 2019. Really, it was only when you tried to claim "YOU MUST ABIDE BY MY PERSONAL INTERPRETATION OF THE OP TEXT" that people began to have a problem with it, and that problem has now fully manifested.

When you decided to recently try and change the OP text to explicitly exclude 2e, it was largely rejected and that's why there's not two generals. It's weird how you want to Appeal to Tradition despite not even following the tradition you are hoping to use as a replacement for your argument. And, your tradition is still a young one compared to the Original /osrg/, so you lose on all counts.

>>96940377
got it so B/X is like a rules light version of D&D?
we like more crunch so I think Shadowdark is more fitting for us

>>96940412
>Who gives a shit?
You do, when you lie about the true /osrg/ having done a bait and switch about the OP. The truth, instead, is that "first decade" has been a non-stop consensus for 6 years and 750 posts until you came along and started whining and shitting up the whole general about it.

>>96940420
>When you decided to recently try and change the OP text to explicitly exclude 2e
It was always excluded by the "first decade" rule. For 750 posts and 6 years:
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/search/subject/osrg/text/first%20decade/
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to clear that misconception up.

>>96940450
>excluded by the "first decade" rule
Is that the wording in your picrel?
>encourage a tonal fidelity to Dungeons & Dragons as it was played in the first decade?
how the fuck does it exclude any ruleset as long as it can be played with the tonal fidelity of first decade of D&D?

>>96940427
I wouldn't go so far as to call it rules-lite, especially because it went from Basic to Basic/Expert to BECMI (Basic/Expert/Companions/Masters/Immortals), getting crunchier with each step. It's not something like a 1-page system, just an effort to try and refine D&D down before it slowly got fatter again.

I do think it's probably not a bad idea to start with SD for your group though, because it much more modern with its rules and presentation, and less of a culture shock for people who are used to more modern design.

>>96940420
>trying to enforce a strict "first decade" clause would omit considerable amounts of OSR material.
It would actually omit no old-school material at all, and the revival material which was made after 2006 or thereabouts obviously isn't included in that classification but in the compatible content.

>>96940463
Why do you want to remove "first decade" from the OP?

Please, ignore the trolls.
2e is on-topic. Let the trolls seethe in their powerlessness.

>>96940477
Because he wants to steal the general and use it for spamming his own DTRPG products.

>>96940494
That actually makes sense. That's why he's also trying to switch the pastebin with his own. So he can insert spam there.

>>96940260
>>muse isn't inspiring me
Read through some adventures.

Inspiration is really just a matter of allowing ideas to enter into you and bounce around a bit. It's like a nuclear chain reaction.

>>96940493
>2e is on-topic.
I'm afraid not. 2e is not an OSR game, so it's off-topic in this thread.

>>96940200
Shadowdark looks nice but it's kind of amateur as a rule set. Its more "casual", though that might be a good thing. A lot of OSR is way too focused on being as groggy as it can be.

>>96940470
got it now thanks anon

>>96940524
>Shadowdark looks nice but it's kind of amateur as a rule set
care to give some examples?

>>96940493
lol they are MAD

>>96939263
It's sick as fuck. High recommend.

>>96940507
I feel like I've read through all the good ones though. I guess I could check Arden Vul.

>>96940494
>>96940501
>>96940477
>>96940523
Just use the other thread bro

>>96938601 (OP)
Reminder: >>96886347

>>96940076
hey-hey people! OP here
you know what I actually like that wording
>encourage a tonal fidelity to Dungeons & Dragons as it was played in the first decade
it sure as hell goes against the hall monitor/mall guard attitude the revisionists are trying to force on everyone

Starting to make a new setting for a B/X game

Hasram -- Starter town
Brandywater -- Halfling/hobbit town
Mousehole -- fishing village
Skara Brea -- small village
Oakheart -- fronteir village
Wayrest -- River trade town.
Whiteop -- Dwarven hall
Elves live in the nice woods to the west, the idea being that the Western side is safer and more civilized then the eastern side of the river, help players guage danger

doing a 3 mile hex so players have a idea what next to them unless they are in the darkest forests and I don't feel compelled to make something in EVERY hex. Might put a dungeon complex in the eastern side of the river

>>96940537
Torches last for 1 hour real time. People die almost comically easily. Lots of random generation popping off constantly. Just lots of little stuff that makes it sometimes feel almost like a parody/pastiche. Not Munchkin or Hackmaster level though, but I can't really see it being used for a really serious campaign and not just for jumping in dungeons, getting loot, dying.

>>96940577
Tonal AND MECHANICAL fidelity.

>>96940640
If we cared about mechanical fidelity then OSE, LOTFP, and ACKS 1 would all be off-topic.

>>96940579
That mountain is looking pretty lonely.

>>96940660
>OSE is not mechanically faithful to B/X
In case anybody needed any additional proof that fishfag has no clue about OSR and is only here to troll and spam.

>>96939142
I haven't played in a Birthright campaign in some 25 years but I enjoyed it a lot.
Tips? Pick players who like politics and administration.That's all I can say at the moment.

>>96940640
>AND MECHANICAL
see now you are trying to force changes to the traditional 2019 OP pastebin and you have NO RIGHT to include things you personally want to astroturf on others so fuck off

>>96940762
The troll's obvious hypocrisy and efforts to gaslight everyone are pretty amazing. They're not even in the ballpark of sanity or reality.

>>96940664
That why the local dwarves colonized it. , there more mountains off map

>>96940798
...it'd be a real...shame... to not... give those dwarves... a visit.

>>96940828
There is always a risk of Thermoberix the dragon visiting :)

>>96938601 (OP)
>beautiful ruined towers edition, post ruined towers
Is this the Zdzislaw Beksinski thread?

>>96940619
>Torches last for 1 hour real time.
Does this even matter? Just carry eight torches.

>>96940312
A friend of mine has been converting lots of old modules into 5e for his group. According to him, it works without any major problems, though there's lots of little things like a few 5e spells he's removed because he doesn't think they feel right (Healing Word, Goodberry, etc.) and he also had to fuck around with the resting rules. The whole "5e OSR" scene is actually pretty big, because 5e is what more than half of all roleplayers are playing at the moment, and it's why so much new stuff is labeled "OSR/5E" compatible.

>>96940619
>Torches last for 1 hour real time.
and that's bad because...
>and not just for jumping in dungeons, getting loot, dying.
wait? you need more?

>>96941590
At least one more thing.

>>96940200
Been in a group running SD for about 8 months and I've really loved it. There aren't a trillion little rules you need to memorize and the torch system is memorable. There's also a quickstart guide your group can try if you wanna see if it's your thing.

>>96940360
>t. stupid fag who is wrong and smelly.

>>96940553
Thanks for the reminder that you you hear voices in your head and need help

>>96940200
Actually I recommend you kill yourself instead

>>96940343
Yeah how about you literally kill yourself instead of posting this bullshit

>>96940427
Please genuinely kill yourself with the nearest violent method available

>>96940470
>Welcome to osrg where we recommend people play shadowdark!
Literally kill yourself as well you piece of shit troll troll

>>96940660
Wow,, 2etardfishfag ESL fuckwit displays his monumental ignorance once again.
In what fucking way is OSE not mechanically faithful?

>>96942688
Good thing your dad trained you to love dirty smelly cock, now open up here comes your dinner

>>96942850
That just your family, retard.

okay, its obvious that this thread cant call itself /osrg/
theres too much fighting and shitposting over it

i propose we let the old /osrg/ keep the name and we rename this thread to /todd/

that way everyone will be satisifed!

>>96942886
Good job figuring out how to look in the mirror, ESL retard.
Going to start throwing a fit again if I use the language you can't understand?

>>96942961
What a novel idea, I'm surprised it hasn't been tried before!

>>96942980
Yes, you found yourself and your family. You retard fag

>>96942886
>>96942989
Why are you bothering to bite at his bait. Just let him tire himself out.

>>96942989
Rich coming from a retard faggot who's the most retarded and most faggot retard faggot in the whole retarded faggoting universe.

>>96943007
Yeah why bite my bait when you both can suck my cock.

>>96943007
Why don't you bother biting at my cock?

>>96943020
>>96943216
It looks more like you bit your own bait, which was a cock.

The /trosrg/ thread coming along swimmingly I see.

>>96943216
You want me to bite your cock? I can do that, 2e stud!

>>96943239
Nice.

>>96943015
Yes, that is you, Sir Fagalot the Retarded.

>>96942541
SD is supposed to be pretty tracking-intensive for what it is. I kinda look down on games that try to slim down rules but can't simplify bookkeeping.

>>96943369
No, that's you.

>>96943380
No u and your dumb faggot face.

>>96943376
>pretty tracking intensive
>having a time keeping device that automatically counts for you is tracking intensive
lmao

>>96943393
But enough you.

>>96943411
Eat my shit, faggatron.

>>96943418
Rich, coming from a fagdroid.

>>96943446
Rich, coming from a cyberfag.

>>96943411
Yes, we heard enough from you and smells

>>96943449
Rich, coming from a BrOSR fag rapist.

These puppet shows you keep trying are not working, you can stop.

im a little hesitant to ask due the rampant retardation at display here, but here goes.
im in the process of making a megadungeon.
so far i have two distinct groups (a band of thieves and a community of myconids) and two specific npcs (a construct and a good witch) that are spread across 5 layers, which can be either be attacked, left or befriended.
not counting potential other groups which could set up a short distance from the dungeon.
is this enough to satisfy the social pillar of the game or do i need to add more?

>>96943454
Then cut your ears off and fill them up with shit.

>>96943460
>BrOSR
You and your boogeymen

>>96943471
But no one wants to be like you.

>>96943480
You're a booger man, ACKShill.

>>96943241
They're charming people, these 2efags.

>>96943487
I learnt everything I know from you.

>>96943495
Go back to twitter BrOSR

>>96943506
Show me on the doll where the BrOSR touched you.

>>96943509
It touched you in the gay club, ACKShill

>>96943517
You need to pick one Boogeyman you can't have both.

>>96943524
Like there's a difference>>96943517

>>96943535
>All the BrOSR bros, ACKS fans are the same person, and /osrg/ posters are the same person.
Classic fishfag.

>>96943470
I'd say start off with that, but leave room for things to further develop. The best megadungeons are far from static, and can be influenced by the players. If the players decide to wage war on the Myconids, and the Myconids corpse-clearing activities are left undone, a necromancer that was keeping to himself in some corner of the dungeon might rise in power.

>>96943543
There's no fishfag you BrOSRetard

>>96943554
Is this "BroSRetard" in the room with us?

>>96943560
Yeah sticking his tongue up ACKShit's ass

>>96943566
But enough sharing your gay fantasies.

>>96943573
They're your gay fantasies, faggabot

>>96943573
You're the one who shared them

>>96943470
>2 Specific NPCS
Definitely add a few more. It's a megadungeon. And, making a few more tailored NPCs lets them share rumors about each other.

>>96943588
They're your gay fantasies now. I gave them to you. Now you're a gay faggot.

>>96943602
Rich, coming from a gay faggot cocksucker.

>>96943609
Rich, coming from a homofaggadroid

>>96943613
But enough about your mother.

>>96943616
But enough about your father.

>>96943554
If you are a genuine person, please stop replying to the troll.
If you continue, we will all assume you are just the troll falseflagging to shit up the thread.

>>96943627
But enough about your sister.

>>96943631
But enough about your family

>>96943643
But enough about your inlaws

>>96943549
noted.
any advice on keeping the dungeon open to change by the players or pitfalls to avoid leaving it static?
that seems to rely a good deal on skill and intuition.

>>96943643
But enough about your neighborhood

>>96943656
But enough about your gayborhood

>>96943661
But enough about your gaybothood

>>96943666
But enough about the homofaggatron factory in which you were manufactured

>>96943672
But enough you BrOSRfag go back to xitter

>>96943690
>BrOSR everywhere
Meds

>>96943594
i should probably have said four (the two groups each have their "face"/leader)
but ill think about what other colorful characters i can put in.
in case you may want to weigh in with ideas, the overall design for the layers are:
Overgrowth
Ruins
Caves (bandits)
Fungal (myconids and witch)
City (construct)
Chaos

>>96943695
You need to take meds homofag

>>96943709
Okay. You win at retardation, fishfag. I can't top you. Enjoy your victory.

>>96943722
Good fuck off BroSRetard

>>96943652
The good thing about skill and intuition is that you are free to suck as much as you want in the beginning, because with practice you will almost certainly get better. A big dungeon gives a lot of opportunity to let things grow and develop, just make sure to plant enough potential seeds. If the players don't reach them or interact with them, that's fine, just try to think up some things that might make one activity in the dungeon affect another. If the thieves are exploring, they might be disabling traps and taking treasure, which might in turn be upsetting whoever's been making/resetting the traps in order to protect the treasure. What the players do when encountering the thieves should have consequences, and that could even be something basic like them taking a cursed item from the thieves that needs to be returned to its resting place or something else in the dungeon will awaken.

>>96943630
It was just a troll all along. Obvious in retrospect.

>>96943819
A good reminder that we don't need to troll or engage with the trolls any more than neccessary, and that engaging in trolling like they do is something only an idiot would think is neccesary.
Let them troll, just ignore them, and they will continue to self-destruct as they have been.

>>96943813
thanks for the advice, ill try to keep that in mind.
also if the other retards here would kill themselves that would be great.

>>96943549
That's easy to overdo. Overwhelm the DM and the players.

Even small dungeons can get too complicated and be too much to track. Players forget a lot between sessions.

I like megadungeons that are simple. Rooms with weird stuff. Solve a problem, forget about the problem, move onto the next problem. Do that for dozens of rooms, and nobodies going to get bored, and it won't feel like work.

>>96944013
That's kind of what undermountain is. But I don't know if that's intentional or just the limits of a premade module vs. what a DM can do.

>>96943498
You learned everything from yourself and smells

>>96940669
>>96942839
I don't remember THAC0 in B/X, but I do remember that in 2e.
Ascending AC is not mechanically faithful to any TSR edition, that's 3e faggotry.
I think that's sufficient to prove my point.

>>96943460
It's not rape when you begged me for it
*violently fucks your face*

>>96943703
You should at least have one big NPC per layer, kinda like how every layer of the Abyss has its demonlord.

Ruins should have some tragic figure desperately looking for something, something impossible to find, like a black apple from a tree that has long since died and withered in the center of the ruins.

And the Witch will just have one casually sitting on a shelf somewhere.

>>96943731
No, just kidding!
Illkay ourselfyay maolay

>>96944988
Yeah, fishfag is genuinely fucking retarded lmao

>>96943703
Every big dungeon needs a wandering merchant.

Does anyone have a pdf of the LotFP spell descriptions sorted by spell level? I hate that they're just alphabetized.

>>96945623
I've only got them for levels 1+2.
https://talestoastound.wordpress.com/2016/12/19/lamentations-of-the-flame-princess-spell-booklets-for-clerics-and-priests-levels-1-2/

>>96945357
Fuck off chuddie rape is not funny

>>96945442
Keep banging your head on the keyboard you might get smarter retard

>>96938601 (OP)
Broodmother Skyfortress is the best module

When do all the Dolmenwood books release?

>>96946553
>>96946623
>having no content and no posters, the fishnigger is once again forced to feign activity by bumpfagging with empty one-sentence posts

>>96946553
I don't think I've ever enjoyed any LotFP module and I think that may have been intentional.

>>96944988
>You think I'm retarded? That's right, I actually am retarded. Let me prove it to you.
Never change, fishfag.

>>96946879
I don't understand Lament.

The last book I looked in had a moon covered in vaginas.

Giant literal vaginas instead of craters.

I always feel like I'm being low key pranked.

>>96947405
>He doesn't want to explore the inner depths of the vagina moon then never call her back
Pleb

>>96947405
It's edgy. It's about as edgy as it can be.
It's very self-aware about this though, not like how Shadows of the Demon Lord is edgy but it ends up coming off as tone-deaf instead of over-the-top.

how is your prep going anons?

>>96939142
Hey I just asked in another thread what the best books for TSR settings are. I don't use modules but anything else I am interested in stealing from for my games.

>>96948783
What do you prep? All of mines is logistical based on where and how I am playing, I don't prep content.

>>96948852
Picking up the intro Box Sets for most settings is the obvious first step, especially because most other books in the line assume you've already read them and will frequently reference them. From there, you can just dive into whatever personally attracts you.

I'd generally stay away from the novels, because a lot are just total trash and huge time sinks for little gain. The Mystara Gazetteers are worth a look. These sometimes just feel like off-brand history, but at least they're not like anything in the Stafford library.

>10 hours without ackshills and BRO[sr]S spamming the thread
nature is healing

>>96948975
naturally I will sail for them but thanks, I will give the books that come with box sets a look. I've read some of Dragonlance comics and they are pretty bad but enjoyable for it.

>>96950433
You severely need to get a life, fishfag.

>>96948783
Preddy good.
Got everything ready for next's week game, now I can relax this week and at most just add any shower thoughts I might end up having.

I had a little trouble with a brainblock earlier this week, but I just used donjon to generate some inspiration by seeing the results and thinking how I could improve on what came out. It's only half cheating.

>>96948040
>>96948276
You're fucked up in the head. Stop trolling the whole fucking board.

>>96948871
Dunno if it counts as prep, but gonna watch Conan tonight.

>>96907835
>>96907850
Stop this bullshit, you fucking subhuman.

>>96917480
>>96929687
>>96939251
You're trolling what, six different threads at the same time now? Are you proud of yourself?

>>96950548
You mean re-watch, right?

Right?

>>96950471
This one is on /osrg/

>>96950547
These ones are on
>/3.5g/ /3eg/ /pf1eg/ /d20g/ Dungeons and Dragons Third/3rd Edition/Pathfinder 1e/D20 General
Whatever the fuck that means

>>96950578
These ones are on 3.5eg

>>96950598
These ones are on an Eberron thread.

What the fuck are you doing? Have you decided to shit up the whole /tg/? Is this your plan? What do you get from doing that? You need to stop.

>>96947841
And this is you on /nsrg/.

>>96950630
>>96950636
Is it just one person doing all of this? Or are you organizing a brigade? What's the plan here? What's the endgame?

>>96950642
Yes, it's one person, with his weird-ass shibboleths and ahistorical axes to grind:

https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/96767555/#96795418
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/96767555/#q96795555

I doubt he has a coherent plan, as he's a legitimate example of one of the most overused 4chan terms: a real-life, honest to god schizo. Fishfag wants NSR and 2nd ed and OSR all in one thread, and all D20 stuff in one thread. Maybe he ultimately wants to combine all D&D-related threads into one? But who the fuck knows what a crazy person truly wants. All you can be sure of is that he's batshit crazy and is going to keep trying to hijack threads.

>>96950693
Why is he being allowed to shit up so many different threads? Is this how 4chan works? Everybody can do whatever the fuck they want?

>>96950642
I think he's just compiling a list of "posts that made me mad."

I think we can add "BrOSR" to the list of words that trigger him. Use it wisely.

>>96950642
inb4 you're just setting yourself up to reply to yourself

>>96950710
You called it too late kek.

>>96950702
I have no idea. Up until late August there was a mod who would actually delete any post that called out fishfag, while leaving any troll post intact. That guy seems to have been fired or reassigned. Then for about a day or two fishfag actually had his own posts removed, including the first example of this hijack thread. Since then though they seem to have just decided to let him do whatever he wants. And since he's a) batshit insane, and b) obviously free all day, he just posts all day, every day, any way he wants, and never suffers consequences for it. You just have to deal with it. There's no moderation, no penalties.

>>96950642
It's pretty obvious that he went into the archive, typed "BroSR" and then started mass replying here. I'd guess he's mad that he's been called out and that the jannies no longer take his reports.

He seems super mad now.
Who's the last guy who hit him, and what did you say?

>>96950693
so true, you can recognize fishfag by his shibboleth of using vowels in his posts

>>96950766
Those posts were mostly collected by another Anon else and I copied the link from him. Another one or two I noticed myself.

And yes, I might start replying here in the future. Why shouldn't it? Seems perfectly appropriate.

>>96950803
This post is barely comprehensible but the tl;dr seems to be that yes you are brigading.

>>96950768
I'm guessing >>96950424 shouldn't have reminded him that he hadn't hit his shitposting quota for the day.
Only two hundred more posts from him.

>>96950803
>Those posts were mostly collected by another Anon else
lolwut

>>96950834
He forgot that we aren't in the discord.

>>96950768
Sorry, it was me.
While I was fucking his mom, I told her to call me "fishfag" because I knew it would annoy him, and she was screaming it loud enough for the whole trailer park to hear.
Then when the next guy showed up, he ALSO told her to call him fishfag. And so did the next six guys in line.
I guess I'd be upset to, if I had to witness that and hear that and try to clean up after that.

>>96950548
Reminded me I need to listen to that soundtrack again.
I'd actually only give that move a B or a B+, but man do I love that fucking soundtrack. Easily in the Top 10 Fantasy soundtracks.

>>96950918
A guy, first time dming, and he just put the Lord of the Rings soundtrack on while we played.

Not a curated list. The whole thing. And things kept being akward. The wrong music would come up for what was happening. Battle music blasting out of nowhere or a love theme playing during a battle or celebration music when someone gets mauled by a monster.

The guy DMing was too focused on running the game to pay attention to what song was playing. Several minutes of "gay hobbit frolicking" while we're getting raped by ghouls.

>>96950548
Sure it counts
>I cast snake

>>96947405
I tried googling that.
Not what I expected.

What is your favorite monster nobody ever talks about and why is it the Malfera?

>>96950424
Yeah I'm not sure what you think you are talking about but I hope you genuinely kill yourself soon. You and your trolling and disruption is a scourge on this general and the board.
I'm going to go ahead and continue posting about acks and the brOSR.
I didn't actually care about them before, but you've driven me to radicalization. Hope you're ready to experience an osr Taliban

>>96950630
>Whatever the fuck that means
Genuinely what's the point of saying something like this? Clearly the people playing that game style understand, why would you just claim that you are ignorant on the topic as though it was some type of emblem of your status?

>>96952191
The last time I used it my party hated it and it was fantastic. It was guarding a very powerful magic item that they ended up loving as

>Y-you've radicalized me
>Says man who just admitted he's been the one posting about it all along
Schizos should really be permabanned.

>>96950803
>Those posts were mostly collected by another Anon
>fishfagtard forgets that we aren't in his brigading discord

>>96952264
They are nasty motherfuckers. Everything about them is all "FFFFFUCK this."

>>96950630
>Fishfag is now seething about the solid /osrg/ consensus and his made-up definition of the BrOSR in completely unrelated generals
lmao, he's lost another bit of sanity nobody even knew he had

>>96952251
>didn't actually care about them before, but you've driven me to radicalization
lol no one is going to belive you, ackshill

>>96938601 (OP)
NEW THREAD

>>96953037
>>96953037
>>96953037

>>96953040
>215 posts ITT
>posts new OP
wtf

>>96953091
I assume he hoped by making yet another hijack thread on top of this one he could somehow get the real /osrg deleted. It also lets him use his hijacked pastebin rather than the original.

>>96953104
The level of mental illness on display is really something. Shows that the entire thread coming together to clarify the OP really got to him deep, kek

>>96953118
You should go bump the other thread to do it again.

>>96940664
...Say that again.

>>96953091
the BROS[r] niggas are trying a new strategy out of desperation
what they fail to understand is that all their ideas require more effort than just naturally maintain a single true /osrg/ thread (which is what we are doing by just having a thread of our own) so they are doomed to fail each and every time

let them seethe and waste their lives while at it
ignore and report

PS
meanwhile SD is the biggest OSR game played, that's what is going to define what OSR is

>>96953288
The biggest OSR game ever played is B/X faggot, Shadowdark is NSR at best. Kikestarter numbers mean literally nothing btw. 90% of those are faked just to try and generate hype over nothing.

>>96953303
>90% of those are faked just to try and generate hype over nothing.
oh I imagine you would know everything about things like that
please followup with what a success ACK!s revised is by pointing as evidence that it did like $300K on kickstarter
that will really bring out the schizo in you

>>96953325
Pivoting to ACKS again eh fishfag?

>>96953330
>took the bait
sacredow killa or they name him whatever?

>>96953342
Nah, that guy's name is ArgentAegis. He's been shilling ACKS on every discord there is for years, as well as seeking out ERP games. He's also friends with (and possibly is) an MLP Diaper fetishist.

>>96953342
Isn't it weird that ackshill instantly started implying it's shoped instead of asking who are those people?
>>96953364

>>96953325
It did 300k with less than 2k people. That's kind of concerning.
I wonder if one of those seven 2.5k backers visits this board.

>>96953303
NSR games are OSR.

>>96953774
yeah and also it seems like he has stopped spam-posting, usually it's his rushhour innit?

>>96953303
Actually, the biggest OSR game ever played is a Norwegian title, Baller på Haken. It's almost infuriatingly popular, dominating tables at cons all over the world, with over 40 million players, thousands of youtube channels/podcasts, and even three different television shows.
It hasn't been translated into English yet, which is why its not that popular in the Anglosphere, but BpH is the only OSR game people seem to want to play across most of the world.

>>96953801
And your suicide is enjoyable, at least it will be for the rest of us!

>>96954520
We really don't care about hearing any updates about your discord chats on this board.

Hey guys Anyone have a good OSR ShadowPank 1 moudle guide?

>>96952770
I don't care if they believe me, I just want them to see the results of my actions. Like I said, I used to be ambivalent, but now I'm legitimately radicalized and angry about it. You've driven me from a normal citizen of the board to somebody who wants to enact violent vigilante justice on you.
Picrel, it's going to be your last fucking moments when I get my hands on you irl. And you can screenshot this, and send it to your local authorities. This isn't idle online talk, this is a legitimate real life threat that I want to cause extreme violent harm upon you.

>>96954564
So come and fucking try it you shit head bastard i am not afraid of anything here or you for that matter. And I'm not going to take your fucking shit in our thread. You are the ass hole

>>96954619
Faggot you are the one who is too afraid to even post a picture of your character sheet because you think it will get you doxed (by your friends who also use this website?).
Probably the same little cretin taking spy screenshots on discord as though it does anything other than make you look like an actual schizo.
This isn't a 2e thread, it's an ACKS2e thread, and you won't do shit about it except go hiding under a cab looking for a cop car.

>>96954651
NTA, but you being this upset about people seeing those embarrassing discord screenshots is not really helping you here.

Your best move is probably to just try to help return things to regular shitposting levels, instead of trying all these weird plans and strategies that keep backfiring, especially because they keep escalating against your favor. If you don't actually have that many people agreeing with you, and so many people disagree with you, your best move isn't to fight reality, but to just be normal. That means no more spamming, samefagging, boogeymanning, brigading, flooding, ban-evading, OP/general-hijacking, fake guide making, etc.

It'll make the board happy, it'll make the mods happy, hell, in time you might even become happy. Complain about systems, praise systems, but remember that other people can and will do the same, regardless of what dumb stuff you use to try to get them to stop. This board is elastic, and the more pressure you try to exert, the more the board is going to push back.

>>96954651
I will fuck your fucking mother you piece of shit ass hole. You are a fucking gay and a coward you would not talk to me in the street because I would fucking give you it you mother fucjed you fucking mother fucker fuck you you will be fucking in a dox soon tough guy? You want to see me? I will fucknyour mother let's see it fucking you I fucking hate you I

>>96954529
You're the one who's posting discord screenshots you fucking loser.
Everybody in this thread is waiting to see your immediate suicide. We want you to make it violent, and do it as soon as possible.

>>96954564
Sounds like someone needs to be send to the psych ward for mental health evaluations.

>>96954734
Nta, but how about you stop posting discord screenshots in an attempt to hijack the thread? Would be phenomenal if you'd just stick the the 2eg, thanks

>>96954781
ESL fishfag, please go away.
>>96954810
Not only are you brain defective, brain damaged, and brain debilitated, but you're a subhuman troglodyte. Go cut off your own toes and run around playing in traffic

>>96954819
literally not even him you schizo, those things you just said should alert the psych ward of your jurisdiction if anything, you are mentally unhinged and unwell. That's where they take people like you with potential harm to oneself or others who can't handle their emotional outbursts, enjoy getting a needle up your ass faggot.

>>96954785
Honestly, not the guy who posted those screenshots. I'm actually not even sure I approve of the guy doing so, because it's kind of a low blow, a little too close to the kind of activities you partake in.

But, in all fairness, you have been acting like a little creep on this board, and trying to organize things on discord is where you're really just hoping to abuse this place.

>>96954852
The brigading being real is the part where it's good everyone knows.

>>96954619
Post your fucking character sheet then already

>>96954819
Whoa - can we cool it down a little? This is a hobby that we all enjoy, let's try to refrain from the insults!

>>96954916
I do not want to get a member of the moderating staff involved. You can check out my YouTube channel, Dungeon Craft at any time.

>>96954852
Nobody organizes shit on discord, least of all myself. Where would you even get that delusion if you weren't on discord doing the same shit?
You have no character sheets you don't play games and you're a disruptive troll trying to hijack multiple threads.

>>96954852
>>96954973
>>96954921
Hey faggots, this isn't the thread for you to be posting discord screenshots to stir up drama.

Instead why don't you try talking about games, or even better, why don't you post a character sheet as proof that you actually play?

>>96954973
Is this a broken AI reply? What the fuck does it have to do with you posting a character sheet?

>please please don't post the discord screenshots!
>report for doxing so the images get deleted
Hmmm
It's almost like the screenshots were on point
Well now you know

>>96955039
I'm giving you context - because you're talking with one of the founders of the OSR movement. Check out my YouTube channel, Dungeon Craft, before trying to act as an expert here. You don't know who you're messing with, kid.

Has this general ever thought of making a shared setting? Everyone could run in different corners in it, treat this as a shared GM hub.

>>96955067
Hi. I'm Johhny OSR, sole founder of the OSR movement, and I'm really getting tired of people trying to take credit for it or define it the wrong way or try to police people about it.

Beelzebub only gave me five minutes of time back on Earth to explain a few things, so I'll be quick.

>OSR stands for "Old Skool Revivification"
>Anyone who use "sc" instead of "k" is not kool enough for the Old Skool.
>I started the OSR because the devil tricked me into making three wishes. My first one was to get a new copy of Jungles of Chult. (my second wish was for a hot babe and my third wish was for a giant cock, but with the 3rd wish the devil just gave me a huge cock but not enough blood for me to survive with it so I died).

And that's time. Gotta get back to hell.

>>96955145
My group does that, including round robin DM

>>96955145
I prefer "connected" settings, rather than shared.

Just something like there being a hub dimension where people from different worlds can temporarily visit but not pass through, and only items made of amber can pass from one world to another.

Players can meet PCs from other games, and exchange information and amber gifts, but can't dick around too much or unbalance each other's worlds.
(except for the mages who start etching spellbooks into pages of amber).

>>96954819
>>96954812
Hi Trollcow!

>>96955314
He's doing it AGAIN lmao

You Mongrel Banquet Club subhumans don't know how long a decade is.

>>96955314
Hi, fishfag! Are you still posting discord screenshots?
Do you still not have a character sheet from any game you have ever played?

Stop the drama and let's discuss something interesting for once.
So yeah, psionics, i've been obsessing over it lately, specially the 1e version of it. I liked it when it wasn't just a class and more like a universal system, like magic everyone had access to. It felt like the force from str wars.
I made a post in the other general but I just want to hear your opinions on it so i'll repost it here:
I like 1e psionics, it's a cool system, but the 1e DMG doesn't really explain when to use it in combat, it's so vaguely explained, it just says that there's 10 mental exchanges per melee round. Most people assume that means at the begging of each turn here's 10 constitutive mental duels but that just doesn't work because that means anyone with low psionic strength will instantly die to any psionic monster, like a mindflyer.
Ah yeah, the mindflayer, it was actually an instrinsec psionic monster, and it's a shame nobody used psionics because that means nobody really saw the mindflayer as it truly was designed.
Have you tried playing the psionic rules as written? How did that turn out?
Also I heard that after Gygax moved from TSR, he did another RPG with another psionics system, does anyone know anything about that???

>>96955757
Go back to the Mongrel Banquet Club discord, fishfag.

>>96955757
You don't play games at all and you're a fucking embarrassment. Go back to your discord raid server

>>96955757
Most of my experience with psionics is with Dark Sun, where it's pretty rampant because regular magic tends to be really bad.

The 1e system of psionics is a weird minigame I'm not a huge fan of, like someone dumping in a half-baked ideas for another system into the game. I'm fine with the general idea of psychic abilities, but the particular execution usually makes me never even mention their existence.
>that just doesn't work because that means anyone with low psionic strength will instantly die to any psionic monster, like a mindflyer.
I think that was the intention. Having it go at segment speed before regular combat and then someone just drops while everyone else is just going "WHOA DID YOU SEE THAT?" is the kind of wank psychic abilities are all about.

>>96955937
I think it certainly had potential, I very much like the idea as it is, having mental duels and heads exploding around in middle of combat and all that.
I have been pondering about it (i'm currently a no gamer lmao but maybe i'll eventually try to play AD&D with psionics some day) and trying to make it work, and I realized that it's actually a more interesting system if the mental exchanges are spaced out during every melee round, one mental exchange per segment maxed out at 10.
The manual says that if a character is attacked during mental duels it looses concentration and can't mentally attack, only defend. So that creates ground for strategic planning: someone in your team mentally attacks the mindflayer while someone distracts him hitting him with an axe. That makes the mindflayer not that scary actually.
idk haha I just want to play this so hard, but y'know it's hard to find players that will bother with old editions (i'm a zoom zoomy)

>>96955757
>Also I heard that after Gygax moved from TSR, he did another RPG with another psionics system, does anyone know anything about that???
if you're talking about Heka from Dangerous Journeys, I don't like it. It has a lot of first-draft sort of ideas.
To be fair though, I don't think there's anything in DJ I like.

>>96955916
nigga you have been literally just outed as a discord tranny
why don't you stfu
and go back
you don't belong here (you don't even belong there)

>>96956069
>someone in your team mentally attacks the mindflayer while someone distracts him hitting him with an axe. That makes the mindflayer not that scary actually.
Up until the Mindflayer's Umber Hulk slave bodies the axe guy. The real scary thing about Mind Flayers is their extremely high intelligence, so if the rules made it so that they'd feel more threatened by physical attacks, they likely would take extra steps to protect themselves from them.

>>96956170
Yeah that's a fair point, a good master needs to balance and roleplay thing accordingly.

>>96956129
I don't know who you think you're replying to, but I've been on this website for almost 20 years every day.
Please, for the love of God post a character sheet and prove that you actually play games?

>>96956069
Yes, like you have been called out already we are very well aware that you are a no games.
You are also a tourist, and likely one of the brigading discord trolls

>>96955757
I never liked psionics for players characters.
It worked well enough for things like Mind Flayers and such but that was just to make things feel very alien and weird and back as a kid DM I never bothered with using it much.

>>96955266
>dimension slop
Not OSR

>>96956809
You're a genuinely retarded fuckwit

>>96956809
Yo man, you've ever been to the
NIGHTMARE DIMENSION?!?

It's where these guys come from.
>>96952191

>>96956837
He doesn't actually play games, he's just here to be a disruptive troll.
Has no idea that dimension hopping has been a staple of fantasy basically forever.

>>96956338
>but I've been on this website for almost 20 years every day.
that's kinda depressing really
but then again that would explain a lot

>>96957321
>Oh no you're in the same place that I'm in, I'm now going to look down on you!
Yeah you're the kind of spineless twerp that doesn't last very long here

>>96956170
The thing about intelligence in regards to monster entries, should directly correlate to how informed, and how prepared they are to deal with general and specific threats.
The more intelligent creature, the more layers and options it's going to have, and that includes tough guy henchmen.

>>96957500
>You wouldn't post on 4chan every day for 20 years heh
This is an own in some trannys mind.

>>96958227
Enjoy being a hypocritical self hating scumfuck lmao

>>96956837
I don't know if Nightmare Dimension is rad as fuck or dumb as hell.

>>96959735
You're allowed to enjoy cringe

>>96938668
It's been wrong for so many years in a row it should stay wrong? Great argument.

>>96940139
>If you want to do change the topic of the general so radically that's fair enough, but you have to use another name than /osrg/
No, you. Since at least March 2019 you're claiming.

>>96940389
Don't lie. Already proved you are lying in >>96935977 before you even posted here.

>>96960584
Wrong according to...?

>>96959735
If you play card games too hard you get sent there.

>>96960760
...NTA, but aren't you the guy who thought it was wrong, and decided to try and make it explicitly exclude 2e sometime in the last few weeks, as opposed to what it was for years where it just said it broadly encouraged a certain style? A style that didn't exclude 2e, a game discussed all the time in the /osrg/?
Either way, 2e is OSR, so no need to act like hijacking an OP can change that.

>>96955757
>Have you tried playing the psionic rules as written? How did that turn out?
It was a joke. The chance to get psionic ability was so small that most people never got it, and if you need the random number of powers and the random selection of those meant you might get something not all that useful like psychic impression, or something really useful like cell adjustment (for healing wounds and disease). Far too swingy.

>>96956069
>I realized that it's actually a more interesting system if the mental exchanges are spaced out during every melee round, one mental exchange per segment maxed out at 10.
You know, that's what whoever wrote the PHB realised too.
>Psionic combat takes place at a rate of 1 exchange per segment, 10 exchanges per melee round.

Mindflayer psionic attacks are only useful against psionically able targets. They have attack mode B but the only attack mode that can affect a non-psionic creature is mode A.

>>96955757
>anyone with low psionic strength will instantly die to any psionic monster, like a mindflyer.

Not quite instant.

A mindflayer starts with attack mode B and about 300 psionic points. A typical pc will have about 60 points, that's d100 roll + a couple of stats above 12, if the pc has two abilities above 16 that's 120 points. Because it costs points to use a defence, against mind thrust they are going to be losing about 20 or about 30 total points per segment. It doesn't make all that difference even though. half the total psionic strength is defense strength

Against a mind flayer they'll do nearly the same psionic damage for one segment, then their loss in power means their attack lessens while the mind flayer is still top tier for psionic strength.

However, they will have also lost defense modes permanently and that as well as loss of defense points makes them defenseless in what, about 3 to 6 segments at most and then they start taking daze results and hp damage.

That's like half a round, not quite instant.

>>96960760
The people at the start of OSR, almost everyone else since outside of 4chan, and a lot of people who use 4chan, including the people who started the OSR general.

>>96960828
>NTA
lol, why do you even bother, fishfag?

>>96960930
fuk you Argent you fucking diaperfag Discord troon you bloody bastard

>>96960930
Why do you do this boogeyman thing? You tag people's posts, and then address a voice in your head.

>>96960760
According to a few very motivated trolls.
None of them want to actually discuss the games they're crusading to have included. Its just to fuck things up. OSR is a very clique and politically motivated crab bucket.

>>96959735
>nightmare dimension scrying pool
>fug everything is exactly the same

>>96960865
>It was a joke. The chance to get psionic ability was so small that most people never got it,
I don't think the chance dipped below 1%, and could be as high as 10% (or theoretically 15%), so if a group was chewing through characters fast enough the odds weren't that bad. You just needed to have five or so characters kick the bucket each night.

>>96960625
>ACKS edition
kek

>>96960871
Okay well they're not here and they aren't us so maybe you should try to fit in with the people you're actually talking to instead of begging ghosts to save you

>>96960865
You must be some genuine type of nogames retard. I have had several first edition characters that were granted random psionics based on their ability percent chance

>>96962770
You really need to learn how to say "I" and "me" instead of "we" and "us".

>>96962795
>I posted it again!
How about you go eat shit and die, you fuckin troll?

>>96962934
You keep making the same mistake.
On 4chan, it doesn't matter how many voices are in your head, you only get to speak for one person at a time. Otherwise, it looks pretty obvious that you're trying to gaslight people by insisting a larger group shares your personal opinion.

We know you're just a faggot. All of us are tired of your trolling. Everyone wants you to shut up and give up. The entirety of the planet, all the souls in Heaven and Hell, every speck of dust in the all the universes, we all want you to give up your personal crusade.

>>96962969
You know that you can just make a new thread instead of spending this amount of time crying about how the thread you're in isn't how you like it?

>>96962969
You really know that you should be saying "I" instead of "us"?

>>96962969
>You only get to speak for one person at a time, except for me I get to speak for everybody!
Except there's literally only one person here who wants what you want, and that's you. I can't wait for you to get bored of this website and move on to trolling something else

>>96963040
You do understand that no one could believe anything you say at this point?

You're way too used to discord. Here, people are experienced with anonymous posting. On 4chan, people generally know to mistrust people like you, so doing things like samefagging while pleading that everyone needs to trust your baseless assertions just makes them trust you less, not more.

>>96963057
Yeah, thanks for the lecture on honesty, fishfag.

>>96963071
The whole "call everyone who disagrees with me the same name" thing also doesn't work here. It makes you look like you don't know how to argue, so you need to try to shift the discussion away from whatever you happened to just have lost at.

>>96963094
Thanks fishfag, taking notes here on all your wisdom.

>>96952191
Love the Malfera it has a strange and eviler Tower of The Elephant vibe as for "where the fuck is this thing from"

>>96963057
Hi fishfag. DARVO only works on people who are unaware that you are using it. Please try talking about games or just making a new thread if you don't like the one you're in :-)

>>96963169
I got those same exact vibes too.

>>96962774
>My random number generator produced different results than your random number generator therefore you are wrong.

Anything else you want to write for me to laugh at?