Thread 212565338

Was this scene a deliberate dig at MoS? Superman is constantly keeping the dragon from crashing into buildings, and makes sure to save absolutely everything in its path (even animals).
Was it a criticism of Snyderman, who would have intentionally punched the dragon through each building in Metropolis, regardless of the thousands of innocents who would be killed?

>>212565338 (OP)
No that's just normal Superman stuff

That's just how Superman is supposed to act in-character.

Why has everyone constructed this false creative feud between Gunn and Snyder?

>>212565338 (OP)
Oh look it's another "guess my film" brought to you by some retarded zoomer sperg who just assumes we all watch the same garbage he does

>>212565399
You know exactly what film it is, Snydercel.

>>212565373
Because their superman are complete opposites

>>212565338 (OP)
It is just an over correction.
>Goys we’re upset over the cool action and destruction so now Superman has to be a delicate butterfly so as to not offend the 9/11 Muttmericans

>>212565338 (OP)
it's not a criticism. That's literally what Superman is supposed to do. You only think it's a criticism because Snyder got literally everything wrong about the character.

>>212565338 (OP)
It gives me dbz ocean dub vibes
>good thing the city was evacuated before I nuked it
KEK

>>212565399
You dont know what reverse image search is because YOU are a zoomer faggot

>>212565454
And Gunn's Superman is just comic book Superman. What does that say about Snyder?

>>212565338 (OP)
>who would have intentionally punched the dragon through each building in Metropolis, regardless of the thousands of innocents who would be killed?
When does this ever happen in Man of Steel?
The most Superman ever does is drag Zod's face across the side of a building and push him into a grain silo because he's about to kill his mother

>>212565552
Shut up, Simple Jack

>>212565575
>And Gunn's Superman is just comic book Superman.
You've never read a comicbook in your life retard

>>212565578
He punches him through like 20 skyscrapers

>>212565609
Saar

>>212565663
No he doesn't
Link a scene where he does that and not Zod

>>212565696
GUNNVERSE HAS FULL SUPPORT SAAR

>>212565578
he does get thrown threw a billion buildings and just kind of abandons everyone to their fate as he chases after Zod while building fall on top of them, though he doesn't actually punch through any buildings himself

>>212565578
When he flies down to have a punch off with Zod while Zod is comically running on all fours up the building, when they strike each other it destroys the entire skyscraper kek, and Superman just flies off while debris rains down on the streets below.

Rewatching this scene is actually unintentionally hilarious.

>>212565338 (OP)
>Was it a criticism of Snyderman
No, that's just how Superman is supposed to behave. That Snyderman doesn't just shows how little Snyder understands or appreciates the character and how fucking stupid every single person who defends those shitty flicks is.

>>212565578
Snyder's mistake was not having Superman say
>h-he's too strong
Just to spell it out to brainlets why the city is getting rekt

>>212566041
>Superman should be limited by his power, not by his morals
good job failing to utterly understand a character for children. maybe teletubbies is more your jam.

>>212565980
imagine you're just some wageslave office worker and you look outside your window to see Superman do some epic punch with his nemesis, and the shockwave causes the building to start collapsing and the last thing you see before you're entombed in rock is his red cape flying off lmao

>>212565338 (OP)
Yes. I know they wanted the DCEU to fail from the start but Snyder didn't help with Batman having a murdemobile and the destruction caused by the battle between doomsday and superman's fight (thank god they all left their homes for casino night, right?).

>>212565338 (OP)
Was Donner also trying to dig at Snyder by having Superman freak out that people were in danger in his fight with Zod and then decide to lure him away to fight him somewhere less populated?

https://youtu.be/HFdl_EmdjPI?t=114

>>212565575
Snyder's version was heavily based on Byrnes; and Dini's takes on Superman, with a dash of Wade's Birthright and Johns' Secret Origins in and is very accurate to those versions. Gunn's is heavily based on Morrison, Waid's current Superman comics and a bit of Dan Jurgens and is accurate to those versions.

Believing there is a single "comics" version of Superman is delusional.

Snyder's fight looks extremely lame when you notice there's not a drop of blood in the whole 30 minute fight sequence

>>212565364
feepeebeepee

>>212566413
he almost starts laughing, why did they keep that take?

>>212566647
If anything Gunn's feels more like a blend between Byrne, Morrison, while using the 2nd half of Birthright's plot, what with Superman more or less rejecting his Kryptonian heritage and choosing to view himself as human first. Snyder's Superman still called Krypton "his world" even though he ultimately chose Earth before it.

>>212565338 (OP)
Honestly, this Superman was feminine. Collateral damage is masculine. This Superman ain’t American.

>>212566647
Can you explain all the separate influences?

>>212566413
I just noticed that Superman tried to catch the bus with a gas truck in the background
Is that a retroactive dig at Snyder?

>>212566842
Never before has a man been more victimised than Snyder.

>>212566839
Not that Anon but I'm not really sure where he's getting that it's "heavily" based on Byrne's. Yeah there's some superficial stuff, the birthing pod, Lois having red hair, Superman killing Zod (though it's an alternate universe Zod in Byrne's), but Byrne's Superman wasn't nearly as dour, and the key thing of Byrne's Superman was that he was just a human guy who happened to have powers. People actually complained at the time that the dreaded Mahvel writer as turning Superman into Spider-Man by having him so heavily prioritize his human side over his Kryptonian one.

The entire point of the birthing pod for Byrne was to make it so that Superman was born on Earth, and thus not an alien immigrant. Byrne's Superman is pretty human and emotional, and never as dour as Snyder's. And while Snyder's chooses Earth over Krypton, he's far more tied to it than Byrne's ever was, still calling it "my planet" in BvS.

Why is /tv/ defending this bollywood tier cgi

>>212566842
this scene is so funny. He doesn't even attempt to stop it he just jumps over it as it smashes into a parking garage killing who knows how many people

>>212566262
Batman v Superman is awful but the opening scene is pretty good. It accurately reflects how Man of Steel felt like the climax of an alien invasion apocalypse rather than a fun, exciting superhero showdown.

>>212565980
Funniest thing is the destruction Superman is utterly heedless off is the most amusing thing about the fight because Superman and Zod trading blows endlessly is boring as fuck because neither takes a lick of damage. Who gives a shit if Superman unleashes some sick combo on Zod when it does fuck all to harm him and vice versa? The Batman v Superman fight wasn't that amazing but it is the most engaging fight we ever saw Cavill Superman in because he and his foe were actually fucking each other up

>>212566262
The trailers made the bit right before they collide look so cool, cause we weren't privy to the dog run up the building or the destruction Superman flew away from

>>212567096
Felt like it was a retroactive addition in response to the backlash Man of Steel got, because the end of Man of Steel is Superman casually telling the general not to spy on him, and that he's as much of a good ol' American boy as they come, while the female lieutenant quips that he's kind of hot, and then this optimistic lighthearted tone of him joining the Planet as Clark Kent.

>>212567185
You're right, I forgot about that. What a truly miserable film.

>>212566973
Never read Byrne but it's interesting see Lex Luthor as Kingpin but with red hair. Clancy Brown's arrogant narcissistic asshole but brilliant bastard of a villain was my Lex intro as a zillennial and is fairly definative for me, though Young Justice Lex was alright

>>212565364
Thread

>>212565578
Anons are mad at Superman fighting against a stronger opponent that was terraforming earth?

>>212565364
This

>>212565338 (OP)
OP, they killed more people in this movie than in MoS, all with the government' approval

>>212565338 (OP)
no, and its away too silly how the citizens of metropolis dont care about the city being constantly attacked, and no, thats not like comic books, citizens are always scared and running away from danger, but in the movie they literally dont care, even the little girl that superman saves is right next to that monster but doesn't even look at it, while there are super heroes trying to contain it she just keeps playing on the ground.

>>212565338 (OP)
This is more in line with Superman but the MoS fight was cooler. And I always vote for cool.

>>212567254
For me the baseline Lex Luthor will always be Justice League DCAU version.