https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/taika-waititi-tackling-judge-dredd-movie-1236311752/

Karl Urban not reprising the role is blessing in disguise cause Waititi is gonna ruin it with his terrible humor shoved into this

Dead on arrival

man huge misstep not recasting Urban after MK2
Hollywood is really a bunch of retards

Oi matey im the lawwww

>>212920812
I dont Karl Urban to be wasted on Waititi shit anyway

>>212920755 (OP)
How is he Jewish enough to keep getting work

>>212920755 (OP)
seems like the worst director to tackle that kind of genre, what is hollywood smoking? it must be something from another galaxy at this point

>>212920829
Like that Marvel slop he was in?

>>212920755 (OP)
No Urban no care.

>There is only going to be one good Judge Dredd movie ever made
At least we got one, though.

>>212920849
That is the reason I dont want him to be wasted on Waititi shit further

>>212920862
Stallone Dredd had its moments

>>212920755 (OP)
>>212920836
>Waititi is gonna ruin it with his terrible humor shoved into this

I'm not defending the fag or his movies or the decision, BUT.

Anyone who has actually read Dredd comics or other stuff in the universe knows that it's basically schlock comedy with some pulp action thrown in. The Karl Urban movie was great but it absolutely was not the baseline tone of Judge Dredd for anyone who is familiar with the content.

>>212920910

most people do not read books or comics. have any knowledge of their content or cares about them. they see movies as a totally different subject matter not connected to them in any way at all and could not care less how closely they are matched to them

>>212920952
I'm not denying that. I'm just saying, to claim that Dredd is going to be ruined because someone's shitty humor is shoved in...man, Dredd is 90% shitty British humor.

>>212920910
the Dredd comics ranged from serious to comedy. There's no fixed tone and it would be foolish to translate them 1:1 on the big screen.
Dredd handled it better since it modified the source material for the big screen and worked extremely well with the limited budget. The audiences loved it and Urban's performance.
And please don't imply that Taiki Watit can handle humor besides the generic MCU slop tier.

>>212920910
Stallone was more comic accurate

>>212920910
One thing that's always funny in the comics is whenever Dredd arrests someone completely absurd like that, he does it with the same stone faced seriousness as everything else he deals with.

Dredd but Clint Eastwood as Dredd would have been so good. Maybe they can use his son

>>212920755 (OP)
Taika Cohen

>>212920969
he may be able to pull of the humor, but that doesnt mean hell be able to pull of making a good action movie, hell turn it into one of his whacky comedy movies and ruin it

>>212921077
>>212920989
You people are not actually literate, are you?

>>212920910
Waititi humor is even more shit than shlocky brit humor

>>212921004
>takes helmet off
>kisses another judge
>comic accurate
10 years in the cubes, punk

>>212921004
Which comic?

>>212921086
you are not actually brain dead, are you?

>>212921086
you don't have an actual counter argument, do you?

>>212920755 (OP)
>So uhhhh... THAT just happened!

>>212920755 (OP)
He’s going to turn the franchise into slapstick comedy like his Thor movies.

>>212920812
Knowing Urban, he probably downright refused to be involved because of Cohen

>>212921334
Based Karl
Also, anyone have any idea what happened to the TV show that was in the works?

>>212920882
Stallone Dredd captures the "wacky" comic shit (even if Dredd did a 40k and started taking itself seriously, I believe). I was taken in by Dredd 3d but it actually does have "muh brown and bloom 2010 shooter" syndrome in hindsight (still a great film) and arguably that was "necessary" for the "first" film to not go nuts with the "silly" shit.

Whether you believe it's good or not, it would entirely stand alone as a good action flick by itself.

I would like to see an Urban "serious" Dredd play the straight man to the ridiculous shit that goes on in universe

>>212920830
His birth name is David Cohen.

>>212920755 (OP)
if he doesnt make it funny im ok with this

>>212920910
Reddit wholesome chungus quips would clash with that "British" humour even more than a completely "serious" tone though

>>212921354
He is starring in the new mortal kombat as johny cage. Might see it because of him.

>>212921354
I didn't even know there was one

>>212921455
this tweet was from 2017
Urban was allegedly supposed to reprise his role but I haven't heard a singe update about this project since then.

>>212920755 (OP)
Urban's movie was shit
Judge Dredd is supposed to be funny

>>212920791
FPBP.

>>212920910
When they first wanted to make the Dredd movie it was meant to be PG-13. The director went NC-17 with it, cut it back to R, and it ruined a lot of promotional deals they had setup.

>>212920910
Judge Dredd is good at being funny but its best stuff in my opinion is material like America, which is really fucking dark just like the Urban movie.

>>212921334
You'd think he would have a good relationship with him since working together in the Thor Movies

>>212920755 (OP)
Do you like bisghetti?

>>212921635
Exactly this

>>212920755 (OP)
>start of film
>im the judge....
>*takes off helmet and never puts it back on for the rest of the movie*
>YOU'RE GONNA DREAD CROSSING!
kino

>>212921802
He might but that's probably exactly why he'd never do a Dredd film with him, pretty sure Karl Urban is an autism tier Dredd fan and he knows exactly what sort of quippy skibidi chungus nigger David Cohen is

after watching thor: love and thunder, i hope taika dies painfully in a car accident or something

>>212921975
>Dredd gets hit in the nuts
>Oof! Right in the isocubes

>>212920755 (OP)
Judge Sneed when

>>212920755 (OP)
Only good judge Dredd movie

>>212920755 (OP)
>Taikiko Wikiki
what kind of name is that?

>>212922192
>>Oof! Right in the isocubes
I legit kek'd

>>212920910
Problem is Waititi will make Dredd himself a goofy snarker which will completely ruin the joke.
Compare Thor pre and post-Ragnarok, that's gonna be Dredd.

>>212922534
Samoan

>>212920755 (OP)
>Waititi is gonna ruin it with his terrible humor shoved into this
dredd 2012 fans deserve death

>>212922349
Robocop and Demolition Man are better Judge Dredd movies

>>212922773
>threatening to kill a suicidal person
It's no longer parody when American cops show up and mag-dump suicidal teenagers.

>>212922890
listen if you shoot up a school beforehand you're no longer suicidal you're just a mass murderer

>>212920755 (OP)
>Taika Waititi
This is not the right guy for a Dredd movie what the fuck

>>212922773
>thinks taiki waitato humor is anything close to this
Fucking retard. Be like the fatty and jump off a ledge too

Drokk it, bitches

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTxvg268InA

>>212922955
Thor Ragnorok is literally a Judge Dredd movie with a Thor skin

>>212922829

Demolition Man is for faggots wiping their holes with seashells. Nowhere near Judge Dredd level

>>212922978
Lol. No it isn't. It's bottom of the barrel MCU slop.

>>212922978
You cant possible be this retarded, either you havent seen Dredd or Thor

>>212923808
seen Dredd? What do you mean by that? Cause there hasn't been a single accurate Judge Dredd movie. Or are you just another dumb fuck that thinks Dredd is what Judge Dredd is supposed to be.

>>212923953
I dont claim to know what original Dredd is, but Ive seen both Dredd and Thor to know that they are not the same type of movie at all, other than the action, even someone whos not a huge fan can tell the difference

>>212923953
>muh comics
No one cares, nerd.
Dredd was a great action movie and there's no need for an exact copy of the comics since it won't work within the time and budget constraints.

>>212924030
You are terminally retarded. Read the fucking thread

>>212924073
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND...his arguments dead

>>212920910
Fatties with belly unicycles in a Dredd film what a fucking stu...

>>212920755 (OP)
so dredd is homo now?

>>212922829
Split second has Judge Death so that’s pretty good

>>212922890
"I owned Americans on 4chan" he thinks with a grin, bleeding out from the machete imbedded in his neck. Overhead, a screaming inbred Paki dances

>>212920755 (OP)
Please Taika, set it in Texas City! Dredd fans want Texas City kino!

I have a soft spot for Stallone's movie. But urrbans one of definitive. If it only gets a one and done no worries. I'm happy it's a cult classic and not ruined by multiple sequels like RoboCop and highlander. I just would have thought urban would have pitched and made inroads to Amazon about doing this as a TV series considering the cache he's built up in the boys. I though a peachtrees TV series was happening

>>212925975
Dredd was neat, but I'd never want another one. The best part of Judge Dredd is literally the Mega City, Cursed Earth, and wackiness of the future dystopia. Dredd had zero of that. Its city was just mexico with a few spread out kowloon city buildings. I don't care about Stallone, but give me more mile high super cramped skyscrapers, flying cars, and a desolate unforgiving hellscape outside with mutants and cannibals

>>212925643
dredd is ace

>>212923003
>Honey, wake up! Latest contrarian take just dropped!

>>212920755 (OP)
Nobody likes this smarmy brown douchebag

>>212926066
Dredd was a low budget reboot. It's incredible what we got on 50 million budget

>>212927325
True. It's definitely unique and has its good qualities

>>212921407
>Taika David Cohen
hmm, really makes u tthink