Thread 212141758

There's no chance in hell this gets a sequel after 2020 and BLM, right? What does it doing well after box office say about politics back then?

>>212141758 (OP)
>still waiting 13 years later
lol

>>212141758 (OP)
It flopped box office wise so no.

>>212141782
Eh, it's not like my life revolves around waiting for it. If it gets made I'd like to see it, but I recently rewatched it and thought that this would get absolutely panned for "glorifying police militarization" and "fascist cinema" if it released now.

You work for me now

>>212141758 (OP)
>amazing judge dredd movie
>they lower it by 4 points from 10/10 to a 6/10 by picking a dogshit villain when his rogue's gallery is so rich

>>212141758 (OP)

It didn't do well at all at the box office. It was marketed as "Dredd 3D" and died on that hill of 3D craze that didn't last long.

i never bothered watching it because the same argument still stands: why would you watch it over the original?

>>212142303
because the original is objectively a piece of shit?

>>212142303
Because it's actually a good film.

>>212142303
The original is a terrible adaptation that is boring.

>>212141898
Were you expecting Judge Death at the top of peach tree ?

>>212142303
If you liked the hammy and over the top nature of the original and you wanted that that, there isn't a reason. I personally didn't and I wanted it grittier and more toned down, the 2012 movie did it for me.

>>212142303
Oh you're one of those?

>>212142272
That and It was also a limited release, only being shown in a few theaters. It's such a good movie. Shame that they failed on the business end of making this.

>>212142323
>>212142352
>>212142376
>>212142529
>>212142551

>>212142628
the reason its shit is Dredd is a British perspective satirical comic of America. But its actually more complicated than that. Dredd is used to actually take the piss out of British culture and politics.

The first movie was an American perspective version of the American setting

>>212142303
There's no reason to watch Urban's movie. It's Dredd in name only

>>212142766
thats some tip top bait

So I guess the Mega-City One series isn't happening? Many such cases.

>>212141758 (OP)
It won't get a sequel because it flopped. In part due to the utter dogshit (and lack of) marketing.

how much of a brain rotted faggot do you need to be to link dredd to blm?

>>212143125
Disprove it

LAAAAAAAAAAAAAW

>>212142303
It's not a remake you can watch and enjoy both

God I still can't believe that this was marketed with the goddamn niggercancer 3D glasses dogshit

>>212145195
it still seems so weird to me that both movies and video games pushed that so hard as the next big thing that will take over

so much fucking dogshit put on 3D that just never panned out and I still have no idea what anyone was thinking

>>212142303
they're 2 different films completely. The original is slapstick cheesy comedy. The remake is gritty crime noir. You can't really compare them

>>212141758 (OP)
Believe it or not, Judge Dredd is not meant to be pro-totalitarianism (calling the Justice Department's regime "fascism" is too reductive, imo). Judge Dredd's writers have always been lefties, or center-lefties at best. Problem is that, like Robocop, the satirical aspects tend to fly over some people's heads.

>>212141758 (OP)
>after 2020 and BLM, right
What in the shit are you even mumbling about anymore, retard? This movie came out 13 years ago, was great, did shit at the box office. If it was going to get a sequel it would have already, you fake-outrage cocksucking piece of shit. You're like a failed abortion.

>>212141758 (OP)
Well, the actual comic is a satire. So potentially a reboot could happen. But we've had two failed attempts so far, so I doubt we'll get another one (we'll just have to settle for Robocop)

>>212145856
There is almost an authentic adaptation in there somewhere if you combine the two. As noted Robocop (which started as a Dredd adaptation) pretty much did it anyway

>>212145681
Simply because 3D was better experienced in theaters and not home screens, not that it’s much good in theaters, they figured it’s a gimmick that might make people go to theaters instead of waiting for a home release. It failed since most 3D conversions looked bad

>>212145856
These are like the Hellboy movies.

>>212141758 (OP)
>Netflix’s Castlevania and Devil May Cry showrunner Adi Shankar has turned his attention to the Duke Nukem series after acquiring the screen rights from Gearbox Software.
Just saying.

>>212141827
Read the comics

>>212142303
Unironically a good movie with a lot of love put into it. You are not cool for not watching a movie anon.

>>212148128
>You are not cool for not watching a movie anon.
well not gonna lie he does appear to be somewhat cool. like a young rebel who isnt afraid to speak his mind. dunno man maybe its just me.

>>212147138
why so angry lmao

>>212142705
Isn’t garland a bong?

Soulless film

>>212148377
Based. Dredd really misunderstood Mega City One and the Cursed Earth. When everything was going to be cgi anyway and they were going to spend the whole movie inside the tower, there's no reason they should have made the city so lame and dull.

>>212148512
>noooo they should have spent their entire budget on a comic accurate city even though the movie takes place somewhere completely different!!!!!!!
You will never have sex

Stallone's Dredd is perfect and it's only mistake was removing the helmet but Stallone fucking deserved it. Prove me wrong.

>>212148552
A digital matte or even a miniature would not a have hurt that much.

>>212148552
I will never accept South Africa with some CGI building as Mega City One. Incidentally, this is also probably one of the reasons there is no sequuel. They have no idea how to make anything in the universe without the whole thing being in a tower block

>>212149122
Yep, everything outside the towers was all about the wild futuristic vehicles and technology everyone had that was common place. And the crazy juxtaposition between the lower class slums and the rich class who paid them no mind and had everything they desired. Then of course the cursed earth stories with mutants and cannibals

>>212148377
What works in comics doesn't work on the silver screen anon. The top right is goofy for the grim noir they were going for. The top left is actually captured in the movie.

>>212151340
Judge Dredd is not grim noir. And Stallone's Judge Dredd proved it does work just fine. You dorks just make up any headcanon bullshit and pretend it's fact.

The Chad Stallone "I AM THE LAW" vs the virgin urban "g-guys, stop. guys, I'm the law! not the junkie lady!"
I'll take the movie that doesn't have a completely unnecessary scene of a white woman blowing a groid.
>b-but it was a le dream and she le bites it!
It didn't need to be there at all, interracial cuck.

>>212151766
It is. I've read the Judge Death comics + Dredd/Batman. Stallone's Dredd was goofy and laughable.

>>212151874
>The Chad Stallone "I AM THE LAW"

>>212141898
>6/10
tastelet

I'd rather they reboot it with Stallone in the more comicy tone than use that chinlet Urban in some nolan gritty universe. 2014 Dredd is the most overrated shit shilled on this board

>>212142303
>original
lol

>>212152992
Mentioning Stallone when discussing Dredd exposes you as a faggot

>>212151986
>virgin nitpicker thinks this is some kind of ultimate gotcha insult rather than a mildly amusing moment by the actor that fans thought would be a funny meme

>>212153040
Don't care that he didn't respect the source. He was a incidentally better Dredd than Urban ever could hope to be

>>212153092
lol, you're either baiting or you're an idiot

>>212141758 (OP)
they should make a sequel with just cute judges

>>212153127
>baiting
I'm not. I'm objectively right. Urban can't even do the dredd grimace properly without looking like a total cuck. Cursed actor

>>212153092
Stallone respected everything about the source except the helmet, which is only a meme to give a shit about at this point. No one got into the comics first, read them all, was a giant Judge Dredd fan, then watched the movie and was crushed by seeing stallone's face. They just looked online that people were about it and took as their primary thing to whine endlessly about. It's fucking dumb.

>>212148777
>Rob Schnieder as wacky sidekick

>>212153277
Everything in Stallone version is absolute trash and faggotry, and anyone over 12 enjoying it is an idiot

>>212151340
Cope

>>212141758 (OP)
>tacticool rent a cop tier costume
>shitty over use of slo mo and badly choregraphed action scenes
>generic megacity one instead of crazy cyberpunk dystopia look
>snyder tone
>underwhelming villain and plot
This movie was a giant piece of shit only sucked off by the reddit normie crowd

>>212153460
>Lawmaster replaced with a rice rocket

>>212148377
It's a dystopia. It isn't supposed to look pretty.

>>212148377
>>212142303
Dredd (2012) is to Judge Dredd (1995) as is The Dark Knight (2008) is to Batman (1989)

the entire era of 2005-2013 had 'grounded' capeshit

>>212153292
Kino

>>212148184
Bad taste isn't cool. It's just bad taste.

>>212153543
You have no knowledge of judge dredd kek. So shut up

>>212153433
>Toronto is just like a post-apo massively overpopulated city

>>212148377
Which Judge Dredd comic is that exactly?
I want to get into the comics.

>>212153691
Concession accepted. You lost, I won.

>>212153759
80% of judge dredd comics are trash

>>212153081
Lol, you're seething

>>212153460
>Normie
Unless you're a millionaire or a total hermit, you're a normie too.

>>212153460
Only a homosexual can compare costumes of Stallone the clown with Dredd, are you even 12?

>>212147987
just make your argument

>>212141898
yeah hedley was a dogshit villain

>>212142303
because it's about dredd being a judge instead of what i assume is a climax of the comics

>>212143212
as rotten as any blm nigger

>>212142303
>original
Lul, what? 1995 movie and this has nothing in common except the character they're based on, and the 1995 movie is Dredd universe version of picrelated.

>>212153759

Can't tell from the pictures. The comics have been on going since 1977 and artists have fairly big freedom in how they depict the city. There's been everything from noir to bright super futuristic depictions over the years.

The big thing is that setting/stories develop mostly in real time and there's no retconning/rebooting shit like superhero comics. Dredd really is 70+ years old and the city has been dwindled down from a massive megacity with hundreds of millions of people to being on the brink of collapse after various wars and mass crisis events.

>>212141758 (OP)
Just be glad we got it anon.

>>212141782
It was the last good movie ever made

>>212142303
While urban's performance is worse this is offset by stalone having his helmet off 90 percent of the time and halfway through the movie becoming just another stalone movie. Dredd sticks with the story which is grittier, more violent and in a complete episodic package as if it was a volume in a comic series itself

>>212148377
most of the dredd comics are black and white retard

>>212154336
I like that there's several megacities plus a few in other parts of the world to visit

This is pure Judge Dredd. The city is HUGE. It is TALL. There is a distinct difference between Haves and HaveNots. The rich live at the top, and the poor live at the bottom and fight all the time. The MegaCity is key to the universe. It's not just some city with a few overcrowded towers.

>>212154563
>urban's performance is worse
kek, i bet you're one of those tastelets that think tulsa king is actually good

>>212154657
right, this is better scifi, better props, more fleshed out theme. kind of like how the only parts of bladerunner that people like are the action sequences and the city shots, but that doesn't make a movie

>>212154735
No? I just don't like the grumbliness of his voice, it's not commanding enough. I do like the stoicism, I wish they had more of the psycher reading his mind because what's going on in Dredd's head is a major part of the comics

>>212154657
>muh bladerunner copy/paste just insert rob fucking schneider
puke inducing

>>212154735
Tulsa King is pure kino, sorry if it isn't woke enough for your millennial tastes

>>212141758 (OP)
I remember Carl Urban himself tried a Go Fund me thing to raise money for a sequel to get somebody on board but it flopped too.

As much as I liked the film a second would of crashed and burned so damn hard.

>>212154866
yeah, i thought so, that's the kind of homos that salivate on judge dredd (1995) and batman and robin

>>212154903
Instead he's stuck playing essentially the same character but as an aussie in a shitty tv show where gay superheroes crawl up each other's orifices

>>212154849
>t. I don't give a shit about about the source material, I just like to latch onto other's complaints and whine about things I know nothing about

>>212154949
i probably read 10 times more dredd comics than you faggot

>>212141758 (OP)
I think this movie bombed because it came at the tail end of the 3d movie craze and people saw it as just another low quality 3d movie.

Imagine this scene in Dredd. Instead of something poignant, walking out into a harsh almost alien wasteland, it's just a dude walking out into the Mexican desert. Wow.

>>212154944
>he's my wife's son

>>212155027
this scene doesn't belong in the original movie either

>>212141758 (OP)
With Carl Urban doing the Boys and all and it's success, I had imagined Amazon might do an adaptation, like a miniseries

>>212155069
What is it about Judge Dredd threads that attracts such imbeciles as you?

>>212153934
>t.comiclet

>>212141758 (OP)
Good movies rarely have a real sequel. That's the only good Judge Dredd movie.

>>212153725
It's worse, Mega City One wasn't full of Indians

>>212155124
the entire second act of the movie is balls, visually it's great hard scifi but stallone hanging out with inbreds like he fell off the set of demolition man is not Dredd

>>212142272
Which is a shame because Ive always thought it was a film that did 3D RIGHT. Rather than jump scares coming out of the screen, it went backwards, providing real depth. Worked especially well on the drug sequences too. A beautiful movie.

>>212155217
As a comic reader, it was cool to see Cursed Earth, but both movies have too many of their own problems to be too faithful to the source. Judge Dredd can only be done right if someone fully commits to the zaniness

>>212154657
The city shot is cool and holds up, but that's all this is. The actual movie holds no candle to 2012 Dredd.

>NOOOO HE TOOK OFF LE HELMET!
>I DON'T CARE IF THE CITY BARES ZERO RESEMBLANCE TO MEGA CITY ONE! THE HELMET STAYED ON SO IT'S 100% COMIC ACCURATE!

>>212155424
Judge Dredd starts right and what's the hook? He's been framed for murder. Right off the bat that's uninteresting as fuck

>>212155424
you made the same point 10 times in the thread troll, doesn't make you any more right, this is not reddit

>>212154657
>"Judge Dredd" armour costume designed by Gianni Versace
now that's kino

>>212141758 (OP)
judge dredd shoots some niggers... nobody cares.

>>212142303
both are good, the new one is darker while the old one is more citemetic

Compare
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv6pfQTl-d4
to
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RNAFl4oblM

For some reason the 2000s had a gritty art style for cities when the 80s and 90s put much more effort into making good looking cities. It's the only real gripe with 95 vs the new version. It's not exclusive to Dread but a problem with CGI replacing particle effects and other tricks as a whole.

>>212145856
>The original is slapstick cheesy comedy
It really isn't.

>>212151874
your victimhood is showing

>>212158636
Really regret missing this one in 3d on the big screen.

>>212158636
Great score in this fucking film
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QepEvM0m1yw
https://youtu.be/5QJGp32CC0c?si=SnBC3nOxTxtBwHrC&t=5

>>212147038
or that leftists people have seen what leftists in charge do to cities (see the former liberal utopias of the west coast)

>>212159846
or that some people*

>>212147038
Punisher is pro police. You wouldn't get it, jeet

>>212141758 (OP)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWP88WKVBKs

there was no chance about 10 years ago.
Dredd made 1 million pounds at the box office.
skyfall made a 100 million.
the modern market does not care for 80s law power fantasy/satire

>>212141758 (OP)
>after 2020 and BLM
What does that have to do with a Dredd sequel?

>>212141758 (OP)
>What does it doing well after box office say about politics back then?
Anon it fucking flopped

>>212159934
Not really

>>212147038
Chuds think if something is cool in a movie that means we should adopt that policy in real life. They're mentally toddlers

>>212160125
* in the UK, (where all the dredd fans should be))

>>212160198
cops bad now (brough to you by the news media owned by the criminals that profit from most of your country)

>>212160326
t.ranny waiting for his letter from pigfarts

>>212159934
retard alert

>>212160271
It totally is

>>212151874
>Trying too hard.

>>212160379
>t. bootlicker that's sentenced to 1 year for illegal sugar possession.

>>212161765
im more of an illegal boinger truth be told

>>212141758 (OP)
Maybe if Karl Urban wasn't a faggot who went mainstream.